10 ms·
Emergency rooms are monopolies
- firefoxd 9y agoIdea: yelp for hospitals. With list all prices and fees. Not that this will solve the problem but it's better than finding out you owe $3k a week later.
- BrainInAJar 9y agoBetter idea: single payer healthcare
- elicash 9y agoRelevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tct38KwROdw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tct38KwROdw The "existing legislation and regulation" section is pretty interesting for wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chargemaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chargemaster
- dqv 9y agoThat's really cool. I think of California as "legislation heavy" - sometimes that carries a negative connotation. But in this case, it's positive. The hospitals really do have to post their chargemasters online! https://www.oshpd.ca.gov/Chargemaster/default.aspx https://www.oshpd.ca.gov/Chargemaster/default.aspx
- wyldfire 9y agoI like the concept in general but it's infeasible here in the US for a third party to survey prices and post results. Insurance plans renegotiate individual prices with providers, and each plan decides on coverage. The only way it could change would be if providers (and insurers) were to do it on their own, but they have no motivation to do so. I think only regulation or a seriously disruptive/innovative competitive force could do this.
- tedunangst 9y agoHospitals should be required to post price sheets. If they take a dozen insurance plans with negotiated prices, then they post a dozen price lists. There's no way this should be secret.
- refurb 9y agoThey already do, they are called chargemasters. However, they don't post the negotiated price lists since they have hundreds of contracts and thus hundreds of lists.
- hathawsh 9y agoCheck this out: https://www.oshpd.ca.gov/chargemaster/default.aspx https://www.oshpd.ca.gov/chargemaster/default.aspx You can download chargemasters for many (most?) California hospitals, over the past 10 years, in Excel format. I downloaded one sample and it has a list of 3700 prices, some of which are as high as $84,000. I'm really happy to discover this resource exists, but is anyone republishing the prices in a format consumers can work with? These sheets need UX design.
- smacktoward 9y agoIf you seriously require the services of an ER, you're not going to be in a position where you want to spend time comparison shopping.
- HappyKasper 9y agoThe insured pay the price. Hospitals will never turn away a patient with a medical emergency - the inability of certain patients to pay is factored into hospital finances, raising the price for those who do pay.
- sxates 9y agoThose who can't pay don't get their care for free. They'll be hounded by debt collectors the rest of their life, whatever credit they had will be trashed, and some will be pushed into bankruptcy. We are all paying for it.
- Danihan 9y agoNot when they just lie about their identity.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI don't see why you're getting down-voted. If you've got "bad" insurance that fake ID from college and memorizing 12 random digits is probably more useful when it comes to emergency care. Sad but true.
- watwut 9y agoIt has zero to do with problems of people who don't lie. None at all. And mojority don't. It amounts to "situation is ok, because I can point to some fraudster that is not suffering". What exactly that has to do with someone being haunted for debt? Or is he suggesting you should fraud ER and you are suckers if you don't?
- praneshp 9y agoI wish I could upvote you twice to help with the other downvotes. I know of at least 3 cases so far where folks walk into ER and lie about who they are when they leave. All of the cases are because of no health insurance, but they aren't hounded by any debt collectors.
- mbroshi 9y agoIn order to open a new hospital in most jurisdictions, by law you need the permission of other local hospitals [0]. That's like being required to get the permission from Google to start a new search engine. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_of_need https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_of_need
- limeblack 9y agoMy father is an executive at a major hospital and this is only part of it. There is also issues of brands forming monopolies when appearing in communities. Mergers are also incredibly complex. Also lots (but not all hospitals) are nonprofits which complicates it further. ERs are required to treat patients if they come in which means some are making tons of money while some not at all. One person can significantly alter ERs profits[0]. [0] https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/the-12m-patient-that-drove-insurance-rates-higher-in-iowa.html https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/the-12m-patien...
- FireBeyond 9y agoIs very insightful to read those comments. So many people who, faced with socialized medicine, screamed "DEATH PANELS!"... See premiums rising and all of a sudden, "We need to consider letting this person die a noble death." It's like a paradigm shifting, without a clutch.
- Shivetya 9y agohowever this issue like the costs of health care are exaggerated by local and federal government rules. when you prevent competition, when you force coverage regardless of need, and you lock out more options, costs only go one direction. just like tax laws, medical laws and implementation are done to favor specific groups to the detriment of others unfortunately
- raquo 9y ago> force coverage regardless of need This is like, the main way to make insurance affordable. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/adverseselection.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/adverseselection.asp
- pimmen 9y agoWe pay a far lesser portion of our GDP in Europe for health care and we have a longer life expectancy, higher chance of survival for the majority of cancer and cardiovascular diseases. It’s not that hard to understand; you try to control market forces when you’re talking about inelastic demand because that kind of demand is an opportunity for serious abuse. Isn’t that the reason the US has its war on drugs? Yet it can’t see this more expensive and deadlier problem?
