9 ms·
The cities mentioned as being great for cyclists are Copenhagen and Amersterdam, and now Berlin is trying. What is interesting is that the countries these citi
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
The cities mentioned as being great for cyclists are Copenhagen and Amersterdam, and now Berlin is trying.
What is interesting is that the countries these cities are in Denmark, Netherlands, and Germany have fertility rates of 1.7, 1.7, 1.5 births/female [0].
In other words, people aren't having that many children. When transporting children, cars become a whole lot more convenient than bicycles. You don't have to worry about them getting too cold or hot or wet. You can easily transport 3 children in the back of a car without difficulty (try doing that on a bicycle). The car can easily carry all the diapers and baby food you need for an outing as well as changes of clothing for inevitable accidents kids make.
Bikes are awesome for adults without children, cars seem better for those with children, especially young children.
I wonder if this push to bike friendliness is driven in part by the changing demographics of more adults without children.
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependencies_by_total_fertility_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d...
- nihonde 9y agoAnyone who lived in Japan knows about “mamachari” bikes, and a diminutive young mother with two kids and groceries on her bike. Not to mention all the senior citizens who ride everywhere as well. Electric-assist bikes, being able to ride on sidewalks or dedicated lanes, and safe parking help make it possible. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RLXnCu-KMdY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RLXnCu-KMdY
- ekianjo 9y agoPoor example though. There is plenty of car traffic in Japan about everywhere, and parking yout bike is not free at all. And cyclists are super dangerous here, not respecting any rule on the road. I was almost hit by bikes going in the wrong direction several times. And mamachari riders are no exception. they speed up on the sidewalks without any regard for pedestrians.
- CalRobert 9y agoFor what it's worth, I just had a kid and am contemplating whether I want to keep living in a cycling-hostile place. I would like my kid to be able to ride a bike without dying.
- fovc 9y agoIf that were the case you'd expect that families with children in those cities wouldn't be bike users. In Amsterdam at least they very much were. I lived next to a primary school where 90+% of parents would show up on bikes to pick up their kids. You can easily transport 3 kids in a bakfiets
- scythe 9y agoThat's not statistically valid reasoning. If biking vs driving makes some people not have kids, but not everyone, then in a city where driving is prohibitively expensive you'd still expect most parents to be on a bike. That's because the others didn't switch to cars, they didn't have kids, or they moved. I don't know what riding with one of those bike chariots is like, but being confined to a bike already sucks, I assume dragging a kid around behind you is even worse.
- bkor 9y agoYou're assuming the cycling is causing people to have less children. It would be nice to provide some statistically valid sources to explain why you think that's so. I live in the Netherlands and your assumption is pretty strange one. Mostly because it's not one or the other. You can do loads of things by bike while also having a car. Further, especially now with electric bikes you can transport an insane amount of children via a bike easily. Meaning: I see people transporting 5 or 6 children by bike (PS: this is on some fixed schedule, so not a one off, it is around the same time Mon-Fri). A bike is often more convenient than a car.
- scythe 9y ago>You're assuming the cycling is causing people to have less children. It would be nice to provide some statistically valid sources to explain why you think that's so. No, I'm providing alternate explanations for an observation that the previous poster claims shows that cycling does not cause people to have less children. I don't need to prove it happens, just show it's possible. Of course the "burden of proof" will always be assumed to fall on me because I disagree with popular opinion. I hope you enjoy the Netherlands. I never want to live in the Netherlands, and I'm sick and tired of people trying to turn the places I like into the Netherlands. Biking sucks. I do not want to ride a bike. Take your self-righteous crap and fuck off.
- kiliantics 9y agoI have family in Germany and they have two young children. They own a car but they only use it occasionally for trips. Their daily commute involves one of the parents transporting children to or from kindergarten using a bicycle trailer that both children can sit in. They do this year round and it works out fine. It works out a lot better, in fact, because cycling is much faster than sitting in rush hour traffic.
