12 ms·
A link between polygamy and war
- t3rmi 9y agoThis looks like a case of correlation vs causation. The author tries to link polygamy as a factor to unstable states. I would say poverty is a far more common factor among the countries presented. A counter example would be Saudi Arabia which has polygamy but is stable due to its wealth.
- sohkamyung 9y agoThat is true. But the form of polygamy practised in Saudi Arabia appears to be a 'milder' form: only up to 4 wives are allowed and most marriages are monogamous. But no mention of the 'bride price', as far as I can tell [1] [1] https://www.quora.com/In-Saudi-Arabia-are-women-forced-into-polygamous-relationships https://www.quora.com/In-Saudi-Arabia-are-women-forced-into-...
- t3rmi 9y agoI think polygamy just occurs in societies with unequal distribution of power between men and women. The reasons are generally either economic or religious. Poor economic conditions and religious extremes are both breeding grounds for conflict. Polygamy is mostly just a symptom of these two conditions.
- usrusr 9y agoPower imbalance between men and men seems to be just as important. Monogamist societies can be just as misogynic as polygamist societies.
- down 9y agoSaudi Arabia is not stable at all, take out the easy money from oil, and hell breaks lose, you should compare same wealth & polygamy vs non polygamy.
- t3rmi 9y agoAs I said in a comment above polygamy seems to be a symptom of extremes in poverty and/or religious beliefs, both of which are direct causes of conflict/war.
- svantana 9y agoYou consider Saudi Arabia "stable"? They just had a coup d'etat this month, and have been involved in plenty of wars in the region, most recently in Yemen.
- zajd 9y agoI'm not sure "being involved in war" has anything to do with being stable, seeing as the US has been "involved in war" for the past 250 years. Also, Saudi Arabia did not have a coup d'etat by any reasonable definition. MBS "purging" his political opinions does not a coup make.
- svantana 9y agoI only mentioned wars since the article was about wars.
- mezuzi 9y agoBut there is no war inside the country. USA is involved in wars, but it is stable.
- jpalomaki 9y agoOlder article which claims the link between surplus of young men and instability [1]. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/03/angry-young-men-are-making-the-world-less-stable/284364/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/03/an...
- kazagistar 9y agoAn article from the same publication with the same claim is not a good supporting resource.
- mrleiter 9y ago> Wherever it is widely practised, polygamy (specifically polygyny, the taking of multiple wives) destabilises society, largely because it is a form of inequality which creates an urgent distress in the hearts, and loins, of young men. I expected that the sentence ends with "...of young women", because they are obviously seen as objects of a man's wealth and not as individual beings. It is an inequality not only of rich and poor but also one of male and female. How can one not see this?
- owebmaster 9y agoYou are confusing "rich men" with "young men" (and men in general actually). If women are treated as objects by afluent people the ones to blame are the "objects" selling themselves and the buyers.
- 0xdada 9y agoMy guess is because women are already severely oppressed in these societies and it is men's distress that can cause instability because they at least have power.
- krona 9y agoThe men generally don't select the women in these societies; the marriages are arranged by both sets of parents. That's quite a different type of inequality.
- mrleiter 9y agoStill, women have a quite measurable exchange value. And from the perspective of who has what to say in a marriage, gut feeling tells me it is the husband.
- antientropic 9y agoPolygyny may actually be advantageous to most women, while being bad for most men: https://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200707/ten-politically-incorrect-truths-about-human-nature https://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200707/ten-politica.... This is because it allows many women to have a more desirable mate than they would otherwise have, while many men end up with no mate at all. From that perspective, it's no wonder that many patriarchal cultures outlawed polygyny.
- blunte 9y agoI cannot find the excellent psychologist essay about this topic from a few years ago, but here's a relevant summary of the concepts: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/resolution-not-conflict/201109/how-do-sex-and-power-abuses-lead-terrorism-and-war https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/resolution-not-conflict...
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoNow you've got me interested, look harder! (:
- blunte 9y agoIf I find it, I'll post it. I did just find this, however, and it touches on the same concepts (and may lead you to relevant content): https://medium.com/homeland-security/the-sexual-origins-of-terrorism-ab29878db9a5 https://medium.com/homeland-security/the-sexual-origins-of-t...
