17 ms·
Modern life is lonely – We all need someone to help
- peterburkimsher 9y ago"needing some comfort, had been showered instead with practical solutions to a practical problem, which had just upset her even more" When something bad happens to someone you care about, don't say "What happened?" That focuses on the problem. Maybe they don't want to talk about it. Ask "Are you OK?" You can always say this even if there's nothing wrong. If they say "Yes, why?", they're your friend. If they say "Fine." then they don't trust you. If they tell you "No, ..." they think you're a close friend. Then ask "What can I do to help you? You're not alone." Focus on the solution. If you want to know if someone trusts you, just ask "Are you OK?" and they will tell you.
- acorkery 9y agoIf they say "Yes, why?", they're your friend. If they say "Fine." then they don't trust you. If they tell you "No, ..." they think you're a close friend I'm guessing you're a programmer :) It's surely all about getting them to talk and open up, regardless of their answers?
- solarkraft 9y agoI'm guessing close to everyone here has something to do with programming, no?
- darepublic 9y agoIt's more a comment on the switch statement style approach to personal interaction :p
- Ultimatt 9y agoProtip you're a close friend when the positive emotional result for them after 20 minutes is the same regardless of how they answered. A bigger reason to say "fine" is they are depressive and dont trust themselves with their emotion.
- colechristensen 9y agoThis is simplistic and generally bad advice. Human relationships don't universally follow flow charts.
- ThePadawan 9y agoUnfortunately, "I'm fine" is a strongly ingrained default reaction in some circles. I feel this largely depends on culture (e.g. the British 'stiff upper lip' ideal) and negative media influence (personally, I'm thinking of the misguided idea of 'real men don't cry'). How do we get through that barrier?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago"I'm fine" is the default reaction because we've learned that the asker almost never genuinely gives a shit.
- colechristensen 9y agoIn many cases, respect the cultural difference, don't try to make other people into what you prefer. There is a difference between emotional intelligence and willingness to freely express emotion. "I'm fine" in many cases just means "no, thank you".
- grondilu 9y agoLately I've become more and more convinced that indeed, modern society sucks, or at the very least that I, and people like me, am not well equipped to flourish in it. I'm sure some people are though, but I suspect they are becoming the minority. Few days ago I also read Ted Kaczynski's essay[1], and it's hard for me not to acknowledge how right he is on many points. However, I do believe it is possible to survive all this, and that stoicism is a way. Kaczynski wrote for instance : "It is true that primitive man is powerless against some of the things that threaten him; disease for example. But he can accept the risk of disease stoically. It is part of the nature of things, it is no one’s fault, unless it is the fault of some imaginary, impersonal demon. But threats to the modern individual tend to be MAN-MADE. They are not the results of chance but are IMPOSED on him by other persons whose decisions he, as an individual, is unable to influence. Consequently he feels frustrated, humiliated and angry." Is it not possible for the modern man to accept the drawbacks of modern life, including loneliness, just as stoically as the primitive man was accepting adversity and death? Whether adversity is man-made or "natural" should not matter for the individual. From the stoic point of view, in each case it is just an external factor. It seems to me that as long as someone understands what is happening to him, he can make his mind at peace with it, whatever it is. Was it not after all one of the lessons of Epictetus, that what matters is not so much what happens to us, but how we react to it? That as long as we are ready for the worst, we can not really be troubled by it? 1. http://editions-hache.com/essais/pdf/kaczynski2.pdf http://editions-hache.com/essais/pdf/kaczynski2.pdf
- skrebbel 9y agoI had to google Ted Kaczinski (I'm not American), so I just want to mention here that Ted Kaczinski is a terrorist and mass murderer. No criticism on your post itself btw, I just felt it's relevant context.
- xorfish 9y agoHe was also subjected to, well lets say "ethical questionable" experiments at Harvard. https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/impromptu-man/201205/harvards-experiment-the-unabomber-class-62 https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/impromptu-man/201205/ha...
