4 ms·
Forgive my ignorance, but who are all these people setting up these forks, and who is actually buying the forked currency? It makes no sense to me.
by nerdponx 9y ago
Forgive my ignorance, but who are all these people setting up these forks, and who is actually buying the forked currency? It makes no sense to me.
- techbubble 9y agoAny change in the network requires consensus among miners, wallet providers and exchanges. The consensus occurs through debate in online forums primarily. When there isn’t consensus, groups go their own way with a fork. If they can garner enough support the fork thrives as an alt coin, otherwise it dies out.
- liquidify 9y agoBitcoin Cash is a fork of bitcoin which has no segwit or RBF and implements larger blocks. Basically it is bitcoin with on chain scaling. No idea about the rest of them, but BCH is pretty popular and pretty usable. Transactions confirm in 1 block and 0-conf transactions are pretty reliable.
- stale2002 9y agoNot only is it popular, but it is currently the third largest crypto currency in the world. It is closing following behind the market cap of ethereum.
- antome 9y agoFor those who like to keep track of these sorts of things, https://coinmarketcap.com/ https://coinmarketcap.com/ is a great resource.
- spiorf 9y agoBy market cap. That is a meaningless number for a coin that magically rained on those who have bitcoins.
- cies 9y agoIf not traded, it has no market cap at all. It has serious cap because it is not traded at 0.001 usd. According to the market it has value.
- topmonk 9y agoI think you can take that with a grain of salt considering how much of it is probably unclaimed at the moment.
- nerdponx 9y agoTo clarify, I was asking about shitcoin forks like Bitcoin Diamond, not BCH.
- oelmekki 9y agoThis is the result of conflicts between bitcoin actors, mainly miners and core devs. We'll probably see more of those, btw, as those conflicts are far from resolved. The core problem is scalability. Miners are very incentivized to fix it, because they get fees on transactions (so, the more transactions the better). Core dev, on their part, want to keep the closest possible to original design (any change can have dramatic consequences). In 2016, scalability issues started to become really serious, and miners asked to increase block size (that is, to allow to add more transactions in a single block, so that transactions wait for less time before being validated). In return, core dev proposed segwit as a solution for scalability problems (I still don't exactly get what segwit does). Miners still wanted to go with block increase, so it was a stall (and scalability problems got worse). A few forks tried to take matters on their hand to fix that problem (although, more like competitive softwares, since they did not use the same blockchain history, they started new blockchains at block 0). In 2017, everybody finally reached an agreement: blocks size will be increased and segwit will be deployed, so both solutions would be implemented. But core devs asked for it to be done in two steps: first segwit, then segwit2x (segwit with double block size). Miners agreed and started to run their mining software with segwit, effectively making it used by the network (Bitcoin cash was born at that time, from miners who wanted block increased, but not segwit). But when came the time to implement the second part of the deal (segwit2x), core devs decided it was not needed anymore (and bitcoin gold was created as a reaction). I would take two things away, here: 1. each time a decision need to be made, it generates a fork from people not agreeing to the final decision 2. the trust between miners and core devs is probably broken, there probably will be more and more forks, and more stalling on main chain This wikipedia article explains more thoroughly the scalability issues: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_scalability_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_scalability_problem
- shawabawa3 9y ago> Miners are very incentivized to fix it, because they get fees on transactions (so, the more transactions the better) This is not true at all. Miners are much better off under bitcoin's crazy fee market (in the short-term at least). No other cryptocurrency is generating anywhere near as much value from transactions as bitcoin
- 9y ago
- xorcist 9y agoThe same people who are buying into all the ICOs, including the obvious scams. The following is my speculation only and not based in any real world data: Many people have found themselves on the winning side of a high risk bet and their Bitcoins are suddenly very valuable. Some of them look to put a part of their winnings in some equally unlikely bet, and it seems like any unlikely bet will do. When enough people do this it becomes self perpetuating.
- cies 9y ago> perpetuating Sounds like it can go on forever. But the reality is that forever it is most certainly not.
- naveen99 9y agoPeople who might have been otherwise applying to ycombinator for social startups or launching ICOs. Speculators.