4 ms·
So the right thing is to have phones crash as the battery age? This is not a question about battery life in terms of how many hours the phone can run. This is
by wodenokoto 9y ago
So the right thing is to have phones crash as the battery age?
This is not a question about battery life in terms of how many hours the phone can run. This is a question about the phones ability to draw high amounts of power for short intervals.
- kleptco 9y agoThe right thing is that people who replaced their deliberately slowed down iPhones with new iPhones because of their ignorance about what Apple had done, should have an appropriate remedy not contained in this "we're sorry if you didn't understand that we care a lot about you" press release. It doesn't matter anyway, even though millions of similar batteries in Android phones apparently didn't require a similar secret performance degradation, we are still a long way from reaching the depths that Apple can go to before Apple fans will seriously consider an alternative.
- bb88 9y agonitpick: "ignorance" puts the blame on the consumer -- in this case it's not their fault. > should have an appropriate remedy I think a lawsuit is appropriate.
- rlanday 9y ago> even though millions of similar batteries in Android phones apparently didn't require a similar secret performance degradation You know for sure how the power-management code works in every Android device ever produced?
- JesseObrien 9y ago> we are still a long way from reaching the depths that Apple can go to before Apple fans will seriously consider an alternative. You're literally proving the point here. There's much, much more transparency on the Android side of things. Custom ROMs and the stock Google Android images have been combed over for almost the last decade by loads of different individuals and groups around the world. Now, we surely don't control the Samsung-esque bloatware that they slap on top of stock Android, but there's absolutely no way there's throttling code that lives in Android that we don't know about yet. Anecdotal evidence of my own: I have a Nexus 5 that's nearly 5 years old now that my kids use daily. It's using a stock Lineage ROM. The battery certainly isn't the best anymore, but the phone doesn't feel different than the day I bought it, and it doesn't crash.
- greedo 9y agoAndroid does/did the same: https://plus.google.com/+YgorCortes/posts/CZ2GhoxgHk3 https://plus.google.com/+YgorCortes/posts/CZ2GhoxgHk3
- kleptco 9y agoGood point, must of helped Google sell another dozen of them. Thats what makes this whole thing creepy, how many iPhones did this scheme sell for Apple - I imagine a non-trivial number.
- freedomben 9y agoI don't understand the opposition to giving the customer a choice. If they prefer a crashing but faster phone, what do you or Apple care? The default setting can be to slow down, then if someone cares enough they can change it. This seems not only reasonable, but optimal. But then again, I'm on Android now precisely because of this attitude of hiding information and configuration abilities (I hate paternalism), so I'm not the target market.
- gordyf 9y agoYou really want Apple to put a “Crash: on/off” checkbox in Settings?
- freedomben 9y agoLol yes, it should totally say "crash" and then "true/false". In fact the user should have to type the string "true" or "false" in a text box rather than using a switch or check box. Fallacies involved in your response: strawman and false dichotomy.
- WerstPerson 9y agoYour response involves: entitled assholism, idiocy
- sbuk 9y agoFor many, choice is a burden, especially technical choice.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThe right thing is to be honest with users about the state of their equipment. Many, many people shelled out to replace their "dying" phone when all they really needed was a new battery. I don't believe that Apple didn't intend that.
- stouset 9y agoHave you never worked at a large organization? Things that appear like a good idea locally within an organization can easily be bad decisions at the scale of the company as a whole. It's not like Tim Cook or higher-ups personally had any idea that this was being done, much less asked for it to happen — this was likely just one of a million mini-features that team within Apple ship every release. One that was even likely well-intentioned, if poorly thought-out.
- kryptiskt 9y agoAs the ultimate cause is a bad design where they have underprovisioned the battery with little margin for degradation, presumably in order to fit it into a thinner phone, it becomes Apple to handle the issue in a transparent way. The right action for Apple then is not to degrade the performance to hide the problem under the rug, but to make it clear to the customer how they can have the phone serviced in order to make it work like before. Apple is so lucky that this got noticed and they got called on it. The alternative is that millions of customers would continue to get an inexplicably bad user experience, which would chip away on their reputation in a more indirect but not less dangerous way than facing the press.
- compiler-guy 9y agoThe battery is not underprovisioned. Every single battery starts to go bad eventually. The question is what to do when it does.
- kryptiskt 9y agoOf course it is, if it can't deliver the current the phone requires after some usage it's not fit for purpose. It's BECAUSE every single battery starts to go bad that they should have put in a battery that will work after a couple of years of degradation.
- mlindner 9y agoLol. You can't just violate battery physics because you want it to be so.
- imtringued 9y agoOlder phones manage to violate those just fine.