8 ms·
What We Get Wrong About Dying
- nulbyte 9y agoI'm sure this is interesting, but if I can't read a simple article without enabling cookies, the site isn't worth my time.
- agumonkey 9y agoas usual pf is your friend: https://app.printfriendly.com/print?source=homepage&url_s=uGGC_~_PdN_~_PcS_~_PcSAnHGvymHF_~_PcSvFFHr_~_PcSff_~_PcSGEHFG_~_PcSJunG-Jr-trG-JEBAt-noBHG-qLvAt https://app.printfriendly.com/print?source=homepage&url_s=uG...
- amriksohata 9y agoThe biggest thing we get wrong is living like we will live forever and assuming we will never die and therefore never prepare for it whether it be financially or spiritually
- tw1010 9y agoHow should one prepare financially for the fact that you're going to die one day?
- wildleaf 9y agoHave money to be independent in your final years so that you can be cared for appropriately without burdening your family.
- melling 9y agoThat could be a decade or more. For instance, some people are living longer because of medical advances. Alzheimer’s might be more of a problem as more people live into their 80’s, 90’s... https://www.livescience.com/59261-alzheimers-deaths-increase.html https://www.livescience.com/59261-alzheimers-deaths-increase...
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThat's true but it doesn't effect what GP said. Many of us on HN are in professions where we are able to save enough money to live without being productive after the age of 65. But also many of the people reading this will be 50 years old and have the option to purchase a second (vacation home), or a boat, or a fancy sports car, OR completely secure their retirement. Many of us will choose one of these luxury items and hope everything works out rather than saving for a retirement that could last into our 90's.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- matte_black 9y agoAnd many still might forego those luxury items and instead save for retirement, only to be dead, buried and forgotten at 71, all the same. It’s a balance. Money, Age, Enjoyment. Most can choose two, some can choose all, and some can choose none.
- jcadam 9y agoI'm 37 and am counting on effective anti-aging treatments to come along before I'm too old to work. Then I won't need to retire and can continue working for the man until the end of time.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dh-g 9y agoAnd for those who don't have that option / affluence?
- wildleaf 9y agoThen you'll have to rely on your family. I have an elderly neighbor with no money/family and it's quite depressing. She often can't feed herself or clean her apartment due to chronic pain. She's bipolar, suffers from COPD, and lives in filth. She can't afford any kind of assisted living, and has to rely on her rapidly diminishing friends (who're old and dying) to help her get through the day.
- kingnothing 9y agoPrepare for your end of life costs as well as what will happen to the remainder of your assets and debts. Write a will. Talk with an estate attorney. Consider adding names of your loved ones to your bank accounts and assets in order to avoid probate. I'm not a lawyer or accountant, but I had to deal with the financial aspects of an unexpected death in my family. Had there been any kind of planning, it would have made everything much easier for those who were survived, and saved a large amount of money that the estate had to pay out during the probate process.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoAs you get older and your loved ones (e.g. parents) start leaving, you become much more aware of your own mortality! I lost my last parent this year, and it bothers me a lot that my mom left at 59 and dad left at 70.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoThe biggest thing we get wrong is assuming we will live forever without taking specific steps to make that more likely to happen. By far the most important open problem to be solved, and not nearly enough attention or resources on it. I wish we treated the elimination of aging and age-related degeneration the way we do traveling to the Moon, or Mars.
- zipwitch 9y agoWe treat them almost exactly the same. As the province of starry-eyed dreamers to whom we pay lip service while only allowing them a pittance in comparison to what we spend on wars, enriching the few at the expense of the many, and indulging our varied desires for swift gratification.
- elwell 9y ago"He has made everything beautiful in its time. He has also set eternity in the human heart;" - Ecclesiastes 3:11
- reasonattlm 9y agoThe biggest thing? Since arguably sometime in the 1930s the technological capacity has existed to store at least the brains of dead individuals at liquid nitrogen temperatures indefinitely, waiting on a future that can restore them. In a different, better world, the funerary industry was swept aside by mass cryopreservation, and the vaults of those who would one day live again would be now be vast. The biggest thing we get wrong is that we continue to equate clinical death to oblivion, rather than it being only the second worst thing that can happen to you, and acting accordingly.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThe technology exists to feed and house everyone too, which seems like a more pressing goal.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoA hundred and fifty thousand people die every day. We have the resources to solve multiple problems at once.
- anigbrowl 9y agoYes, but not the political will. Death in and of itself doesn't bother me since it's a natural process, albeit a sad one. I've had ample opportunity to consider my own mortality, having had quite a few brushes with death.
- eitland 9y agoIf anybody wonders why this is currently downvoted it might be because it shows a huge lack of understanding of the real issues here. Let me mention a couple: Who decides people living now are more worthy of living than future generations? Who decides who will live forever?