- captainmuon 9y agoOf course, this applies only if the polygynous marriages are exclusive. I find it in any case hard to imagine how to support four or more wives not just financialy, but also emotionally by myself (unless you think of them as just property). Most people spend hardly enough time with their one spouse. One could imagine that actually polyamourous marriages would reduce violence in such a country. Why don't let your fifth wife be happy when you are busy with the others, or doing warlord stuff... I imagine people thought modern contraception would remove a lot of social norms and taboos around sex and marriage, but that didn't happen. I guess some things die hard.
- a2tech 9y agoYou'll find from the article that in many cases the wives work at some task and the husband takes the money. So supporting them isn't entirely one sided (ie the husband isn't entirely providing). So you could look at wives in a lot of these cases as productive assets-they work, they provide you with children and raise them, and since they have no/little legal rights you can treat them however you want.
- swombat 9y agoPolyamory (mentioned by captainmuon) is a universe away from what's described in the article. I recommend reading the book "Sex At Dawn" for a thorough (if somewhat evangelical) dive into polyamory (as opposed to polygamy or monogamy), and how it has been used throughout human history and prehistory to construct stable societies with strong social bonds.
- DyslexicAtheist 9y agofascinating article. These 2 were mentioned in the comments give additional insight: - Article on brideprice: https://today.tamu.edu/2017/08/08/what-is-brideprice-and-how-is-it-linked-to-terrorism/ - Paper: https://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1162/ISEC_a_00289
- underqwalified 9y agoHN is just not equipped to discuss this sort of thing.
- ashleyn 9y agoI think that's because an acknowledgement that the kind of marriage one selects has an "environmental impact" immediately brings the sacred cow of gay marriage into question. When it really shouldn't. You still have a fundamental right to select the type of relationship that's right for you, but you do have a responsibility to be mindful of its effect on society. This doesn't just mean ban stuff. Perhaps for polygyny, that would translate into making the relationship non-exclusive, rather than choosing against it altogether.
- mLuby 9y agoAgreed w parent (not GP). Ability to choose your relationship structure is usually overridden by economic forces. (Related: do cows suffer from inflation?)
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoFrom past experience I've found that taking an economic/scientific approach to certain things, especially human relationships, is considered a profane act in certain parts of modern day society. Many of my past attempts to discuss the economics of relationships results in accusations of sociopathy for attempting to understand relationships under a transactional framework. I've yet to figure out the cause of such opposition. That HN doesn't result in this reaction (at least not nearly as strongly as other places) means it is one of the places most equipped to discuss it. But it is possible for the most equipped place to discuss something to still be woefully inadequately equipped to discuss it. The richest person in a room can still be poor.
- khrm 9y ago"This is a remarkable article: it literally pins the blame for everything bad that non-white people do on the one thing white people (read Western Europeans) have criticized others for for two millennia: polygamy. Violence? Polygamy. Terrorism? Polygamy. Domestic violence? Polygamy. Child mortality? Polygamy. Of course the article is so high on its own supply that it ignores divorce/remarriage of wives of elite polygamous men and, even more so, that enormous reality of western life: extra-marital sex. Despite this article’s claims, polygamy is always relatively uncommon. It would be good to know how common it is in comparison to men hogging more than one woman in non-marriage sexual relationships. Temporary? So are, in effect, many polygamous marriages. I’m stunned this article got published."- Jonathan Brown
- rayiner 9y agoThe first paragraph is unresponsive. The second paragraph ignores the obvious fact that: 1) in the societies at issue here, divorce and remarriage, and extra-marital sex are not common; and 2) statistics showing that polygamy can be common (e.g. 40% of marriages in the Sudan).
- khrm 9y agoGreat article. So much well researched that author even doesn't know that place where Arab Spring erupt first (Tunisia) has outlawed polygamy. That article claims that all ills are due to polygamy which is complete nonsense. In Daesh countries (Iraq and Syria) polygamy wasn't that common.
- golergka 9y ago> it literally pins the blame for everything bad that non-white people do on the one thing white people ... have criticized others for for two millennia While I don't think that polygamy is the root of all evil, it is a fact that "white people" countries don't have these bad things happening. Wouldn't it be logical to suggest that some difference in behaviour might be the reason for it?