- estebancastano 9y agoFor the past year, I've been working on the social isolation problem. Here's the idea we're currently developing. Would love to hear folks' feedback. Would you be excited about using this? "A social app, like Tinder but for hangouts with friends. See what your friends want to do, and swipe right to show you’re interested. You can also join hangouts in the global feed to instantly expand your social circle. Hangouts are capped at 10 people so you can actually get to know each other. Post things you want to do, like "Hike in John Muir". When 10 people swipe right, a chat opens up so you can coordinate when to meet & who is down to go."
- rorykoehler 9y agoThese ideas always ended up becoming dating apps in the past so the idea to restrict it to your existing social circle is a smart one. I would consider using it if it was well executed.
- estebancastano 9y agoThanks Rory - very helpful!
- solarkraft 9y agoBut what if I want to build one up? I think something like a dating app (but not for dating) could work. You'd just have to do some a policing to avoid the trend towards people trying to find love, since both apparently don't work together.
- jsemrau 9y agoI have approached the problem from another angle. My hypothesis is that social groups only form through continued joint experiences. The easiest way is to achieve this is go to regularly go to free events. I have build drop!in [1] for the event discovery and message your friends informally that you will be going. Interestingly just a couple of day I wrote about the topic of loneliness in the modern age at my medium [2] [1] http://www.idrop.in http://www.idrop.in [2] https://medium.com/@thisTenqyuLife/life-after-facebook-is-real-social-interaction-1e240c0c6344 https://medium.com/@thisTenqyuLife/life-after-facebook-is-re...
- solarkraft 9y agoNot having things in common with others doesn't exactly provoke loneliness. You can be lonely around people you have a lot in common with. Worst thing is that if you don't start a conversation you won't even know whether you do have anything in common.
- RandomInteger4 9y agoBest solution to loneliness is to gain massive debt, become dirt poor, and battle daily with attention deficit issues while you struggle to learn and become productive enough to get a job in the software industry with a pretty horrible work history, an incomplete bachelors, and a near worthless associates. Living one rung lower on Maslow's hierarchy makes you forget about the desire to be around people, or even leave the house (father's) all that often (2% of the time). Granted, I think maybe my concern for my health (irrational or not) has been exacerbated, so I've traded loneliness for frequent panic attacks concerning whether or not I might have cancer or a heart defect. On the plus side, I know for a fact that I've torn back muscles weight lifting, so all I really need is the medicaid office to get back to me after submitting my 4th application with no phone calls or emails as to my status.
- martin_andrino 9y agoLet’s leave politics aside please.
- fsloth 9y agoWhy? Policies affect happiness very much, if we include 'not being miserable and destitute' as an option in the happiness spectrum.
- RandomInteger4 9y agoPolitics? Que? I didn't mention anything political.
- marincounty 9y agoI'm in a similar situation. People don't talk about it, but the club has gotten huge, at least from my vantage point. I don't think people are being more honest, or it's the ease of communication over the internet. A lot of people are trying to manage a mix of intense anxiety, and depression. I look around and technology has just made things worse. (Yea--I know one day--technology might eradicate cancer. I'm not going to argue. Today--I wish the smartphone was Never invented. ) I have always thought too much about death. It's kinda ruined my life. That said, my only preparation for eventual illness is getting rid the television. I've never thought it was healthy to be reminded daily through commercials I will get cancer, or if lucky just, die of a quick heart attack. And so many lonely people use t.v to alleviate the pain of being alone, or at least I do. I haven't got rid of it yet, but it will come. I do have a healthy collection of movies on dvds. As I aged, I do see why people do drugs. And yes--I do exercise daily. It does help.
- partycoder 9y agoModern society may have issues, but it as bad as it is usually portrayed. 10,000 years ago, you would live in a tribe. If you were not popular among your tribe, it is likely you would be either exiled and forced to live in solitude and die during winter or be constantly subject to violence. 2,000 years ago, you would live only to work in a farm or be in a state of perpetual war. To make things worse, literacy rate was something around 0.001%, if you were lucky. 1,000 years ago, you would be essentially doing the same while dying from a plague. There was no sanitation of any kind. 200 years ago, you would be working at a factory and going to war every 30 years. 100 years ago, there was no radio or TV, so you still had stuff like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulsa_race_riot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulsa_race_riot About 60 years ago women were predominantly housewives and were vulnerable to all sorts of abuse. So no, right now things are better.
