12 ms·
California lawmakers have tried for 50 years to fix the state’s housing crisis
- cobbzilla 9y agoMaybe replace "tried" with "failed" in the headline?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- megiddo 9y agoIt all comes down the regulatory hurdles. Even land prices are the result of rent-seeking behavior among land-holders due to regulatory impediment. If California would pass legislation radically limiting regulatory burdens that municipalities and other legislative bodies could pass, this problem would disappear within a year or two.
- conanbatt 9y agoWell, a bit more than a year or two, pluis its impossible to take out all reg's immediately. Just eliminating rent-control could have devastating political effects. But even california official economist reports say the situation is harming the state tremendously. There is no debate about what needs to be done. Its just about politics now.
- slg 9y agoSimply removing regulation is not enough to fix everything. Downtown Los Angeles is a prime example of that. It has been seeing a construction boom in recent year and loosened regulation is probably responsible for part of that boom. However since there is little regulation on the type of housing that is being built, the new construction is all coming in at the top of the market. This is because buying land and building a mid-market apartment building is not much cheaper than buying the land and building a luxury apartment building. The end result is that Downtown Los Angeles is full of luxury apartments with some of the areas highest vacancy rates as landlords are making more money charging high rents at 80-90% occupancy than they would with lower rents at 100% occupancy. Meanwhile these new buildings are replacing much more affordable housing which is pushing lower income renters out of their homes. Eventually those luxury apartments will trickle down to cheaper rent at the bottom of the market, but often times that means forcing a low income family out of their home in a gentrifying neighborhood into a less desirable area that is often farther from amenities the city offers like public transit which objectively make their lives worse.
- greggman 9y agoknowing how bad downtown LA is/was in terms of poverty and crime it's hard for me not to be happy at the gentrification and cleaning up of DTLA. It still has a ways to go but I'd love a safe and clean DTLA. I don't know what the implications are for the poor that get displaced but old DTLA was (and still is) a blight on the city. Of course a solution that some how helps the poor down there would be great but keeping the place a cheap ghetto doesn't seem like the right thing either
- slg 9y agoYou are taking the perspective of someone who is at least middle class. If you were a lower income family and you are pushed from DTLA to Whittier because of gentrification it could have a huge negative impact on your life. A "safe and clean DTLA" would do you no good in that instance. Also it has now been a few years since DTLA was a "blight" or a "cheap ghetto". Is there a bigger sign of gentrification than Whole Foods[1]? [1] - https://www.wholefoodsmarket.com/stores/downtownlosangeles https://www.wholefoodsmarket.com/stores/downtownlosangeles
- santaclaus 9y agoMost of the construction in DTLA was previously parking lots... I find it hard to believe that mostly vacant parking lots adjacent to a mostly vacant sports stadium is somehow a superior proposition to a sustainable urban fabric than much needed housing.
- slg 9y agoWhen was the last time you were in DTLA? There are many new buildings that weren't built in former parking lots and the gentrified area isn't purely centered around LA Live. You can walk 10 minutes south or west of the Staples Center and be in non-gentrified areas but if you walked 30 minutes north it is heavily gentrified.
- Decade 9y agoAbout 10% vacancy seems to be a healthy amount. If that were over the entire city, and not only in new developments, then people would have much more freedom to move. And then prices would go down. 100% occupancy is bad, because it means the city is not flexible to changing demands. Fill up that new development 100%, and then the next person who needs to come in would need to double up, or bid higher and displace somebody. That is my big problem with the Planning process, trying to manage growth. It’s slow and brittle to unanticipated changes.
- altria 9y agoSaving for retirement is hard due to the government's inflationary policy. The returns on savings accounts, bonds, or other traditional savings vehicles are untenably low. Thus, every Mom and Pop is thrusted into speculative investments such as the stock market or real state. Small wonder then they seek to protect their home equity. It's largely their only retirement plan.
- morio 9y agoIt's the other way around. A deflationary economy forces the feds to lower interest rates to encourage lending. We've had record breaking low inflation rates for a decade now. A 'healthy' inflation rate would be in the 3.5-4.0% range. Yes, money is supposed to lose value. If it did not no one would spend.
- adrianN 9y agoPeople would still buy things they need. They might not buy things they don't really need, but that doesn't sound like such a bad thing to me.
