10 ms·
Please Don't Show Us Another “Typical Family Earning $270,000 a Year”
- esmi 9y ago“Rafa Nadal and I have an average of 5 French Open titles.” That is a quote I'm going to have to remember. Should come in handy often.
- rogerfederer 9y agoInteresting. Rafa and I have 6 French Open Titles.
- Axsuul 9y ago"Bill Gates walks into a bar and the average net worth of everyone there goes up $1M"
- knodi123 9y agoBill's net worth is $90 billion. It would be more accurate to estimate that everyone's average net worth of the bar population goes up by several billion.
- cjlars 9y agoMore like "Bill Gates walks into a football stadium and the average net worth of everyone there goes up $1M"
- eesmith 9y agoAssuming a stadium with 30,000 seated people, that would imply an average net worth of about $67. With 10,000 seated people, $200.
- cjlars 9y agoYour math's off, $90BN / 30k = ~$3M: https://www.google.com/search?q=90.2+billion+%2F+30000&oq=90+&aqs=chrome.2.69i57j0j35i39j0l3.3564j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=90.2+billion+%2F+30000&oq=90...
- jerkstate 9y agothat would be a very crowded bar!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 111_1_111 9y agoYeah, but that's only because the bar has 90,000 people in it. If the bar had more people in it, the net worth wouldn't go up as much.
- eesmith 9y agoHow big is this bar? Time bring out the quadratic equation. If the average net worth of a US citizen is $100,000 (it's less, but I'll go with that), and Gates has a net worth of $90 billion, and the average net worth of those people goes up $1M: average worth = aw = 100000 n people total worth = aw * n Bill Gates comes in: total worth' = aw * n + 90000000000 aw' = (aw * n + 90000000000)/(n+1) difference = aw' - aw = (aw * n + 90000000000)/(n+1) - aw * n = 1000000 = (100000 * n + 90000000000)/(n+1) - (100000 * n) = 1000000 => n ≈ 944 people in the bar https://www.thebalance.com/american-net-worth-by-state-metropolitan-4135839 https://www.thebalance.com/american-net-worth-by-state-metro... says the average net worth is $68,828 in 2011, which implies about 1,136 people in the bar. Big bar. If they were millionaires already, then only 300 people are needed. If they were billionaires, only about 30.
- cperciva 9y ago> difference = aw' - aw > = (aw * n + 90000000000)/(n+1) - aw * n = 1000000 Somehow aw turned into aw * n there, which sent your calculations wildly off. You want: n * aw + 90 * 10^9 = (n + 1) * (aw + 10^6) n * aw + 90 * 10^9 = n * aw + n * 10^6 + aw + 10^6 90 * 10^9 - (10^6 + aw) = n * 10^6 n = 89999 - aw / 10^6 i.e., almost 90000 people, no matter how wealthy the population of the bar is.
- ithkuil 9y ago> no matter how wealthy the population of the bar is. That doesn't sound right. What if the population of the bar is as wealthy as Gates? The average net worth should change if you add another value equals to all the previous ones. Am I reading something wrong?
- cperciva 9y agoWhat if the population of the bar is as wealthy as Gates? My point is that you can't find 90000 people who are as wealthy as Gates. In fact, you can't find 90000 people whose average wealth comes anywhere close to Gates -- even the Forbes 400 average out at a paltry $6.7B, and you'd need to stock the bar with 83300 people with that level of wealth before Gates would fail to raise the average wealth by $1M. I think the average wealth among the top 90000 people is around $100M, so you'd need to have around 89900 of them... plus or minus a few thousand depending on how the stock market is doing on any particular day.
- chch 9y agoReminds me of a similar factoid: Wayne and Brent Gretzky hold the National Hockey League record for most combined points by two brothers: Wayne Gretzky with 2,857, Brent Gretzky with 4.
- antognini 9y agoI heard it told a little less charitably: Who were the most successful NHL brothers? Wayne Gretzky and whoever Wayne Gretzky's brother was. I've also heard a nerdier variant: Who was the most influential father-son pair in mathematics? Gauss and whoever Gauss's father was.