- Smaug123 9y agoThere's not necessarily a "who is more worthy of living" judgment here. Future generations are free to turn off the cooling mechanisms which suspend the bodies or heads of the dying, if they deem it important to have the resources now. In the meantime, it doesn't take that many resources to suspend a head; and the burden would become less if suspension became common enough practice that the "extremely expensive, will either fail or make the rest of your life a hell" procedures were phased out and those resources freed up. The problem I have with your sentences is that they prove too much. They can easily be read, for instance, as advocating that it might be worth abandoning medical science.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThis will sometimes result in clinicians performing painful and pointless procedures on a dying child as weeping parents stand by, watching their child’s final moments in horror, having not understood what they were signing on for. My father had cancer in his late 60s. He wasn't expected to live. He did live about 2 more decades. But following his surgery, he spent considerable time in ICU. At the same time, another elderly patient spent the last two weeks of their life there in ICU. They repeatedly coded and had massive intervention. Doctors routinely did things like drain a gallon of fluid from the lungs, restart their heart, etc. My mother was pretty disgusted. She felt the family knew this woman was never going home again and these torturous treatments were not extending life. They were merely dragging out her death horrifically because the relatives were not yet ready to accept it. In many cases, this is the better answer: ...they tell us that attempting resuscitative efforts that are likely to be futile is not consistent with their values. In these situations, rather than asking for intubation and chest compressions, parents just want to hold their child and find meaning in those final moments of contact.
- magicalhippo 9y agoMy dad had cancer in a lymph node that spread to the lungs, significantly reducing his lung capacity. After a few years of steady decline, he caught pneumonia. After a day of treatment, he knew it was all downhill from there. Doctors said further treatment would likely make him recover from the pneumonia, but that could take months, and scar tissue from the pneumonia would reduce his lung capacity further. Even before the pneumonia he was reliant on oxygen supply at home just to sit in a chair. So in the early hours of the second day, he requested they turn off the oxygen supply. A doctor got called in to ensure he knew what the consequences could be, which he did, and then they turned off the oxygen. He passed away peacefully a few hours later. Painful as it was to lose him, I'm so glad they respected his decision.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- williamdclt 9y agoIn which country did this happen? This sounds illegal in quite a lot of countries that I know of (nothing judgemental in this comment, I'm genuinely curious)
- darkerside 9y ago> “Never forget, if you accompany your patients only until the battle is lost and they are dying, if you abandon them at that point and leave them alone, you have done only part of your job, and not done it well. Your job is to accompany your patients until they are either better or safely on the other side.” Worth reading for this line alone. Beautiful.
- kbenson 9y agoEvery once in a while you read something where there's a statement that so epitomizes the content, and seems to resonate so closely with the author, that it's obvious that what they are doing is presenting one of their core beliefs. And not just core as in "I strongly agree" but core as in it's become integral to their way of life and how they perceive the world. Those are interesting pieces, as whether you fully agree with them or not, they are generally well thought out, as the author can and has put quite a lot of time into thinking about the subject.
- hammock 9y agoDo we really get that part wrong, though? There are specialties like hospice care and anointing of the sick, which accompany patients after "the battle is lost" and ensure they comfortably and safely make it to "the other side." These tasks are just done by people other than your oncologist.
- darkerside 9y agoIt reminds me a bit (perhaps oddly) of technical consulting work. Sure you can check the box, deliver the letter of the contract, and collect your pay. There's a difference between that and building what the customer wants, not what they need; driving end user adoption to make the project successful; caring about outcomes and satisfying your stakeholders, not just about solving the technical challenge as it is presented. There are specialist techies who want nothing to do with half that equation, and don't need to pretend that they do because they are so valued for the specialized thing at which they are a truly expert professional. If you're not like that, another way to add value is by blending technical skills with the other half of that equation.
- rayalez 9y agoRelevant article from Slate Star Codex - Who by very slow decay: http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay/ One of the most impactful things I've read in my life.
- andrewjl 9y agoWith sufficient time and resources, death can be prevented. https://nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon.html https://nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon.html
- ssivark 9y agoA truly cathartic read. This soulful article's understanding of the process and trauma of bereavement touched me profoundly. Such empathy is rare in modern bureaucracy -- something about doing things at scale numbs us to the emotions of individuals. For another keen perspective on how doctors deal with terminal illness in personal life, as humans, rather than as professionals, see this: http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2013/03/06/in-the-magazine/health-in-the-magazine/how-doctors-die.html http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2013/03/06/in-the-magazin...
- eecc 9y agoI struggle to find enough words of gratitude for people like the author. The amount of trauma and stress they endure to do someone else some good is something I cannot even imagine myself doing.
