8 ms·
Since 1700, Wine Glasses Have Gotten 7 Times Bigger
- DrScump 9y agoThe paper: http://www.bmj.com/content/359/bmj.j5623 http://www.bmj.com/content/359/bmj.j5623
- matt4077 9y agoThis references the study showing that people eat more when using larger plates, but I think wine drinking is the one instances where those results aren't easily transferrable. Wine glasses today are usually filled to about 1/4, where (judging by the painting in the article, and my guess) glasses 1/7th the size of today's were filled to the rim.
- jgibson 9y agoI wonder how much of the liquid/volume ratio is just due to people trying to protect their white carpet...
- justinjlynn 9y agowhat do you mean? that'd be an amusing correlation to show, actually, but the study would be torturous.
- fosco 9y agosome anecdata - I spilled an oversized glass of red wine our carpet ina previous house and escalated my wife's 'need' for wooden floors by unknown to immediate. :-) on a side note we were much happier with the wooden floor
- lostlogin 9y agoI hope your dog need reduced in parallel. Skating dogs are surprisingly destructive.
- berberous 9y agoYou don't know many drunks, I guess. Lots of people fill the glass much more than they are supposed to.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoExactly. The photos in the article even show this. The modern glasses shown in the article clearly aren't filled with 7x1700-size servings each, otherwise they'd be drinking literally thimbles worth of wine in the 1700's. Restaurants do tend to pour only part of a glass, usually 100-175 mL, depending on location, quality of wine, and country. However, I've seen plenty of people in a home environment pour to the top, or at least 2/3 of the glass, they're usually counting their drinks by the bottle though, rather than the glass.
- maxxxxx 9y agoEverything is getting much bigger. The candy in my youth was really small compared to today's bars. With ice cream it's even worse.
- snug 9y agoThat may be true from your youth, but things are getting smaller from a decade ago, candy[0], chips, fountain drinks, etc. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/jul/24/sweets-are-shrinking-youre-not-imagining-it-ons-tells-shoppers https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/jul/24/sweets-are-...
- maxxxxx 9y agoThis is an interesting dynamic. First they made things much bigger and now they are trying to deliver less at the same price. It would be interesting to see how decisions for pricing and size are made.
- coldacid 9y agoWhatever maximizes profit.
- freeflight 9y agoIt's also interesting how difficult they can make comparing sizes/prices for even the simplest things, like for example toilet paper. Even comparing similar quality rolls with each other can sometimes be quite a math exercise, as different manufacturers sell different numbers of rolls, with different numbers of sheets, sometimes even in different sizes per sheet. So how to calculate the best value toilet paper? Based on sheets? Based on average area of paper you get per roll? And who wants to do all that when you are simply looking for something to, literally, wipe your butt with? Sometimes I think having choices can be a really bad non-choice.
- WhyNotHugo 9y agoHuh, we've fixed that in Argentina, because supermarkets have to label the price both by unit, and by a standard measure (eg: kg / litres). So the price tag on toilet papers will display the price per metre, and the price tag on coffee has the price by kg. This makes it trivial to compare same-quality products, and also trivial to compare across different stores. Note that they MUST do this by law, so all supermarkets (and also wholesalers) do this.
- mattzito 9y ago> These days, the average British pour of wine is 250 milliliters, “larger than the mean capacity of wine glasses available in the 1980s,” writes Marteau. Wow that’s a big pour - you expect to get 4-5 glasses of wine out of a standard 750ml bottle, potentially a little more than that if you’re ordering by the glass in a restaurant.
- celticninja 9y agoThat's a large wine though. A standard is 175ml, large 250ml. However many places nowadays just serve large by default.
- Geojim 9y agoYeh, bet sensationalist. Study actually refers to "wine is increasingly served in 250 mL servings" and "usually a 175 mL measure".
- abalone 9y agoThe article misquotes its source. The study states "wine is increasingly served in 250 mL servings" (emphasis mine), not that the average pour size has become 250ml! 250ml is a typical carafe size. Carafes are a more common way to serve wine in Europe, compared to ordering two separate glasses.
- r00fus 9y agoCarafes are usually house wine though. Hard to get carafe sizing for a higher end wine.
- abalone 9y agoEven if true, this does not support the claim that Britains consume significantly more wine than in 1700. (Which may be true but it’s not supported.) If anything it would suggest that higher end wine is sold by the glass or bottle... again the source does not claim otherwise.
- djrogers 9y agoI have heard that such small glasses were a) somewhat necessary due to the difficulty of glassmaking in the 1700s, and b) not a problem when you have servants following you around keeping your glasses topped up.
