4 ms·
My main feeling about all this is that "let it burn" probably is the only way to deal with the mess. It must have been pretty obvious from quite early on that t
by zokier 9y ago
My main feeling about all this is that "let it burn" probably is the only way to deal with the mess. It must have been pretty obvious from quite early on that trying to fight blackhats on level field as a single individual is not sustainable, and the time that he has been buying is in no way enough to employ the major cultural shift needed to improve the landscape. Attempting to suppress the attacks seems just to make people complacent, so it might be better just to let the attacks to do their damage and hope that those spur some improvement.
- rbanffy 9y agoThis is how the forests of California dealt with fires before humans started fighting them. As humans fought fires, there was a buildup of flammable material in the forests, making each successive fire incrementally worse.
- nautilus12 9y agoI was using this exact same analogy to explain this to someone earlier, although I have to admit that I agree with the person above. Going out and starting forest fires in national forests without official government sanction, even if your intention is to create controlled burns and prevent a bigger fire will still land you with a verdict of arson.
- rbanffy 9y ago> Going out and starting forest fires in national forests without official government sanction, even if your intention is to create controlled burns and prevent a bigger fire will still land you with a verdict of arson. No good deed goes unpunished.
- chii 9y agoIf there weren't any forest rangers/firefighters organization to back-burn, then the lone person trying to do some good may be the only way forward. But for forest fires, such an organization does exist, and no-one should be burning by themselves. There is no such organization for the internet. So we are left with lone white-hats who risk personal safety to do some good. I wish there's a better way.
- askvictor 9y agoI'm probably starting to stretch the analogy a bit thin but: In Australia, similar issues, but we've been doing back-burning/fuel-reduction-burns for quite a few years now to deal with these problems (the indigenous population practiced controlled burns for a variety of purposes well before whitefellas arrived). However, some evidence is now starting to emerge that the mode controlled burns is effecting the long term ecology of the forests, and favouring certain species over others, and preventing the build-up of larger, less-flammable trees. So, to tie it back to IoT: Would a 'controlled burn' (i.e. a bot which bricks vulnerable devices) only destroy the low hanging fruit (i.e easily exploitable devices) and leave the harder vulnerabilities in place, building up for the bigger fire in a years time?
- colorincorrect 9y ago"let it burn", as in a self-correcting feedback present in large dynamical systems (such as forest fires). major internet disruption potentially larger than anything we've seen before, as in you and I and every single aspect of modern society that relies on the Internet (aka pretty much everything). do you not see what will burn?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe time to let it burn is now, gradually, while we're not that interconnected yet. It may inconvenience a lot of people, but continuing the status quo will lead to a lot of people being ruined or killed in the (not so distant) future.
- gldalmaso 9y agoThis is probably the only way to enforce the correct incentive for manufacturers. Build them right or they will fail. IoT being so hyped right now is specially troublesome since all they will care is time to market, and when the market is filled with insecure devices what else will there be to done?
- AFNobody 9y agoCorrect. The OP was very noble but quite misguided. 0) Let it burn was how CA operated until we started fighting fires and building in unsafe spaces and it worked pretty well. The Thomas Fire is a good example of this problem. You can reduce the damage but there still will be damage. 1) Legal issues if you are detected and someone wants to "make an example" to be malicious doing this, even if you are found "not guilty" the consequences are non-negligible. 2) In any capitalist culture, prevention only becomes "cost effective" when multiple headline making disasters convince people in suits they will look like idiots if they don't pay at least lip service to prevention. 3) If a criminal ever figures out who you are and that you are invalidating their large $$ investment in a criminal attack, they may be willing to engage in criminal acts to stop you specifically and you don't have the legal protection and training a LE organization would have. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2017/02/men-who-sent-swat-team-heroin-to-my-home-sentenced/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2017/02/men-who-sent-swat-team-h... > It’s been a remarkable week for cyber justice. On Thursday, a Ukrainian man who hatched a plan in 2013 to send heroin to my home and then call the cops when the drugs arrived was sentenced to 41 months in prison for unrelated cybercrime charges. If you aren't equipped to handle events like this, tangling with blackhats means a single opsec mistake is going to result in shit like that.
- QAPereo 9y agoGiven the scope of criminal activity using the net now, 3 is surely non-trivial.
- DyslexicAtheist 9y agoa practical demonstration of N.Taleb's Antifragile principle, if you will :)