6 ms·
Engineers create plants that glow
- lowglow 9y agoHasn't this been a thing since forever? I remember also reading something about a glowing rabbit at one point in school.
- _Wintermute 9y agoYou're thinking of GFP, which requires gene editing and certain wavelengths of light which fluoresces rather than "glows". This is a pretty different approach.
- ainiriand 9y agoYeah I remember that one. Even glowing vegetables for medicine, not only decorative plants. Offtopic: I missread 'Engineers create plants that grow' and I was thinking: 'Yeah, this thing is going to catch investment'.
- lucozade 9y ago> The vision is to make a plant that will function as a desk lamp There's something about that sentence that is just brilliant (excuse the pun). I'm not really sure why. Maybe because it has never occurred to me that what a poinsettia was missing was a dimmer switch? No idea, but I love it.
- zaarn 9y agoI doubt plants will replace desk lamps. Maybe only very dim ones. Even larger organisms like humans aren't powerhouses, we only need about 100 Watt (25 Watt for the brain), imagine you also had to power a 20W lightbulb. You'd have to suddenly increase your daily food consumption by 20%. While this sounds easy for a human, it's not going to be that healthy, even less so for a plant which probably consumes less than a couple watts and a 20 Watt light output will probably exceed any other energy usage of the plant easily.
- carlmr 9y ago>Even larger organisms like humans aren't powerhouses, we only need about 100 Watt (25 Watt for the brain), imagine you also had to power a 20W lightbulb. You'd have to suddenly increase your daily food consumption by 20%. This sounds like it could be an amazingly healthy diet product.
- lucozade 9y agoI think you're making an assumption about lumens/watt that may or may not be valid. Who knows what a Light Emitting Daisy could achieve?
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoI know one thing for sure: it will achieve less output radiance than it receives as solar insolation. I would be surprised if they were able to make it glow only when it was dark, so put a 50% modifier on that. Then you need to account for the energy needs of the plant, any inefficiencies in the light producing chemistry and light emitting apparatus (a semi-opaque bulk emitter will absorb a lot of the radiation it produces), but we'll generously assume that's equal to the difference between a conventional electric bulb and its light output, so we can approximate the light intensity with our expectations of regular lights. But you also need to account for the photosynthetic efficiency which Wikipedia says is about 2% [1], so you are at 1% of incoming light energy in equivalent electric light power. Solar insolation gives you up to 1 kW per square meter, a large daisy might have an irradiated area of 0.01 meters or 10W input, and you get 1% of that so 0.1W output. That's a couple lumens, or about 10x less than a typical solar landscape light. Which is as you would expect, because we eliminated the light sensor and (more importantly) used photosynthesis instead of a solar panel. But fortunately, these things literally grow like weeds, or on trees! [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency
- IanCal 9y agoI think this will depend on the overall efficiency, but I can find portable reading lights at 1W, and I've got a 5W bulb in my hall. 20W is quite a lot for LEDs. In general I agree, though I'd be interested to see the overall efficiency and output, whether your could get that kind of output from a larger plant. I'm concerned about the (even theoretical) end to end efficiency compared to something like a solar panel + led setup. > This technology could also be used to provide low-intensity indoor lighting, or to transform trees into self-powered streetlights, the researchers say. Streetlights that glow up significantly sounds like a horrible idea for light pollution. While interesting, and I'm happy seeing research done without clear monetisation, I'm not sure what key problems glowing plants actually solve. An honest question, as lots of smart people working on this I assume know a lot more about the issues than someone who's been thinking about it for 5 minutes.
- acoye 9y agoWe now can engineer a forest like in Avatar. I like this idea.
- carlob 9y agoWhat I really want to know is whether the leaves keep growing after you cut them: I want to eat some glowing salad!
- wcoenen 9y agoIn related news, Taxa Biotechnologies (the company from the Glowing Plant kickstarter[1]) is shutting down. It seems they were just a bit too early, I think the idea still has merit. [1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/antonyevans/glowing-plants-natural-lighting-with-no-electricit/description https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/antonyevans/glowing-pla...
