6 ms·
Starbucks in-store wifi provider in Buenos Aires uses CoinHive
- flibble 9y agoDoes anyone have an idea of the ROI on this? I'm thinking you'd need a massive number of 10 second to mine any meaningful number of BTC on consumer laptops.
- ct0 9y agoI wonder if sbux even knows. Im sure theyve outsourced their wifi by now...
- dvdhnt 9y agoProbably $0 after the backlash, perhaps even net negative.
- diggan 9y agoNot sure about the ROI, but I do know that Coin-Hive (which is being used in this "trick") mines Monero, not Bitcoin.
- ryangittins 9y agoEven if they did this in all Starbucks locations, I can't see it really making any money. Ten seconds on a laptop CPU rounds to zero. Coinhive has just never made any sense to me in practice. Maybe 5+ years ago, but not today. What a mismatch of effort and timing.
- mipmap04 9y agoCoinhive seems pretty upfront with this though (to answer "Will this work on my site?": "Technically yes, economically probably not. If you run a blog that gets 10 visits/day, the payout will be miniscule. For the captcha and shortlinks with a sensible hash goal (1024–16384) you'll need to have a whole lot of users to make this worthwhile." I do like it as an accessibility friendly captcha system, though.
- 55555 9y agoCoinhash mines monero and it is a business aimed towards hackers who want to monetize websites they have access to.
- criddell 9y agoI've wondered what the ROI would be for me to leave my home office computer mining bitcoin while I'm at work. I know the likelihood of me mining something is tiny, but so is the expected payout when I buy a lotto ticket. I spent about $20 / year on lotto tickets (basically whenever Powerball gets near a record jackpot). That same amount of money will keep my i5 ThinkPad running for a long time. Am I more likely to mine some Bitcoin or win the lottery?
- Jemmeh 9y agoI am by no means an expert, but my understanding is that a personal computer isn't energy/heat efficient enough to make a profit from mining. It costs more in energy than you would make from the bitcoin. My friends who do some mining have told me the same. You're competing with computers that are made exclusively for bitcoin and people who are heavily investing their time into it so it makes sense. It would probably be fine just for trying the system out and seeing how it works before you invest though.
- astura 9y agoJeez, you're completely missing the point. The GP was asking for a comparison the odds/cost of mining a coin with the odds/cost of winning the lottery. Not about "investing," and not about "making a profit." Basically, which form of gambling is better from a cost/rewards perspective.
- Jemmeh 9y agoMy understanding is you are always outspending on energy costs because of the energy inefficiency of personal computers for mining vs. a dedicated machine. So the chance of return would be more or less 0%. More like, "If I pay $5 for a lottery ticket where the max I can win is $4, what are my chances of profiting?" But again, not an expert. Just the articles I've read and people I know who mine bitcoin say you can't profit that way.
- RandomTrees 9y ago
- maltalex 9y agoIt makes no economic sense at all. Mining Bitcoin using CPUs is unprofitable. They're basically gaining cents worth of bitcoins using dollars worth of electricity. See https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/41276/in-the-asic-age-is-it-worth-starting-mining-bitcoin-at-home https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/41276/in-the-asi...
- QAPereo 9y agoAre they paying for that electricity?
- eberkund 9y agoSort of, I'm assuming a lot of people bring their chargers with them if they're using the WiFi at Starbucks
- ErnestedCode 9y agoI suppose the cost benefit depends on whether they stay in the store charging their laptops longer because of that 10 second delay. If the customer plugs in their laptop at 1pm and plans to leave at 1:30pm, then at least they'd be making money 10 seconds longer while spending the same amount of money on electricity. If the customer leaves at 1:30:10, then they'd be paying extra for the time. But in any case, they're not paying for any extra hardware.
- freeflight 9y agoAnother comment pointed out they are not literally mining Bitcoin but rather Monero [0], which seems to be profitable to mine on CPUs and SoC. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monero_(cryptocurrency) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monero_(cryptocurrency)
- Vadoff 9y agoCoinhive estimates that a user with a mid-range laptop would have a hashrate of 30 h/s. 10 minutes of mining = 30 * 10 * 60 = 18,000 hashes Since Coinhive pays out 0.000090 XMR per million hashes (current rate as of Dec 11. 2017), that's $0.0004250394 per user (18000/1000000 * 0.000090 * 262.37). In order to make $1, you would need 2,353 visitors with laptops mining for 10 minutes each.