- toopok4k3 9y agoI wonder what will they say about us in 100 years? Or 1000 years? Let's continue improving.
- _pp9c 9y agoWait, do you think that the Tulsa race riot happened because people didn't have radio or TV? Wtf? Race riots occurred in this country because of the acute structural contradiction between the white settler-nation and the other nations; these contradictions have not been resolved by radio and TV in the interim. We will see more of these riots in the future.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- partycoder 9y agoI do not think that. But I think is that more people would not have been OK with that level of violence and destruction if they had a chance to actually see it, rather than presented through words on a newspaper.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago
- ensiferum 9y agoAnd talk about modern online dating. It takes defeat to a wholly new level. Back in the day one could be rejected by a handful of ladies in a conventional setting (bar, club, whatever). Now when you're dating online you can instantly rejected by an infinite number of women \o/ ;-)
- sigsergv 9y agoI don't think number of lonely people increases, they just become much more visible. Social networks and other changes in modern society make loneliness acceptable and people stop hiding it.
- martin_andrino 9y agoAt the same time, social networks create an illusion for lonely people so they feel accompanied. It’s not all that bad.
- thirdsun 9y agoOn the other hand one might argue that they also create the illusion of how fantastic and exciting everyone else's life is - an artificial and often unrealistic image that's broadcasted and probably not helping lonely people at all.
- Falkens_Maze 9y agoJunk food isn't bad once in a while. But if you eat junk food all the time, it's pretty obvious that one of the immediate consequences of eating junk food every day is the general decline of your health. So it goes for social media. Social networks are the junk food of socializing. And don't get me started on what that does to someone's sense of self, well-being, norms, ethics, morality etc. Maybe this picture will be illuminating to you[1]. It succinctly summarizes what I'm trying to say. I should probably mention the image might be NSFW. [1] http://artfucksme.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/controversial-illustrations-gunsmithcat-luis-quiles-2-700.jpg http://artfucksme.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/controversi...
- jsemrau 9y agoWe are currently using technology to tear people apart with the illusion of social contacts. Instead of building communities we are supporting the development of hikikomoris. Already now, you don't need to leave your apartment for work, food, non-food supermarket items, payments, etc.
- unabst 9y agoWe're paying the price for the proliferation of existentialism, and it's flavor of capitalism and justice. "You're on your own" is good when reaping rewards and thriving in a meritocracy, but not when you need help, are losing, or just want warmth. But a healthy dose of loneliness is what has us reaching for each other. So we should all just give in, and reach for each other. Natural feeling tend to take care of themselves, so long as we're capable of being honest. Of course, that's the other issue.
- bbctol 9y agoHow are you defining "existentialism" here?
- goldfeld 9y agoI'd think it's a variation of the "life is meaningless and we're all irrelevant specks of dust anyway" line of thinking.
- propogandist 9y agoembracing the irrelevance brings your soul into hell, in this life and the one after you become dust.
- dnissley 9y agoI think they mean nihilism.
- henriquemaia 9y ago> "L'enfer, c'est les autres" or "Hell is other people" From "No Exit", by Jean-Paul Sartre, 1944. source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Exit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Exit
- unabst 9y ago"I think therefore I am." The essence that precedes the thought. "Our actions are the outcome of our being." The notion that success is reserved for the deserving, and criminals are devils that require punishment. That there are good and bad people; good do good, and bad do bad. All we need to do is sort them. And that all depends on our individual essence, our free will. Everything good pre-exists and we shall be the judge. As opposed to, "There are no actors, only actions" and "We are the sum of our actions." "I think therefore I'm thinking." "I committed a crime, got caught, and that is why I'm in jail." "I witnessed his birth, I changed his diapers, I taught him how to walk, and he follows me around. He must be my son." I actually don't have the name for the latter philosophy. I really wish I knew. It's along the lines of Nietzsche and Aristotle, but I can't say they put their finger on it. Any pointers welcome. It also holds the key: "I'm lonely. And that's the only reason I need you by my side." That's all we need.
