8 ms·
Alaska is warming so fast, quality-control algorithms are rejecting the data
- throwahey 9y ago> The missing station was just the result of rapid, man-made climate change, with a runaway effect on the Arctic. I'm not a climate change denier, but isn't it disingenuous to label this as man-made. There isn't enough science around how the climate functions in general to make the assumption that in this specific area, the changes are a result of humans rather than natural cycles we have yet to identify because of the very little data we have.
- Retric 9y agoWe have vast amounts of data. Of course we could always use more, but we have oceans of data around weather and climate.
- mikeokner 9y agoIn the last decade or even century, yes. But we have very little idea what the actual norm is in terms of fluctuations over the course of a few decades in the context of millennia because we don't have data at that granularity for the vast majority of history.
- Retric 9y agoWe have less data going back millennia, but it's their. Now, if your talking 100,000+ year cycles then fine, but you need to demonstrate what makes today different from yesterday on such a scale. Consider creationist's can request an intermediary fossil from A and C, but if you find B between them they now say their is two missing links A to B and B to C. Repeat as needed. What specific data do you think is missing, for what time period, to defend what hypothesis, that makes what testable prediction?
- gerdesj 9y agoNo, we have data that goes back millions even 100's of millions of years. The granularity of much of that is rather coarse. The data for 1000s of years is quite fine grained. There are trees that are over 1000 years old and ice cores that give near monthly data going back a very long time. There are also a lot of other clues as to climate from other sources. The UK's Met. office was established in 1854 and I'm sure that several others are just as old. That's simply when weather prediction became interesting. There is loads of data (temperature, wind speed etc) from before then, from ships and land based sources. We even have data from ancient civilisations and this can sometimes be corroborated and hence other things be reasonably inferred. More modern, we know that people were ice skating on the river Thames in the 18th century - that's quite a big river and it does not freeze these days - that was a mini ice age. Anyway, we have a lot of data and it goes back a long, long, way (with a few gaps)
- jquery 9y agoWe have oceans of data around a lot of things that supposedly scientific-minded people prefer to ignore. There's also the fact that agenda-based science (not saying that's what this is) can easily produce an ocean of data, e.g., showing that tobacco doesn't cause lung cancer. EDIT: To the downvoters, I shouldn't have used "Big Tobacco". I would prefer not to name other areas of research to try and keep this non-political. I am only pointing out that data and its interpretation are two very different things, and the incentives matter.
- Angostura 9y ago> There's also the fact that agenda-based science (not saying that's what this is) can easily produce an ocean of data, e.g., showing that tobacco doesn't cause lung cancer. reply Ah yes, Big Climateology chasing the big bucks by fabricating CO2 measurements.
- Retric 9y agoBig Tobacco never actually had data preventing the link from cancer to tobacco. They simply did not publish their studies and required more data to prove the link, because it 'required more research'. Basically, the same issue people bring up with climate science, while never defining what 'enough data' is other than simply more than we have.
- orf 9y agoIt's a pretty firm scientific consensus that mankind is having an outsized impact on the changing climate. It would be disingenuous to report otherwise. Sure, we could be exacerbating natural cycles, but according to the large volumes of data we do have it's pretty clear that humans are a major contributing factor.
- uncoder0 9y agoFrom what I've read it's much closer to 100% than it is to 50% in terms of what percentage of the current warming since 1950 can be attributed to humans. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2014/sep/15/97-vs-3-how-much-global-warming-are-humans-causing https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97...
- jquery 9y agoSerious question for those who think we know all the science (I believe in warming). Are there any models of climate change which have been predictive for the past 100 years and which existed at least 5 or more years ago?
- flukus 9y agoMost of them to varying degrees. They don't just start a model and hope it can predict the future, they test them by starting at a passed date and seeing if the can predict the present.
- throwahey 9y agoConsensus is not conclusive. It takes a special kind of hubris for someone to think they understand climate change with the minute dataset we have. We don't have enough data to guess next month's weather let alone the possible effects in 10+ years.
- oewfoewf 9y agoConsensus enough that geoengineering countermeasure "proposals" (they've already started these programs decades ago) explicitly counter the mechanisms that only humans could have started.
- gerdesj 9y agoThey go on to say: "The temperature in Barrow had been warming so fast this year, the data was automatically flagged as unreal and removed from the climate database. It was done by algorithms that were put in place to ensure that only the best data gets included in NOAA’s reports." These are algorithms that have not been triggered before. I understand that seasonal and "natural" fluctuations are taken care of. In theory that leaves man made. There is rather a lot of science around that indicates us lot as buggering up not just the climate itself but the oceans and even near space (junk). I'll grant you that this article sounds a little breathless but then the issue is a little bit important. I'll never forget the sight of an Aussie near sobbing on camera as he described coral bleaching over huge parts of the Great Barrier Reef ("Blue Planet II" - BBC). Sun Fish are seen off Cornwall, Polar bears are running out of ice to hunt across, 1 in xhundred year weather events are being seen much more regularly than their name suggests. We can ignore the science but as civilians we can only attribute so much to el Nino, seasonal variability and such like. Read a few papers yourself or read a few summaries from sources that you trust but don't summarise a shed load of research as: "There isn't enough science around how the climate functions"
- phkahler 9y agoThere isn't enough good science. If you look at the historic record (a million years or so) you'll see glaciations and interglacial periods. One thing we should expect is a new round of glaciation if nothing changes. But it's not time for that yet. A simple google for "interglacial high water mark" yielded this: https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/climate-change/changing-ice/high-water-mark https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/climate-change/changing-ice... Which indicates that sea levels have historically been several feet higher than they are today during the interglacials. There is no data on the exact temperature profile over short (100 year) historic time scales. We have evidence of data tampering - i.e. a climate model that showed the "hockey stick" regardless of what the input data was. It's a highly politicized thing. And lastly, if I accept climate change as a result of human activity I say we still don't have decent models. We need to accurately account for the effect of contrails. There is significant evidence that this matters. There is correlation between temperature rises and the increase in air traffic. It may not be "carbon" but "water vapor" that is the cause. I find these things interesting, but the headlines and stories are all very alarmist. Look at this fine article we're talking about. The data isn't all that interesting, it's just that it tripped a plausibility check someone implemented, and we don't know what the stated requirements for the check were.
