8 ms·
Removing street signs, lights and arrows increases safety and road capacity
- ck2 16y agoSo local traffic knows local roads? Signs and indicators are for people who are not from the area.
- scott_s 16y agoIt's a long article and I didn't read all of it, but the changes they made seem more fundamental than that: A year after the change, the results of this “extreme makeover” were striking: Not only had congestion decreased in the intersection—buses spent less time waiting to get through, for example—but there were half as many accidents, even though total car traffic was up by a third. Students from a local engineering college who studied the intersection reported that both drivers and, unusually, cyclists were using signals—of the electronic or hand variety—more often. They also found, in surveys, that residents, despite the measurable increase in safety, perceived the place to be more dangerous. This was music to Monderman’s ears. If they had not felt less secure, he said, he “would have changed it immediately.” That the locals who know the roads perceived the intersection as more dangerous indicates to me there's something more than "people familiar with roads don't need signs."
- radu_floricica 16y agoSo if one would believe in a universal "fair trade" principle, the cost you pay for security and fluidity is heightened attention from the participants in traffic. One would wonder how well would this scale: if drivers had to pay the same attention to every intersection, how long before they would start making mistakes?
- thingie 16y agoSo, you mean that the locals can ignore traffic signs because they know the place? Like in "oh, yes, there's a speed limit, but it's useless, see, the street is safe enough, screw that". That could be actual quote, I've heard it so many times. And I guess it's much better to remove such sign and make the street actually look like it's not safe so you have to pay attention. And of course, routine and automatization are a grave danger for any driver. Especially at the roads where the conditions are constantly changing. Traffic signs would just provide a false sense of security.
- senki 16y agoGood article, but lacks some pictures. Drachten: http://maps.google.com/maps?client=opera&q=Drachten&oe=utf-8&ie=UTF8&hl=ja&t=h&sll=53.103684,6.109396&sspn=0.001293,0.003422&split=1&rq=1&ev=zi&radius=0.09&hq=Drachten&hnear=&ll=53.103869,6.109041&spn=0.0013,0.003422&z=19 http://maps.google.com/maps?client=opera&q=Drachten&... Makkinga: http://maps.google.com/maps?client=opera&q=Makkinga&oe=utf-8&ie=UTF8&hl=ja&hq=&hnear=%E3%83%9E%E3%83%83%E3%82%AD%E3%83%B3%E3%82%AC,+%E3%82%AA%E3%83%BC%E3%82%B9%E3%83%88%E3%82%B9%E3%83%86%E3%83%AA%E3%83%B3%E3%82%B0%E3%82%A6%E3%82%A7%E3%83%AB%E3%83%95,+%E3%83%95%E3%83%AA%E3%83%BC%E3%82%B9%E3%83%A9%E3%83%B3%E3%83%88,+%E3%82%AA%E3%83%A9%E3%83%B3%E3%83%80&ll=52.97232,6.218066&spn=0.001297,0.003422&t=h&z=19&layer=c&cbll=52.972151,6.21858&panoid=FJjqWFu--jacMvCpGx7ZqQ&cbp=12,2.83,,0,6.41 http://maps.google.com/maps?client=opera&q=Makkinga&...
- prewett 16y agoThanks for the pictures. I can definitely see how the traffic circle in Makkinga is safer than just a through street. I didn't expect to see a bunch of Japanese labels on the maps of these German towns, though... :)
- praptak 16y agoI have one doubt about this idea. It might be possible that it only works because such "naked" roads are rare and thus prompt a (temporary) raise in drivers' alertness. Even the article provides a hint in this direction: "They also found, in surveys, that residents, despite the measurable increase in safety, perceived the place to be more dangerous. This was music to Monderman’s ears. If they had not felt less secure, he said, he “would have changed it immediately.” It is possible that once people get used to it, they'll feel more secure -> less alert -> things'll go back to normal.
- ergo98 16y agoYou have it EXACTLY right. Most Indian roads have exactly this sort of system in place, so it's a pretty good comparison. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/India-is-worlds-road-deaths-capital/articleshow/6023344.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/India-is-worlds-roa... Not so great of an example. The model is like every classic "We turned up the lights and people became more productive. And then we turned down the lights and they became more productive. And then..." It's flawed.
- sp332 16y agoparent is referencing the Hawthorne Effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect
- Retric 16y agoThe other major possibility is the road markings where distracting drivers. Understanding the rules while driving is more complex than simply not hitting people. I would much rather someone trying to make a U turn thinking “Is this safe?” vs. “What does the sign say?”
- Pengwin 16y agoIn some ways i agree, but in others i disagree. I'm a person who loves traffic lights, because the traffic light specifically tells a road user You can go or no you cant go. nobody has to do any guesswork as to who is allowed to go. I see the whole "more alert because its more dangerous" every day. There used to be a single lane roundabout that i traveled through every day that they have now changed to a double lane roundabout. I am not sure of actual crash statistics related to it, but i see that people are more alert, because it is far more dangerous to what it used to be.
