7 ms·
How Being Hit by a Vehicle Changed Times Colleagues’ Lives (2014)
- OliverJones 9y agoInteresting. It's dangerous to be a journo in the big city. The newspaper should change its style guide to prohibit the use of the word "accident" to describe car crashes, except in verified quotations. They should call them "crashes" or another word that doesn't connote inevitability.
- JackFr 9y agoThat would be weird because 1) what they are literally describing is the plain definition of 'accident'; 2) 'Accident' doesn't really connote inevitability.
- lostlogin 9y agoThe Oxford dictionary almost disagrees, I think you could argue the point. Note the origin too. “by accident Unintentionally; by chance... ...Origin Late Middle English (in the general sense ‘an event’): via Old French from Latin accident- ‘happening’, from the verb accidere, from ad- ‘towards, to’ + cadere ‘to fall’.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoIt's worth disagreeing about - calling them 'accidents' removes responsibility from the drivers involved, think about phrases in English like "accidents happen" - which are used specifically for this purpose. Calling them 'crashes' is simply a description of what happened, without any suggestion of why.
- pizzetta 9y agoI'm ambivalent about that. It's one of those words whose meaning has changed in a context. Like trying to take back the word senile to mean "old age". Generally people take accident to mean a "collision", whether intentional or not. Negligent or not.
- SilasX 9y agoPerhaps, but I think it's good when major publications use what influence they have to favor precise, accurate language over ambiguous euphemisms.
- noblethrasher 9y agoI took a precision driving training class a couple of years ago. The instructor, a retired state trooper, said that many first responder departments have begun referring to them as "crashes" for the very reason that you mentioned.
- poolbath1 9y agoI thought this as well, and was about to comment to the paper about updating their terminology. Then I saw this is an article from 2014. I think using the word “accident” would be less likely today. There has been a real effort to change terminology. NYT even had an article about this in May of 2016.
- Steltek 9y agoIn the US, cars kill more people than opiods, more people than guns. If you're under 35, your highest chance of dying is in a car crash. After 35, it's heart attacks and diabetes; in other words, severe lack of exercise because we drive everywhere. It's truly the silent health epidemic of our time. Of course, you won't see improvement any time soon. Every bike lane or safe street initiative is met with "But my parking!" Every fatal accident due to driver intoxication, negligence, or road rage is dismissed by judges and juries alike because "That's just how it is".
- shrimp_emoji 9y agoThe answer is not to surrender the comfort and convenience of cars for the utter misery of being exposed to the HARSHNESS of the elements on longer commutes; it's to fight comfort and convenience with MORE comfort and convenience! Staying at home, working via VR telepresence, eating liquid soylent pumped directly to the home like water and gas.
- Steltek 9y agoSkipping over what I'm pretty sure is sarcasm, never leaving your house isn't a really great long term strategy. Unfortunately, what I believe to be the ideal solution: denser living, better public transit (high freq. w/ bus lanes would be cheap and effective), and pedestrian-first streets (sidewalk/bike area = car area); is simply a non-starter for most of the US. Outside of coastal cities, most Americans can't even imagine what that's like without immediately jumping to visions of Manhattan urban canyons (not even Queens). And even then, as this article points, Manhattan is not some oasis of car-free lifestyle either.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago> Every fatal accident due to driver intoxication, negligence, or road rage is dismissed by judges and juries alike Do you honestly believe there's even a shred of truth to this? Vehicle accidents where people get hurt typically result in pretty severe punishment if there's even a hint of some performance impairing drug (e.g. alcohol) or malicious intent involved.
- pkaye 9y agoI'm going to guess a lot of these accidents are during a turn right on a red or an unprotected left turn? In a very crowded city they are very difficult to make with constant pedestrian traffic. And then my own experience in Berkeley and SF is that pedestrians tend to be impatient and cross on a red at all the minor intersections. One of the reasons I just avoid driving in such crowded places.
- hangonhn 9y agoWow. That's a good guess because that's pretty much what happened to me. Someone hit me turning right while I was in a crosswalk. Because drivers are so car centric, all she did was check that there were no cars coming from her left and immediately started her right turn even though I was in the crossroad already. She had a yield, which she failed to do. (They later made that an actual stop sign. Probably because too many pedestrians were getting hit?) Know what the craziest part of the experience? The car wasn't even moving that fast but because cars had so much mass there was an enormous transfer of energy that resulted in a "bumper fracture" for me and pushed me so hard that my foot ripped through the top sole of my running shoes. I've largely recovered but I've never been able to run as fast I used to. Up until day I was breaking various personal best times in running and had actually finished third in my age group in a local 10km race earlier that year. That was the peak of my running ability and it's been a struggle to get back to it ever since.