- imjasonmiller 9y agoThose trailers are very common in The Netherlands! Weather doesn’t play that much of a role, from what I know, neither does the fertility rate as cycling has been popular here when it used to be much higher, decades ago. It is very much a cultural thing in my experience. Nearly all children go to primary and high school on their bicycles, by themselves, although the trips for high schoolers are often < 8 km I would guess. I think that touches on why it might not be as popular in other countries, as other countries might not be as flat or lack city planning that takes cyclists into account, e.g. dedicated bike lanes. It’s also an excellent choice for a country of our size that has limited space, as bicycles make much better use of it than cars.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThis is how I plan on transporting my two kids by bicycle when they're a bit older (electric cargo bike): https://yubabikes.com/ https://yubabikes.com/ Disclaimer: no affiliation/promotion/etc
- SirLJ 9y agoTry doing the same during the winter in the northeast or central US
- kasey_junk 9y agoI live in Chicago and my family and our neighbors transport our children to school/stores/activities via bikes or feet. When the snow gets real bad we switch to sleds. Anecdotally from observing my kids school I’d say that yuba bike linked is very popular. As are the Dutch bikes with the big front thing for hauling kids. That of course relies on living in a place with infrastructure that enables it. Which is what Berlin is trying to build...
- walshemj 9y agoyou mean a cargo bike not very safe for the kids though
- kasey_junk 9y agoThis thing: https://jclindbikes.com/cargo-bikes/nihola-family/ https://jclindbikes.com/cargo-bikes/nihola-family/ Not sure why it would be any more/less safe for kids.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 9y agoPlenty of people in northern Scandinavia cycle throughout the winter. With the right clothing and equipment, the weather isn't a particular problem. Many of the highest-rated cities on the Copenhagenize Index of cycle-friendly cities are far north. The highest-rated city in the US is Minneapolis. Malmö, Helsinki and Montréal also make the top 20. http://copenhagenize.eu/index/ http://copenhagenize.eu/index/ People from non-cycling cultures tend to badly under-estimate the quality of utility cycling equipment and over-estimate the impact of weather on a well-equipped rider. Schwalbe Marathon Winter tires have hundreds of steel spikes and will grip securely even on black ice. SKS Longboard fenders provide a huge amount of protection from rain, spray and road grime. Lobster mittens keep your hands toasty warm in arctic conditions, while still allowing you to operate the brake and gear levers. Epicyclic gearhubs provide up to 14 gear ratios in a completely enclosed and practically maintenance-free package. Good LED bicycle lights are stunningly bright, rivalling the performance of car headlamps. A long john or Christiania cargo bike will comfortably carry two children, a week's worth of groceries or even a washing machine; with electric assist, these bikes are viable even in very hilly areas.
- jacobolus 9y agoI have a 1.5 year old child, and I must disagree. Car-centric places are horrible with a child (or really anyone who isn’t a healthy ~20–65 year old adult who can afford a car). To get anywhere you need to pack all your stuff into a car, get the child in and out of a carseat, unpark and park, walk around in a big parking lot, etc. Every trip has huge overhead. It gets even worse when there are multiple kids involved. Living in a walkable neighborhood with access to transit is so much nicer. I just pick the kid up in my arms and go out the door, and many destinations are a few minutes walk, all of which is time spent actively moving and being part of the outside world. In a couple years, if I need to drop him off somewhere within bike distance (but far enough away that walking is less practical), it would be great to use a child seat or little cart attached to a bike. It’s going to be an even bigger difference when the kid is older, and can walk around and take transit and engage with the city by himself, instead of being completely isolated and dependent and needing to be chauffeured and chaperoned by an adult on every trip.
- abalashov 9y ago> It’s going to be an even bigger difference when the kid is older, and can walk around and take transit and engage with the city by himself, instead of being completely isolated and dependent and needing to be chauffeured and chaperoned by an adult on every trip. This. I don't think most Americans realise how detrimental and significant this often-overlooked aspect of average middle American suburban life is.
- ocschwar 9y agoWalking down an English high street with an intrepid 1 year old explorer was an eye opener for me. (Translation: a high street is a main street in an English town. They're usually car-free.) Every time my son bolted, I had a full 30 seconds of slack before having to chase him down because there was no risk of him being squished under a tire.