- blowski 9y agoPersonally, going to Church has helped me suffer less with loneliness. I've made meaningful friendships, and relationships with people from all sorts of backgrounds. It has given more meaning to my life than anything I found at work, or by random socialising. Of course, YMMV. Please take this as a random anecdote, not as evangelism.
- mwang 9y agoI know a few people who have suggested attending a Unitarian Church (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarian_Universalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarian_Universalism) as a way to get the social benefits of church without having to subscribe to a religious belief. Many congregations include atheists and agnostics.
- cfontes 9y agoThere is one in my city, never heard of it before... thanks for the input I will give it a shot...
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThere is also Sunday Assembly: https://www.sundayassembly.com/ https://www.sundayassembly.com/ "The Sunday Assembly was started by Sanderson Jones and Pippa Evans, two comedians who were on the way to a gig in Bath when they discovered they both wanted to do something that was like church but totally secular and inclusive of all—no matter what they believed."
- hkmurakami 9y agoHad no idea such a thing existed. Thanks for the information.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoI've had this on my mind for a few months, but something would push it aside before I could look into it. Your post inspired me to finally look up my local Unitarian Church, and we're going to check it out. Thank you!
- joshsyn 9y agoI have always been lonely all my life. I will use this to my advantage.
- fgjjgutjvnu 9y agoFascinating how feminist mouthpiece the Guardian manages to make even this topic about the alleged failures of men (offering solutions instead of emotional support), with a fictional TV series painting men as callous assholes for proof.
- gerbilly 9y agoWe have to meet people more in real life. Humans need face to face contact to be fully happy. Why, as supposedly modern humans, do we have to rediscover this?
- crimsonalucard 9y agoIts how we live and dine. Prehistoric humans ate, hunted and lived together as tribes while at the same time acting very antisocial to other competing tribes. We are built to be social at the same time we are also built to be wary and even hostile to people we dont know. Its a contradiction. If you are not eating and living with anyone then you are most likely lonely. The answer is to find a community that eats and dines and live together.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikeokner 9y agoI think a large part of the problem is that the younger generations have grown up with pretty strong expectations placed upon them to do things like go to college (at whatever cost), land a white collar job, climb the ladder, etc. The obvious solution is to own your decisions and start doing what you think is right for you, but it's far easier said than done to step out from under the expectations you've been saddled with your entire life.
- Jhsto 9y agoI think you are right. Just the other day there was a posting in our anonymous university group chat and someone complained how she thinks she is unable to start and finish masters degree and its thesis work. The first suggestion which adviced taking time off to re-evaluate her choices of continuing with graduate studies were downvoted. Instead, replies supporting going through the masters with various lifehacks, even though the OP clearly states she doesn't want to do it, were upvoted. I understand its natural for students to pep talk their peers to study more, but I don't understand why controversial suggestions are being dismissed. I almost feel like these calls for help are just seeking validation to continue hoop jumping instead of actually finding alternative ways to fix the root cause. It makes me sad to think that my peers don't think they are ready for working life until they graduate, whilst I would, as an employer, much rather hire someone capable of self-inspection and listening of people with differentiating viewpoints.
- Bartweiss 9y agoThere's an experience I had in undergrad that's always stuck with me. The computer science department and the careers office jointly brought in some startup founders to talk about founding or joining startups and take questions; it was really quite a good idea. Someone asked about degrees and majors - do you need a Master's, which degrees are 'relevant', and so on. The first few founders hemmed and hawed, said "technical skills from any degree" and "undergrad is enough" and so on. The last founder didn't play the game. His answer was: "I'm not worried about your name on a sheet of paper. If you're good at what you do, I'll hire you." Cue nervous laughter from the moderator, and a gentle prompt: "but of course it's worth finishing up school for the people who are already here, those are valuable skills, right?" Founder: "I guess I was unclear. If you drop out today, I will hire you. I recommend it." The next year that panel wasn't repeated.
