17 ms·
Goldman Sachs Plans to Clear Bitcoin Futures When They Go Live
- sam111 9y agohigh risk, high return!! LoL!!
- sam111 9y agohttps://us.teamblind.com/article/bitcoin-at-14k-mOXX5B6L https://us.teamblind.com/article/bitcoin-at-14k-mOXX5B6L $14k!
- baldgeek 9y agoThe bigger it grows the harder it will fall. The design/implementation of bitcoin as a currency is severely flawed. Projects like Ethereum, Hyperledger, and IOTA have a more long term focus. Full Disclosure: I have no positions in any crypto but have been reading a lot. Also, in the midst of two courses that go that cover crytpocurrencies and blockchain tech. 1. https://www.coursera.org/learn/cryptocurrency https://www.coursera.org/learn/cryptocurrency 2. https://www.edx.org/course/blockchain-business-introduction-linuxfoundationx-lfs171x https://www.edx.org/course/blockchain-business-introduction-... #1 gives a very good history of what a blockchain is, and how is implemented by bitcoin. This is enough to keep me away since I have learned about all the technical flaws: #2 discusses blockchains, and consensus algorithms. This project shows lots of promise. They just added code that allows the consensus algorithm to actually be changed via a transaction, without a hard fork. Bitcoin gets all the credit for introducing the world to the blockchain concept, but its far from a sound solution as a cryptocurrency.
- sp821543 9y agoYou should take a look at IOTA's github repo.
- baldgeek 9y agoI plan to. The blockchain is here to stay no doubt. and I skimmed over the IOTA whitepaper, definitely very interesting
- CryptoPunk 9y agoI agree that Bitcoin is extremely risky, but I've looked at IOTA, and it's an utter nonsense project. It's centralized, because the tangle security model it purports to use doesn't work, and its developers have pulled antics like explaining away a flaw in the client code by claiming it was put there intentionally to thwart copycats, and claiming a "partnership" with a company after IOTA used that company's software. Hyperledger meanwhile is not a distributed cryptocurrency project. It's software for building consortium blockchains, meaning blockchains run by trusted third parties. I agree with you on Ethereum. It's now processing more transactions than all other decentralized blockchains combined, including Bitcoin.
- coryl 9y agoI suspect the investment banks that say they're going to stay away will quickly get FOMO and jump in sooner rather than later. Crypto is always in the headlines and will constantly occupy the headspace of trader's colleagues and peers, so it's just human nature that they will not be able to resist having a taste.
- jerkstate 9y agowow, these guys seem even shiftier than usual, trying to deflect whether or not they have a bitcoin strategy..
- ucaetano 9y agoOh, they have a bitcoin strategy: making money out of the fools trading it.
- tCfD 9y agobitcoiners in 2012: "Bitcoin will eliminate the wall street banksters!" Bitcoiners right now: "OMG Goldman is getting in, who's ready for their moon rocket?"
- mirimir 9y agoExpectations are rather more mixed than that.[0] Sure, the price could spike even higher after futures go on sale. But volatility will increase dramatically. And you can't count on exchanges, if the price collapses. 0) https://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-futures-make-way-new-kind-whale/ https://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-futures-make-way-new-kind-w...
- CryptoPunk 9y agoFutures markets reduce volatility.
- mirimir 9y agoAs I understand it, that's true only if there's a balance of buy-side and sell-side hedgers. Owners and miners are sell-side hedgers. Who are the buy-side hedgers?
- lbotos 9y agoCan you do an "Explain it like I'm 5" of this? I don't doubt you but I'm struggling to make the connection. Will futures affect the pricing of the underlying asset? (I don't think so?) I think you are saying "futures reduce volatility for the trader" but I'm not sure.
- cm2187 9y agoIt allows participants to short and therefore should allow more balanced flows. However one needs some pretty steel-made cojones to short a bubble....
- 9y ago
- curiousgal 9y agoI have been trading crypto for 5 years now and it is a wet dream for rogue traders. There was a myriad of stories about traders and even banks that tried to pull of some shady statretgy in the stocks markets that the SEC shut down, those same strategies seem to be fair game in the crypto world, you just have to have pockets that are deep enough. My point is that if you are smart and think you can beat or even keep up with the crypto market, you will end up losing because it’s been rigged for years.
- coryl 9y agoIf you are short term day trading you're likely to be a victim of pump and dump groups and manipulation. Going long on high market cap coins with a longer timeline is a relatively safer bet.
- curiousgal 9y agoThere are fees to any position you hold so even though going long is indeed the safe bet, having a longer timeline requires deep pockets.
- bonestamp2 9y agoYou can avoid the fees on some bitcoin exchanges if you're a market maker, and with the volatility that's pretty easy most days. I made a couple 0% fee trades today alone. But, the second part is definitely true... you still need deep pockets to hold a long position.
- coryl 9y agoBuy and hold doesn't have any recurring fees. If you look at the opportunity cost between crypto and any other financial security in the market, its an easy decision.