- easy_lucky_free 9y agoI mean, the average person didn't exactly have servants. Glass-making concept makes sense to me though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- excitom 9y agoBack in the day a Royal Navy sailor's daily ration of beer was a gallon, or a half pint of 115 proof rum. I don't think the dainty wineglasses are a good indication of volume consumed.
- dragonwriter 9y agoOTOH, the phrase “drink like a sailor” for heavy consumption of alcohol exists for a reason; RN alcohol rations probably aren't a good indication of society-wide consumption patterns.
- rsynnott 9y agoIf a sailor died of cirrhosis at 40, though, the Navy wasn’t too bothered. Alcohol is more of a heath threat these days partially because consumption has tended to rise, but also because people aren’t dying of other things as much.
- Amezarak 9y ago> but also because people aren’t dying of other things as much. Historical life expectancies were usually not that bad. The shortness of pre-modern life is generally grossly exaggerated, with the raw numbers being dragged down by things like infant mortality. See, for example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2672390/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2672390/ > Analysis of the mid-Victorian period in the U.K. reveals that life expectancy at age 5 was as good or better than exists today, and the incidence of degenerative disease was 10% of ours. In times of great calamities like massive, prolonged wars and plagues - which some societies are more susceptible to than others [1] - things certainly turned grim, but by-and-large things weren't so bad. One way you can get a picture of this yourself is by looking at your genealogical history, which effectively lets you calculate "life expectancy from teens/early 20s", since all your ancestors were old enough to have kids. It's a somewhat selective picture, but if you fill out enough branches to the early 1700s, you can get a probably reasonable sample. [1] And actually, Victorian England was particularly unsanitary and subject to disease - it really says something that even a plague-ridden society of people who ate arsenic and mercury still lived just as long or longer than us.
- matte_black 9y agoAre historically accurate classic size wine glasses sold today? They look classy.
- fatjokes 9y agoYou can get sherry glasses.
- Tade0 9y agoThey look a lot like modern cordial glasses.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThat's because they are. The article is wrong.
- astura 9y agoI've seen port served in similar looking glasses, like this: http://whitecompany.scene7.com/is/image/whitecompany/GLHMP_2_MAIN?wid=1624 http://whitecompany.scene7.com/is/image/whitecompany/GLHMP_2...
- erpellan 9y agoWine was probably vastly more expensive as a proportion of income in the 1700s compared to today. Makes sense that glasses would be that much smaller.
- gozur88 9y agoI believe that. I'll bet mead, beer, and rum were more affordable.
- justaaron 9y agoWhy has no one mentioned that "wine" to a Brit in 1700 meant FORTIFIED wine like Port wine or Sherry (aka 18-20% alcohol instead of 11-15%)? The fortification of Port wine is legendarily attributed to both British tastes for sweet or "stalled mid fermentation by addition of spirits" wine, and the voyage by sea, in which normal wines suffered excessively from spoilage etc.
- arca_vorago 9y agoThe world was never the same for me once I discovered madeira wine. All the richness of port with half the sweetness.
- lqet 9y agoThis is what I thought. I regularly enjoy a "modern" glass of wine, but for port wine, even a full shot glass is too much for me. It's just so heavy and sweet. The glasses depicted in the article seem to hold exactly the amount of port I would be able to comfortably drink in 10-20 minutes.
- bootcampjs 9y agoHave you looked into cordial glasses? They’re made for this! They’re the perfect size for a nice port after dinner.
- wahern 9y agoHave you tried a Sercial or Verdelho Madeira? Almost all Madeira sold is Malmsey, which is the sweetest. You'll sometimes find bottles of the Boal style, the next sweetest, sold as a digestif if the restaurant is a little more discerning. But the best styles, IMO, are Sercial and Verdelho. Sercial is dry and Verdelho medium-dry[1], IMO have more fascinating flavors, and tend to be more acidic than the sweeter styles, which as a soda drinker I especially like. Both are really good for extended sessions as they're not nearly as cloying as Port. And the Sercial in particular suitable for drinking by the glassful with dinner if you care to splurge. And one of the greatest things about Madeira is that it's already completely oxidized. Opinions very, but as for myself I still enjoy bottles of Madeira that I opened years ago. By contrast, IME an opened bottle of Tawny Port starts to lose its punch after a week or so (on the outside). This is why you can still buy Madeira from the 1800s and even 1700s and still enjoy it today. The oldest enjoyable Ports (Ruby or Tawny) tend to only go back 50 or 100 years if they've been preserved well. If you're not a regular drinker (like me) or are the sole drinker in a household (like me), and don't enjoy hard liquor (like me), then the long shelf-life of opened bottles is really nice. The Historic Series Madeiras from the Rare Wine Co are good exemplars of the various styles https://www.rarewineco.com/rare-wine-co-historic-series-madeira I don't know if they still do, but they used to offer a 4 half bottle sample gift set. [1] Though both still sweeter and thicker (mouth feel) than a Sherry, with less of the distilled spirits-like flavor/smell coming through--which is why I dislike Sherry.
