7 ms·
A History of the Silmarils in the Fifth Age
- appearsonline 9y ago>I would guess that Maglor survived, found his Silmaril, lost his Silmaril again, and that Pulp Fiction is an account of him getting it back. And now I want to rewatch and reread everything again!
- murrayb 9y agoQuite possibly the best thing that I have read in 2017.
- pcnix 9y agoYou might want to give Unsong a try then, it's the same author: http://unsongbook.com/ http://unsongbook.com/
- Wildgoose 9y agoThis is great! A very amusing What If?
- xyzzyz 9y agoIf you enjoyed this, you'll probably enjoy the Unsong book, by the same author. It's basically the same idea, only bigger and better. http://unsongbook.com/ http://unsongbook.com/
- itronitron 9y agoIt reminds me of Thomas Pynchon's writing in which he threads together various bits of historical information to explain current events in a new light, 'The Crying of Lot 49' is a good start for anyone interested but unfamiliar with Pynchon.
- elvinyung 9y agoI feel like Unsong is much more attractive to a community of programmers if you describe it as King James Programming in story form :)
- stared 9y agoAs a note on Santa Claus being something different than we think: "Is Santa Claus a god?" (http://nautil.us/blog/is-santa-claus-a-god http://nautil.us/blog/is-santa-claus-a-god). tl;dr: Omniscience (of child's deeds), rewarding the good (with gifts) and punishing the bad (with coal).
- tootie 9y agoI always wondered how Christians were able to square the existence of Santa with the 2nd commandment. Then again, how they can reconcile Jesus with the 2nd commandment is bit dodgy to me too so what do I know.
- williamdclt 9y agoI don't think any adult Christian thinks that Santa is actually real, so there's nothing to reconciliate
- tootie 9y agoSure, but they're teaching sacrilege to their kids.
- krapp 9y agoOf course, but sacrilege is in the eye of the beholder. It used to be sacrilege to own a Bible not written in Latin and for a layperson to read it directly, now many Christians consider any Bible other than the King James version to be sacrilegious. There's no objectivity or rational thought at work, it's essentially cultural norms and politics. Many Conservative Christians do believe Santa Claus is an attempt by the "atheist establishment" to remove the Christian identity from the holiday, but that's due to a modern interpretation of Santa Claus as a capitalist icon, and the defensive nature of Christian conservatism. No Christian would likely have questioned the "Christianness" of Santa Claus a century ago, when the status of religion in Western society was unquestioned.
- baddox 9y ago
- radicalbyte 9y agoThanks, great read. It really reaffirms the brilliance of Tolkien's work. Lord of the Rings isn't just a nice story, it's a world with its own mythos and history.
- teilo 9y agoI realize this article is a tongue-in-cheek fan theory. However, it does make me wonder what Tarantino was up to with Pulp Fiction. The Ezekiel "quote" always bugged me because even without looking it up, anyone who spent any amount of time in the Old Testament, could tell that it was fabricated. "Finder of lost children" is not an OT motif in general, and certainly not in Ezekiel. Obviously, Tarantino knew people would look it up and go "what the heck is this?" Therefore I have to think it was an intentional move on his part, but why? I think it's a tell that there's a story-under-the-story in Pulp Fiction which lends credence to the other observations. There's obviously something supernatural going on. One of the things I love about the film is that Tarantino doesn't explain anything. He lets mystery stay mystery, as any good story should. I don't buy the Silmarillion connection. Nor do I think that this movie is a loose retelling of any specific classical tale, ala O Brother Where Art Thou. It's more likely that he doesn't have any specific story in mind, but sprinkled the supernatural element into PF to give it an air of mystery. But I'd love to be proven wrong.
- bbctol 9y agoThere's nothing supernatural going on, except that the film is a very obvious and self-aware pastiche of, uh, pulp fiction plots. The Ezekiel quote is borrowed from an old martial arts movie, and the characters fully admit they just say it because it sounds cool before killing someone.
- phonon 9y agoBecause he took it from a kung-fu movie https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LYT4JC2dd4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LYT4JC2dd4
- teilo 9y agoThat's awesome. Thanks for that.
- sevensor 9y agoI think Tarantino put mysteries into Pulp Fiction for the same reason Scott wrote this post -- the mind likes to make connections where there are none. Scott did this quite deliberately, to entertain us both on the meta-level and on the level. I suspect Tarantino added inexplicable elements so that we as the audience would be entertained by speculation. There's nothing underneath. If you want to see what happens when the writers lose their nerve and try to explain everything, watch Lost.
- hyperion2010 9y agoAbsolutely wonderful, now I want to hunt down all the alternative theories so we can test them!
- elvinyung 9y agoExtremely relevant, there's a rational fic that's about exactly this topic: http://archiveofourown.org/works/3451040/chapters/7569143 http://archiveofourown.org/works/3451040/chapters/7569143
- macintux 9y ago"Spoiler warning for The Silmarillion" (but no corresponding spoiler warning for "Pulp Fiction"). I've read The Silmarillion, but not seen Pulp Fiction, so thbbbbbt.
- chaostheory 9y ago> The movie Pulp Fiction centers around a mysterious briefcase. We’re never told exactly what’s inside "Tarantino has admitted that there is no official explanation behind the briefcase’s contents, and that it was simply written into the screen play as an intriguing McGuffin." I liked the soul theory better i.e. Marcelus's soul was in the briefcase and he sold it to the devil.
- logfromblammo 9y agoThe briefcase held a new drug that had been in development for 10 years, ever since Huey Lewis requested it in 1984. The request that it not spill or come in a pill required a novel delivery system, producing the high via modulated stimulation of the optic nerve, but subtracting the shorter blue wavelengths that might disrupt the circadian regulatory system and therefore keep the user up all night or make them sleep all day. Hence, the golden glow. Every time someone opens up the case, they are taking an e-drug.
- chaostheory 9y ago"If you all are anything like me then you had no idea what was in the briefcase in Pulp Fiction. So, through a friend of a friend of a friend who had a two hour conversation with Quentin Tarantino himself, I now know, and I thought I would pass along the information because it makes the movie even 100 times better than it already is. Remember the first time you were introduced to Marsellus Wallace. The first shot of him was of the back of his head, complete with band-aid. Then, remember the combination of the lock on the briefcase was 666. Then, remember that whenever anyone opened the briefcase, it glowed, and they were in amazement at how beautiful it was; they were speechless. Now, bring in some Bible knowledge, and remember that when the devil takes your soul, he takes it from the back of your head. Yep, you guessed it. What is the most beautiful thing about a person: his soul. Marsellus Wallace had sold his soul to the devil, and was trying to buy it back. The three kids in the beginning of the movie were the devil’s helpers. And remember that when the kid at the end came out of the bathroom with a 'hand cannon,' Jules and Vincent were not harmed by the bullets. 'God came down and stopped the bullets' because they were saving a soul. It was divine intervention." https://www.snopes.com/movies/films/pulpfiction.asp https://www.snopes.com/movies/films/pulpfiction.asp