- ivm 9y ago"We live in a culture where it has been rubbed into us that to die is a terrible thing. And that is a tremendous disease from which our culture suffers, and we notice it firstly in the way in which death is swept under the carpet. This is one of the major problems in hospitals — when a family conspires with the doctor to keep from grandmother the knowledge that she is dying. Grandmother suspects that she is dying but probably doesn’t really want to know for sure and her family talk with her in such a way as to say, 'Well you’re probably be getting alright in a few weeks' — because they have this funny feeling that it’s important to build up courage and hope. And so they become liars and the mutual mistrust develops. So the person is left to die alone, suddenly, unprepared, and doped up to the point where death hardly happens. And there is no derivation from it of the peculiar spiritual experience that can come with death." – Alan Watts
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> We live in a culture where it has been rubbed into us that to die is a terrible thing. Not nearly enough, or we'd do more about it on a systematic basic. It's an abstract kind of professing of it being terrible (leaving aside people who don't even manage to do that much), without any of the concrete action that could take place if it was actually treated as a horrific tragedy on a species-wide scale.
- ivm 9y agoI'd say it has more to do with our overall poor long-term planning capabilities.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoI'd argue it has more to do with widespread cultural taboos about what it's "acceptable" to challenge and what deviates too far from the norm.
- drb91 9y agoWell, it's certainly acceptable to challenge it, but fear of death is rather dogmatic and polarizing. Many people, from diverse backgrounds of philosophy, have submitted world views where the quality of life and your impact matters more than your length of time. Others, like many on this forum, I suspect, have argued we should be investing in fighting death and aging, using war and financial metaphors, without establishing why this is such a worthwhile fight and/or investment. Why length of life and not quality of life? For sure, they're related, but how you frame these questions will dictate the response and interest in the conversation. I doubt humans as a whole will ever feel strongly that death is a negative force. However, improving quality of life is one of the easiest pitches to make, and doesn't necessarily disproportionally value the rich. In fact, the least worthwhile place to spend improving the quality of life would be people with enough money to dictate it already. But hey—the idea of living for centuries is cool, I always wanted to be an elf.
- andrewjl 9y agoOur culture, and even our language, fails us by treating death as a given and as something we passively accept. There are many avenues of research to achieve radical life extension, and it's a worthy thing to pursue.
- techman9 9y agoThat's true in the abstract sense, but this article primarily deals with the weeks, days, and hours immediately preceding death.
- theonemind 9y agoDeath is a given. If we manage biological "immortality", then the heat death of the universe should come along eventually.
- temp-dude-87844 9y agoThere are several things we -- as a broad generalization over many societies -- get wrong about dying, and this article illustrates one of them in the medical, caregiver sense. While there are several contributing factors, like an activist reading of the Hippocratic Oath and fear for malpractice claims against the caregivers, this reckoning is consistent with the value system of many societies that assumes that one's informed choices must always tilt towards their continued life, and any feelings to the contrary are morally corrupt or simply misinformed, and therefore don't confer valid consent. It's impossible to separate analyses of one's own medical death without considering wishes of one's death in the general case. Modern societies tend to make discussing death taboo, not just because it's an uncomfortable topic to grapple with, but also because people who can control the terms of their own exit have an opportunity to do great harm in ways that can't be disincentivized by punishment. It's no accident that religions attempt to rectify this loophole by ensuring that mortal deeds will determine one's fate after death.
- oldandtired 9y agoWe live in a world where death is inevitable. All of our systems wear out. Within the various cultures across the globe, death is viewed in very different lights. Sometimes we can do something about it, sometimes we can't. Death can, in some cases, be quick and painless and in others slow and painful. How an individual handles this is very much up to that individual's internal being. What doesn't help is other people acting and living their lives in such a manner that brings hopelessness to the individual affected. The medical fraternity is one group that regularly hides death from themselves and the patients and their families. Yet they will also regularly kill those who they feel have nothing left to live for and without regard to those individuals themselves. When I was at university all those decades ago, the medical students of the time had courses in handling death - how to deal with death themselves and how to deal with patients who are dying and how to deal with families so affected. It didn't seem to help those medical students. My own wife has survived four different kinds of cancers. The treatments she has undergone over the years has adversely affected her body and she suffers much now from those treatments from the past. We have been blessed that we are together and that we have seen and are seeing our children grow and our grandchildren grow. Just by living, each of us will face both good and bad. How we live each day is predicated on what gives us hope and what we see for the future. If there is no hope then death is a dark time ahead. For me and mine, death, when it comes, will be a doorway into a better, greater future in the glorious presence of my God and Saviour. Till that time, we are here to live as examples to those around us with hope, joy and love.