7 ms·
Maybe we could do something crazy, like bring back SROs, instead of de facto as a society acting like we think it is better for people to sleep in a tent than h
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Maybe we could do something crazy, like bring back SROs, instead of de facto as a society acting like we think it is better for people to sleep in a tent than have "sub standard" housing. Because tolerating rampant homelessness while turning our noses up at modest rentals basically amounts to the nation saying that is exactly what it thinks.
Miner said she was skeptical of the proposed campaign to educate homeless people about fire risks.
Yeah. A homeless person making a cooking fire is probably hungry and probably has no other viable option. Trying to "educate" the homeless about fire risks sounds like "Honey, we don't care if you starve. Just make sure you don't burn down any mansions. Kaythxbai."
- GarrisonPrime 9y agoI don't disagree, but I will point out that many homeless people want to be homeless, if being housed means submitting to questions and forms. Autonomy is a powerfully strong motivator.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe vast majority of homeless do not want to be homeless. If we provide enough affordable housing -- at market conditions, with no more forms and the like than other rentals -- you will be left with a much smaller number of quirky hobo-by-choice types. Shrinking the problem is very worthwhile.
- TheCoreh 9y agoDon't rentals require a credit score, a stable source of income, and usually a guarantor?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYes. But I am trying to make the distinction that most poverty relief programs are much more invasive and bureaucratic than most market based solutions. I am thinking of low cost rentals where they require you to live there and won't rent it to well off people looking for a weekend getaway that is cheaper than a motel. But other than that, I don't want a lot of extra requirements tacked on.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI think you're very misguided about "market based solutions". The homeless don't have money, therefore they have limited/no exposure in the "market". I don't know if you've been present before about why companies don't form around low income or homeless segment - there's no market in them. No money = no RoI. You cater to people who have money. You're describing something that price discriminates and doesnt at the same time. > I am thinking of low cost rentals where they require you to live there Forced to be there X amount of time. This is a reduction of freedom, which sounds like reinstating the bureaucratic nightmare you talk of. > and won't rent it to well off people looking for a weekend getaway that is cheaper than a motel. Means-testing. The homeless aren't going to have the paperwork to show lack of means. Remember, these people probably have no ID or anything. The census allows them to highlight landmarks where they "frequent", along with voting homeless allowed similar. > But other than that, I don't want a lot of extra requirements tacked on. And what you stated is already too much. What needs done: if you're homeless, you get a small room. It's yours. It won't be much. We can at least afford that as a population.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe homeless are not some other population. They are people who currently lack housing. With enough affordable housing, some people would never land on the street to start with. They would move to an SRO temporarily, get their act together and return eventually to more conventional housing. I am not talking about a homeless service. I am talking about policies that shrink the problem in part by preventing homelessness to begin with. I will add not all homeless are completely penniless, and I have formally studied the subject.
- crankylinuxuser 9y ago> The homeless are not some other population. They are people who currently lack housing. True, however not having housing then brings on a host of other problems. Basic sanitation and food are just 2 of those big issues - and the food issue is why the fire happened in this place. > With enough affordable housing, some people would never land on the street to start with. They would move to an SRO temporarily, get their act together and return eventually to more conventional housing. Or, they would do like what we see happen in China and Japan - where the prices keep going up and up and up, and those people never leave the SROs. That's also a market eventuality, and a noted fact in those areas. This idea that SRO's are some "gift" to homeless and that they'll clean right up is a farce. > I am not talking about a homeless service. I am talking about policies that shrink the problem in part by preventing homelessness to begin with. I have a completely curveball outfield suggestion: We the government/people build SROs. If you're homeless, you can have 1. End of discussion. Because shoving this on "The Market" is how in part why they became homeless. So yeah, splatter more "market". It's about as true as trickle-down theory (aka: getting pissed on by above). > I will add not all homeless are completely penniless, and I have formally studied the subject. Yeah, so did I. I was homeless. You researched it for a single sociology class. When I was homeless, we met lots of students from the local university. The homeless epidemic has gotten nowhere but worse. But hey, there's some papers published reaffirming time and again the same things.
- ams6110 9y agoNot all of them. In smaller towns you can rent an apartment or even business space on a handshake.