- megiddo 9y agoThat's nonsense. There's no objectively healthy inflationary rate. Low interest rates are the key factor in driving demand for borrowing. Low interest rates signal a healthy supply of savings from which to borrow. So, low interest rates naturally match a large supply to a healthy demand. Such a scenario would create a market for investment-led expansion. High interest rates signal the opposite. Either the supply of available savings is insufficient, or relative demand is high enough to drive out uncompetitive demands for savings.
- alexasmyths 9y ago"regulatory hurdles" those may be in place because the citizens want it that way, which is kind of their right.
- IncRnd 9y ago> It requires cities and counties to develop plans every eight years for new home building in their communities. After more than a year of work and spending nearly $50,000, Foster City had an 87-page housing plan that proposed hundreds of new homes, mapped where they would go and detailed the many ways the city could help make the construction happen. But a crucial element was missing: Foster City was never going to approve all the building called for in the voluminous proposal, Perez said. Why would a municipality spend $50,000 on a do-nothing report? Instead keep the $50,000 and spend $2.00 on a report that says, "It would be best to do something about housing. Someone should build more houses." Sure, the law is a failure, but the municipalities that spent that kind of money willy-nilly are just as limited in their success.
- ajmurmann 9y agoTo me the most mystifying part is why the city is involved in any of this planning? I find it utterly appalling that the city is planning housing units. What bizarre planned economy, communist system is this? Americans tend to be very pro-market, but as soon as it's about housing we get this bizarre stuff.
- vkou 9y agoOur economy is already highly planned. Particular behaviours are tax advantaged, particular investment in particular industries is centrally planned through government procurement, healthcare prices are controlled through Medicaid/Medicare, almost every corporation heavily practices centralized planning... The strange part is not that planning happens, its how we are so bad at it when it comes to land ownership.
- cmurf 9y agoAny time there's perceived market failure (or suboptimal outcome) in a democracy, voters will try to legislate alternative outcomes. There's nothing bizarre about it, it's been going on for a while now. And not even cities, but towns of 10,000 have these kinds of issues where there's only so much physical room for them to grow and everyone there asserts the right to a view, so there are height restrictions for buildings. And then they also realize they need people who aren't millionaires to be teachers, waiters, plumbers, lawn care, and so on. And they can't all live in town, so now they live in the next town and commute, leading to traffic problems and a need for regional public transit, and all kinds of really obvious classist side effects. You either want to live in an aristocratic homogeneous society or you want something quite a bit more diverse and less walled garden than that. And for sure not everyone is in agreement. Hence there's a problem and there's arguing about it.
- BurningFrog 9y agoThis is from June. The bill from Scott Wiener it talks about (SB 35) passed. We'll see what effect it has in reality. http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-housing-legislation-deal-impact-20170915-story.html http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-housing-legislatio...
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoJudging by the endless thread on Nextdoor with people in my East Bay neighborhood complaining about the “Manhattanization” of their small town, due to 7 units being built on an empty lot, the housing crisis is going to get a lot worse before it gets better. The “FU, I got mine” attitude is going to choke California. How we got here is a fascinating story, and recommend reading literature on it.
- afpx 9y agoI don’t feel like I’m saying FU at all. My perspective is that I spent over 15 years in a house that I initially took a risk on. I helped build the neighborhood and community and schools that made it a nice place to live. And, now people who didn’t have to do all that work want to live here cheaply. And, they’re trying to use government and political power to force me to give up what I’ve helped build. Why is that fair? As I’ve said in the past, No one is addressing the demand side of this issue. Make places less attractive, demand goes down, and prices go down. There are huge swaths of the US other than San Francisco that are in dire need of industry and people. Why not encourage companies and people to move to those places? I believe that the bulk of the problem starts with the companies in CA. Wages clearly aren’t high enough to give workers salaries that allow them to buy properties. Raise wages, and some companies will naturally move elsewhere. Jobs will go with them, and demand will go down. Also, the elephant in the room is foreign buyers. I looked through SF tax records the other day. I picked a random street, and most of the homes were owned by foreign trusts. Why not try to stop that first? I’m not sure how one can disagree with my points. So, I’m probably clueless on this issue. Please educate me. (Clearly, I’ve angered the mob. Please don’t bring torches and pitchforks to my door tonight. I just wanted to get an alternative and unrepresented viewpoint into the discussion.)