- lurr 9y ago> Who were the most successful NHL brothers Sutters, arguably.
- twoodfin 9y agoIt turns out, though, that the median family of four has an income pretty close to the average family of four, so this point is a little less clever than most of the folks who are making it believe. http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/actually-the-average-family-of-four-really-will-save-more-than-2000-from-this-bill/article/2644184 http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/actually-the-average-famil...
- gumby 9y agoBy the way you may be surprised to know that the average person as slightly more than one ovary and slightly less than 1 testicle. It's true!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thisisit 9y ago> Is the media hopelessly out of touch? What income group do these media outlets think their readers belong to? If anything this kind of reporting might show why "bottom half of earners in America" are turning towards stuff like Breitbart etc.
- daveguy 9y agoI'm sure Breitbart is blindly trumpeting the tax cut, just without the profiles/statistics showing what types of people it helps. There's a reason these outlets are showing "typical" families making $250k. That's how they can show that "typical" families benefit significantly. Most news outlets also stand to benefit significantly because it is primarily a tax cut for businesses.
- phamilton 9y agoI think there's also the "I haven't made it yet, but I'll get there" mindset of a lot of readers. If someone hopes to be making $250k someday, then being assured that when they do they won't be penalized for it is reassuring.
- jrochkind1 9y agoI think they mostly just haven't been covering it. Definitely not the policy details, a little bit of the horse-trading.
- gozur88 9y agoTaxes are complex enough that media outlets can't cover the details without having readers lose interest.
- eesmith 9y agoHere are the current headline on their front page which mention 'tax cut'. "Trump: Patriots Owner Robert Kraft Building Factory in N. Carolina After Tax Cut Bill", "Bank of America Paying $1,000 Tax Cut Bonuses to 145,000 American Workers", "Ted Lieu: Tax Cuts Make Poor People Jealous", "WINNING: Germans Fear Job Losses from U.S. Tax Cuts…", "‘Avengers’ Director Joss Whedon Has Two-Day Twitter Meltdown Over Trump, GOP Tax Cut Vote", "Winning: President Donald Trump Signs Historic Tax Cut Bill". Put "typical family" into the Breitbart search box. The first match is for http://www.breitbart.com/economics/2017/09/30/mainstream-media-distort-cohn-says-gop-tax-plan/ http://www.breitbart.com/economics/2017/09/30/mainstream-med... . In it, "Gary Cohn, the White House’s chief economic adviser and its lead advocate for the GOP tax overhaul" talked about the effect of the then-tax plan on "a typical family earning $100,000 with two children that has been a standard deducter, has used the standard deduction and continues to use the standard deduction". (You'll notice that Cohn used $100,000 of income, which is the same income that Texas Sen. John Cornyn was quoted as tweeting.) Other media sources misinterpreted that as saying that the typical family earns $100,000, when "the average American family makes $74,000 a year". Breitbart's article complained about "the difficulty of persuading a skeptical mainstream media that the proposal would cut taxes for the middle class." I found no article describing how the tax cut would benefit the typical family.
- twotwotwo 9y agoNot convinced by the bit at the end arguing that profiling mainly rich families is right because that's where the money is. If you want to look at where the money is, charts breaking down the overall changes in revenue--literally breaking down where the money is--are the right tool, and plenty of news outlets and think-tanks have been making those. (Like, I don't know, this: https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/DxNLXVIK9jjf6JdZlijXboCAnIA=/800x0/filters:no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/9910265/CHIP_VS_TAX_CUTS.jpg https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/DxNLXVIK9jjf6JdZlijXboCAnIA=... -- also, interesting URL with the rescaling operations there.) The point of looking at particular individuals and families is to translate it into impact on people's lives, and 1) a lot more lives are lived in those lower income ranges, so there's a greater multiplier to the impact there, and 2) the impact of a given dollar change in take-home pay is larger for someone less rich. For an example of the second factor, like a lot of people in the US tech business, my life probably doesn't change that much if my take-home pay goes up or down $1K. If someone only has a couple K of discretionary income every year it's a bigger deal; if someone can barely make rent anywhere in their city or can't afford to fix the car they take to work when it has mechanical issues, it's crucial.