- rukittenme 9y agoGasoline is an inelastic good but its price is relatively low and affordable because of the abundance of suppliers. In the US, local monopolies provide health care.
- dv_dt 9y agoGas inelastic as a good, but gas vendors are easily substitutable with low friction. The vendor you get gas from one week doesn't need to be the same as the next. And that transaction, the purchase of gas is completely interchangeable and identical from one week to the next. Medicare care in general does not have any of those characteristics (except for maybe annual checkups - but that's not where the bulk of medical costs are in our system). That has to do with the nature of the product and how it must be delivered, not necessarily with any monopoly effect. Even with a checkup, if you go to a different doctor every time that would reduce the effectiveness of the care.
- eesmith 9y agoHow is that relevant? In many European countries, gasoline taxes are quite high. Wikipedia's "Fuel tax" page says that in 2014 Germans paid US$6.14 per US gallon of gasoline. Yet there is also an abundance of suppliers in Germany. The hospitals in many European countries are publicly owned and operated. Quoting Wikipedia's "Healthcare in Denmark" page, "The central government plays a relatively limited role in health care in Denmark ... Hospital care is mainly provided by hospitals owned and run by the regions." There are five such regions. Aren't there, using your argument, also five local monopolies in Denmark? But the situation in Denmark is nothing like the US.
- dv_dt 9y agoFor costs: medical service + profit + profit accounting overhead + cost shifting overhead > medical services There was a period in time where there were very high losses in emergency rooms because there are legal obligations for conferring care in that setting. Many emergency rooms were getting closed down and that's also a big problem for communities. So it's in a way understandable (not necessarily excusable), because some of this I would infer is cost shifting to meet those obligations. Maybe it's shifted to too much profit now. Both sides of the problem, IMHO come from completely disconnected cost/profit transaction loops in America's healthcare. It's one big reason why single payer systems cost so much less. There is a much more straightforward relation between costs, care, and budgets in those systems so you can actually manage the direct problems instead of managing multiple red-tape layers each trying to competitively maximize, minimize different areas.
- wahsd 9y agoSorry, but "single payer systems" "cost so much less" because they externalize and obscure and obfuscate the costs in many different ways and the whole accounting of the system is totally inaccurate. You are also trying to compare an American system agains single payer systems that are made up of generally healthy people. There is simply no easy way to determine how the single payer systems would deal with things like the huge black obesity rates and accompanying diabetes and dialysis and associated complications. And that doesn't even address the fact that, of course single payer systems "cost so much less" when the government sets the qualifications for care AND the government further obscures the true cost by heavily subsidizing it with tax money that is involuntarily taken from lip service citizens. I find it rather baffling that ostensibly intelligent people simply cannot seem to wrap their minds around the fact that the true costs of single payer systems are not at all easily detectable. And that doesn't even go into the far greater issue of the authoritarian nature of single payer systems where you are forced to not only pay for something, but you don't even have control over it.
- bluGill 9y agoWe are talking about ER rooms here: people who need ER services are not in a position to do any sort of shopping around. When seconds count you cannot afford the minutes needed to get to the next ER. In theory it is possible that one is significantly better and so it would be worth the time, but in practice all the ERs in any given area are going to be not very different in ability to provide care. Even if the closer ER transfers you to the other getting to the first in time started care sooner.
- oftenwrong 9y agoIf you are interested in the various failures of the American health care system, I recommend reading Catastrophic Care by David Goldhill. It's a bit depressing, but eye-opening.
- ohazi 9y agoIt's not a monopoly, it's a cartel. There are a dozen hospital networks near me, but they all have opaque pricing and billing, so they all charge like this. You can try to regulate these facility fees, or force them to be made public, but as it stands there's no reason for them to go anywhere but up, indefinitely.
- scythe 9y agoEMTALA is also a huge welfare cliff. Let's say Antius and Grasshoppedon both work at McDonald's. In accordance with the wisdom of the prophets, Antius saves 20% of his paycheck every month (somehow) eventually accruing... oh, say, $9001 in savings, or way more than the average US household. Grasshoppedon spends all his money, because that's how the fable goes. One day they're both injured in a workplace accident and rack up a $25000 medical bill. Antius's savings are wiped out, he goes bankrupt, no credit for seven years, etc; Grasshoppedon meets exactly the same fate as Antius, i.e., Antius's fiscal prudence amounts to diddly-squat. And then economists wonder why the savings rate is so low.