- thriftwy 9y agoI don't know, I have a wife and a few friends and loneliness doesn't enter into the picture anymore. If I was lonely I think I'll go somewhere where board games are played and there find an unlimited company.
- cousin_it 9y agoI think individualistic cultures like the West can only work by teaching their members many subconscious habits for pushing away other people. That's great because it enables individual creativity (not to mention freedom from some ugly hierarchies we'd rather forget about), but the flip side is that people feel more distant from each other. Thankfully, solving this problem doesn't require changing all of society. You can solve it for yourself: take a few years to notice and unlearn your habits for pushing away other people. I'm confident that you have many such habits right now, from the way you stare at your phone in public, to your posture and facial expressions every minute of the day. To give you a picture of the end result, imagine a stereotypical immigrant from a more collectivist culture. Their reputation for openness isn't undeserved.
- 50 9y agoI think I have suffered from loneliness before. A stomach-stabbing loneliness really. No friends to truly communicate, going on car drives with no destination/intention but to just think, walking in the evening hoping someone would strike a conversation, etc. Though I find my loneliness usually arises because I expect something different than what already is. Expecting something different than what is is a way to suffer (accept what is, and you’re free?). Consequently, I find that I must make a home out of this loneliness. You know how when you move into a new place and you are organizing or reorganizing or maybe decorationing your work station at home to make it feel comfortable and home-y? Well, that’s what I think I had to do internally to make my loneliness not loneliness. I suppose convert loneliness into solitude. Then again, I have this vague thought that many people suffer from loneliness (depression, etc) because of how we are raised, how society, culture, civilization, have molded our minds. I think in modern day, consciousness is everything. But because it’s an unknowable object, we ignore it or worse: pretend it doesn’t exist. Consequently, we end up hard-headed in a matrix of half-baked beliefs, lonely, depressed, fearful, and anxious. I don’t know, the whole social order I think is set up in order to avoid the unknowable, if you will, of what everything is. The idea that the radio is blaring at all times. That we are all taught to listen to channels but never taught to turn it off and listen to the silence. If only we were to listen we would see that from the unknowable arises a reflection; the consciousness of everything, the I-am. At this point, I think, sort of in the poverty of true humility, everything that appears is seen as a miracle. The birds chirping in the morning is as much of a miracle as being in the perfect spot in the knowable universe for life to exist. The question then arises: Why is it that we remain deaf/blind running around anxiously in the noise when pure consciousness is right here out in the open all the time? Above all: I think loneliness may be combated through several forms: reading really good fiction, doing drugs (weed in particular), having passionate sex, or any form of escapism. I find that the latter are only temporary ways to combat loneliness. If we would like to conquer loneliness, making a home of yourself and reflecting on what truly is is really important.
- ForRealsies 9y agoHave you thought about taking upon more responsibility? Be it to your community, to a volunteer organization, pets, and even plants. Modern society is malnourished when it comes to the sense of belonging. “The higher degree of responsibility that you agree voluntarily to try to bear the richer your life will be.” -Jordan Peterson
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago>How can a person be expected to be happy with, and in, themselves when the eternal message is: “Try harder, do better, climb higher, don’t fail”? "Success is as dangerous as failure. Hope is as hollow as fear. What does it mean that success is as dangerous as failure? Whether you go up the ladder or down it, Your position is shaky. When you stand with your two feet on the ground, You will always keep your balance. What does it mean that hope is as hollow as fear? Hope and fear are both phantoms That arise from thinking of the self. When we don't see the self as self, What do we have to fear? See the world as your self. Have faith in the way things are. Love the world as your self; Then you can care for all things." -Lao Tzu
- gumby 9y agoThis is actually why I am so concerned with (as in: working towards) the elimination of all jobs. "But what will people do?" I am often asked, as if the worth of someone is determined by their job. They can write bad poetry or watch TV, but I suspect and hope that a lot of the time will be spent with others. Humans are social animals.
- cyberpunk0 9y agoWe need a return to primitive values. Money is the problem, it is the driving factor in virtually every problem we have today directly and indirectly