4 ms·
The Atlantic to Install Paywall
- junkscience2017 9y agoDespite what these publications tell you, the oversupply of people wanting to write things on the internet means you actually do not need to pay for "quality" journalism. For every grizzled vet that throws in the towel, frustrated with adblocking freeloaders...two young idealists take their place. Anyone can publish a blog. Mastheads don't have a reason to exist anymore. My advice to a young writer is to build your own brand and forget about print operations trying vainly to stay relevant but have no reason to exist anymore. On any given day, on any given topic, I can usually look around for a few minutes in any Reddit thread and find something genuine, well written, and useful that is equal to or superior to "quality" journalism that apparently won't survive without my money
- godzillabrennus 9y agoInvestigative journalism takes money. Freelance bloggers can’t be expected to put in the time to do the job while they pay for their hobby writing.
- junkscience2017 9y agoIn 2017 you learn things when they are leaked, not when they are investigated. How much was Edward Snowden making for the story of the year? Atlantic on the other hand publishes long form opinion pieces
- robin_reala 9y agoLeaks still require investigation.
- danso 9y agoWhere was Snowden initially published?
- bhhaskin 9y agoWhen was the last time you saw real investigative journalism? These days it's a race to get what ever click-bait headlines you can get from 'unamed sources' (or my favorite 'sources close to X') up and out the door. Gotta get those sweet sweet ad views. Journalistic integrity is long dead and what's left are those Freelance bloggers; except they no longer write for blogs, but major entertainment outlets.
- robin_reala 9y agoParadise / Panama Papers was a good example of recent modern investagative journalism.
- ralfd 9y agoTake this story about the "banned words at the CDC" which double checked a story by the Washington Post: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/16/health/cdc-trump-banned-words.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/16/health/cdc-trump-banned-w... The NYT contacted the agency spokesman and several present and former federal officials. They contacted the agency spokeswoman of the FDA. They quote a former Surgeon General and an outsider expert. > Sheila Kaplan reported from Washington, and Donald G. McNeil Jr. from New York. Pam Belluck contributed reporting from New York. Three people wrote the article and pooled their contacts or input. It was likely edited to make it short and concise. How many blog posts care to do that instead of rehashing or just spinning opinion?
- simula67 9y agoI don't think calling people up and asking them to make a statement is beyond the reach of a blogger. Investigative journalism does take a lot of effort and it needs to be encouraged, however vast majority of journalism produced is not investigative and could be made more efficient and democratic
- jdietrich 9y agoBuzzFeed have a superb investigative team. This year, they broke the story of the alleged assassination of 14 Russian citizens on British soil and a subsequent cover-up. Six journalists were credited for the piece and it's clear that they spent months on it. https://www.buzzfeed.com/investigations https://www.buzzfeed.com/investigations https://www.buzzfeed.com/heidiblake/from-russia-with-blood-14-suspected-hits-on-british-soil https://www.buzzfeed.com/heidiblake/from-russia-with-blood-1... Inside Housing revealed that tower blocks were being fitted with unsafe cladding months before the Grenfell Tower disaster. They uncovered the issue through lengthy reporting of previous fires in high-rise buildings over the course of several years. This obscure little trade magazine has won a shower of national awards for their doggedly determined investigative work. https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/news/news/inside-housing-beats-national-papers-to-land-top-journalism-prizes-53563 https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/news/news/inside-housing-bea... There are hundreds of superb investigative journalists working for local and regional newspapers, doing crucial work under severe constraints. They're underpaid, underresourced and underappreciated, but without their work, all manner of injustices would go unreported. Numerous national scandals have been identified because of the work of one local reporter, doing the dog-work of sitting in courtrooms and knocking on doors.
- pm90 9y ago> A spokesperson for the Atlantic said the magazine will launch with annual pricing equivalent to “one fairly nice cup of coffee per month. If every online property asks me to do this, I would be buying wayy too much coffee and losing too much cash. That being said, it is a difficult problem and I'm not sure what the answer is. I pay for my NYT and WaPo subscription, but probably can't (or won't) be paying for Atlantic. I really really like Vox media though, but they don't seem to have a subscription based option. Also: Politico.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoI say pretty much the same thing when charities try to get me to sign up for a monthly payment. If I gave money to every charity that asked for it, I wouldn't have any money left myself. Maybe what we need is a sort of central payment system for news media. Sort of like Spotify for news, except that the outlets keep their own sites and you have a single sign on for all the sites. Your monthly payment would be distributed according to how many articles you read on each site (or some other, more fair metric to reward high quality articles, maybe time spent?).
- cbcoutinho 9y agoThere's already an app that I know of that does that - or at least close enough. Blendle is an app where you pay per article you read, paid through your in-app account. My uncle uses it to selectively read articles from some large publications. I think one downside is that those publications don't let you sign in on their systems, so you have to rely on the availability of the articles through a third-party. I agree that it would be great to have publications allow you to sign in through a third party system instead of their own. Maybe we can hope for one in the future?
- geraltofrivia 9y agoAlso, while I'm sure it's there for practical reasons, the per article price makes me very uncomfortable. There's this split second decision that I make as open an article - is it worth my time? To ask "if it's worth my money?" before every read seems less than ideal. For instance if my music service asked me a penny for every song I play, I'd probably end up listening to a lot less songs than I do.
- craftyguy 9y ago> “More than a million people come to our site 10 times or more every month,” Mr. Cohn said. “What we’re doing now is we’re saying to that group: ‘Help us continue to expand our journalism.’” No, what they're saying is: $-)
- dx034 9y agoIt's hard to expand journalism without hiring journalists.
