5 ms·
> I don't believe the evidence is on your side. Interesting. I can find a lot of studies on pubmed with dietary restriction comparisons. While I am not a docto
by KirinDave 16y ago
> I don't believe the evidence is on your side.
Interesting. I can find a lot of studies on pubmed with dietary restriction comparisons. While I am not a doctor, I'm familiar enough with scientific and academic literature to read papers and work through them. I think you probably can to, so here are a lot of links:
1. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679559 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679559 (No difference with carb restrictions vs. fat restrictions)
2. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20663066 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20663066 (Inconsistent results on carb restriction.)
3. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20670466 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20670466 (Medium-term suggests low-fat diets are superior to low-carb diets in obese individuals due to complications).
4. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20571327 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20571327 (Obesity treatment is a maintenance treatment, not a triage)
And the final nail I will hammer in your statement today:
5. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20670466 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20670466
The conclusion to this paper is quite germane:
Ad lib, low fat, high carbohydrate diet was superior to fixed energy intake
for maintaining weight after a major weight loss. The rate of the initial
weight loss did not influence long term outcome.
It's important to understand that linking to a book or a single doctor's blog is not going to be good evidence. These studies are what good evidence is, because they are evidence instead of hearsay and anecdotes. And please note the dates on these studies, they are not old.
- rubashov 16y agoFrom quickly scanning through those studies I don't think any one of them actually looked at a high fat, low carbohydrate diet. The so-called high fat diet was ~40% calories from fat, and they never defined what kind of fat (soybean oil, known to exacerbate obesity?). That necessarily means it was mostly a carbohydrate diet. Another of the so-called low carb diets is about "low glycemic index vegetables" with a weekly increase in carb serving. One of the studies is about MUFA. Nobody is advocating a high MUFA diet. The key is saturated fat. These links don't add much to the discussion. GCBC rigorously breaks down the entire body of research. It was the product of years of careful review. I suggest you read it.
- KirinDave 16y agoThey do add to the discussion because they are real data, not anecdote or speculation. And I'm a fan of the book you are referencing. Especially when big studies like #5 contradict some of the things you claim are from that book.
- briancooley 16y ago1. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679559 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679559 (No difference with carb restrictions vs. fat restrictions) No difference? "A low-carbohydrate diet, which consisted of limited carbohydrate intake (20 g/d for 3 months) in the form of low-glycemic index vegetables with unrestricted consumption of fat and protein." (emphasis mine) "During the first 6 months, the low-carbohydrate diet group had greater reductions in diastolic blood pressure, triglyceride levels, and very-low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels, lesser reductions in low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels, and more adverse symptoms than did the low-fat diet group. The low-carbohydrate diet group had greater increases in high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels at all time points, approximating a 23% increase at 2 years." That's a pretty big difference if you ask me. The low-carb group was not calorie-restricted. The low-carb group had more positive changes in the most important heart disease indicators (VLDL and HDL). Notably, the HDL increase is very important.
- KirinDave 16y agoI meant within the context of weight loss and long term results. I did not mean to imply there are no differences, and I welcome a clarification there. And even if I did read a few of them wrong, I'm fine with that. I want people to talk in terms of evidence and fact, not "this very smart doctor's blog" or "this book hawking yet another clever secret diet". That's of far more value to the news.ycomb community, and if it costs me a few bruises to my ego, so be it. These studies are accessible and readable, let's use them.
- rubashov 16y agoUnfortunately, simple citations aren't really a way to keep things tied to fact. Most studies are garbage. It really takes a book or two to lay out a case.
- KirinDave 16y agoI tried to select large studies from journals with good indexes. Please give examples of why these studies are bad. In particular the last one i cited, as that seemed quite large and the methodology seems sound.
- msluyter 16y agoI'm not sure these studies support your case. I didn't bother to read all of them, but for example, according to the first one: During the first 6 months, the low-carbohydrate diet group had greater reductions in diastolic blood pressure, triglyceride levels, and very-low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels, lesser reductions in low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels, and more adverse symptoms than did the low-fat diet group. The low-carbohydrate diet group had greater increases in high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels at all time points, approximating a 23% increase at 2 years. Limitation: Intensive behavioral treatment was provided, patients with dyslipidemia and diabetes were excluded, and attrition at 2 years was high. Conclusion: Successful weight loss can be achieved with either a low-fat or low-carbohydrate diet when coupled with behavioral treatment. A low-carbohydrate diet is associated with favorable changes in cardiovascular disease risk factors at 2 years. Not sure what they mean by "adverse symptoms," but generally I read that as: low carb is better for your heart. By all means, don't trust my personal anecdote or what Dr. Davis has to say on the matter (though I do recommend reading through his blog, as he does stay abreast of the literature and often refers to new studies, and he does have tons of empirical evidence via his patients.) Trust really isn't required, when it's easy enough to run your own experiments: simply eliminate wheat/grains/potatoes/juice/etc... for a few months and see what happens. (If you do this, do a lipid profile before and after.) If, like me, your LDL cholesterol drops dramatically and you lose 20-30 pounds, then that's the evidence that really matters.