4 ms·
Humans tended to live in small groups of mostly related people. If you met another human outside of your group you usually tried to kill each other. It's thoug
by colechristensen 9y ago
Humans tended to live in small groups of mostly related people. If you met another human outside of your group you usually tried to kill each other. It's thought that the global human diaspora resulted from these small bands of people trying to avoid each other as much as possible.
- watwut 9y ago"Humans tended to live in small groups of mostly related people." That is perfect situation for bullying. The victim cant leave. Close knit groups are great, until they are not.
- colechristensen 9y agoThey were generally family groups that very much depended on each other constantly for survival. The social dynamics would be very different than what can readily be imagined today. Harassing someone whose existence is necessary for you all to eat tomorrow or to avoid getting eaten by wild animals is going to be quite a different situation. Applying the fad buzzword for children being mean to each other in suburban middle schools to primitive human culture isn't exactly a valid comparison.
- monob 9y agoThe only people who long for a large family are the ones that aren't in one. Look at how much constant violence and bullying there is between any siblings when an adult isn't around to stop it.
- perfmode 9y agoDifferent environment, no? Back then, kids would need to rely on each other more, no? Nowadays, what good is a sibling really?
- monob 9y ago"Back then" you would try and kill your oldest brother to inherit the 2 chickens and a goat your parents would leave to him. Read no further than the histories of nobles and their feuds and murders to see how bad the best families were.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe nobles were the richest families, but not necessarily the best by any other measure.
- monob 9y agoBest by food availability, shelter, labor. Given that even in good years a large portion of the population was malnourished in whatever time period you want to pick before the middle of the 20th century, the rich were always better off than the poor and rich families were better than poor ones.
- dragonwriter 9y agoRight, all those things are different ways of saying wealth. The implication made uphtread is that the rich were best in terms of (lower) intrafamilial conflict. One might assume that wealth produced that effect, one might also assume that the rich were more dependent on social status and property for support, while the poor were more dependent on having close relations who could give aid and lacked assets to fight over, thus leading to less intrafamilial conflict than among the rich.
- meebs 9y agoI have a huge extended family 20+ kids my generation and while we aren't all close and kids will beat each other up sometimes there's no bullying. Blood is blood.
- watwut 9y ago"Harassing someone whose existence is necessary for you all to eat tomorrow or to avoid getting eaten by wild animals is going to be quite a different situation." Then again, harassing someone who depends on you is entirely different. Then again, bullying someone so that you ensure pecking order and he does what you want and is beneficial for you a bit more in situation with scarcity is different too. Suburban middle schools kids did not invented cruelty nor mockery nor ostracization nor beating other kids up. My grand parents remembered such stories. Old books contains such stories. If anything, this get worst with bad situations - hunger or war. There is no reason to think primitive people were somehow magically honorable and noble.
- colechristensen 9y agoI'm talking about primitive human hunter-gatherer society, you're talking about your grandparents.
- watwut 9y ago"small groups of mostly related people" still bully and harass each other which is case of grandparents childhood. Why would hunter-gatherers not? Especially since victim leaving his group makes him vulnerable to all those other tribes that would "tried to kill" you (plus your old)?
- solarkraft 9y agoI am guessing that it's both the ones who won the fights and those who avoided them survived. When these groups meet in (fairly) modern society it's not that hard to imagine what happens to the latter group.