7 ms·
World's Largest Water Diversion Plan Won't Quench China's Thirst
- Arbalest 9y agoWater security is an issue everywhere. Here in Australia, we have the Murray river. It is a major lifeline to Adelaide. However upstream farmers have been identified as stealing water, and their parent states aren't doing anything about it. I'm sure there's many farming practices that could be improved to reduce water consumption, but with lax policing, it's not happening.
- catmanjan 9y agoI'm in NSW and I can guarantee you that if the upstream farms were more efficient with their water they would use the same amount, but grow more... It's a bit like the mining industry, government doesn't want to even risk damaging the top 2 industries this country has.
- femto 9y agoThe problem in NSW is some farmers taking more water than they are legally allowed to, to the detriment of all other users of the river system, and then the law not being enforced. In the 4 Corners report that exposed the (mal)practice, there were reports of rivers flowing backwards due to the amount of water is being sucked out of them. It's not a state vs. state thing, as even the local NSW communities are screaming about it. It's a small corrupt group vs. the nation, and it stinks.
- mattfrommars 9y agoFrom what I've read in the past, it's not the crop is very water intensive, but rather the technique used to irrigate are water intensive. Take in comparison, "flood irrigation" vs techniques developed to irrigate in desert condition using "drip irrigation".
- smartbit 9y agoBeautifull documentairy Sud eau nord déplacer [0] on Nan Shui Bei Diao – North South Water Transfer [1] [0] https://www.idfa.nl/en/film/34d44e48-0092-4d5e-abdf-d501b5247d6c/south-to-north-cine-concert https://www.idfa.nl/en/film/34d44e48-0092-4d5e-abdf-d501b524... & http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3755604/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3755604/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South%E2%80%93North_Water_Transfer_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South%E2%80%93North_Water_Tran...
- tmoneymoney 9y agoMy family is from near the Danjiangkou reservoir. My family's ancestral land were flooded in the 1960s to create the reservoir. http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/04/26/ghosts-by-the-water-line-china-north-south-water-transfer-project-beijing-consequences-chinafile/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/04/26/ghosts-by-the-water-line...
- mc32 9y agoThis is quite a feat. It's tunneled under rivers, passes through cities and travels nearly a thousand miles north. I do wonder tough, about contamination given floods can easily breach the levies and in the cities runoff is pretty polluted. And wonder if any gets syphoned off --unless they have the very long fencing guarded 24x7.
- nshepperd 9y ago> Still, in many cases there’s little incentive for farmers to save water. Agriculture uses 62 percent of China’s water, but crops have a relatively low marginal value. So the government bans the sale of agricultural water to industry, which pays 10 times the price, to ensure food supply. This discount on water is effectively a cash subsidy for agriculture that increases with the amount of water wasted instead of useful goods sold. Seems like every country everywhere has the same issue: they don't want to sell water at the price it is actually worth, so it gets wasted and people complain about water security issues. (Then if it's a city residential area, they introduce rules like "no watering your lawn" in the hope that it will reduce waste, instead of canceling the 90% off all-year-round water sale.)
- freeone3000 9y agoYour inclusion of a city residential area is problematic. Selling water at the price it is actually worth would increase the price of necessities for humans. Differential billing by amount consumed is already a thing. Use restrictions are a stop-gap measure to conserve water when you wouldn't trigger the higher price due to high consumption. Our water security solution should not stop us from growing food. Increasing the price of water used for drinking, washing, and bathing is the outcome we want here.
- pas 9y agoNo, we want water efficiency. Agriculture has access to cheap water, thus no incentive (nor the economic ability to invest for equipment) to conserve it. If they would get water at the normal price, their goods would all increase in price, but from a higher price with the same profit margin they'll be able to save for water saving technologies, which will allow them to increase their margin further (or offer lower prices - as eventually everyone will invest in water conservation methods). And then cities will have more water and food will cost a bit more.
- jimmywanger 9y agoYou subsidize one way or another. Farmers are land rich and cash poor. You can subsidize them for their water, or capital investments, or you can not get food. Domestic food security is a national security issue.
- jimmywanger 9y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Water-Knife-Paolo-Bacigalupi-ebook/dp/B00NRQOR26/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1512973178&sr=8-1&keywords=water+knife https://www.amazon.com/Water-Knife-Paolo-Bacigalupi-ebook/dp... Eerily relevant.
- spodek 9y agoDozens of high-tech and massive public works solutions. None address the root problem: population growth. Globally, not just in China. Everyone will knee-jerk respond about their one-child policy. It doesn't change that population growth is the root problem and all the other solutions only enable more population. The article doesn't even suggest the possibility of lowering the birth rate. It's long past time we put the topic back into civil discourse.
- lancebeet 9y agoThe fertility rate in China is currently 1.57, well below the replacement fertility rate of 2.1. In fact, fertility rates are below replacement rates or rapidly declining nearly everywhere, even in places like India where the fertility rate will almost certainly reach sub-replacement levels in a decade. Africa is the only region that doesn't show this pattern.
- sremani 9y agoNo, population growth is not the biggest problem for China, the median age of China is about 38 years old, their growth has already petered out. The population growth problem is right now mostly Africa and South Asia. China already has less than replacement ration (2.1) child births, what do you want ? People to not have children?
- pixl97 9y ago>what do you want ? People to not have children? If you believe that areas have already overshot their carrying capacity. Then yes.
- spodek 9y agoThe issue is not what I want. The issue is that there is not enough water per person. Efficiency gains and technology will help with the numerator somewhat, though probably swamped by increased material consumption. We can talk about the denominator or not, but we probably can't do anything about it if we don't.