- jpindar 9y agoNormal apartments usually do. But there are also businesses that rent rooms or studios by the week, without a lease. Much like a hotel (and some of them also function as hotels), they can simply refuse to rent to a problem tenant next week so they don't need any of that.
- kurthr 9y agoIf 20-25% of homeless suffer extreme mental illness (as claimed by the National Coalition for the Homeless) , then I'm not sure that the vast majority simply lack for affordable housing. That's true for families, the elderly, and those living out of vehicles... but many of those living in encampments (e.g. >> 25%) are doing so because they do not want to be in any shelter or no shelter would have them (drug use, prostitution, violence, etc). I agree shrinking the problem is useful, but many of the homeless wouldn't want to live near other homeless, when they have the choice. http://www.nationalhomeless.org/factsheets/Mental_Illness.pdf http://www.nationalhomeless.org/factsheets/Mental_Illness.pd...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoLet's go with your theory and assume the worst. That still leaves 75% of them who would like a "normal" life and just can't manage to arrange it.
- kurthr 9y agoWell, actually worst would be that as many as 25% of those living in encampments are extremely mentally ill and unable to even find or stay in low cost housing. Another 25% might be involved in illegal behavior that wouldn't be allowed in and SRO (prostitution, drugs, violence, bike theft). Another 25% might be opposed the the idea of living with constraints of an SRO (when you can go in/out, how much room you have, who you have to live with). Then it's only the 25% (families, elderly, kids, disabled, sick, poor) living in an encampment because they don't have a vehicle that would move into low cost housing. That's an improvement, but it's nothing like a solution.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI have had a college class on Homelessness and Public Policy. I did an internship in a homeless shelter. Later, I spent time on the street myself, including six months in downtown San Diego attending homeless services. I consider myself to be more knowledgeable than average on the subject. You would need to provide a lot of data to substantiate this claim to have me take it seriously. I don't believe that is remotely realistic.
- arebop 9y agoYou can rent an apartment in Urbana, IL for $350/month where the minimum wage is $8.25. The HUD rule of thumb is that a person on that income would not be "cost-burdened" by a rent of up to $458/month. So although housing affordability is a real problem on the west coast, it doesn't really explain homelessness. The homeless on the west coast are people who either have deeper problems than affordability (such as profound disability/drug addiction), or who simply prefer to be homeless in LA than housed in a less fashionable part of the country.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> who simply prefer to be homeless in LA than housed in a less fashionable part of the country. I don't believe this is true. Many homeless people may make their way to the west coast because they'd be homeless either way and services (and weather) are better in LA (often with "help" from their local government, since a bus ticket is much cheaper than actual support). But ideological freegans who actually choose to leave decent homes and jobs are a microscopic fraction.
- s0rce 9y agoAlso, it costs money to move across the country. It would be interesting to know if there are charities that help with relocation and getting people back on their feet with minimum wage jobs and housing in lower cost of living areas.
- koolba 9y agoSometimes cities will fund it themselves. A one way bus ticket out of town is way cheaper than providing housing.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThere is some truth to this, but it is much, much more common to stick you in the back seat of a police car or sheriff's vehicle and drive you to the edge of their jurisdiction and drop you by the side of the road. In some cases, it is done nicely and helpfully because you are traveling on foot, it saves you a bunch of walking and you don't die in their jurisdiction. Other times, it is asshole behavior for pan handling (I never panhandled, I just know it happens). When I was in downtown San Diego, word on the street was that there was an organization that would help with travel to get back home. But when I have searched online, I haven't located such info. I have idly wondered if we could create an organization for donating travel points of various sorts to help homeless people get train tickets or other travel expenses covered.
- zouhair 9y agoCan you back up this outlandish claim?
- Spooky23 9y agoIt’s not outlandish. The government shifted from institutional commitment to voluntary community based care for the mentally ill and chronically addicted in the early 1980s. For a variety of reasons, just providing apartments doesn’t work. Most homeless people require substantial and ongoing assistance to get and remain independent. Our social welfare system is a patchwork that varies from state to state and counties within a state. Until that changes, you’ll see no progress, as people will migrate to get better benefits and services, which makes delivery of those services impossible.