- Gibbon1 9y agoOne of my bugaboos is people using the wrong metrics to try and describe problems. In this case relative price level means nothing at all. It's all about job security, opportunity and margin. You comment about the difference of $1k is all about margin.
- phamilton 9y agoThe conversation is repeatedly borked by differences in COL. Touting the national median income and then claiming someone earning $100k in SF (where the median income is ~$100k) is "out of touch" is frustrating.
- Eridrus 9y agoIt's interesting to think about how a progressive tax code is meant to tax those who can afford it the most, but it ignores COL differences so the taxes fall disproportionately on those in high COL locations.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoHigh COL locations typically manage to offer higher salaries too, though.
- Eridrus 9y agoExactly. You get a higher salary, but everything costs more. And the government takes a larger percentage of your salary. It's hard to nail down the magnitude of the effect, but it seems like a policy that basically subsidizes lower COL locations.
- eropple 9y agoSalaries versus COL, and the impacts of the perception of both, are not (usually) linearly correlated, but which side of the line any given locality falls upon is hard to predict. Salaries in San Jose, for example, are significantly better relative to COL (in part because of the halo effect from the rest of the Bay Area) than they would be in Los Angeles, where cost-of-living is high but a commensurate lifting of salary has not been seen. But considering this as a general note of unfairness rings pretty hollow to me. It's a relative scale problem; my yearly net is going to be more actionable and more usable than that of someone in a low-COL area because the work usually isn't there to begin with. As an example, from the numbers I've seen whenever I've talked to companies out there, I would probably take home between 40% and 50% more money if I relocated to San Francisco from Boston; I'm very good at what I do and my set of skills is in high demand. I'd probably pay between 20 and 25% more in expenses, including taxes. The biggest increase would, of course, be housing costs--but I would have more disposable income that I could then (because that kind of money is buy-capital money--unlike, say, a tiny pacifying bribe to look the other way while the rich monumentally loot us) use to invest and reap consistent returns in a way that is functionally unavailable to most people living in, say, the Lakes Region of Maine, where I grew up and where the average household income is about $41,000.
- Johnny555 9y agoA salient point from the article: So when we look for examples to illustrate the tax code, it makes sense to use a bunch of pretty wealthy families, because the big pictures is that nobody else really has very much money.
- matwood 9y agoThis is a good point. If someone is going to highlight what a federal tax cut does, they have to go to people actually paying federal taxes. Most people in lower incomes brackets already pay near 0 in federal tax. This is why tax cuts do not really help those who need help the most. To help those who really need help we have to spend money on things like healthcare, education, and jobs programs[1]. [1] As an aside, people rightfully rip on military spending waste a lot, but it is still a decently functioning jobs program.
- joshuaheard 9y agoOn the other hand, a tax cut helps a husband and wife working 60 hour weeks each, who barely have time for each other, in order to pay for the mortgage, health insurance, and try and save for retirement, and pay over 60% of their money to the government (40% fed tax, 14% state tax, 10% sales tax).
- dlp211 9y agoIf some family is taxed at those rates, they don't need a tax cuts because they are pulling a 7+ figure income. For reference, I make close to $200k and my effective federal tax rate including FICA taxes was 16%.
- Tostino 9y agoWhat are you even talking about... Who pays a 60% tax rate?
- jwlato 9y agoYou're claiming that 40% of their total earnings are lost to federal tax? In this example, what types and how much income are you proposing? Doesn't seem realistic to me.
- vowelless 9y agoI've been seeing quite a few slate.com articles on the frontpage lately (the dockless cycle comes to mind). I hope this is not the new normal...
- rainbowmverse 9y agoCan you expand on this for people who don't have an opinion on the site?