- athenot 9y agoAt night the ED is the only place open. I believe there should be 24/7 Urgent Care centers, where people like the person in the opening of this article could go and receive care that (1) is not life-threatening but (2) can't wait till dawn. However, in the mean time there are ways to help. 1. If you don't already have one, get a Primary Care Physician. Go for a wellness visit, get their practice to know you. Then if something like that happens at 1am, you can call the office, leave a message and get a callback from a nurse within 15-30m who can help you through your options and help with over-the-counter options to make it through the night until the office opens (or until urgent care opens). Or of course they can counsel you to go to the ED if they think there's a risk. But the point is, you can already weed out some unnecessary ED visits that way. Note: not all providers have that service, so it's best to enquire when selecting a physician. 2. Many insurers have a nurses hotline but few people know about it. Check your policy. In the same way, they can help triage your situation, though it's less ideal since they don't know your medical record so they will tend to play it safer (ie. higher likelihood to send you to the ED). But it's better than nothing. 3. If the issue is pain management, you can also try your neighborhood 24/7 pharmacist. They can't diagnose you but again they might have tips to help you through the night until you can get proper care.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe only way to get widespread 24 hour urgent care in the US is to make it a billing code in the emergency room. There's often already 24 hour urgent care available in major urban centers. Of course, this raises the question. Why isn't urgent care a billing code in small emergency departments?
- staticautomatic 9y agoIs that a rhetorical question?
- FireBeyond 9y agoPushback lobbying from healthcare companies and the American College of Emergency Physicians, to be blunt.
- 9y ago
- quickben 9y agoI'm amazed at the stupidity permeating this thread ( and wiling to burn karma to defend against it). A random guy wakes up at 1am with a cramped muscle. Goes to facility that is equipped to deal with anything. On the spot surgeries, ability to break teeth safely to intubate and keep alive, drugs, cabinets with up to date equipment. Staffed with non-expired drugs that are regularly recycled. Staffed with people that can use all that round the clock, multiple backups. Staffed with people that keep the place reasonably sterile and safe. Staffed with all others to support an operation like that and expecting to get sued if it fails even a bit. And then complains, he had to pitch in for all that. An engineer, most likely earning above 8k usd, had to give a weekly salary for something that he considered worth dragging his butt out of bed at 1 am. The guy is delusional. The US health care is, on the expensive side, and can be better, but nobody can argue it without taking into account all that goes into maintaining that, just so one can randomly walk inside with a spasm, or after a huge carcrash with 40 broken bones, and liters of blood lost, and probably stay alive. I'm also amazed how most people here just ignore the reality of the scope of the overall operation, and claim that for a limited use case, it's too expensive. I'm not even going to insert a car analogy here. If you can't see why health care by nature is socialized and a utilitarian model, I'm not going to argue with people from USA thinking that everything should be proportional to the service and their pocket. Man up. You are not the center of the universe. This civilization was built for you, by people, and no matter if you like it or not, you will pay to maintain it for the people coming after you. Humanity, is a social concept worth defending.
- peterwwillis 9y agoDid you know that in the rest of the developed world, what you described is considered absolutely insane, and never happens? Not the people going to hospital thing - that happens all the time. It's just that nobody is ever charged thousands of dollars for it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jfnixon 9y agoSure they pay for it. It is called taxes, and it does come to thousands of dollars.
- peterwwillis 9y agoOne of the ways consumers can push back on this is by becoming educated on health care practice. I would never have let a hospital give me a CT scan for a simple throat problem. Then there are other issues that (supposedly) you have no control over. When I was hit on my bike, I refused the trip in the ambulance to a hospital. But when I got worse just an hour later, I ordered a taxi to go to an urgent care clinic. The clinic said I needed to be treated at a hospital, and then insisted that they would not let me leave except in an ambulance - which I then had to pay for. Another thing that's stupid: apparently you have to pay for your ambulance ride in Pinellas County, Florida, but you never have to pay for your ride in Montgomery County, Maryland. The reason you don't have to pay in Montgomery County? The state forced the county to shoulder tens of millions of dollars in teaching funds, and they had to come up with the money - so they made a law that county EMS could directly bill insurers, and this money goes directly to the county.
- davidcbc 9y ago> One of the ways consumers can push back on this is by becoming educated on health care practice. I would never have let a hospital give me a CT scan for a simple throat problem. The average person doesn't have time to become enough of a medical expert to second guess their doctors about everything.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> and then insisted that they would not let me leave except in an ambulance - which I then had to pay for. As an EMS provider, that is against the law. As long as you can show competence and comprehension, you are entitled (as you did with the ambulance in the first place) to refuse care, or any part of it ("You can dress my wounds, but not transport me"). They may wish to document your refusal AMA ("Against Medical Advice") for their liability / stave off abandonment claims, but "refusing to let you leave" is akin to kidnapping, no different to if anyone else had done it. (Psych holds and such in my area require Law Enforcement involvement, even on scene, as they are the only people authorized to actually 'enforce' the involuntary transport/hold laws, though it's with our recommendation).
