6 ms·
Exercise is good for boosting memory and thinking skills, new guidelines say
- grwthckrmstr 9y agoIf you're like me who's read enough from enough sources, you'll have likely arrived at the same conclusion. To be healthy (which can have many implications,including and not limited to better memory, thinking skills, lifespan etc.), You need to master a few basic principles in life. Those basic principles seem to be Body - adequate rest (sleep), regular exercise (activity) etc. & Mind - less stress/destress, positive mind, happiness etc. Huh. Rocket science?
- sus_007 9y agoAs you've read from different sources, how much sleep do you consider as an adequate amount of sleep for a day ?
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 9y agoI think it's based on your body. Mine is very explicit: if I sleep less than 8 hours my stomach burns. If I sleep less than 7 my brain is useless. So, 8 for me (my wife needs 9!). My general suggestion is that you should naturally wake up before the alarm rings. I set it to 9 hours and naturally wake up between 8 and 8:30 hours.
- swah 9y agoIf I "naturally" wake up after 6/6.5 hours, does that mean that my body needs less sleep, or I should control more variables to sleep 8 hours (light, temperature, melatonin..) ? (I do feel great some days when I sleep for longer..)
- overcast 9y agoDo you feel well rested after that? Or do you feel run down? If the former, that's how much is required for you. Myself, I need nearly exactly 8 hours. More is fine, but anything less and I will feel like garbage for the whole day.
- cesnja 9y agoExperiment by going to bed sooner. Personally I figured out there's a certain time in the morning when I'll wake up which does not depend on the time spent sleeping. After some trials, I figured that less than ~7 hours of sleep will leave me in a bad mood, but only in the afternoon -- I seem to function quite well in the morning.
- RandomInteger4 9y ago6-8 hours, depending on your body, unless people who say they're fine on 6 hours are just lying to themselves and others. From what I've experienced, I think the time of day you go to bed matters as well, meaning even with a full fresh perfect feeling 8 hours, your body doesn't enter REM the same or produce the same amount of growth hormone or clean out the brain properly if you go to sleep everyday at say 6am vs sometime shortly after sun down. I guess it has to do with the light levels you experience.
- grwthckrmstr 9y agoAs people have pointed out, it completely depends on your body. However, a good measure to see whether you're fully rested is to be aware of your energy levels after you wake up, and to be aware whether you feel sleepy/sleep deprived (not the I ate too much sleepy) during the middle of the day. I've found them to be good indicators to whether i need to catch up on my sleep.
- yodsanklai 9y agoI'd add healthy eating habit.
- andai 9y agoI recently discovered the "holy trinity" of human energy and metabolism: regular sleep, regular meals and regular exercise. My previous chaotic approach caused chaotic (and very sub-optimal) energy levels. I realized instead of working on my productivity directly, I need to work on stabilizing my energy level, because everything else ultimately depends on that. Regular sleep, meals and exercise, practiced consistently, get your body into a pattern, where at each time of day it knows whether it should be releasing energy or resting, so it gets easier over time as the metabolism begins to work with your plans rather than against them.
- ambivalents 9y agoI wonder if intermittent fasting has a place here. It has many health benefits; what is the optimum regularity of meals? To expand - I generally fast from 7pm in the evening until 2pm the next day. This helps me with appetite/weight control, discipline, and I overall feel better this way. That said, I'm also a lot more productive later in the day. I chalk it up to not being a morning person, but maybe IF is working against me here. However, I notice when I eat in the morning, I feel off the rest of the day. Figuring out the right balance here is harrd, man.
- andai 9y agoDo you do this on certain days of the week, or every day? I'd like to expand on the Holy Trinity by saying not only does chaotic sleep/meals/exercise lead to crap energy levels, but also chronic anxiety, because the body never knows what to expect, so it has to be ready for anything.
- ambivalents 9y agoI do it every week day. Weekends I'm a little more lax, I might eat my first meal at 11. That's an interesting perspective on anxiety. I experience some social anxiety, you've given me something to think about.
- InternetUser 9y agoCan you please fill out the first "etc." there? When you have the energy, of course. Thanks.
- always_good 9y agoIf you need more detail about healthy lifestyle, you're better off doing your own basic research than asking someone on HN to give you a few more words.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 9y agoAll these things.. I started exercising in May, my brain was working fine before and I see no difference now that I'm exercising. The improvements are my muscles (yay), my back pain is gone, and I can eat more. But that's it. Oh and contrary to popular belief, I sleep worse when I exercise because overnight my body emits so much heat that I sweat myself (but if I don't cover myself I get woke up by cold), and the adrenaline is there and makes harder to fall asleep (even 4 hours after gym). I still sleep better without sport. But I'm happy that backpain is gone and I can eat more, so I'm going to stick with it ;)
- RandomInteger4 9y agoYeah, I experience that same heat related exercise induced insomnia in the summer. Even in the summer though, I absolutely must have some blanket or something, or else I feel weird. Counter intuitively, I feel cooler wearing a shirt to bed in the summer as well, even with a blanket. Right now though it's so cold where I live that I can just dress warm and cover up with the comforter, whilst saving money on heating.
