4 ms·
I feel that calling it "Mac OS series 0" comes too close to a touchy subject for it to be considered a better name. Raskin's original vision for the Macintosh
by eesmith 9y ago
I feel that calling it "Mac OS series 0" comes too close to a touchy subject for it to be considered a better name.
Raskin's original vision for the Macintosh project was a text-based UI. (The Canon Cat was a descendant of that design.) Only later did Macintosh gain support for the Lisa-style graphical programs.
I don't know the timeline, but I can point to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh which says:
> Smith's first Macintosh board was built to Raskin's design specifications: it had 64 kilobytes (kB) of RAM, used the 8-bit Motorola 6809E microprocessor, and was capable of supporting a 256×256-pixel black-and-white bitmap display. Bud Tribble, a member of the Mac team, was interested in running the Apple Lisa's graphical programs on the Macintosh, and asked Smith whether he could incorporate the Lisa's Motorola 68000 microprocessor into the Mac while still keeping the production cost down. By December 1980, Smith had succeeded ...
Then at https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story=Scrooge_McDuck.txt&sortOrder=Sort+by+Date https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&stor... you read that "the very first prototype of the very first Macintosh sprung to life early in the first month of the new decade, in January 1980" with the 6809E. That would be before the 68000 was added.
If that prototype - or any prototype before the 68000 was added - had an operating system, then that should be called "Mac OS series 0."
- DonHopkins 9y agoWow, the 6809 was the Chrysler Cordoba of 8 bit microprocessors! It was tastefully luxurious and highly orthogonal, sporting a powerful hardware multiply instruction, and soft Corinthian Leather. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_6809 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_6809 https://youtu.be/tfKHBB4vt4c?t=10s https://youtu.be/tfKHBB4vt4c?t=10s But I'm sure glad they ended up using the 68K for the Mac.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoUsing a 6809 they could have made a far cheaper, far more accessible machine. Moving to the 68000 meant moving to more expensive support chips, and required more RAM, and the like. But it did mean they could use the QuickDraw code from the Lisa. And in the end the Mac interface ended up being a kind of dumbed down ripped off version of the Lisa, instead of the Jeff Raskin thing with hot keys and the like of early prototypes. I just wish they'd worked instead on making an actual cost reduced Lisa, using the same Lisa OS, but without the crappy copy protection and the overpriced hardware...
- protomyth 9y agoLooking back, I wonder how much the switch from the cheap 6502 to the expensive 68000 killed the original 8-bit companies. Both Commodore and Atari had higher market shares than the Apple II. It seems like playing in the higher price bracket moved them too close to the PC. It feels like people making the opposite decision of the 6502 over the 6800. Plus, I did love the 6809 and its ISA. It was fun to program.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoTramiel's Atari Corp did manage to keep 8-bit-ish pricing on its ST line, despite the 68k switch. But yeah, if the 65816 had come out a year or two earlier, I wonder if Amiga and Tramiel and friends would have chosen to develop on that instead. An 8/16 processor that could address larger memory regions but still could use 8-bit memory and 6502 support chips, and had the cycle efficiency and simplicity of the 6502. Apple came out with the IIgs based on it, but overpriced it.
- protomyth 9y agoWell, the 520ST was $799.99 for the monochrome computer, so it was quite a bit more expensive than the Atari 65XE at $99.99. If I remember correctly the 68000 itself cost north of $200 in quantities, so it was impossible to stay in the old price range. I remember a story of Commodore / Amiga trying to use the Amiga chipset with a cheaper processor. Of course they also tried it with a PA-RISC.
- rwallace 9y agoI thought the 68000 was down to something like $10 by that time? Given that, the price discrepancy is surprising, since the ST was intentionally a rather simple design. What exactly made the ST have to cost that much?
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoIndeed this article seems to indicate that the 68000 was $15 by 1984: http://www.nytimes.com/1984/06/29/business/motorola-s-powerful-new-chip.html http://www.nytimes.com/1984/06/29/business/motorola-s-powerf... But 512KB or 1MB of RAM was really expensive then. Atari cheaped out a bit by running their RAM a bit over its spec, tho. There were a few custom chips in it too (the Shifter [video], the MMU, the GLU [logic], and DMA chip.
- joezydeco 9y agoThose who put down the 6809 have never programmed it. It was (and still is) a joy to work with and way more powerful than the other 8 bit chips of the era. This is a 6809 at 1 MHz and no special graphics hardware: https://youtu.be/yrkx6vuiMrE https://youtu.be/yrkx6vuiMrE
- osullivj 9y agoTwo stack pointers! Great fir Forth impls. In the early 80s UK home micro mkt the Dragon was 6809 based.
- anthk 9y agoThe Vectrex had it.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoGeh, in reality the Mac didn't get an operating system in the true sense of the word (proper process separation, memory protection etc.) until like... System 7.6 or maybe even later in OS X. Classic Mac OS was more like an overgrown API than a proper OS environment. A real step backwards from the Lisa... It's baffling to me that instead of cost reducing the Lisa, Apple ran two parallel product lines (Mac and Lisa), similar to each other and competing with each other.. and from reading histories it sounds like it came down to territorial turf wars and Job's ego that made this the case. Lisa wasn't Jobs baby... so it was killed.
- glhaynes 9y agoLisa wasn't Jobs baby True in one sense... false in another!
- eesmith 9y agoIf I accept your "True sense of the word", then many early operating systems, like the "SHARE Operating System" from 1959, are not, actually, operating systems. I prefer to believe that you are using a stricter definition of the word/phrase, rather one which encompasses how that word/phrase was actually used by practitioners in the field.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoSure, fine, I agree that back then the definition of OS was more fluid. Though in reality I don't think that in those early days they even called what was running on the Mac an operating system at all. The term "Mac OS" didn't arrive til much later, and it wasn't until there were later revisions that they used the phraseology "System" for it. But to the original point, my understanding is that the Lisa had a more classic OS architecture when compared to the Mac: multiple processes, dynamic memory allocation, etc. But until I can actually read the source for it (soon!) I'm just repeating hearsay. I've run the OS on emulators, but that doesn't tell you much about its inner workings.
- eesmith 9y ago