- soperj 9y agoSounds like you've never been there. I spent some time right outside Amsterdam (in Haarlem), and you can easily get a couple kids and a baby on a bike(in a bakfiets). You can easily carry all the diapers and baby feed you need for an outing in a stroller which is all you really need because nearly everything you could want is within walking distance. -had 2 kids at the time(nearly 3 and 6 months), as well as cousins in town(same age) that we took on the bike as well, not that we used it that much, mostly to go out to another town like Zaanvoort on the coast (11 km away) or to the train station if we were going somewhere further. Also, every single kid of school age got themselves to school by bike, so the whole pick up/drop up culture of North America wasn't happening.
- arximboldi 9y agoAgreed. Berlin is a very child-friendly city, and the biking is part of it. It is very common for parents to carry their kids in the bike. And heavy traffic makes the city less child-safe, not more.
- airza 9y agoIt's an almost daily occurrence to see a parent riding their bike full of kids in Leiden or Amsterdam.
- AndyMcConachie 9y agoAs a Dutchie with no kids I must kindly disagree with you. Go to any Dutch city and you will see tons of parents riding on bikes with their kids. It's common to see 1 adult and 2 kids on the same bike.
- ekianjo 9y agoGo to any city thats not flat and you will soon find bikes to be unpractical for about everything.
- adrianN 9y agoYou can get an e-bike a lot cheaper than a car.
- brailsafe 9y agoThat's where efficient and reliable public transit comes in, as well as living near a denser area.
- pg314 9y agoI live in a city that is not flat. If you have a bicycle with gears that is no problem.
- ekianjo 9y agoWhen you have to carry several kgs of shopping bags as well as your kid in the back seat, no matter what gears you have you will soon reach your limits.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat's why we've got these: https://www.christianiabikes.com/ https://www.christianiabikes.com/ https://www.babboe.nl/ https://www.babboe.nl/ They're so common that during the morning rush hour it seems like every other bike is a 'bakfiets'. They're a direct descendant of the old cargo delivery bikes from the previous century. There are two wheeled versions as well and then there are trailers to put behind normal bikes (though I don't like those much, because cars tend to overlook them due to their height).
- adrianN 9y agoIf people with children in their cars made up a majority of traffic that would be a good argument. Most trips are made solo though. Replacing at least some of those trips with cycling is better for everybody: the cyclists health, the environment, the children playing on the streets.
- tatami 9y agoAnd for drivers! Less cars on the road makes it better for those who are left.
- rconti 9y agoYou'll see this kind of arrangement all over Amsterdam and Copenhagen. Hell, even here in the SF Bay area I see (almost daily) a couple of parents on my bike commute route riding home with bicycles with those long racks on the back that can hold 2-3 kids, with a helmet dangling from the rack as they've obviously just completed the school run. https://i.pinimg.com/originals/91/7c/7a/917c7a6c31acf962cb21a72820f718e2.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/91/7c/7a/917c7a6c31acf962cb21...
- Someone 9y agoIf you have >2 children, chances are the oldest can ride his/her own bicycle (especially if the infrastructure provides lots of safety) Also, see https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/tag/children/ https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/tag/children/
- lagadu 9y agoI take it you've never been any significant amount of time in Copenhagen. There a bicycles for transporting children that are made to transport up to two children, usually up to 3-4 years old, after that they can cycle themselves so I've never heard about it being an issue because the eldest will usually be old enough to cycle. edit: I guess you could increase that to 3 children if you attach a bike trailer, but those aren't very popular here.
- sqren 9y ago> You can easily transport 3 children in the back of a car without difficulty (try doing that on a bicycle). I see this everyday in Copenhagen: https://christianiacykel12.files.wordpress.com/2010/12/image-3.jpg https://christianiacykel12.files.wordpress.com/2010/12/image...
- megy 9y ago> When transporting children, cars become a whole lot more convenient than bicycles. Cars are almost always more convenient for most people, with or without children.