14 ms·
A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient
- Jedi72 9y agoThe suit is back!
- atarian 9y agoNon-paywall link: http://archive.is/XwCtU http://archive.is/XwCtU
- lafar6502 9y agotech-driven kaboom? oh no, not again
- evolighting 9y agoYES, "Tech-driven", but FOR PROFILE. SO it is none of ordinary people's business. It is economy, not people's wages.
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop using uppercase for emphasis in HN comments? This is basically yelling, and it's against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- swarup182 9y agoHasn't it been coming like every 4/5 years after internet (web) happened.
- inciampati 9y agoI have frequently wondered if the lag in productivity is partly due to the distracting power of the internet and social media. This isn't really paralleled by the other technical advances that the authors of the study this piece summarizes were examining. Also, AI? We don't have anything even approaching AI in play now nor on the immediate horizon. The energy costs it would have are still enormous, even if we really could implement it. Maybe that's a revolution that's yet to begin. We got really good at problems that can be mapped into single precision matrix algebra, where the inputs and outputs are relatively small. It's a big jump to hard AI from there.
- rectang 9y ago> We got really good at problems that can be mapped into single precision matrix algebra, where the inputs and outputs are relatively small. General AI is a "wave of the future -- always has been, always will be" technology. Only when a piece gets broken out from general AI do we get practical benefits. The benefits from applying all that matrix algebra aren't small, though!
- eggie 9y agoSo we are breaking off small pieces of a bigger thing. If that thing is AI, does it already have a form and an older name in the world? Would agree that in this article AI is a stand-in for what used to be called Math, Statistics, and Computer Science? Our scientific output is an artifice, and it is "intelligent" in its ability to guide our action. To me it isn't then strange to think of the sciences as the "general AI".
- Wildgoose 9y ago"A third of the rise in the S&P 500 stock market index this year is attributable to Apple Inc., Amazon.com Inc., Google parent Alphabet Inc., Facebook Inc. and Microsoft Corp." And yet don't those companies directly employ only around 150,000 workers in total? Yes, Apple off-shores employment to Foxconn but they are open about their plans to automate their factories and replace all the workers. This isn't a matter of patience, it's waiting on the never-never.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agothat's not the argument the article was making - they note that tech and media (the fastest growing sectors, which not coincidentally employ most intensively IT workers) are just 5% of economy. the argument is that when the rest of the economy employs IT at the same level of intensity, the remaining 95% will have similar productivity growth and hence see gains of wealth creation. we then have to work out how to distribute those gains (hopefully fairly and equitably) There is a oft quoted parallel with electricity replacing steam in factories- it took a generation or more for factories to stop being clustered around one large steam engine, running each corner of the factory to the speed of one central spindle. the idea is that eventually companies will adapt to use "Digital" rather than adapting digital to fit them. As a mental sanity check, think about just how, ignoring ML/AI, just how advanced you could rewrite any company you have worked in in past ten years. All the crappy inefficiencies, the pointless spreadsheets. And you have probably worked at the tech end of the economy. is today's IT usage really the best we can do as a society? i doubt it - there seems to be a lot of room for improvement...
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThe limits are human - psychological, emotional, political - not technological. So yes - today's limits probably are the best we can do, in this society at least. Also, just because it's "obvious" that it's possible to re-engineer a company's code base, that doesn't mean it's as easy as it looks.
- mistermann 9y ago
- godzillabrennus 9y agoIf you want to avoid the paywall: http://archive.is/XwCtU http://archive.is/XwCtU
- DeonPenny 9y agoI'm hoping it's bioengineering .
- petegordon 9y agoAnyone else questioning this, “The integrated circuit was commercialized in the 1960s yet 25 years later computers still represented just 5% of the value of all business equipment”? ICs are everywhere around us (in our phones, cars, refrigerators, coffee makers, weight scales, HVAC, etc.) and are rightfully invisible to us. Let alone all the major business equipment. Or, am I missing something?
- empath75 9y ago25 years later was in the late 1980s
- petegordon 9y agoGood point. Thanks.
- DougHaber 9y agoAs pointed out, 25 years later was in the 80s. I wonder if some of the delay in adoption was due to the relevant patents, which were filed around 1959. Maybe that gave a two decade monopoly to Texas Instruments making it hard for others to adopt or innovate around the technology?