- kazagistar 9y ago
- a2tech 9y agoA neat (for lack of a better word) thing to look at is bride prices-this article briefly touches on it but it was something I discussed a lot with our exchange student from Turkmenistan last year. Prior to our conversation I had never spent much time thinking about how buying a bride would work in practice, but it turns out that it ends up being a fine (although horrible) example of capitalist endeavor. So in Turkmenistan its expected that the grooms husband will provide a 'gift' to the parents of the bride. This 'gift' is negotiated between the parents and is for all intents and purposes a bride price. The bride's family obviously is looking for an adequate return on their investment, while the grooms family is looking to get the bride for as cheap as possible. My exchange student's parents are both well educated doctors and her older sister is a US trained economist with an excellent high paying (for Turkmenistan) job, who will in all likelihood inherit an apartment in the city core, and is in fine physical shape. These are all fine qualities and ones that her parents have invested heavily in over the years with the assumption that her bride price will reflect the investments in her. However, the exact OPPOSITE thing happened. The men in Turkmenistan have no interest-like people the world around they want the best deal possible, so they instead go to the villages and buy a bride from there for a few goats and a handful of cash (our exchange student thought this was a shamefully small amount of money, but for the people in the villages its significant). The men don't expect their wives to work, and aren't looking for intellectual equals. Her parents have effectively improved them to such a point that they've now been priced out of the market.
- sudhirj 9y agoThere’s also an expectation that women will marry ‘up’, even in first world countries, I think. It’s very ironic that women who develop themselves have a smaller option pool of mates.
- a2tech 9y agoIf they were willing to marry internationally I think their options would be much nicer, but their parents aren't allowed to leave the country and they're very close so that puts a pretty big barrier in place for them to leave.
- 9y ago
- golergka 9y ago> every time a rich man takes an extra wife, another poor man must remain single Or he could simply be already dead from all the warfare. These two things connect in positive feedback loop: men dying in war create gender misbalance that would push more women to become second and third wives as well.
- louithethrid 9y agoEverytime a woman marrys a second or third cat - some poor men must become a culture warrior.
- dingle_thunk 9y agoWorth pointing out that in most of the schools of thought in Islam, it’s not advisable to have more than one wife, except in situations where there are significantly more women than men. Islam and polygyny have a long and complex cultural history which is pretty interesting. And there is also polyandry in Christian countries like Nigeria, where cultural exceptions have been made. It seems to be mostly an African & Indian subcontinent thing... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygyny_in_Islam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygyny_in_Islam
- bonesss 9y ago> ... in most of the schools of thought in Islam, it’s not advisable to have more than one wife I think this holds true in the general case. I understand the fantasy, but I imagine the reality to be a lot closer to... well, to having two wives.
- MechEStudent 9y agoThis has implications for the economy of prostitution, and pornography.
- lkrubner 9y agoThis suggests that political stability depends on young men being able to pursue their romantic dreams. This would apply in any country, not just African countries. In nations in the West, an important limiting factor is the ability to get one's own apartment. That is, the ratio of average male wage to average rent. In the USA, the happiest year for this ratio was 1958, when people were spending 22% of their income on rent, on average. Not by coincidence, this was the peak year of the Baby Boom. In some sense, it was the best year in history to be a young white male in the USA. It was the year when it was easiest for an 18 year old male to get out of high school, get their own apartment, marry their high school sweetheart, and start a family. And of course, young people did this in huge numbers, which is why 1958 remains the peak year for teenage pregnancy in the USA. But rent has been rising faster than the average male wage since 1958, and politics in the USA has become angrier and angrier. The mechanism that this article suggests, that polygamy leads to war, would also suggest an angry impulse in a country that has transformed from one where 18 year old men have their own apartment to a country where most men don't achieve their own apartment until their late 20s or 30s. There certainly has been a change in the tone with which men talk about women. Nowadays you can find Pick Up Artist web sites where men in their 20s and 30s can supposedly learn tricks to win over women. The tone suggests that women are far away, and need to be tricked into things. In 1958, a woman was a person you lived with and shared your life with, starting when you were 18. Early marriage had its own problems, which have been picked apart in endless comedies, but according to this article, the ease of marriage in the 1950s would have explained the contentment that the American people expressed regarding their own government and way of life. The other implication of this is that Consumer Price Index is a lousy way to track people's standard of living, because it tends to treat socks and lettuce and bicycles and apples and houses and automobiles and Xboxes and Nintendo consoles as all having the same weight to each other as their price. But if this article is right, that men need women or they become war like, that would suggest that one item (housing) has an emotional weight that makes it much more important than any other item. If we adjust the median male wage with the CPI then it seems male wages in the USA have been stagnant since 1973. But if we gave housing the kind of weight that this article seems to justify, then we could say that men have seen a declining standard of living since 1958. That is, the abundance of socks and lettuce and bicycles and apples and automobiles and Xboxes and Nintendo consoles does not make up for rising rent.