- mncharity 9y ago> people will migrate to get better benefits and services, which makes delivery of those services impossible A couple of decades ago, a large town in New Hampshire obtained federal funds to build low-cost housing. But the housing brought in people who used more local services. Services whose cost was only partially defrayed by the state and federal governments. So the town then bought up low-cost housing, and tore it down.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAbout 10-15% of the US population is below the Federal poverty line in any given year, but only 2% are chronically poor. This is typically defined as below the Federal poverty line at least 5 years out of 10. My thinking is we need enough low cost housing for 2% of the population. This would help keep the chronically poor -- those with intractable personal problems -- off the street. I am currently thinking a lot about how to address the issue effectively. I am not for growing homeless services or similar programs. My latest project is aimed at making flexible earned income a viable option, for both homeless people and people with the kinds of barriers to employment that can lead to homelessness: http://independentdigitalworkers.blogspot.com http://independentdigitalworkers.blogspot.com It isn't charity. It is part of how I got myself off the street.
- thesagan 9y agoIt's a valid point but housing is more and more out of reach of folks. As a nation we need to open up housing opportunities. We've really regressed.
- noonespecial 9y agoPerhaps, (go with me here) perhaps we don't strictly need questions, forms, drug tests, credit checks, background checks, arrest warrant checks, and belonging searches to give someone the simple dignity of a little room to spend a night in.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 9y agoI agree. There have to be options for really cheap places to live. For a lot of old people without much money it's the same. They have nowhere to go.
- joe_the_user 9y agoEven more, of course a lot of worries about unsafe conditions are simply a fig leaf over worries that simple, minimal living spaces would cut into rents and mortgage payments for existing places. Of course one could have homeless encampments with strict and specific safety standards, either with tents or shacks ("tiny houses") or RVs or whatever. Existing homeless encampments are miserable, unhealthy and dangerous based on the standard that making homelessness a livable condition is bad.
- andrewflnr 9y agoExactly what kind of "sub-standard" are we talking about, here? Sleeping in a tent definitely is better than in a house that might fall on you or electrocute you. Ed: I like the idea of dialing back some building standards, but I'm worried about defining the conditions where it would be allowed (in particular, making sure it doesn't become a de facto default), and whether it would in fact be logically equivalent to just living in tents.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI specified as clearly as I could. SROs are typically one room. They typically have a sink, refrigerator and closet and shared bathroom facilities and shared cooking facilities down the hall. Some are more like a hotel room, with their own private bathroom, but no kitchen. They typically allow hot plates and the like. We tore down up to 80% of them over the course of a couple decades. If it isn't designed to house a family of four, the US seems to think it should not exist. So, many of our youth end up living with roommates because they can't afford a family home on their own and there aren't more modest options available. Edit in response to your edit: You might find this article a good read elucidating the issue: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2013/07/it-time-bring-back-boarding-house/6236/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2013/07/it-time-bring-back-bo...
- StillBored 9y agoWe also destroyed public housing by failing to fund it (and make it desirable to people who could afford to live elsewhere). Now we just rent the space from private companies that proceed to skim off large chunks of cash, all while selling the now really valuable land under old housing projects to fund such short term logic. Why the government would ever 'rent' something like housing is beyond me. Not only that, but we have millions of churches sitting around getting tax breaks for their "community contributions" while locking their doors 5 days a week so that taxpayers are building homeless shelters to keep the bums from stinking up the pews.
- nihonde 9y agoMany millions of Japanese people live in these conditions (ワンルーム) and consider it to be normal. It’s all a matter of perspective, setting reasonable expectations, and adhering to standards. If everyone acts like these conditions are tantamount to failure, it is failure. If everyone shrugs it off as a fact of modern life, there’s no shame in it.
- Spooky23 9y agoOr let the police eject people from encampments that are a danger. It’s pretty obvious that these sorts of places are threats to public safety.
- Balero 9y agoThese people are the public as well. Kicking them out of what little home they have seems like a threat to their safety.
- Spooky23 9y agoHow many first responders are put at risk to life & limb when you have big wildfires break out? How many sick people suffer from the polluted air? (ie. Asthma and COPD sufferers)
- eternalban 9y agoHow about we get really "crazy" and do some wealth redistribution. "Life, Liberty, and Pursuit of Happiness". It's a catchy motto and its on the tin. It seems a minimum requirement is having a safe and secure place to live in.