- benchaney 9y agoThis is the exact FU attitude that GP is describing. There is nothing about "building the community" that entitles you to prevent other people from living near you. They aren't trying to use political power to force you to give up what you've helped build, they are trying to buy land and build homes. It simply isn't ok for people to prevent other from living near the so they can turn their "communities" into elitist social clubs. Foreign buyers are irrelevant. They wouldn't be getting involved at all if homes in CA weren't so absurdly overpriced.
- gnarcoregrizz 9y agoCA doesn't want more homes or people. The old generation and their heirs are firmly cemented in place (prop 13 + 58/193). No one is going to fix shit, and I certainly don't want any more market distorting policies like rent control. My area hasn't built a new home in 15 years.
- junkscience2017 9y agoCalifornia has 40 million people. We have renewable water resources for 20 million. At this rate we will utterly obliterate our water resources for good. No government can fix that...and no, you aren't going to desal that much water either. We need to figure out how to get 10 million out of the State.
- vorg 9y ago> It gives the public a false sense that a step has been taken toward having more housing when in fact it’s just an illusion. This is the same anywhere there's direct democracy. 51% of the people vote in the government that perpetuates the ponzi scheme of rising house prices because borrowing from the bank to buy a house then selling it later for a profit is the quickest path to retirement. Restricting housing supply is one easy way to keep house prices rising. The government needs to feed a story to the other 49%, hence these illusions like in California. Besides restricting supply, another way to keep the prices rising is to boost demand, so the 51% also vote for the governments that increase immigration, which has been especially successful recently in the western US, Canada, and Australia/NZ. Every now and then, a government comes along that attempts to boost housing supply or restrict demand from immigrants or foreigners, but they soon get voted out because early retirement is the top criteria of voting decisions for the 51%. That government's initiative then becomes another carcass used to fool the other 49%.
- alexasmyths 9y agoPeople in California are generally not voting for this. Most people would rather cheaper home prices, given the choice.
- Qwertious 9y ago>This is the same anywhere there's direct democracy. 51% of the people vote in the government Uh, not quite. 51% of the voters. I highlight this because it's incredibly important to understand that only voters have power, and if you refuse to vote then you will be screwed by politicians in favour of people who actually keep them in power.
- alexasmyths 9y agoThere can nary be such a thing as a 'housing crises'. California does not have one, in general. If California municipalities 'don't want to enable building' because their residents don't want it ... well ... then they will have fewer people, probably higher housing costs and that's their choice. If the 'average bay policeman' or whatever can't afford to buy a home for 100 miles - then the citizens of Cali are going to have to pay their cops more, or, those cops will go elsewhere. It's a fairly fluid and competitive landscape - more so than most places on earth. There's a high demand for living in some parts of Cali and it's going to be like that for a long time, even with some building it won't change. It's a choice Californians seem to be making, it's their choice. If town councils are arbitrarily messing things up against the will of the people - who want to see high rises everywhere ... well that's another story.
- Decade 9y agoIn this era of ridiculously low voter participation, I don’t see the elections as being a great source of legitimacy. Housing is even worse. Many of the people I interact with are immigrants, so they are blamed for the high prices, but they are unable to vote to fix it. It’s the old homeowners who organize and produce fractionally higher voter turnouts, that turn elections their way. Especially local elections, that have the most impact on land use policy. A minority harm the majority because they vote more. The good news is that YIMBYs are now organizing, too.[0] You can even make tax-deductible donations to bring lawsuits against local governments that violate state law by refusing to allow housing.[1] [0] https://yimbyaction.org https://yimbyaction.org [1] http://www.carlaef.org http://www.carlaef.org
- Johnny555 9y agowell ... then they will have fewer people I don't think that part is true -- they'll still have more people, but those people will be doubling (or tripling) up in single family homes or (often illegal) in-law units, causing parking, traffic, infrastructure and other problems of increasing density in neighborhoods that were not designed for it. I see that in a neighborhood I pass through on my way to work -- cars parked on sidewalks and front yards, and long lines of traffic at the only traffic light that leads out of the neighborhood.