- dekhn 9y agothey weren't too "early". people cloned luciferase into tobacco 30+ years ago. the problem is that there are limits into how much you can make a healthy plant glow. Also, the guy working on this didn't really know enough bio to optimize the expression levels.
- tsakas123 9y agoHeard about similar experiments a couple of decades ago. Back then scientists immediately stopped the experiment. If glowing plants escape the lab it would seriously affect the natural day-night cycle in nature. Hard to predict what would happen to the night life in the forests. The pitch back then was to colonise space as plants would not need the sun for photosynthesis.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoApparently this is done by injecting nanoparticles into each mature plant, not by gene-editing, so the plant's offspring won't glow. I still can't see it being remotely practical as a light source.
- Xylakant 9y ago> The pitch back then was to colonise space as plants would not need the sun for photosynthesis. That's a stupid pitch. The light is required as an energy source for the photosynthesis. Making the plant glow would consume energy from the plant. If you could make a plant that glows without an outside energy source and use this light for photosynthesis while still being energy positive, you'd have broken a few fundamental laws of physics. Having these plants escape the lab and light up woods would be the least of my worries in that case.
- kgc 9y agoI initially read this as "Engineers create plants that grow"
- ajuc 9y agoWould be a huge breakthrough.
- spodek 9y ago“If trees could scream, would we be so cavalier about cutting them down? We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason.” -- Jack Handy Potentially relevant about them glowing all the time?
- nautilus12 9y agoThis seems barely better than rubbing lightning bugs on plants. They didn't change the plants genome to produce luciferine naturally and pass that trait down to its young, they just put forced nano particles of luciferine into the plant.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoPermit me to don my tinfoil hat for a moment, but that makes it "better" (for some definitions of better) in a very important way: It avoids the problem Monsanto has with people (intentionally or inadvertently) cross-pollinating their genetically engineered crops and not buying more seeds from them. If they can industrialize and patent or keep secret the process of injecting luciferene, then to get their glowing plants you must always buy a new plant from them. You can't plant clippings or seeds with the modified genome. I too would prefer sidewalks edged with naturally proliferating glowing ground cover, and walking through night landscapes that glow like in Avatar, but that seems to be a few steps away.
- cmac2992 9y agoI had some friends work on a similar project a few years ago. They found that the glowing was not bright enough to be useful for anything meaningful and it significantly hindered plant growth.
- quirkot 9y agoThis is super cool, but it can't solve the "desk lamp" problem. All the plants people try to grow in my cube farm are anemic and sickly... they'd likely never have the spare energy to glow. edit for clarity: unless this is for folks that work night shift, you either already get enough sunlight to have a well lit desk XOR you don't have enough sunlight to power a bioluminescent plant
- logfromblammo 9y agoAs much as this appeals to me on a sci-fi level, I think that most of the potential applications being floated for it are pretty bad ideas. For instance, no plant is ever going to replace my desk lamp when the only color it can produce is 530 nm, it is too dim to read with, and I have to worry about killing it. But the real problem there is that I don't even have a desk lamp any more. Or even a desk. My home computer station is a recliner, and my monitor is on a swing-arm. This technology is a necessary first step to producing nirnroot, but that is the full extent of my expectations. I expect the chiming sound will come later. Any serious application will probably have to be artificial lichens that can be painted onto surfaces that are exposed to light and moisture. Lichens are hardy little bastards, so if you cover a sidewalk in glowing lichen paint, you will likely end up with something that glows just strongly enough to expose tripping hazards on it. Paint a runway with it, and planes might be able to manage an emergency landing without the usual lighting. This light isn't bright enough for me to see any domestic uses that would displace LEDs or electroluminescent panels.
- syphilis2 9y agoIs the plant needed to produce the light? It sounds like the plant is being used as a medium to hold the light emitting particles, but otherwise isn't used to fuel or transport them.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]