- sandworm101 9y agoBiulding codes and standards are not what is making california housing expensive. Construction costs are nothing compared to the cost of land.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe protectionist tax policies in California are not helping the situation.
- mncharity 9y ago> bring back SROs Not my field, but perhaps more than just SROs?[1] Flops (no bed), dorms (no walls), cages (partial walls), and assorted forms of SROs? And perhaps in a competitive market, so there could be a price/quality spread within each type? A continuum of housing options was apparently eliminated. One of the effects of concentrating wealth and power, is governance priorities reflect that: "those parts of the economy on which you people depend... well, we disliked or didn't care about them, so they're gone now. shrug." Verizon might be 100k personnel, but opposition to network neutrality is perhaps 1k managers or 100 execs? "Sorry about your Internet, but, Wall Street and year-end bonuses, you understand." Or perhaps our own "sorry about your driving career, but aren't self-driving trucks neat?" :) [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20120620080305/http://www.city-journal.org/article01.php?aid=1529 https://web.archive.org/web/20120620080305/http://www.city-j... (via Wikipedia)
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYour article is dated Summer 1992. That's over 25 years ago, so the cost comparison figures are significantly out of date. Here is an article from 2013: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2013/07/it-time-bring-back-boarding-house/6236/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2013/07/it-time-bring-back-bo...
- mncharity 9y ago> 1992 [...] so the cost comparison figures are significantly out of date Nod. Perhaps now 2x? EDIT: https://www.google.com/search?q=1992+dollars+today https://www.google.com/search?q=1992+dollars+today
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIt talks about renting a place in New York for $300/mo. When I google "cheapest New York apartment," the first hit is for 16 apartments under $1000. The cheapest seems to be $838. So, it might be more like x3 the "today" figures. /quick and dirty
- closeparen 9y ago
- scruple 9y agoMy mentally ill, currently homeless in Orange County, brother-in-law would rather be homeless than live somewhere that isn't of his choosing (which is why he's homeless to begin with -- he's more than welcome to stay with us in our home, again, provided he follows some very simple rules, but he refuses to play ball with any solution that isn't his own). The fact of the matter is that he and folks like him are adults who are responsible for themselves. Many of them are actively choosing this lifestyle. They are choosing not to acknowledge and address their illnesses. And there's not much that anyone can honestly or earnestly do about that in our society, as long as they don't break the right laws (I'm referring to the fact that, for him, a 5150 is, sadly, _always_ the start of a better period in his life for some time).
- crooked-v 9y ago> mentally ill > responsible Broadly speaking: choose one, but not both.
- scruple 9y agoPardon me? I have no choice to make here. This is the way our society is currently structured. He is a ~30 year old man with an illness. I can't force him to take his medication and, under normal circumstances, neither can the state. Hence, he is responsible for himself.
- mofosyne 9y agoMental illness does not sound like a normal state. I don't think he was talking to you personally. I agree in terms of individuals, we should not be expected to hold the burden themselves of others. The same doesn't apply to society and the governance of it however.
- scruple 9y ago> Mental illness does not sound like a normal state. No, it doesn't sound like a normal state, but that doesn't mean it isn't a normal state for some people. > I don't think he was talking to you personally. I'm not sure who they were talking to. Myself, others in positions like mine, HNers, society at large, or the ether. Regardless, believing that the mentally ill can't be, or aren't in some fashion currently, responsible for themselves is ridiculous. They absolutely are in the eyes of both our society and the state. > I agree in terms of individuals, we should not be expected to hold the burden themselves of others. I agree. > The same doesn't apply to society and the governance of it however. I'd love to hear politically viable solutions that can cross-cut through the myriad issues faced by this specific community of people (the subset of homeless who are diagnosed and known to be mentally ill). I don't think SORs are going even get in the ballpark for them. If I tried to tell a delusional, manic, paranoid person that they need to go live in a room that the state says they are to now live in they'd balk and disappear within minutes. But, I really don't have anything to offer, either, and I think about it more than I probably ought to.
- majewsky 9y agoDefine SRO, please. By looking at the Wikipedia disambiguation page, I'm guessing that you mean "single-room occupancy", with "self-regulatory organizations" being a far-off second guess.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYes, single-room occupancy. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15911743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15911743