- Fire1Assassin 9y agoI’m guessing this would work extremely well if it were set up as a honey pot at University? Tempted to test it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zenon 9y agoThe Coinhive script mines Monero: https://coinhive.com/ https://coinhive.com/ . It's been a while since JavaScript Bitcoin mining was feasible :)
- brndnmtthws 9y agoThe unwashed masses can't understand the difference between different coins, so you might as well call everything Bitcoin.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoMost of these crypto currency exchange are derived from bitcoin's codebase (or at least from bitcoin's white paper) so from that perspective I don't consider calling these other crypto's as "bitcoin" to be incorrect, just not specific. I could imagine that maybe could use the distinction of capital Bitcoin to refer to the specific blockchain while lowercase bitcoin to refer to any Bitcoin forks.
- rileyphone 9y agoI really like the idea of this as a captcha alternative, especially with the "train our neural nets" approach google has been taking recently with them.
- zeusk 9y agoHow would coinhive work as a captcha alternative? There is no human involvement in mining, is there?
- diggan 9y agoNot saying it would be a good idea but something like "Please wait until your CPU have done enough amount of work before submitting this comment"
- misterdata 9y ago
- crb002 9y agoCPU for services seems legit as long as they give an affirmative checkoff.
- technofiend 9y agoAre you suggesting it'll become part of the click-through license agreement in future?
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoIt's stealing money from the user via their electricity bill.
- gentooinstall 9y agoNot really if it's at Starbucks
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoIf you're using their wall outlet.
- ben_jones 9y agoI'm picturing going into a cafe, using the wifi, and my phone turning into a hot coal or my laptop fan blowing me back out of my seat.
- baxtr 9y agoThis is smart...or maybe not. Has anybody done the calculation here? I am very curious to know into how much $s the 10s translate to
- nerdponx 9y agoNot to mention that some (perhaps many) people will be running their devices off of the store's own power outlets. So the store will actually be paying the electrical bill for at least some of that mining.
- Tinyyy 9y agoThis isn’t mining Bitcoin, it’s using Coinhive (https://coinhive.com https://coinhive.com) to mine Monero
- ntietz 9y agoOne of the big problems I have with this (and with mining, in general) is that it's attempting to create value by simply wasting electricity. Come on, we should not be spending CPU cycles just for the sake of spending CPU cycles...
- bsilvereagle 9y agoYou may find GridCoin interesting. GridCoin rewards miners for running scientific computations for a variety of projects. CureCoin & Golem are two other coins that try to use the cpu cyles for something other than heat.
- aquilaFiera 9y agoUsing this logic, dollars are creating value by wasting paper and metal. What you're ignoring is the value of having a publicly auditable ledger of transactions and a decentralized currency. That _isn't_ a waste of electricity. There are plenty of reasons to be skeptical of cryptocurrency; this just isn't a good one.
- thisisit 9y agoThis script is mining monero which uses Cryptonight algorithm. This algorithm kinda famous for being CPU mine-able unlike other cryptocurrencies. Now, the coinhive page is completely blocked by all the plugins so I cannot find the exact story. But, if memory serves correctly, during the launch devs have presented a story where they use the script on a forum. The results were pretty impressive with payout reaching ~ 1k USD. Though there is a section which clearly says this is not economical, my take on this was that they wanted to entice enough people to mine using their script. The devs also promised to look into this kind of abuse but I guess that is not happening.
- apandhi 9y agoI had a run-in with CoinHive this weekend so I did a bit of research. Most modern computers can do about 30/h a second. Coinhive currently pays out 0.00009030 XMR ($0.02 USD) per 1M hashes. For a 10 second pause, they'd mine 300 hashes (about $0.000006 USD). To make $1 USD, they'd need to have ~166,666.66 people connect to their in store WIFI.
- diego 9y agoThat's plausible given that Fibertel is the #1 provider of free wifi in Argentina. It could well be that some IT guy had the idea, figured it was possible to make a few hundred bucks a month this way, under the radar. Completely not worth it for the company.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y ago30 hashes a second seems extremely low and I'm wondering where they got that number. Are they using unoptimized JavaScript I nstead of ASM.js?
- apandhi 9y ago30 hashes a second is what you'd likely see on mid-range laptops. You can test your machine on CoinHive (https://coinhive.com/ https://coinhive.com/) My fully maxed out 2017 rMBP can only do 50-60h/s at full speed with all threads. Most people don't have a machine nearly as powerful as mine.
- cgb223 9y agoHow much Monero can a company reasonably mine using this tactic?
- shak77 9y agoI bet this was done by a contractor without Starbucks permission.