3 ms·
> it's clear to anyone with a thread of financial literacy That's argument from intimidation and not a valid form of argumentation. > In effect, late stage ca
by adventured 9y ago
> it's clear to anyone with a thread of financial literacy
That's argument from intimidation and not a valid form of argumentation.
> In effect, late stage capitalism becomes the anti-thesis of the spirit of capitalism - devoid of competition, free innovation, and upward mobility
Fortunately the world isn't in late stage Capitalism, because there is no such thing. As one obvious example, China has only begun to emerge from its backwards Communist shell, it's still in the first innings of its application of basic market economics. It's still doing trial runs market economic structures in things like asset ownership in general (eg equities), banking and real-estate. Its currency and bond markets are in the very early development stage. Other emerging economies such as Vietnam, Nigeria, Brazil, India are similarly going through their own very early stage experiments with market economic structures.
In the US, more people are moving up and out of the middle class, than are moving down and out of it. That has been the consistent trend for 50, 30, 15, 10 years.
There's zero evidence to support the notion that either the US or the world are meaningfully devoid of competition. It's competetion in fact that is terrifying so many. 20 years ago Google, Amazon, Facebook, Netflix, Apple, Priceline, SpaceX, Airbnb, Oracle, PayPal/Stripe/Square, Cisco, Uber/Lyft, Airbnb, Spotify, Tesla, T-Mobile, eBay, et al. were either non-existent or small compared to established corporate giants. That's just for the US, China has hundreds of business giants that didn't exist 20 years ago at all.
There's so much competition coming from the US tech giants, the EU is taking aggressive government intervention steps to begin restraining them from routing European competition. That's the exact opposite scenario of not having competition.
Leaders in AI? Not IBM. It's AWS, Google, Microsoft, etc.
Leaders in vehicle automation? GM had to buy its way back to the table, Ford is still running far behind. Companies like Google, Tesla, Uber, and dozens of smaller SV companies, have led the charge.
Leader in electrification of vehicles? Tesla has overwhelmingly led the charge, most everyone else (except perhaps for Nissan and partially GM) is running from years behind.
ULA for the future of space launch? No, it's SpaceX and Blue Origin.
GE? Dying.
Exxon? Dying.
IBM? 21 straight quarters of revenue decline.
Alcoa? Who?
US Steel? Who?
Sears? Dead. Walmart? Mortally terrified of a company that didn't exist in 1993. JC Penney? Dead. KMart? Dead.
Pfizer & Merck? Say hello to Celgene, Biogen, Gilead, Amgen, Regeneron, Vertex, Genzyme, et al.
Banking? Welcome to the online, payments, crypto revolution. Ant Financial is moving more money every year than most of the US financial giants; it didn't exist in 2003. Square, Stripe, PayPal, Ant, Google, Facebook, Apple, Samsung, et al. are setting the stage, not JP Morgan or Bank of America.
Travel? Priceline is more powerful than most airlines or large hotel chains. Ditto Airbnb.
Taxi industry? Largely dead, destroyed, bankrupt. Million dollar medallions? Gone. Say hello to Lyft, Uber, Didi, et al.
Food delivery etc? Booming. Dominated by Sysco, McDonalds, Procter & Gamble, Kraft Heinz? Nope. Companies like UberEats, Grubhub, Blue Apron, and dozens more.
Old media? Dying and desperate. Newspapers? Dead. Old radio giants? Dead. Cable? Bleeding out. Say hello to Netflix, Spotify, Amazon, Hulu, Facebook, YouTube, etc.
The list just keeps going.
- Danihan 9y ago- "Innovate or die" Thanks for this post, pretty amazing to read through these.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoYou should try another piece of rather good poetry: "Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. [...] All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned, and man is at last compelled to face with sober senses his real conditions of life, and his relations with his kind." https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch01.htm https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-m...
- oblio 9y agoAll awesome and great for people working in IT. Key questions: 1. How many people worked in the old companies and how many work in the new ones? 2. How many non-IT people work in the new companies? If both answers are what I expect them to be, they point to a huge social problem somewhere along the line.
- tensor 9y ago>In the US, more people are moving up and out of the middle class, than are moving down and out of it. That has been the consistent trend for 50, 30, 15, 10 years. You're going to need to provide a citation for this statement. As for the rest, how many people are getting wealthy from these companies? Largely the same people who were getting wealthy from previous generations, and a few lucky individuals who managed to gain entrance into the elite class. But really, it's the VCs making all the money here. The same sort of "already wealthy" people who have been making most of the money for the past several decades. On your examples, they are extreme hyperbole. GE dying? Their revenue is 123 billion and have over a _quarter million_ employees. They span everything from aviation to healthcare to things like lightbulbs. Presumably you think Tesla is killing them or something? They are at 7 billion revenue and only 33 thousand employees. In automobiles GE has already simply bought self driving and electric car technology and by the time it's mainstream all their cars will have it. Tesla is amazing, but giants like GE have so much wealth they won't be going anywhere that easily, which is part of the point. Ditto for the taxi industry. Dying? They seem to be everywhere still meanwhile Uber and Lyft are getting more and more regulated, or outright banned in some countries and cities. No, the end game isn't the death of taxies here, it's simply a change in the industry. Taxi companies will need to become more like uber and lyft, meanwhile uber and lyft will be regulated to the point where they are little different than taxis. Self driving cars might change the game, but by the time they are normal lots can change. Most of your examples are not example of fundamental change, but rather simply the same rich people changing technology. Cable didn't die, it became netflix, hulu, amazon, disney, etc. Channels become streaming companies. Ads become product placements and internet ads. Same old stuff in new clothes, with the same cast of people running the show.