4 ms·
A couple things to unpack here: Firstly, I'm not sure we're reading the same article, but by my summary count, the total death toll for all combined US war cri
by fastball 9y ago
A couple things to unpack here:
Firstly, I'm not sure we're reading the same article, but by my summary count, the total death toll for all combined US war crimes detailed in that article isn't much more than 10,000.
Next, the veracity of some of those claims is questionable at best.
Finally, it should be noted that the Tiananmen Square protests, were, in fact, protests. This was not an action against civilians during war time, this was an action taken by a government against it's own citizens who were protesting.
Is killing unarmed soldiers or civilians in war time justified? Generally no. But it's a different type of crime when you're in the middle of a war zone. Humans don't deal well with the insane nature of war, and so they do horrible things. That's not an excuse, mind you. But I think collateral damage in a war and civilian casualties in a war zone are very different scenarios than Tiananmen Square.
- jbooth 9y agoYou ever see the shock and awe videos of Baghdad? That our government approvingly worked with cable news to make sure everyone saw it? For an operation very much not endorsed by the UN or international community? Good thing that's not a war crime, though.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoShock and awe was a brief bombing campaign that hit military and administrative buildings late at night when they were empty. I saw the buildings. They were not apartment blocks. If anyone died in that campaign it was purely by accident.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoGo ahead, downvote me. I was there mother fuckers.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> You ever see the shock and awe videos of Baghdad? The ones using precision munitions on generally evacuated government buildings? You're really going to try comparing that to massacring unarmed protesters?
- jbooth 9y agoYeah, those. Watch the video and tell me how bloodless it was. Or how it's not a massacre. I'm not defending a thing about Tiananmen square, I'm just marvelling at the power of nationalism to excuse anything. Bunch of snakes in suits with American flag pins declare a war for no reason, knowing that hundreds of thousands will die, but it's all Legitimate State Behavior. I'm sure it's a huge comfort to the orphans.
- ceejayoz 9y agoLooks pretty bloodless. Are there specific videos you're looking for me to peruse? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yr-LaMhvro https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yr-LaMhvro Now, the Iraq War and it's aftermath as a whole weren't bloodless, for sure. The "they'll greet us as liberators and there'll be a Western-style democracy in 90 days!" stuff was transparent bullshit. Shock and awe was a specific bombing campaign, hitting palaces, military HQs, communications nexuses, etc. The targets chosen made it easy to avoid large numbers of civilian casualties, and trying to compare it to stuff like Tiananmen Square is just silly.
- tw04 9y agoIt's not as if the US ever killed off a bunch of innocent people outside of war, and still ignores them when it doesn't suit their interests (see keystone XL pipeline): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_indigenous_peoples_of_the_Americas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_history_of_indigeno...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]