- NDizzle 9y agoThis page has some good examples: https://taxfoundation.org/final-tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-taxpayer-impacts/ https://taxfoundation.org/final-tax-cuts-and-jobs-act-taxpay... $30k income, single, no kids. $52k income, single, 2 kids. $75k income, single, no kids. $85k income, married, 2 kids. $165k income, married, 2 kids. ... That's the kind of stuff people are looking for, right? The $165k entry is two earners - all of these are fairly realistic examples. Those of you that think that something is missing from these examples - what do you think is missing? I mean, the low income earners even see a break. $30k income, single, no kids, and living in California goes from a federal tax bill of $2426 to $1970. (according to http://taxplancalculator.com/ http://taxplancalculator.com/ )
- eropple 9y agoThey see a break, but it isn't a structurally meaningful one. $500 is certainly short-term beneficial when you are making $30K--it is not enough, by at least an order of magnitude, to create long-term benefits, even if the knock-on effect of those tax cuts was not to ensure that the person making $30K a year ends up spending more than that $500 poorly replicating the government services that will be cut to pay for the top end of it. Even setting aside all that, that these tax cuts are functionally useless except as a transfer of wealth to monied interests, they expire in ten years besides. It's a more complex problem than what a calculator can really express without losing the ability to give a Nice Shiny Number out the other end.
- jedberg 9y agoMost everyone will get a break. There is a weird crunch for people making between $200K and $400K in a high tax state like CA or NY who will come out behind due to the loss of deduction on their property tax and state tax, and since they live in CA or NY, are probably barely middle class at those wages. The bigger issue is that, for example, the Walton family alone will get 5% of the 1.5 trillion dollar tax break. The Trump family will get a huge break too. It's unlikely that the Walton family or the Trump family will suddenly start making a ton of economic activity because of their windfalls, but in the meantime government revenue is down, which means they have to start cutting services. So most of the tax breaks for the lower earners will be eaten up over the next few years in paying for things the government used to subsidize for them.
- indubitable 9y agoThe reason the articles focus on families ranging from the median up is because the vast majority of people below the median income don't pay federal income taxes. [1] The bottom 40% actually have a negative effective federal tax rate. So going from 0% to 0% isn't exactly informative. The title of this submission (originally Please Don't Show Us Another “Typical Family Earning $270,000 a Year” in case it is changed) is misleading. The $270k number references another article [2] that looks at a wide array of different possible income groups. The lowest it goes is a married couple with one child earning $40k as their effective rate goes from 1.29% to -1%. Nowhere is it ever stated or even implied that $270k is a typical family. [1] - https://www.marketwatch.com/story/45-of-americans-pay-no-federal-income-tax-2016-02-24 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/45-of-americans-pay-no-fed... [2] - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-22/trump-signs-1-5-trillion-tax-cut-in-first-major-legislative-win https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-22/trump-sig...
- asimpletune 9y agoIt’s like the family from “Home Alone”. When you think about it, they’re really rich.
- joeax 9y agoIronically, in Winnetka IL where they supposedly live, they are probably looked down on and viewed as "typical".
- serf 9y agoeven when I was young I questioned the cost of putting 15-20 people on an airplane, the cost of daily breakfast of 15-20 people, let alone the fact they they appear to be affluent and live in a small mansion. When I got older I began wondering what the parents did for a living, but I never investigated it enough to see if it was explained. Glad to see i'm not the only one that questioned it.
- vidanay 9y ago$1.58 million in 2012 for the house. http://www.chicagotribune.com/classified/realestate/ct-biz-home-alone-house-may5-photogallery.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/classified/realestate/ct-biz-h...
- stmfreak 9y agoComplaining that rich benefit disproportionately from tax cuts while ignoring the negligible taxes paid by those under median income is politics as usual. It is the opposite side of the "fair share" argument when demanding more hand outs be paid by those with more money than the writer.