- coldtea 9y ago>All these things.. I started exercising in May, my brain was working fine before and I see no difference now that I'm exercising. Doesn't say much. You could have had excellent physical condition, good diet, etc before you're started exercizing and be young to begin with.
- always_good 9y agoAlso, seems a bit silly to be dismissive just because you aren't acutely aware of changes in your body. You also don't notice your own day-to-day cognitive decline due to environmental pollution and aging. I don't even know how you'd be aware of, say, memory improvements unless you're quite scientific about it.
- stefantheard 9y agoAgreed. It's very difficult and definitely a learned skill to even be able to tell why or how your body/mind feels different day to day. You always feel the big things "I feel great!" "I feel like shit." but really digging down into "I am slightly annoyed right now" or "I am frustrated and cannot focus" is more nuanced. As I have grown older and have been fortunate enough to increase stability in my life I have had more time to focus on my own health and state of mind. Only recently have I began to realize what is going on and possible causes (dehydration, lack of sleep, overtraining, etc). This is just happening now after two years of consistent (3-6 days a week) training (brazilian jiu jitsu, rock climbing, or powerlifting)
- Dowwie 9y agoAerobic exercise dramatically reduces cognitive function for hours immediately afterwards. How does this resolve with these findings?
- terraforming 9y agoProvide a source to your claims.
- darrenf 9y agoMy anecdotal experience (5-10k run 3 lunchtimes a week, followed by productive afternoons) doesn't seem to back this up. Can you quote a source for those findings?
- mlevental 9y agosource? last year I ran the 7 miles to work every day and never felt was you're claiming
- lucidguppy 9y agoIt would be nice if the government came up with a basic calisthenics program for the average person to follow. A lot of people cant afford a gym - or sometimes it's too cold. There is so much info about exercise and health that it ends up being "non-information". People give up. If the public health system gave a consistent message about exercise when you can't afford a gym or if it's too cold out - people would be better off.
- andai 9y agoI love to be out and about, but it's been really cold and dark lately and I've been struggling. At the very least I make myself run up and down the apartment stairwell a couple times to wake myself up. I realized that unless I wake up my body, it stays half asleep, and my mind suffers too.
- Jach 9y agoI really doubt this information overload is the limiting factor. Everyone knows what a pushup is. Everyone had to take PE in public schooling (government already solved your problem) and knows many exercises that can be done indoors without needing the whole gym. But exercise sucks.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> I really doubt this information overload is the limiting factor. It's definitely a factor. Even if you filter out the utter bullshit (which is a task in itself), there's a huge amount of stuff out there around the theme of "exercising wrong", most of which doesn't agree about anything outside a handful of basics (e.g. sit-ups aren't very good at engaging abs) and much of which warns of injury if you fail to heed the advice. Are crunches a good exercise, or will they wreck my spine? How deep should I squat? What are the tradeoffs between high weight/low reps versus low weight/high reps? Are resistance bands or dumbbells worthwhile, or is barbell training so superior that anything else is a waste of time? The answers all seem to depend on which "school" of exercise you subscribe to. > Everyone knows what a pushup is. I know what a pushup is, but I can't actually do one, and it's not obvious how to progress it in a practical way ("wall pushups" aren't challenging, but going down to chair level is too much). There are a lot of practical issues like this that are glossed over by mainstream exercise advice (most of which seems to be written for relatively young, fit people with no chronic health issues that might interfere). > But exercise sucks. There's a huge amount of disagreement on this as well. Statements like "your body wants to move" are a common refrain from fitness gurus, for example. The chemical and neurological responses to exercise seem to vary quite a bit throughout the population, all the way from exercise triggering euphoria to exercise triggering depression (but it's only socially accepted to advertise the former). It's also pretty common in exercise studies for a given outcome measure to get no better or even get worse in ~10% of subjects, even when the average response is a statistically significant improvement. Conversely, there's often a ~10% with a markedly above-average improvement; this has been spun by the popular press as some people being "superexercisers" and others being "non-responders", but it seems to be much more complicated than that (i.e. one can be a "superexerciser" on one axis but a "non-responder" on another).
- Jach 9y agoTitle is pretty bad. The actual claim is "exercising twice a week may help preserve memory and thinking skills in people with mild cognitive impairment." Meanwhile things like https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00642/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.0064... directly contradict the title. That is, exercise et al. are good to help cognitive functioning but have no prediction on cognitive performance.
- Toast_25 9y agoThis just in, your brain is actually part of your body! Taking care of it might make you think better, stay tuned folks! In all seriousness, if anybody here has a beer or glass of wine before you go to sleep, cut it out for a week or two. You'll notice a HUGE improvement in sleep quality.
- hackermailman 9y agoSome schools in Canada use exercise bikes to help kids focus on lessons, though there's little research on this https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/stationary-bikes-in-the-classroom-are-we-spinning-out-of-control/article29770497/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/stationary-bikes-in-... My own anecdote is it seems to work, 20-30mins of high intensity bike riding followed by a shower and somehow I can sit and do 2-3 hours worth of focused work on a math text without my mind jumping around distracted in random thoughts or becoming bored.
- skydv 9y agoi say daily. If I don't do it only one day, next day I can't really code until I jog for 40 min. Then the mind becomes clear