- kd5bjo 9y agoUnless the law has changed since I got my California license, pedestrians have the right of way at all crosswalks regardless of what the lights say. Also, every intersection has crosswalks at it, even if they haven't been painted on the street.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAnd unless its changed since I got mine, a car may not enter a crosswalk that has a pedestrian in it. Not often enforced, but I think its there to make it always the car's fault?
- wcarron 9y agoI ride a motorcycle and was involved in a collision a few months ago and I can attest to one thing from the article: "Your life will probably not be the same" I wasn't injured as badly as the author was but flying through the air and breaking bones hurts. Thing is, I only changed my perspective because I was forced to. I'm much more patient on the bike, and more alert too. People everywhere drive while distracted (eating, makeup, the phone, their computer!, putting clothes on) and now I have to assume they will attempt to murder me. Most drivers don't have to go through that. They literally forget that driving is inherently extremely dangerous because they have ever improving cages around them. I would say that the vast majority of drivers are grossly negligent on the road. Like other commenters mentioned, I've changed my language about vehicle collisions. I refuse to call them "accidents". Some may be, but "accident" implies that there's no fault. That nobody fucked up; but that's just not true in real life. People literally merge on top of me, while I'm __not__ lane-splitting at least 4-5 times a week. I consider almost any traffic death manslaughter, at least. If there's clear fault / distracted driving I consider it murder. It might be an extreme conclusion, but distracted driving is essentially saying "My trivial needs are more important than other motorists' lives." and it saddens me that our judicial system fails to adequately select for responsible driving.
- pfisch 9y agoWhen I move into an apartment I like to disable all the smoke detectors in the building and lock all the emergency exits. You know, I like to ride on the wild side, and I like to create the conditions for everyone else to be at risk of accidentally killing people. I consider anyone who starts the fire guilty of at least manslaughter though, and if they were distracted when it happened it is definitely murder. They literally forget that fire is inherently extremely dangerous with all their ever improving safety gear. So I like to keep it real and make sure that we don’t have it.
- dang 9y agoWould you please not post like this? I almost banned you, because https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15883519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15883519 and other past comments also broke the guidelines, but you've posted plenty of civil, substantive comments as well. Please stick to those only. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- TaylorGood 9y agoA friend from my early years was just hit and died from a car. Crossing the street at night. He was a musician and "the one to potentially make it" so it extra stings for everyone who knew him. I'm more alert as I walk my neighborhood daily. A bit more cautious. Cars and other drivers simply do not care about you as much as you care for yourself.
- kcorbitt 9y agoI know it isn't directly about cycling, but this story reminds me of the parody article I saw in The Onion: "Study: 90% Of Bike Accidents Preventable By Buying Car Like A Normal Person" [1]. I commute 30 miles each day on an electric bike, and while I haven't been hit yet statistically it's only a matter of time. I wish we had the infrastructure in place to make cycling a safe alternative, but it'll take years of build out to get to that point. One thing I will say is that San Francisco drivers are actually pretty courteous towards cyclists, even when I have to take up a whole lane (happens whenever there's on-street parking and no bike lane). It feels like about half of the people who swear at me/flip me off for "impeding traffic" have out-of-state license plates. [1]: https://www.theonion.com/study-90-of-bike-accidents-preventable-by-buying-car-1820403123 https://www.theonion.com/study-90-of-bike-accidents-preventa...
- revelation 9y agoThat's a lot! What's your setup like?
- tbihl 9y agoTop Gear did an episode where they made a bunch of PSAs just like that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aK_Ru6tScBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aK_Ru6tScBE
- noer 9y agoI was hit by a van a few weeks ago. I was on my bike, waiting to cross a busy street, the van was next to waiting to turn right and the driver was looking to his left to see when traffic stopped. Unfortunately he started moving before he turned to see what was in front of him. I was knocked off of my bike (I wasn't moving when I was struck) and my bike ended up getting run over & destroyed It was a pretty surreal experience. At first I flipped out at the driver who was at work at the time. A woman called 911 and the police came to take statements. The driver was pretty apologetic afterwards and I apologized for being an asshole. It wasn't until a few hours later that I realized that I could have died pretty easily. He put his foot on the brake reasonably quickly after he hit me, but had he accidentally floored the van, I would have been run over too. I also felt pretty bad for the driver. He probably got in some kind of trouble at work, and I realized that while I was mostly unharmed and only needed to get my bike replaced, he could lose his job. I know that getting hit is pretty serious, and the reason was because of the same carless behavior a lot of people that drive seem to do (myself included).
- tbihl 9y agoWe make driving far too easy. Narrower lanes, trees right next to the roads, and more potholes would probably go a long way toward making driving safer, both for the drivers and for everyone else. Because at the end of the day, drivers subconsciously adjust their behavior to achieve an apparently-constant risk level as roads and cars improve. Or there's always the spike-in-the-steering-column theory. https://jalopnik.com/theres-actually-a-name-for-a-steering-wheel-with-a-big-1791445206 https://jalopnik.com/theres-actually-a-name-for-a-steering-w...