9 ms·
> I would like to think that such explanations aren't always necessary, so long as a computer simulation of the simpler (and well understood) elements can repro
by pdonis 9y ago
> I would like to think that such explanations aren't always necessary, so long as a computer simulation of the simpler (and well understood) elements can reproduce the emergent behavior.
But that just switches the limit to the limit of our computing power. Which is a pretty strict limit. For example, we can't construct computer models to predict the properties of all the elements in the periodic table just from knowledge of the underlying laws of electrons, protons, and neutrons.
- worldsayshi 9y ago> we can't construct computer models to predict the properties [...] from knowledge of the underlying laws Hmm, or can we? This gave me the idea of trying to extract "emergent laws" using machine learning. There should be a way to build an AI that tries to find rules that approximate behaviour of complex systems. I'm sure there's lots of work on this already.
- pdonis 9y ago*> This gave me the idea of trying to extract "emergent laws" using machine learning. This is not what I was talking about. I was talking about a case where we know the underlying laws (the electromagnetic and strong interactions), but the computer models that we would construct from those laws would take more time than the age of the universe to run on our current computers and give us useful output. Using computers to try and infer underlying laws, not currently known to us, from data is a different thing, and I believe there is indeed ongoing work in this area.
- worldsayshi 9y agoBut my point being that if we can construct approximations on top of underlying laws that are cheaper to run, then the outcomes of any complex model could be approximated.
- hliyan 9y agoI think we can, if we get to the layers below those particles. i.e. if we develop full mathematical descriptions of quarks and electrons, and the behavior of the four fundamental forces (strong, weak, electromagnetic and gravity), I think a computer simulation will be able to predict the macroscopic properties of any element.
- naasking 9y ago> For example, we can't construct computer models to predict the properties of all the elements in the periodic table just from knowledge of the underlying laws of electrons, protons, and neutrons Yet. And the upper bounds on available computing are not actually known. Well, not strictly true, as arguments like the Bekenstein Bound suggest that information density that gets too high will collapse into a black hole. But typically, computing properties with precision involves exploiting symmetries and other properties to eliminate impossible cases from consideration and enjoy a shortcut to the answer.