- chrismealy 16y agoI used to think shared space was a great alternative to car-centric streets but after reading David Hembrow's blog about bicycling in the Netherlands for a while it's clear that shared space is just a half-measure. If you want a society where people other than (mostly male) daredevils in their 20s and 30s can cycle then you need segregated biking facilities. Holland's percent of trips by bike (modal share) is around 30% (America is about 2%). It got there by having world-class segregated cycling facilities, not shared space. David Hembrow on shared space: http://hembrow.blogspot.com/2008/11/shared-space.html http://hembrow.blogspot.com/2008/11/shared-space.html If you have the time check out John Pucher's "Cycling for Everyone: Lessons for Vancouver from the Netherlands, Denmark, and Germany": http://www.sfu.ca/city/city_pgm_video020.htm http://www.sfu.ca/city/city_pgm_video020.htm
- Tichy 16y agoWhat definitely does not work is drawing cyclist lanes onto the road. In Germany at least I think for a while it was believed that cycling lanes should be drawn on the roads rather than on the sideway. The result is that the cycling lanes become very dangerous, because car use them for short term parking all the time (it is not unusual to have a parking car every 100 meters). That would mean cycling around the car and hitting the normal road. I think it is safer to just stay on the road all the time, rather than cycle in and out. The parking on the cycling lane is actually illegal, but people don't care. Sometimes I consider just calling the police for every car that parks there, but I suspect they wouldn't really bother.
- mbateman 16y agoI don't see why this is a big deal. Philadelphia has some recently added cycling lanes that I use all the time. If a car is parked you just look and cautiously veer around it. Sometimes you have to wait for a few seconds if there's heavy traffic and the space is narrow. But usually there's even enough room to get around a car without actually going back into the normal lane, since our bike lanes are converted from fully sized car lanes, which are bigger than cars. And of course people park in them short-term with their hazards on. I'm not sure whether it's illegal or not (in Philly people park with impunity long-term in the turn lanes sometimes). But if it is it shouldn't be, there's no better alternative. Park in the non-bike lane, and make other cars go around them into the bike lane? No idling at all?
- TGJ 16y agoNow just do something about auto insurance since everyone doesn't worry about smacking into someone else when they know that their car will be paid for afterward. That will really raise people's alertness.
- jplewicke 16y agoAlex Tabarrok linked to a video of a British town's experiment with this on a roundabout: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vi0meiActlU&feature=player_embedded http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vi0meiActlU&feature=playe... . They saw a 75% decrease in waiting time at the intersection.
- rubyrescue 16y agowhat a well written and thought provoking article; i love articles on technical topics that feel like art.
- russell 16y agoMorro Bay, CA, is a small town that replaced a freeway offramp/frontage road 4-way stop intersection with a roundabout. Transit time through the intersection improved because you no-longer had to stop and wait for your turn. It seems like a good model for low to moderate volume intersections. Flow is increased and speed is reduced.
- m_eiman 16y agoRoundabouts are the New Big Thing here in Sweden, they're building them everywhere. On average it seems to be an improvement, and I have a local anecdote where a very busy intersection was rebuilt and improved vastly (while "everyone" said that it was a bad idea before it was completed).
- wccrawford 16y agoIt's true that some are just eye-catchers that distract. But that bridge sign in the article? It's not for when you CAN see the bridge, it's for all those times in inclement weather when you CAN'T.
- Unseelie 16y agoAnd are speeding down the road, secure in your knowledge that even though you cant see, if the road turned, there'd be large reflective warnings beforehand?
- culebron 16y agoHere's a set of videos on YouTube with Monderman on site in Drachten explaining what's been done http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xo3KWHqmDhA&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xo3KWHqmDhA&feature=relat...
- istari 16y agoCopied from the other thread on this topic. Vietnam: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mr5Gssaxl6g http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mr5Gssaxl6g Ikaruga: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-zSi0xt9fY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-zSi0xt9fY
- jacquesm 16y agoPeople walking on the edge of a 100' drop tend to walk very carefully. The end result of this sort of reasoning is a steel spike sticking out of the steering wheel in the place where the airbag sits now.
- emmett 16y agoIf applying a steel spike sticking out of the steering wheel resulted in a measurable decrease in deaths from traffic accidents, would you support it?
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's a really good question. I think I should, but I find the concept somewhat disconcerting. There are a fairly large number of single vehicle accidents so I don't think that it really would lead to a measurable decrease though. Alternatives: everybody should drive cars with bodies made of hardened but very thin glass (I'd support that one). Maximum weight of a personal car 750 Kg.
- Unseelie 16y agoOr a canister of gunpowder?
- epochwolf 16y agoI don't think we need hollywood car crashes in real life.
- bld 16y agoDupont Circle in Washington DC could take a page from this. It's the exact opposite principle: inner and outer circles, with sets of inner and outer traffic and pedestrian lights at each incoming road. At rush hour, it's fortunate if one vehicle can make it through each light. Other traffic circles in the area, in my experience, work much better without such control.
- Groxx 16y agoI can see this working for traffic circles / roundabouts, as long as people know how to use them, and you have them. They're far simpler to use than a regular intersection. They're exceedingly rare in Wisconsin, for example, especially in any residential area that's more than about 20 years old. The cost of replacing intersections with them (especially as they're often bigger, to handle fire trucks, busses, and whatnot) would be astronomical. In the meantime, I'll take stop signs to nothing at intersections. There are too many rude people in the world, and it only takes one to ruin someone else's life.