- eropple 9y agoIn a healthy, civic-conscious society, it is understood that those who have help those who don't and that this is a moral and ethical good. What we are seeing now with the profound selfishness of the modern American civic system (in some social quarters on the left, in most social and economic quarters on the right) is a breakdown of that mutual understanding and spirit of civic duty. Which leads to those who have incomprehensible amounts of money being defended by those with merely a lot of money against those with no money by characterizing the notion of ensuring a basic standard of living for those with no money as something like "handouts" instead of the mutual cooperation to keep a working society that people, not just rich people, actually want to live in. There is a statement about the need to get over oneself somewhere in there, but finding it is an exercise for the reader.
- perl4ever 9y agoSomething you didn't touch on is that there may be a different viewpoint on whether people are getting "handouts" based on assumed counterfactuals. Say one person makes $30K and another makes $5M. What is the "fair" amount of tax and who is getting a handout? The rich person may think "society provides people with $10K of support per capita, so if I pay more taxes than that, it's generous and if someone pays less, they're getting a handout". The person making $30K may reason that "if it wasn't for society catering to the privileged, nobody would make millions, so nearly all the excess over the average income is a handout if not paid in taxes". It all depends on where you anchor your assumption of what is deserved.
- wfo 9y agoRecall that for someone "making" $5M per year, the majority of income that high is inevitiably extractive and exploitative and comes from ownership and power, not the output of their actual work. One could argue if they deserve any of it beyond their actual real wages at a fairly evaluated rate, which might cap out at $1M in a democratic society. FDR proposed a 100% marginal tax rate on the highest earners, his opponents argued him down to something in the 90s, spawning the most productive period in US history.
- phyller 9y agoThis has been driving me nuts, I'm glad someone is writing about it. I don't think this is happening to show how much the tax cuts are giving back to people, I can't help but think that the reason only high earners are shown as examples is to paint this legislation as only benefiting high earners. If this is the case it has been broadly successful. Apparently half the country is buying into a narrative that their tax bills are going to go up, and I'm not sure where that idea is coming from. ( https://www.monmouth.edu/polling-institute/reports/MonmouthPoll_US_121817/ https://www.monmouth.edu/polling-institute/reports/MonmouthP... ) If the low income earners were included two things would be clear. 1) Many low income earners don't pay federal income taxes at all, many actually get paid by the IRS instead 2) Low income earners actually still benefit by getting either lower taxes or higher credits. The only example I saw of a regular person was in the Bloomberg article that was mentioned. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-20/how-the-tax-bill-will-affect-eight-american-families https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-20/how-the-t... The "renter in Milwaukee" went from paying $515 to actually being credited $400. At this point, there is no way of having a reduction in tax bills that doesn't overwhelming favor the top 50% of earners, because they pay almost all the federal income taxes. In 2015 the top 50% of those that filed tax returns paid over 97% of income taxes (the last table cell at the bottom all the way on the right https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/15in03etr.xls https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/15in03etr.xls ) EDIT: Based on experience on this board I knew this post would be downvoted, but I'm not exactly sure why. Please help make me a better contributor by telling me what I did wrong as you downvote, thanks!
- eropple 9y ago> At this point, there is no way of having a reduction in tax bills that doesn't overwhelming favor the top 50% of earners This is completely true. The reason the top half pay all the taxes is the top half have all the goddamned money. And that, of course, makes sense: the top half have the only realistic chance at accumulating enough labor-derived money to buy into capital and they've been doing exactly that for the last fifty years. Capital is not linear per-hour. Capital is a multiplier. That's why they have all the money. That they have all the money is the core and the source of the mess we're dealing with right now. Which means there is another question to be asked: should taxes be lowered? As someone very firmly in that top half, I am benefited by having people in the lower half of the income distribution not starving and dying in the streets, not dying of easily preventable injuries and illnesses, and not being so crushed by debt that revolution looks appealing. So are you. It's not about you, and it's not about me, but it's about us. We need to do better by us, so we can all keep this thing ticking along. And I gotta say, it's important not to miss that even that Bloomberg article elides a really, really important question: how much of that net $915 from that hypothetical renter now goes to (poorly) covering for the cuts in other services that will be necessitated to avoid budgetary disaster? It's a hard question, because nobody really knows, but it's a question whose answer will impact the people at the bottom of the income distribution the most, by far.