- t0mas88 9y agoFlying a lot around Europe I'm always surprised by how full the British side of things fills a wineglass :-) 125 ml is normal in the majority of places, 180 ml is a British glass of wine. The article is from the UK... But both 125 and 180 ml servings are considerably less than the size of the glass, so the article title is at best clickbaity. The glass got bigger but nobody is pouring 7x as much wine per serving as before.
- padthai 9y agoI think wine glasses became bigger to let the wine breathe and exposing as much surface as possible to air. Same logic as wine decanters.
- realusername 9y agoAnd also in the UK, they generally pour your wine glass up to the top (no idea why) whereas in France it's always served with about a 1/4 of the glass.
- raverbashing 9y agoWeird, I haven't been to those places Most places (bars), they fill a standard measure and pour that onto the glass, which fill it up to the aforementioned 1/4th of the glass Or they give you a standard small wine bottle
- Symbiote 9y agoThat depends on the quality of the place. An average pub might choose these glasses with the legal markings at 125, 175 and 250mL, which probably makes the 250mL serving seem quite full. A nicer place will have larger glasses, or serve the smaller amount. http://www.drinkstuff.com/products/product.asp?ID=21754&catID=1436&name=Saxon+Tri+Lined+Wine+Glasses+12oz+LCE+at+125%2C+175+%26amp%3B+250ml http://www.drinkstuff.com/products/product.asp?ID=21754&catI...
- realusername 9y agoI've mostly been to cheaper places so that would explain it!
- drewmol 9y agoI was thinking the same as many other commenters: Wonder how this compares to the increased size of tablewear or portion sizes in general. In the age of 64oz soda's and XL meal size options, seems wine glasses would increase at a similar rate.
- abalone 9y agoSince 1700, wine has gotten 7 times better.[1] [1] http://drinks.seriouseats.com/2013/06/wine-history-paul-lukacs-inventing-wine-how-wine-was-modernized-ancient-wine-tasted-terrible.html http://drinks.seriouseats.com/2013/06/wine-history-paul-luka...
- JauntyHatAngle 9y agoIsn't wine also meant to be in a bigger glass so the vapour collects in the glass better for smelling?
- esmi 9y agohttp://www.delish.com/food/news/a39120/super-sized-beverages/ http://www.delish.com/food/news/a39120/super-sized-beverages... "For 25 years, a 26-ounce drink was the biggest soda a person could buy. Then in 1980, a shift occurred when 7-Eleven began its Big Gulp campaign. Big Gulp fountain drink cup sizes steadily rose throughout the decade and beyond, beginning at 32 ounces in 1980, then climbing to 44 ounces in 1986, 64 ounces in 1989, and a behemoth 128 ounces in 2006. Called the Team Gulp, the 128-ounce cup holds a gallon of soda." Wine is lagging behind. More wine please... :)
- wmil 9y agoA bottle of wine is less than 26 oz. So the wineries need to catch up.
- greglindahl 9y agoThere are larger wine bottles: magnum, double magnum, jeroboam, ... http://www.wrathofgrapes.com/bottles.html http://www.wrathofgrapes.com/bottles.html
- Symbiote 9y agoFor those outside the US, like me: 26oz ≈ 769mL 32oz ≈ 946mL 44oz ≈ 1301mL 64oz ≈ 1893mL 128oz ≈ 3785mL In America, are these labelled as multiple servings? Even a 500mL bottle of cola in Europe is labelled as two 250mL servings.
- makesthingspos 9y agoThese cups are not usually labeled with serving information. They don't, for example, have how many calories are in them because they can be filled with a variety of different sodas (some zero calorie). FWIW, from my perception, the 128 oz is very rare, 64 oz is fairly common but a small percent of sales, and 44 oz is very common. (edit: these are for convenience stores like 7-11, not restaurants etc where sizes are much smaller)
- 9y ago
- wott 9y agoIt is always funny to see Americans using huge (as in HUGE) glasses to drink wine, believing that it is the French distinguished way of tasting wine, and being disappointed when they discover that French people just use regular/smallish glasses in any context. No, it is just Americans confusing 'big' for 'refined' as usual :-) (and bigger for more refined, and even bigger for super classy).