- mhb 9y agoWhy does anyone care about the sideshow of what the cause of the warming is?
- tinymollusk 9y agoBecause that determines whether humans are to blame or not, which is a core component to virtue signaling. Not saying I see it in this conversation, but I have growing concerns about environmentalism-as-morality.
- kazinator 9y agoUnfortunately, we simply do not have the time to wait until blame is assigned with 100% certainty before taking action.
- tinymollusk 9y agoBut then we're using logic similar to Pascal's Wager to make important decisions.
- greglindahl 9y agoThe statement "if humans didn't cause the warming, than obviously changing what humans do can't possibly stop it" is often behind the question. And on the flip side, scientists advocating that humans change their behavior wish to show that the suggested actions will make an actual difference. Because, you know, proof and ethics and all that.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI'm not a climate change denier, but isn't it disingenuous to label this as man-made. I was always told to ignore everything before the 'but'.
- zimpenfish 9y agoI think the better plan is to negate everything before the 'but' since what follows is almost inevitably something that proves they're exactly what they've just claimed they aren't.
- jquery 9y agoPrevious submissions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15893859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15893859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15083989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15083989
- soperj 9y ago"Just this week, scientists reported that the Arctic had its second-warmest year — behind 2016 — with the lowest sea ice ever recorded. " Lowest sea ice ever recorded is verifiably untrue. http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/2017/09/arctic-sea-ice-at-minimum-extent-2/ http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/2017/09/arctic-sea-ice-at-... It was the 8th lowest in the 38 year record.
- mikeash 9y agoYour article refers to the minimum extent during the season, so I imagine this article was referring to something else. A quick search reveals that 2017 set a record for the lowest maximum extent, for example.
- soperj 9y agoHow could lowest maximum extent ever be confused with lowest sea ice ever recorded?
- negrit 9y agojournalism?
- greglindahl 9y agoScience, actually. The annual minimum and maximum extent of sea ice is one of the longest-duration satellite datasets available for study.
- nate_meurer 9y agoWould you prefer they say "lowest minimum extent" or "lowest average extent"? Is that really a significant improvement over "lowest maximum extent"?
- soperj 9y agoThey mean completely different things, so I don't know what you're getting at.
- owebmaster 9y agoThe title is so technically stupid that I'm not going to lose my time reading. Just flag it.
- mac01021 9y agoAre you a quality control mechanism too?
- owebmaster 9y agoNope, I'm a news/public opinion manipulator.
- King-Aaron 9y agoHow do you think the title is technically stupid? It appears to describe exactly what is happening in this instance.
- owebmaster 9y agoIt is not Alaska (the title was changed) that is warming "too" fast. The models and the algorithms are the ones to blame. And in this case WP for the sensationalism. Don't you agree? Please someone explain so in place of the downvotes.
- King-Aaron 9y agoI didn't see the previous title, so apologies.
- UncleEntity 9y ago> The Arctic is warming faster than any other place on Earth... I was reading like two days ago the Antarctic was warming faster than any other place on earth and shedding icebergs like crazy. Some sort of runaway effect from warm South Pacific water eating them away from underneath. Sea level to rise like 70ft. Get your story straight people...
- yters 9y agoIs there hard data showing sea ice melt causes ocean levels to rise? Because water will displace the same mass whether it is frozen or not. The best explanation I've heard is the loss of reflection from the sea ice will cause the water to warm, and warm water is less dense. But most sea ice is underwater, so am not sure just how much reflection is lost, and how much that affects the sea water warming.
- mikeash 9y agoThe main concern for sea level rise is the melting of land ice in e.g. Greenland and Antarctica.
- yters 9y agoLast I researched, the land ice was melting a lot, but then refreezing a lot. It seems that sea ice is the main thing disappearing.
- gerdesj 9y ago"Because water will displace the same mass whether it is frozen or not." Why do bergs float and have a bit sticking up out of the water? Why do ice cubes in my G&T insist on floating? Sea ice melt is a bit of a worry if you are a polar bear that hunts on pack ice but for sea rise the real snag is land based glaciers melting into the sea. Greenland may be off your radar but it is a bit of a worry - lot of ice turning into water there, along with other places.
- msandford 9y agoBut why do they float? Because they're less dense than the liquid water that surrounds them! If they were exactly the same density they wouldn't float. But since they're less dense, they stick out an amount proportional to their lowered density.
- greglindahl 9y agoSea ice melt is a huge worry because it changes the albedo of the polar ocean. That means more heating from the sun, which means a warmer Arctic and a warmer planet. It's one of the positive reinforcement mechanisms that's a huge worry to the climate community. Greenland melting is also huge, and sea ice melting will make it go faster.
- zeep 9y agoand it's snowing in Florida already...
- apple4ever 9y agoMaybe its because the data input is bad. The Earth isn't warming, that we know. The models that used to predict the warming can't even output data that matches the observed data. In 20 years, when the Earth has cooled, all the people who failed to use science will look like fools.
- King-Aaron 9y ago> The Earth isn't warming, that we know. [citation needed]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]