5 ms·
This is even worse than "we don't like you so we are no longer selling you our service", which is already problematic :/. Deciding "we know what you are doing w
by saurik 9y ago
This is even worse than "we don't like you so we are no longer selling you our service", which is already problematic :/. Deciding "we know what you are doing with our service, so we are going to keep selling you our service but make it do something different" should probably just be illegal. As it stands, if they really want to do this, I hope they realize it makes them de facto responsible for all email that goes through their service (and if they don't, then they are even bigger idiots than I normally paint them to be, as they literally are involved in a similar case in court right now).
This is equivalent to "I know you are going to use our invitation service to invite people to a meeting of your local gang, so we have made the emails go out with a typo in the location and phone number field", which has the same sort of "wait, are you sure it is a gang? how do you define a gang? is the gang even doing something harmful today?" problem that comes with the term "phishing". While this is much better than them claiming to block "spam" (which I will claim has so nebulous of a definition as to be meaningless), this is still a slightly ambiguous classification of any given communication due to how it interacts with trademark law.
Regardless, now that they have shown that they are interested in modifying the behavior of their platform to stop "using the Cloudflare platform for evil" (a direct quote from their blog post), clearly they now also should be using similar techniques to stop people from sending email about drug paraphernalia, and they should stop people from sending email with hate speech, and they should stop sending email about terrorism. They also should, of course, stop people from sending email about software piracy, or sending email about services designed to undermine copyright like SciHub, or sending email advertising "obscene" pornography.
They have now shown both the ability to do this and an interest in doing this, which is exactly what they recently demonstrated with the Daily Stormer SNAFU, where they showed the ability and interest to block use of their service "for evil"; in that case, the people were "Nazis", which may or may not be more clear cut than "phishers", but the scenario is essentially the same... and they are now having to backpedal their actions in court as this is being used as evidence for why they should be responsible for blocking piracy on their platform. The reality is that once you show an ability and an interest in policing content, what kinds of content you are forced to police will be taken from you and given to the state.
https://torrentfreak.com/daily-stormer-termination-haunts-cloudflare-in-online-piracy-case-170929/ https://torrentfreak.com/daily-stormer-termination-haunts-cl...
Cloudflare's decision today is going to be devastating not only for them, but for the Internet as a whole (as usual :/).
- brightball 9y agoIt looks like this is a policy on the FREE DNS, which IMHO, is fair game. Free services needs to be much more heavily scrutinized for potential abuse. I spent a lot of time dealing with phishing and fraud prevention. By far the biggest source that I had to deal with was free service abuse and near non-response from those service providers abuse teams.
- saurik 9y agoSo you are saying that your opinion changes if the user pays some token amount for the service? If they upgraded their plan to whatever the cheapest level is, then this would be no longer be a good thing for Cloudflare to do? Let us not forget that these emails aren't even being sent by or through Cloudflare: Cloudflare is not an email provider. Their interest in this is simply that they provide DNS. I find the ways that cloudflare thinks about how we should stop Internet abuse--such as their plea that all ISPs turn on packet logging to help find the sources of denial of service attacks--extremely concerning from a surveillance perspective :/.
- brightball 9y agoI'm saying that free services are easily abused because of the lack of up front cost and ease of forging contact info. You abuse a service, the service is terminated, you got to utilize it for a while and suffered no penalty aside from having to sign up for a new account. You use a stolen credit card, the service will be terminated and now that stolen credit card can be reported for abuse as well. A legitimate account that is paying for service and has legitimate contact information can actually make contact and rectify the issue, clear up a misunderstanding or be made aware that their domain is being abused in some way. I signed up for Sendgrid a few years ago for a company that I worked for and we used it to send the company's first newsletter to 300,000 users in about 14 years. About 70,000 of those bounced and somewhere shortly into delivery process, Sendgrid halted it and called us demanding to know where we got our email list and insisting that we verify user information for multiple addresses that had bounced. Once we explained the situation and verified everything, they released the halt and that first volley continued creating records for which email addresses we shouldn't be sending to again. Everything was fine from that point forward...but even with a paid account they were actively working at fraud prevention...and as long as there was a legitimate contact on the account it was perfectly reasonable to get resolved.