- reaperducer 9y agoThe problem is that the people putting together these scenarios almost exclusively live on the coasts, where $270k/year can be average more often. But just watch a TV show like House Hunters, and see how many people in America are struggling to buy a house that costs about the same as what people on the coasts spend on a fancy new car. There's your "average" person. There was one episode a few years ago where a guy in Atlanta had a budget of $46,000. Yes, just $46k for a condo. It was small, but it was home. It should also be of no surprise that the politicians view $270k as an "average" family. They're all completely out of touch. Remember back in the early 90's when Bill Clinton said that anyone making $200k/year was technically a millionaire, because there's no reason they couldn't save a million dollars in five years. Red or blue, they're both clueless.
- k__ 9y agoHow come so many people buy houses in the US, while most of us Germans rent? Even people considered of average income talk about their "condos" all the time. I always think, how can they be average if they own a whole house?!
- jadell 9y agoIt's a combination of factors. First off, culturally, it's just one of those "things you do" if you're pursuing the American Dream. Many people believe that owning your own home is one of the major milestones to living successfully. Secondly, for most people in the US who own homes, their home is their only source of equity or savings. Very few jobs in the US offer any type of pension, and many people don't have enough left over at the end of the month to put away in an independent retirement savings or investment account.
- betterunix2 9y agoPoliticians have encouraged home buying over the years, and there is a cultural ideal of home ownership (which goes hand-in-hand with owning and driving a car). This was a factor in the 2007-2008 financial crisis; banks had been encouraged to give loans to people with less income, in order to encourage more home ownership among the working class.
- jimmytucson 9y agoThe author makes a valid complaint about the examples these senators used to promote the tax bill but he doesn't further my understanding of the bill. In fact, what little he says about it seems wrong: > All changes to deductions, for example, only affect people who itemize their deductions (almost always high earners)—and within that group, only the subset whose deductions topped the new, doubled standard deduction. And this means that if your income is in the bottom half, your tax return won’t showcase many of the ways the law is changing. Let's break it down: > Most people who itemize are high earners. From what I found[1], 1 in 3 tax filers itemize. Most deductions come from mortgage interest and state and local taxes. I pay a mortgage and a hefty NJ state income tax. Am I a high roller? > The amount you pay in taxes will not change unless your itemized deductions top the new standard deduction. That's exactly wrong, right? If your itemized deductions top the new standard deduction then you will still itemize, so your deduction won't change. If you do not itemize (looking at you, non-high rollers) then your deduction will double. If your itemized deductions are lower than the new standard deduction (peasants like me), your deduction will increase to the new standard deduction. Also, I can't tell if he's saying you won't pay less in taxes, or if he's saying "your tax return won’t showcase many of the ways the law is changing". The latter is vague enough to be non-falsifiable. The former is just wrong because the tax rate is changing for every bracket but the lowest one. This is a contrived example, but a single filer making $50k who took the standard deduction last year would have remained in the 3rd tax bracket (25%) without the bill. With the bill, he'll deduct an additional $6k, which drops him into the 2nd tax bracket, which is now 10% (down from 12% a year ago). That's a nice chunk of change for a deadbeat! 1. http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/publications/who-itemizes-deductions http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/publications/who-itemizes-ded...
- poke111 9y agoI think this is often a dumb complaint and it shows itself in other contexts sometimes. There's a natural floor to income, it's $0. But there is no ceiling. So naturally if you want to give a sampling of scenarios covering most people, most examples will be high earners (even if there are fewer of those) because how many meaningfully different scenarios are there between $0 and $50k of income? EDIT: Another corollary of this explains part of why income inequality increases over time. As markets become more global, the upside for successful enterprises goes up - there are a lot more potential customers. So today someone at the top of their field can have a much higher income than he could in the past, whereas the income floor at $0 is unchanging.
- relics443 9y agoJealousy and greed is driving the opposition to the tax plan. If you look closely, you'll see that most complaints aren't about not getting a tax break, because 99.99999% of people will get one. No, the chief complaint is "the rich are getting more."