- panic 9y agoIf you live in California, consider writing or calling your State Assemblymember in support of the Healthy California Act (http://www.healthycaliforniaact.org http://www.healthycaliforniaact.org), which is stuck in the State Assembly right now. It would establish a single payer system for the state and let people get emergency care without these outrageous bills.
- refurb 9y agoWasn't that tried before and the estimated cost was more than the entire State of California budget? The chance of that bill ever going anywhere is effectively zero.
- epmaybe 9y agoI think I'd be in favor of introducing a public option and seeing how it competes with other commercial insurance options. Going completely single payer seems very risky, and could upset a large percentage of californians due to the subsequently necessary rise in taxes.
- redblacktree 9y agoI wonder just how big those increases would be though. I've seen several informal surveys of my Facebook friends with respect to the cost of their health insurance, and numbers range from $400-$1200/mo. And keep in mind that many of these are subsidized by their employer. That seems like a lot of money that could be taxed. (i.e. you'd pay the tax instead of a health insurance premium)
- epmaybe 9y agoThe rational thought process is that yes, tax what would have been spent on health insurance premiums. However, in practice I'm not so certain that it would interpreted as such by taxpayers.
- dv_dt 9y agoThe problem there (but not necessarily a show stopping problem), is that private insurance could then pick out and kick out groups of customers according to profitability. The public option would likely end up picking up the most costly cases.
- DoodleBuggy 9y agoPutting aside the often absurd costs for a moment... Many ERs are also severely overburdened, understaffed, and overcrowded often with very high ratios of non-emergency patients to emergency patients. This creates huge wait times for patients and puts significant stress on medical staff. Talk to your friends, family, coworkers, almost everyone has a bad story to share, whether about absurd wait times, wild costs, billing screw-ups, insurance debacles... And talk to your doctors and nurses too, they are just as frustrated.
- dsr_ 9y agoThey're overcrowded because they are the only health care available for a large number of people. There's only one way forward which will work, although there are lots of different ways to do it: universal healthcare.
- gbacon 9y agoInvigorating the malady is not the cure.
- MrFantastic 9y agoI never hear the Healthcare Insurance companies complaining. I guess they are too busy skimming off the top and weighing their profits.
- mywittyname 9y agoERs are one of the few places where hospitals actually earn a profit. My partner fights on behalf of hospitals when insurance companies deny a claim. And over the past years, insurance companies have taken to denying valid claims just to get out of paying. An egregious example being a patient that needed heart surgery and the insurance company deemed it medically unnecessary because they claim he should have been observation only. Claims denial departments are exploding, they used to be 4-8 person teams for a major hospital five years ago. Today my partner has 32 direct employees at a much smaller, regional hospital. Hospitals have come to the realization that it's basically impossible for insurance companies to deny ER claims. After all, the patient came in with an "emergency."
- FireBeyond 9y ago> An egregious example being a patient that needed heart surgery and the insurance company deemed it medically unnecessary because they claim he should have been observation only. United Healthcare got in hot water for denying coverage for airlift EMS for MVA victims saying that the "trip wasn't preauthorized with the insurer"...
- moonbug22 9y agoToday's instalment of how America's healthcare is a trainwreck.
- trgv 9y agoSomething I've noticed are advertisements for ERs. Really. I was a little shocked when I saw one on the way to work. It says: "Trouble breathing? Nausea and fever? Stomach pain? Our ER can help." "What's your body telling you? Any one of these symptoms could be a warning sign of something serious. Our emergency room offers fast, expert care 24/7 to keep you healthy." I had never really thought of hospitals, especially ERs, as a business before I saw that. I guess that was naive.
- selimthegrim 9y agoI saw a lot of these in Houston for some reason.
- tlb 9y agoIt's a mystery why hospitals are still considered worthy recipients of large gifts. People donate tens of millions of dollars for a hospital building, inside which the hospital proceeds to rapaciously overcharge its patients. It's true that most hospitals themselves are non-profits, but the service providers in the hospital range from moderate capitalists to very predatory ones. Donating to the hospital just means they charge less overhead, and the medical corporations operating within them keep more. Doctors are great and all, but I don't feel like they need my charity.
- spott 9y agoAnyone have any good data on the profitability of hospitals? I've always gotten the feeling that they are generally not making a whole lot of money, but I don't have much data to back it up. Is this kind of data even public? You can construct a narrative for a bunch of different situations for Hospitals: * High ER costs in order to offset the large number of people who just can't pay, but need to be treated anyways. * High costs in order to deal with all the regulatory requirements on Hospitals (it seems everything is regulated in a hospital, down to the kind of TP in the bathrooms). * High costs because hospitals have local monopolies and can screw patients. * etc. I don't have enough data to figure out which one of these is the "right" version of the facts. Does anyone else?