- throwaway5752 9y agoMost people in the US go to a specialty retailer if they need wine glasses, and a nice one has Riedel or something comparable. The sales associate will invariably say "oh this is made to enjoy red Bordeauxs, this one is for white Burgundies, etc, etc" and they will be nudged to go fancy. I don't know if they go in with the expressed plan to buy an enormous wine glass set, but just look at https://www.riedel.com/restaurant/collection/d/sommeliers/bordeaux-grand-cru-1/ https://www.riedel.com/restaurant/collection/d/sommeliers/bo..., it's 30 oz. I think it's fair to say there is an element of industry pushing consumer demand in a more expensive direction. Also, I think it's fair to point out Riedel is European and has been around for 250 years. Also, even if I was presented with that wine glass, I would expect nothing more than a standard pour. I don't think you're being entirely fair to Americans in this particular case (even if a number of them would be happy with a pint of wine).
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Most people in the US go to a specialty retailer if they need wine glasses [citation needed] If I were going to bet, I'd say most purchasers of wine glasses probably do it through general retailers like Target or Amazon, not specialty retailers. I would be less surprised if the greatest number of consumer purchases of wineglasses were from specialty retailers because the people who buy from them but more glasses per person, but I really doubt most people use a specialty retailer.
- throwaway5752 9y agoYou got me. I have no idea, and I'm not invested enough to find out. I'd assumed Williams-Sonoma or something comparable. Let the record show that Target sells Riedel, too.
- bootcampjs 9y agoI have the hardest time finding standard 4.6-oz cocktail glasses. No, I don’t need to make an 8-oz martini; that would probably kill me.
- emrekzd 9y agoNot sure about wine glasses but universities have at least 7 times more incentive to publish BS papers these days. >> "These days, the average British pour of wine is 250 milliliters". According to data collected from dive bars. And I'm serious, see the article they referenced in the paper: https://www.morningadvertiser.co.uk/Article/2014/10/24/Direct-Line-wine-glass-pub-measures-research https://www.morningadvertiser.co.uk/Article/2014/10/24/Direc... Modern wine glasses are designed for drinking experience and you are supposed to hold the glass using your fingers from it's stem. And that's exactly why you don't fill half of your glass and try to carry 250 milliliters of liquid with your fingers.
- jdietrich 9y ago> According to data collected from dive bars. How do you know? A British pub can be anything from a squalid shabeen to a comfortable community space to a restaurant that happens to sell beer. In the UK, wine by the glass can only be legally served in measures of 125ml, 175ml or multiples thereof. The vast majority of pubs today only sell 175ml and 250ml measures. A few decades ago, asking for "a glass of red wine" would have got you a 125ml glass unless you specifically asked for a large glass, which would be 175ml. Gradually, the default moved to 175ml and the 125ml "small" glass was phased out in favour of the 250ml "large" glass, with 175ml becoming the new "small". It's abundantly clear that there's been a vast increase in the quantities of wine drunk over the past few decades. Wine consumption has contributed to the legitimisation of heavy drinking amongst the middle-aged and middle-class. Drinking several large glasses of wine doesn't carry the same stigma as drinking several pints of strong beer. As a result, we've seen a quadrupling of chronic liver disease, with the increase mainly being seen in middle-aged, middle-class and disproportionately female drinkers. https://www.gov.uk/weights-measures-and-packaging-the-law/specified-quantities https://www.gov.uk/weights-measures-and-packaging-the-law/sp... https://www.morningadvertiser.co.uk/Article/2008/06/27/Major-pub-operators-shun-125ml-wine-glasses https://www.morningadvertiser.co.uk/Article/2008/06/27/Major...
- hmmon321 9y agoAround 40% of deaths from liver disease are attributable to alcohol consumption, so I'm not sure how an increase in wine drinking within one age group could be the main cause of a 400% increase in liver disease.