- gdne 9y agoThe problem isn't housing. The problem is transportation and infrastructure. People need to work for a living. They also don't want to spend a significant amount of time commuting to said work. California's transportation, road, and highway infrastructure is completely and utterly inadequate for the population in the SF and LA areas. This forces people into living situations that are far from ideal and creates a fight over housing. Create multiple ways for people to commute from 30 miles away in 30 minutes and housing will be much less of a problem with people having many more options. Proof: If people could instantly teleport between work and home no matter how far apart they are, do you really think they would still cram into SF Bay Area or LA housing? Hell no. Housing is the symptom of poor transportation infrastructure.
- SomewhatLikely 9y agoWhile this is true, you get better return on investment on transportation and infrastructure when people live in more densely built up areas.
- flexie 9y agoThis is true. But the easiest way to fix the inadequate transportation is to build more densely. Build more highrises. A 30 floor highrise with 8 apartments per floor can easily house 500 people but only takes up the land that 4 single family houses with less than 15 persons would occupy. But the effect is multiplied if this highrise is in an city with many highrises. Now, instead of commuting 30 miles to pass another 1,500 single homes to reach work, the inhabitants of our highrise may only have to walk 1 mile to pass the homes of a similar amount of people and reach work.
- codedokode 9y agoit is very uncomfortable to stand near a 30-floor building looking up. Also, people in the building will have troubles with parking all of their cars. By the way this [1] is what those buldings look like. [1] https://varlamov.me/2016/china_ray/09.jpg https://varlamov.me/2016/china_ray/09.jpg
- 9y ago
- true_tuna 9y ago“We’ve tried everything except building more housing and we’re all out of ideas!” I’m baffled how local governments can’t seem to connect the supply side. 30k new jobs + 8k new housing units = higher housing prices Or for a more hilarious ratio, look at Mountain View over the last 15 years. I think for a decade there were effectively zero new units created.
- Cookingboy 9y agoThere has been a ton of new apartments and townhouses built in MTV in the past 3 years.
- tzakrajs 9y agoYeah maybe like 1000 units tops
- pascalxus 9y agoAnd what makes this even more tragic, is that this is happening in a highly educated cities. What's so hard to understand about supply and demand? I think, deep down, they're fundamentally misguided: democrats and liberals think that they're somehow fighting against capitalism, and by limiting developers, they're somehow helping humanity. Red Cities and red states get it, they generally don't have these problems, even the extremely high growth ones: like Houston.
- closeparen 9y agoIf they were serious about fighting capitalism, they might do more to resist the biggest and most profitable companies in the world expanding their own real estate portfolios and footprint. Instead they have decided to attack the employees. Relatively privileged employees, but workers nonetheless.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoDon't red cities and states tend to have much lower population densities?
- codedokode 9y agoHeight limits and zoning are a good idea. If you don't have limits then you will have only high ugly 25-floor apartment buildings. Like the ones they build in China [1][2] or in Russia. Look at any old European city like Paris or Amsterdam or Saint-Petersburg. A historical part of the city with 3-5-7 floor buildings looks so much better than modern cities with skyscrapers. And I am not sure that building new houses will solve the problem. New houses and lower living cost might attract even more people to move to California. [1] https://varlamov.me/2016/china_ray/09.jpg https://varlamov.me/2016/china_ray/09.jpg [2] https://varlamov.me/2016/china_ray/11.jpg https://varlamov.me/2016/china_ray/11.jpg
- citrin_ru 9y ago1. High-rise building can be build in different styles. I like most Manhattan buildings from 1920s - 1940s. 2. There are a log of ugly box building built in Russia (and China), because it is a race to the bottom. People can't afford apartments in good looking buildings and can only buy in cheapest ones. Given how expensive land in California it is unlikely that developers will try to save every cent on buildings them-self.
- closeparen 9y agoYou’re correctly pointing out some truly awful towers, and I’m happy to counter with some awful single family houses. Towers, like houses, can be good or bad.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoSo what you’re telling me is that people are going to be paying me $15,000/mo if I do get that property
- NTDF9 9y agoI mean, just pull something from HongKong's playbook? Or Singapore or even NYC. Why does the government have to be incompetent? Maybe just admit that prop 13 was a bad idea?
- newintellectual 9y ago*California lawmakers have created the state's housing crisis for at least 50 years. Fixed that for you.
- aaaaajkjkjkjk 9y agoThe Bay Area is an international hotspot. You have people fighting to move in from the whole world. I would expect it to be one of the most expensive places on the planet. And given it is an American city, I expect the worst infrastructure on the planet.