- murtnowski 9y agoYou’ve reached your article limit
- rak00n 9y agoOpen in incognito.
- whack 9y agoI'm opposed to polygamy for the obvious humanitarian concerns, and other issues raised in the article. But at the same time, I'm curious about the long-term genetic impact of monogamy vs polygamy. IQ and many personality traits have been shown to be correlated significantly with genes (many of these studies are based on adopted children, for whom genes and upbringing are decoupled). In monogamous societies like in America, someone who's highly smart and industrious, will likely end up with the same number of children as someone on the opposite end of the spectrum. In polygamous societies, someone who's smart and industrious can easily end up with 2-10x the number of children as the average man. In terms of natural selection, this clearly puts significantly more selective pressure on intelligence and personality-traits. Over a few decades, I doubt this will amount to much. But over a couple centuries/millenia, I wonder if polygamous societies would wind up as a race of smart-hard-working-competitive-assholes, in comparison to us monogamous dolts.
- betterunix2 9y ago"I'm curious about the long-term genetic impact of monogamy vs polygamy." I think you might be overlooking the fact that women can and do have sex with other men than their husbands.
- zzzzzzzza 9y agoIt's a complicated issue certainly, however as far as I'm aware cuckoldry (where children are product of adultery) is relatively rare, under 2%, don't have a source offhand but that's the hearsay as it were.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoI think the implications were about sex before marriage, not just actual cases of having another persons child. Rates of births out of wedlock has been steadily increasing and is nearing 50% (may already be passed it).
- pitt1980 9y agoIts an interesting thought - couple thoughts, its assumes a cream rises to the top, such that your mating success will correlate with whether you're smart and industrious I suspect that there might be a tendency in polygamous societies for there to be a lot of effort put into setting up structural barriers to prevent mating competition from smart and industrious competitors. Such that you actually weed out a lot of smart/industrious genes. --------- Its not the case that history doesn't have examples of monogamous societies competing with polygamous societies over the time span of centuries/millennia. And from a back of the envelope scorekeeping, it doesn't appear that the results are polygamous smart-hard-working-competitive-assholes outcompeting monogamous dolts.
- stared 9y agoRelated: "8,000 Years Ago, 17 Women Reproduced for Every One Man" https://psmag.com/environment/17-to-1-reproductive-success https://psmag.com/environment/17-to-1-reproductive-success
- tabtab 9y agoI've heard variations of this called "Blue-Balls Theory". Reproduction for males becomes a high-stakes all-or-nothing prospect such that using violence is often a better reproductive strategy than "peaceful failure".
- hullsean 9y agocorrelation does not equal causation. the article does not seem to consider open relationships and the many other non-traditional arrangements that are becoming more common & widespread.
- NoB4Mouth 9y agoMaybe the topic may sound funny for some but it's not when you experience it. I am currently dating a girl who has been force-married at age 12 to a cousin of his father. The man is two decades older than her but she had nothing to say because her consent is not need according to "traditions". Women are "exchanged" as cattle in their culture. Those transactions build inter-tribal relations. I know a bit about their culture because i read social Anthropology @ uni. She run away from the man 4 years ago & came back to live with her parents. The father is still pushing her to go back to the man. He has heard that his daughter is dating someone (Me) and is very treating her shabbily these days. Whereas the girl's mother got to know me and we interact regularly. She is a very kind & soft-spoken woman. Her husband is now accusing her of supporting the "dalliances" of their daughter. The father is the one who is supposed to take the bride-price in case of marriage. I'm currently confused about it. I don't want to marry someone i've not paid the bride-price for. I don't want to leave the girl either because the love she has for me. Hmmmm I'm confused... I'm really confused... Any help or advice...