- jdonaldson 9y agoI'll start off echoing what others have been saying... ports and madeiras were more popular. They resisted spoiling due to the high alcohol/sugar content. They can kick like a mule, so you can't just down 250ML in a sitting. Wine glasses are also fragile. A lot of places serve wine in common water glasses of roughly the same size. Italians have been doing that forever. Bigger glasses are more fragile, but they greatly enhance aeration and aroma. The smell of wine is over 50% of the experience for me. If i'm trying to maximize the experience of a good bottle, I'll use ridiculously large Riedel Vinum Old World glasses : https://www.amazon.com/Riedel-Veritas-World-Pinot-Glass/dp/B00KJWW4P8 https://www.amazon.com/Riedel-Veritas-World-Pinot-Glass/dp/B... They're enormous, fragile, a pain in the behind to wash. However It's tough to go back to standard wine glasses after you try one. All in all, I would say glasses are getting bigger in some cases, but the article is totally missing the how and why of it.
- wahern 9y agoFWIW, Sercial (dry) and Verdelho (medium-dry) Madeiras, sporting less sugar and nice acidity, can be quite quaffable. The acidity also helps, I think, to mask the stronger alcohol content. Those styles are really hard to find, though, as both cheap and expense Madeiras tend to be of the Malmsey style and only slightly less cloying than Port. The second most common style is Boal, which is less sweeter than Malmsey but lacks the acidity.
- jdonaldson 9y agoThanks, I gotta bone up on my madeiras.
- microcolonel 9y ago> For regulators keeping a worried eye on increased drinking, Marteau suggests encouraging the use of smaller glasses. After all, water is a bit safer to drink these days. Can you please stay out of it? Just because port glasses from the 1700s have less overall volume than tasting glasses from the 2010s, doesn't mean it's anyone's job to say how big they should be. At most, the volume of the pour has increased by maybe a factor of four, while (compared to the wine that went in the 60ml glasses) the alcohol content has decreased in a single step, from fortified to straight.
- blahedo 9y agoHuh. This explains something I've been wondering about for a while: I thought I had remembered figuring that a bottle of wine (standard 750 mL) was good for about six glasses. But at a recent event I helped host, the wine caterers said to count on about four pours per bottle. I assumed I had just misremembered, but "six per bottle" seems in line with what others in the thread are suggesting was more typical a couple decades ago, and it's just more confirmation that standard serving size has gone up....
- jasonkester 9y agoTo me, this indicates that the pattern of wine drinking has changed over the years, not the quantity. "A glass of wine with you, sir" was a friendly thing to say at the table, and resulted in both parties filling and downing an entire glass. The small glasses seem to be a way of carrying that on over the course of a large meal with a dozen people without any of them actually dying. Accounts of those meals also talk of going through around 2 bottles of wine per participant. In the article photo, the bottle looks about the same as it does today.
- arihant 9y agoThis is quiet meaningless, almost an Onion article. Nobody serves a 449ml wine pour. Just because the glasses have gone larger, does not mean the serving size has too. The photo that says it was probably 14 servings back in the day, the glass is not even filled to a third of its capacity.
- yCloser 9y agoIn Italy each region has its own, sacred, defined volume for a glass of wine (from 80 to 100 ml). The correct one ofc is 100ml. Who would pour 450ml of wine in a single glass?! (and > 250ml before dinner will likely get you tipsy)
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoDidn’t they drink out of wine skins? Cheaper, more sturdy than glass.. and beer was drunk from wooden tankards, 4 pints in size unearthed, probably 2000 years ago in wales. https://museum.wales/articles/2010-04-01/Ancient-Drinking-Culture-The-Langstone-Tankard/ https://museum.wales/articles/2010-04-01/Ancient-Drinking-Cu...
- pbhjpbhj 9y ago>When full, the tankard would have held nearly four pints of beer or cider. It was held in two hands and was probably passed around a group as a communal drinking vessel. // Like a wassail cup or so.
- jaclaz 9y agoAs a side note, at least here in Italy, serving a glass of wine at a restaurant is a relatively recent use (say in the last 15-20 years) new thing (most probably "imported" from other countries). Until then you either ordered a bottle (around 75 cl) or some "house" wine, served in (measured) of either 25 cl (a quarter, "un quartino") 50 cl (a half liter, "un mezzo") or 100 cl (a liter, "un litro"), that looked like these: http://bar-barman.com/1183-thickbox_default/caraffe-misura-bollo-con-scritta-025l-05l-1lt.jpg http://bar-barman.com/1183-thickbox_default/caraffe-misura-b... Or, in many places, wine was "a consumo" (upon consumption?) where the waiter would bring on the table a full "fiasco" (large bottle of wine, usually 1.75 l) and then estimate how much of it you emptied when it came to calculate the bill. In any case normally each person would drink no more than "un quartino", no matter the size of the glass.