5 ms·
> I understand why they do it: they trying to bring down transaction costs with payment processors. These fees on small amounts is death by thousand cuts. Then
by geofft 9y ago
> I understand why they do it: they trying to bring down transaction costs with payment processors. These fees on small amounts is death by thousand cuts.
Then they should have never strayed from the original model, where they charge you once per month for all your pledges, causing only one fee paid to the payment processor.
(If they needed to accommodate people pledging small amounts to very few creators, they could have introduced some sort of quarterly, biannual, or even annual payment option instead of just monthly. I'm curious if they evaluated this option and what they concluded.)
- hinkley 9y agoMy coffee shop has a sign: $0.50 fee for card transactions under $5. I’ve seen that sign over the years at a dozen places. The idea isn’t entirely novel. And you’re right, in that perhaps they should send $3 every three months or. $6 every six if you’re only giving to one person.
- DrJaws 9y agoThat's illegal on my country, they cannot change the price for different payment methods.
- vetinari 9y agoWhich country it is? Payment cards are not a legal tender, so you can do whatever you want, provided you didn't sign a contract not to do.
- francoisfeugeas 9y agoIn France for instance if you accept credit cards, it is illegal to add a fee for accepting it. You can impose a minimum purchase amount for accepting it though. Certain professions (i.e., taxis) are even forced to accept credit cards.
- vetinari 9y ago> In France for instance if you accept credit cards, it is illegal to add a fee for accepting it. Are you sure, that it is by law, though? In most countries, it is a contractual obligation: when you make a contract with your bank or payment processor, one of those terms & conditions is not to discriminate against the card payers. The purpose is to force the processing fees on the merchant, otherwise the cards would be at a disadvantage and would not get popular. For a case study, see Southeast Asia (1. cash rules there; 2. you can pay with a card, but you will have to cover the fees too; 3. as a consequence, everyone uses cash, see also point 1). In the case of taxis, I would understand if they voluntarily had terminals for their own protection (so they would not get mugged for few banknotes), but forcing them... that sounds wrong.
- ernesth 9y ago>> In France for instance if you accept credit cards, it is illegal to add a fee for accepting it. > Are you sure, that it is by law? It is: Article L112-12 from the Code monétaire et financier. "Le bénéficiaire ne peut appliquer de frais pour l'utilisation d'un instrument de paiement donné." (The seller shouldn't charge any fee for the use of a given payment instrument). https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichCodeArticle.do;jsessionid=38CA22FA6FC4594244490A070DF3E92A.tplgfr41s_2?idArticle=LEGIARTI000020861872&cidTexte=LEGITEXT000006072026&dateTexte=20110125 https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichCodeArticle.do;jsession... More generally, the law requires that the total to pay is to be presented to the client before he choses how to pay.
- vetinari 9y agoInteresting, thanks.
- DrJaws 9y agoSpain, and its the same thing as the user from france. They cannot charge you any extra fee for using cards or any payment method.
- hinkley 9y agoCould be. There are a lot of places with minimum orders for credit card too. That probably works easier for the business anyway.
- marshray 9y agoThe reason you don’t see that everywhere is it’s specifically against the merchant agreement to charge cc customers extra. The only places I’ve ever seen getting away with it are very small shops and government agencies (like the auto tag office) that legally cannot pay those costs out of ordinary revenue.
- slg 9y agoGas stations seem to still regularly have a credit card price that is different than their cash price.
- steffan 9y agoIt's semantics: I believe the wording or the typical agreement states that you may not charge a customer more for using a card. It does not, however, prohibit providing a 'cash discount'.
- slg 9y agoWhich is why this whole debate seems a little silly from a practical perspective. It doesn't matter whether a fee is paid by the seller or the buyer or if a difference in price is a discount or a surcharge, it all washes out in the end. How Patreon or gas stations frame the difference is simply marketing. Patreon's mistake was just poor marketing.
- aeorgnoieang 9y agoOT, but why don't programmers say or write "It's syntax". Different semantics, in the programming language sense, isn't what that phrase usually means.
- BillinghamJ 9y agoI'd say they were quite the opposite! "Semantics" is about the meaning you're trying to express. "Syntax" is the way you've chosen to express that meaning in this particular case. e.g.: def blah "a" end versus function blah() { return 'a'; } Semantically identical, but unrelated syntax.