8 ms·
I think this is more negative for ICOs than your quotes imply. Look at this: > By and large, the structures of initial coin offerings that I have seen promoted
by modeless 9y ago
I think this is more negative for ICOs than your quotes imply. Look at this:
> By and large, the structures of initial coin offerings that I have seen promoted involve the offer and sale of securities and directly implicate the securities registration requirements and other investor protection provisions of our federal securities laws.
Basically, almost all ICOs so far are illegal. He says that it's possible to make an ICO that isn't illegal by following SEC rules, but I would be surprised if a single existing ICO actually qualified because most of the benefit of doing an ICO comes from not complying with the regulations.
- ikeboy 9y agoMost of the benefit of doing an ICO is that investors are throwing a ton of dumb money into ICOs.
- modeless 9y agoExactly. And SEC regulations are designed to stop dumb money from going into risky investments. If you comply then you can't cash in on that dumb money and there's no point to doing an ICO.
- ikeboy 9y agoA lot of that dumb money is being put in by wall street, so not sure you're right.
- modeless 9y agoThis is not my impression. It seems to me that the dumb money is people who made early fortunes in crypto or regular people looking to ride the next pump and dump. If Wall Street money is coming in it's mostly to take advantage of the dumb money for a quick profit, for example by getting preferential pricing or timing so they can sell to later investors).
- ikeboy 9y agoI think most of the money that's going in is by people with more than the 250k limit. Above that you can market pretty much anything as long as you're honest, I think. So I don't think it would be affected much, except that ordinary users wouldn't be able to use it (unless they could get it on exchanges, which may be under different laws?) Not a simple question, I guess.
- username223 9y ago> If Wall Street money is coming in it's mostly to take advantage of the dumb money for a quick profit,... Examples? Is Goldman playing in the current bubble?
- thinkmassive 9y agoYes. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-07/goldman-sachs-is-said-to-clear-bitcoin-futures-when-they-go-live https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-07/goldman-s...
- mrschwabe 9y agoIs dumb money also considered money that is going towards free speech activists? Why do you think the SEC should be arbitrators of what and what is not dumb money?
- phaed 9y ago> Basically, almost all ICOs so far are illegal. They are only illegal in the US if they allow US citizens to participate, and the majority ban US citizens. So I think you have it backward.
- eximius 9y agoLegally speaking, are they on the hook if they merely say that and don't take preventative measures against US citizens? It could come back to haunt them if they ever want to expand to the US down the road and didn't take precautions.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoYes, they are on the hook in that case. (Not lawyer, not legal advice.)
- londons_explore 9y agoA simple dropdown saying "citizenship" and then turning red with an error message saying "United States is not allowed. Did you mean United Kingdom instead?" will encourage most people to put something else. Then the company can fairly legitimately say "The customer lied to us about their citizenship. We took all reasonable measures to determine their citizenship, because there isn't a freely available database of which people have which citizenships"
- tfha 9y agoMy understanding is that the SEC expects you to require proof of an alternate citizenship via a passport. Simply having a drop-down that users can lie about by clicking a box or using a VPN is not good enough.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoUnless they're using expensive KYC procedures, I doubt that many ICOs have done enough to exclude US investors that the law will excuse them from SEC regulations.
- zemo 9y ago> almost all ICOs so far are illegal. a lot of them are offering to sell you an asset that they advertise as being sure to appreciate, with the subtext that you will sell the asset at a later point for a gain. Selling something purely to be a store of value and appreciation is basically the textbook definition of a security, isn't it?
- bufferoverflow 9y agoHow many ICOs "advertise as being sure to appreciate"? I've looked at like 40 different ones, bought into none, but none of them promised any return on investment. That's some straw man argument.
- ianamartin 9y agoAll of them. The more coins have been mined, the fewer are left to mine and the harder they are to mine. It's guaranteed scarcity. By design. All you have to add to that formula is the idea that there's a demand. And that's what every ICO is: hype about demand for a decreasingly available thing. Once you have been sold that there's a demand, the appreciation is guaranteed by definition of what it is.
- eudoxus 9y agoSeeing as most ICO are ERC20 tokens on the Ethereum chain you are most certainly incorrect about your deflationary theory implying appreciation. Since most ERC20 tokens are 100% premined and sold during the ICO, there is no concept of "mining" with those ICOs (except maybe Minereum :p ). Please avoid making generalized statements, especially ones that are flat out wrong.
- dkersten 9y agoIf they’re “pre-mined” then surely there is already a preset limited amount of tokens?
- 9y ago
- api 9y agoThere is a second benefit. Right now the crypto space is like the entry point of an MMORPG. Picture a bunch of dollars entering and then walking around and trying things. "What do I do here?" "How do I play?" Obviously it's bubbly but that's not the point. The point is that all this new money entering the crypto space is looking for something to do. Putting out an ICO will attract some of it. It is not accessible in any other way. ... and unfortunately ICOs and crypto have sucked a lot of the air out of conventional crowdfunding, equity crowdfunding, and small time angel investing. So crypto is where the money is and you have to go crypto to reach it. It's dumb but markets are not rational.