4 ms·
Allow me to make a farfetched analogy: Bitcoin is like Obamacare. Obamacare wasn't made perfect the first time; this is normal. The way you fix issues with co
by rossdavidh 9y ago
Allow me to make a farfetched analogy: Bitcoin is like Obamacare. Obamacare wasn't made perfect the first time; this is normal. The way you fix issues with complex legislation, is you have it passed by significant members of both parties, so that you can revisit it the next year and fix things. But, with no trust between parties, the Dems had to get everything right in one go, when they had both houses and the White House, and guess what, there were problems. Which we can't fix.
Bitcoin wasn't made perfect the first time. No problem, all software that becomes popular does, and all new financial arrangements (money, credit, credit cards, etc.) had unforeseen problems that had to get worked out. But, with no government involved, there is no mechanism for working things out. It's not surprising that everything wasn't perfect, or that things need fixing later; the issue is that no one has the mandate to do it.
- MBCook 9y agoThe problem I see with that analogy is that Obamacare has been actively undermined at every step by the Tepublican party. Nothing like that is happening to Bitcoin. I think this was all inevitable. How could you make a new currency and not expect all the people who take advantage of monetary systems to move in? I’m not sure it’s preventable.
- zbentley 9y agoI think the undermining of Bitcoin's original promise by speculators is just as inevitable as Obamacare's undermining by conservatives. Both are driven by hype. Both are primarily driven by greed ("temporarily embarrassed millionaire" greed, in many cases). Both are aspirational. Both run counter to the cynical "humans will always subvert" narratives of their times. That's not a judgement on either one. Just an observation of similarities. They're very different in many ways, too.
- MBCook 9y agoWhat I meant about undermining is that I don’t think the speculators are out to sabotage bitcoin, it’s a side effect of what they’re doing. When it comes to Obamacare it’s very clear that the sabotage is intentional. The more I think about it the more I wonder if bitcoin could have ever worked. The way my name works pretty much guarantees a individual or small group would end up with the majority of the hash power if bitcoin was ever actually valuable. And that immediately undermines the peer-to-peer decentralized no one in charge of it aspect. Without something that disincentiveses people with significantly more cpu power people are just going to run away with it. That kind of seems like a flaw in all of these crypto currencies, even if it’s not CPU power that you use.
- netsharc 9y agoI think I read this too much from people saying bitcoin will work... "sure it sucks now, but it will have all the features you want in the future!", and hah, as you say, but no one is actually working on those features, and indeed 100 people probably have 100 different wishes and if they're a bitcoin-belieber they think bitcoin will get all those wishes. Just like how Trump will make America great again, with "great" being defined differently in around 63 million heads.