- PhoenixReborn 9y agoI would gladly fork over money for them and other news sites to keep the servers running in lieu of ads.
- Havoc 9y agoIt’s funny how initially everyone thought those media barons pushing their sites behind paywalls were seen as crazy. They seem to have achieved their vision though - if everything is behind one then it no longer looks abnormal.
- jmfayard 9y agoI see paywalls as win-win deal. The abundance cliché tells us that more news outlets reaching more readers is always a good thing. In reality though for the news producers, what's the point of reaching many millions if you become a slave of advertisements and of the competition for people's attention? And from our perspective as readers, we should drop the abundance mentality and understands our news consumption much like we understand our food consumption. There is the equivalent to consuming too much food and to consuming unhealthy food. Consuming more don't make us more informed. As Steven Pinker says, even when it's honest and good, "News is a misleading way to understand the world". It's all about dramatic events that just happened and slow but powerful and meaningful evolutions naturally take the backseat. But they do make us meaner, angrier, more pessimistic. I prefer to choose to consume less news, but to really enjoy the ones that I do consume. And "I am ready to pay for it?" is a very good assesment of wether that's the case. https://www.vox.com/2016/8/16/12486586/2016-worst-year-ever-violence-trump-terrorism https://www.vox.com/2016/8/16/12486586/2016-worst-year-ever-...
- Fnoord 9y agoAgreed, paywalls are a win-win because it has the potential to remove the chains of clickbait and pulp. Except that "a cup of coffee" is a US-centric term which doesn't apply everywhere in the world. Not everyone in the world (or even the US) can afford to spend those few USD a month on a news outlet. And if they, they can only afford to buy so many cups of coffee. So a lot of people who can't afford won't resort to it. Except, perhaps, in their native languages. (Comment written on the cost-free, advertisement-free website Hacker News.)
- muzani 9y agoI would really be happy if there was a journalism company that I could pay for quality articles. Unfortunately, most articles are low quality. Clickbait journalism is like this - a lot of people produce things that people would be willing to pay to not read. The quality articles are also extremely rare; most media sites are one hit wonders, creating only one or two quality things. So a subscription would not be helpful either. I think a better way to monetize would be to write a book or something, collecting the best of the best, or digging deeper into an idea that went viral. Tim Ferriss and Cal Newport comes to mind.
- QasimK 9y agoYou’re looking for things like blendle.com. I don’t use this particular service because they don’t allow “+” in email addresses.
- danso 9y agoLOL that's the reason that I gave up trying to subscribe to the WSJ digital edition, even after as much Imliked heir Theranos investigation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 9y agoQuality content takes time and effort to produce, so it's very expensive. A serious long-form investigative piece could take several man-months, whereas a clickbaity opinion piece can be knocked out by an intern in a couple of hours. It's a chicken-and-egg problem. If you don't pay, they can't afford to produce quality journalism. If they don't produce quality journalism, you won't pay.
- jlebrech 9y agoit'll never happen, it's all listening to what YOU want to hear.
- egeozcan 9y agoWhere is the Spotify for online newspapers already?
- rusk 9y agoWell I think that both Apple and Google have tried to do this with their respective newstand apps but I'm not sure how successful this has been. Also revenue I guess, for such a service is probably a good bit less than getting your readers to pay soley for access to your publication.
- stiller 9y agoBlendle offer a pay-per-article model. It's very hard if not impossible to make a sound business case for the Spotify model in journalism. The running costs for creating new content on a daily are much higher.
- rusk 9y agoI found I was reading a few Atlantic articles here and there so I thought sure why not support journalism and sign up for subscription. Signed up for print and digital. The whole experience was awful. After three months I never received a single print copy. The only digital edition I could access under android was the one that was freely available anyway. I couldn't access the premium content. For that I had to go and download the PDF which is quite suboptimal. The IOS app wasn't great either. (EDIT: I should say that I was back and forth with their "support" numerous times about my issues before I took the decision to cancel) In the end I cancelled, but it took a few goes to get in touch with anybody about it... I figured out how to do the cancellation myself on their "site" but even then had to go through some third party fulfilment agency to get the full refund. Promised me a cheque. Cheque never arrived and eventually I kicked up a stink and they just refunded to my credit card. Good luck to them I suppose. They do some great long reads and those writers have to be paid. Hopefully this paywall signals transition to a more solid commercial framework ... totally put me off them though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gexla 9y agoThank you. I have already been getting some pretty good practice in ignoring any of the current paywall sites. It's a great way to cut down on distraction. If the best content sites do this, then I can ignore the rest as well. I feel they should all get paid and I would rather that model rather than ads. My comment sounds negative, but I think it's a good move. I have switched to newsletters which give headlines and summaries.
- Jaruzel 9y agoWhat we need is a central payment body that we can 'subscribe' to and then select the websites with paywalls we want access to. Then its a) easy to manage your budget as it's one payment per month/six/yearly, and b) reduces reader friction, as a SAML/oAuth type logon can be performed when you click through the paywall notice on your selected news sites. All that needs to happen is for someone to stand up and be the payment body, and for a critical mass of news sites to sign up. Doesn't seem that hard really.
- stiller 9y agoBlendle provides something close to what you describe: https://pay-docs.blendle.io/ https://pay-docs.blendle.io/ So it's mostly a matter of these publication signing up.
- jaggederest 9y agoMaybe now they'll stop gaming the system on sites like Reddit and HN. They were banned from reddit for shady practices for a while, and went so far as to switch to different domains to get around it.