- andars 9y agoTI definitely did not have a monopoly on ICs for those 25 years. Those first patents were on Kilby's process which was essentially abandoned. Fairchild and Intel did a tremendous amount of work getting ICs to be more useful over that timespan (see self-aligned gates).
- adavidoaiei 9y agoEpyc amd for datacenter, titan v
- adavidoaiei 9y agoEpyc amd, titan v
- jgalt212 9y agoThe boom will come when the monopolies are broken up and the excess profits filter through the rest of the economy.
- true_tuna 9y agoDon’t post paywalled articles. Do you want a paywalled internet? Because that’s how you get a paywalled internet.
- vannevar 9y agoIncome for the top 1% of the population is up over 400% over the past 30 years, while remaining largely flat for the rest of the workforce. The tech boom is well underway, it's just that only a tiny fraction of the population is capturing the vast majority of the benefits. The boom is not just about efficiencies, it's also about centralization and winner-take-all market dynamics.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoGlobal absolute poverty has plummeted from 40% in 1985 to less than 10% in 2015: https://ourworldindata.org/slides/world-poverty/#/declining-world-poverty-1820-2015-step2 https://ourworldindata.org/slides/world-poverty/#/declining-...
- yomly 9y agoI see this fact touted around a lot, often in the context of stagnating/eroding wages. It 100% goes without saying that global poverty decreasing is cause for celebration, but eroding quality of life for a economic bracket of people should not be ignored. If you look at both facts together however (global poverty is down, wealth has concentrated at the top) then it would suggest that the wealth of the non-wealthy has merely been redistributed. Indeed, this is intuitive if you consider the trend of moving your labour to a cheaper country. Having travelled to many developing nations, it also (admittedly anecdotally) feels evident that most the wealth reaching developing nations is concentrating with the already wealthy / those in power. So what it feels to me is like that local inequality is increasing while global inequality is decreasing - the rich are getting richer everywhere while the working and middle classes are slowly converging everywhere. Unfortunately, as history has so far told, the notion that the erosion of the quality of life has led to improvements of life to someone very far away is a hard sell.
- prostoalex 9y agoThe wages are a proxy for buying power. Starting at the bottom of the Maslow’s pyramid and moving up, do today’s wages buy less of food, shelter, water, clothing, transportation, etc. than someone receiving wages 30/50/100/200 years ago?
- graycat 9y agoAutomation is usually deflationary. Deflation is the easiest problem in the world to solve -- just print money. So, print it and pass it out. As people spend the money, we don't have to give raises to the robots. If a few rich people end up with nearly all the money, then tax it back and pass it out again.
- lightblade 9y agohttps://apple.news/AtfflfmCvRzublEC6RnuxmQ https://apple.news/AtfflfmCvRzublEC6RnuxmQ Apple News link bypasses the paywall
- studioego 9y agohmm
- monksy 9y agoWhen people talk about AI and Robotics, I don't believe there is na understanding about how complex those topics are and how difficult it is. AI: There's a lot of active research, and there has been a lot of aggressive pushes to be buzzword compliance there. I think this has a lot of potential to make improvements, but with AI you have to understand what you're doing there. (To be effective) I think there would be a lot of value in having research institutions on AI (and a consultancy). Robotics: We've seen a lot of improvements on this, but I'm not getting the feeling that it's a mature technology. We're still having difficulty getting this to be easier to implement and working with it. The algorithms behind navigation, and motor control are intense and have taken a lot of research.
- zengid 9y ago[meta question] Are most HN readers subscribers of wsj? I never see anybody mark these posts as pay-walled.. Either way I'm considering buying a subscription.
- sigmonsays 9y agoother folks have mentioned it, its not desirable to receive pay-wall articles. Don't post them, its not polite. For everyone else, Non-paywall link: http://archive.is/XwCtU http://archive.is/XwCtU
- jessaustin 9y agoMaybe this was because I read TFA outside the paywall, but I find the included chart obnoxious in that it just has a vertical scale from 100 to 300, with no indication as to what that scale represents. Is it sales? Productivity? Number of press releases? Who knows?