4 ms·
A good place to promote this would be with secular homeschoolers. Those homeschooling for nonreligious reasons are often dealing with a bright kid interested in
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
A good place to promote this would be with secular homeschoolers. Those homeschooling for nonreligious reasons are often dealing with a bright kid interested in advanced subjects. They often need lay explanations that make advanced subjects approachable without dumbing it down.
A lot of stuff is intentionally overcomplicated. My oldest was furious when I finally explained to him that algebra is basically renaming the blank space in an equation as X so you can more easily move the blank space around.
He had been doing algebra in his head for years to infer stats in games while simultaneously feeling baffled and intimidated by formal math, like the concept of algebra. He had assumed all variables were like E=mc^2 where letters stood for specific concepts, not for floating "=___".
- colomon 9y agoI've actually been trying to explain that exact concept (algebra variables) to some advanced third graders. It's been surprisingly hard to get them to grasp it.
- opportune 9y agoWhen I was a child, the first thing that made sense to me was that "x is the number that makes the statement true". That is, 100 = 100, so if 25 * x = 100, you need to figure out what value of x multiplied by 25 gives you 100. I didn't even understand the manipulations or how you would really solve for x at first, but I did understand that you were trying to figure out the number that would do that. I would just phrase it like a puzzle, like "what plus 9 equals 14" or "3 times what equals 42"? For some reason, one of my earliest memories I have is from when I would try to show off to older kids that I understood algebra.
- mturmon 9y agoHave you looked at the Dragon Box app?
- corysama 9y agoI shill DragonBox every chance I get ;) It does a great job of teaching abstract algebra to children who don’t even know arithmetic.
- burp3141 9y agoI've always translated "x" to "?" (the value to be discovered) as a mental shortcut. The "?" symbol might be easier to interpret for third graders.
- colomon 9y agoI think they are used to seeing empty boxes for mystery values.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI think it helped my son for me to explain that letters were just short "names" in place of the phrase "mystery number." Or something along those lines. Like "We are just going to call it X or Y instead of the unknown number we are trying to figure out."
- threatofrain 9y agoHave you tried analogous approaches, such as showing kids an empty box, a question mark, multiple metaphors, etc? I find that visual approaches work well, but when you write an English letter which has already been used for other purposes, it's a little less clear.
- dbcurtis 9y agoI'll add to that. We fell into the secular homeschooler camp. At some point, it takes less effort to just homeschool than to spend endless time arguing with school administrators to challenge your child appropriately. "We can give them extra worksheets for homework." Oh wow, thanks. A great resource for "mathy" kids is Art of Problem Solving. https://artofproblemsolving.com https://artofproblemsolving.com There are free resources, their math books are outstaningly excellent (well, they could use more excercizes, but the exposition is superb), and they have online classes. The online classes are run with a live chat room that typesets LaTeX. The pace of the classes is blistering, so not for everybody. But you can buy the same books for cheap and use them at home at a pace that is right for your kid. We used AoPS as the main spine of our child's math curriculum. At the time, it topped out at about AP Calculus, I'm not sure if they go beyond single variable calculus yet. Anyway, after that a local university let our kid take multivariable calculus along side the freshman engineering students. We were lucky to have that resource. Next problem: when your kid completes multi-variable calculus at age 13, what next? We did discrete math and freshman engineering physics, and counted them toward the high shool transcript. Which is another problem homeschooler's face -- the so-called "mommy transcript". When it comes to college applications, it's good to have somebody in addition to mom posting grades to your transcript. The Uni grades in math and physics and recommendation letters from university profs helped the college application package a lot. For that matter, AoPS is well ennough known now that it is good on a transcript. While I'm on math resources, http://www.mathpath.org http://www.mathpath.org is a truly wonderful summer math camp for kids in the 11-14 age range. Great faculty, great staff. Now would be a good time to think about applying for 2018. Just so you understand the scale here: My kid spent all of their spare time for two weeks on the quailifying quiz, attempting 5 of the 7 questions, a couple of those attempts were a bit weak. (A good solid attempt at 2 or 3 will get you in.) If you think your child might like MathPath, I'd encourage you to download the quiz now and let your kid start pondering the questions.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoMy son is actually math challenged and also a science nerd. This is a whole other mind-boggling challenge. I bought math books full of words off the bargain table for as little as a dollar and, after sorting things out with his father, just gave my son the stack of books to read. No tests. No written work. No problem solving. Just read these books. That finally worked and he has a good grounding in math, though he can't crunch numbers. He is, as they say, calculator dependent. But he absolutely understands important concepts. To my mind, this is vastly better than a kid who can estimate to 8 decimal places in their head, but can't grasp GIGO (garbage in, garbage out).
- iak8god 9y ago> A good place to promote this would be with secular homeschoolers. Those homeschooling for nonreligious reasons are often dealing with a bright kid interested in advanced subjects. I don't see any reason to restrict this to those homeschooling for nonreligious reasons. There are plenty of bright homeschooled kids interested in advanced subjects regardless of their parents' primary motivation for homeschooling.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI am in no way restricting it, merely suggesting fertile ground to find enthusiastic early adopters who can help it flourish.
- iak8god 9y agoI am suggesting that the broader homeschooling community may be equally fertile ground to find enthusiastic early adopters.