- mitchellberry 9y ago"Fees" I see the margin lending rates on some exchanges right now being 0.003% daily. This is for coins that move 10% a day. Probably fair to assume fees aren't what the traders lose sleep over.
- osrec 9y agoI wonder what Jamie Dimon thinks about this! Funnily enough, my sources tell me JP will be in on the futures contracts as well. What hypocrisy!
- workthrowaway27 9y agoIt's not really hypocrisy. There's money to made by clearing futures and some of the banks want that money. What's being traded doesn't really matter.
- osrec 9y agoMaybe, but then the things he said about his potential future clients are just downright hurtful: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/13/jamie-dimon-says-people-who-buy-bitcoin-are-stupid.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/13/jamie-dimon-says-people-who-...
- kough 9y ago> "The only value of bitcoin is what the other guy'll pay for it," Dimon said. "Honestly I think there's a good chance of the buyers out there are out there jazzing it up every day so that maybe you'll buy it too, and take them out." Is there any reason to consider this statement inaccurate?
- osrec 9y agoIt's accurate, but it's also accurate for almost every fund/structured security that many of JP's desks are peddling.
- cm2187 9y agoHe was talking about market making, not clearing. The bank doesn’t really take a principal risk on clearing. It does on market making.
- osrec 9y ago
- bogomipz 9y ago>"The decision to clear client trades will be made on a case-by-case basis, the person said." Could someone say what "clearing the trades" mean here?
- curiousgal 9y agoClearing the trades means both buying and selling.
- bogomipz 9y agoSo they are the market maker?
- workthrowaway27 9y agoNo, they just serve as a central point to match buyers and sellers so the buyers and sellers don't have to find each other themselves. They aren't making a market but they do get clearing fees.
- tedunangst 9y agoMore like match maker.
- cm2187 9y agoNo more like a broker. When you buy stocks through your broker, all the broker does is to pass on your order to the exchange, and to report when it was executed. The broker doesn’t take any risk, other than you not making a payment after you gave the buy order. If the broker was a market maker, he would keep an inventory of that stock and your order would be filled by the broker directly. Who would then report and clear the transaction on the exchange.
- vostok 9y agoClearing doesn't mean buying and selling. There's not really a great analogy, but the idea is that Goldman is on the hook if one of their customers can't maintain the margin/haircut.
- bcg1 9y agoThis should give the big Wall St banks the ability to muck with crypto prices however they choose, just like they can do with gold and silver and other commodities (for example, Goldman magically closed gold positions and sold short 2 days before historic 25% price drop in 2 trading days in 2013[0]) Hopefully people will read those contracts and understand how delivery actually works and realize that COMEX or whoever can halt delivery and settle in cash if they want to, etc. [0] - https://www.cnbc.com/id/100630626 https://www.cnbc.com/id/100630626
- vkou 9y ago> This should give the big Wall St banks the ability to muck with crypto prices however they choose, The current status quo is that large bitcoin holders can muck with crypto prices however they choose.
- partiallypro 9y agoFutures exchanges will have to buy large sums of underlying assets (one reason for the recent spike.) So, in the end a lot of exchanges will be some of the largest crypto holders.
- bjl 9y agoThe futures are cash settled, none of the futures exchanges need to own any bitcoin at all.
- rmah 9y agoThe currently proposed CME and CBOE futures are cash settled. No actual bitcoin is involved. Neither the buyers or sellers of the futures, nor any other entities involved, will need to buy/sell/hold any bitcoin.
- Havoc 9y agoKey part being that they'll let client's play that game. I don't see any enthusiasm from them to put their own money into futures layered on top of what looks decidedly bubbly.
- topmonk 9y agoBecause the best way to trade is to announce your intentions 2 weeks before you execute...
- teilo 9y ago> In fact, the Bloomberg system is a blockchain, just instead of having the users control it, we control it, but it has all the attributes of that. Thus proving that whatever he thinks about Bitcoin, Michael Bloomberg is clueless about the blockchain.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoActually they might be running a separate Blockchain to manage their side. Similar to https://github.com/jpmorganchase/quorum https://github.com/jpmorganchase/quorum which uses raft con sensus. He is being confusing though and you could be right so...
- stuffedBelly 9y agoThey are not running a separate Blockchain and equating their system with how Blockchain works is quite misleading. I work in finance and use Bloomberg's system daily. It's essentially an online data provider/analytics platform running in a terminal-like environment. I don't think they would sneak in a private Blockchain without clients knowing about it. Even if they would, what for?
- lifty 9y agoI wouldn't be surprised if someone in the IT department explained to him that they are using some kind of consensus based mechanism (zookeeper, etcd, consul etc), that works just like a blockchain, to manage the bloomberg infrastructure. He then goes on tv and tells the world that bloomberg is using The Blockchain. Just wild speculation but its seems plausible to me. Edit: a quick google lead me to Bloomberg's consul deployment cookbook: https://github.com/bloomberg/consul-cluster-cookbook/blob/master/README.md https://github.com/bloomberg/consul-cluster-cookbook/blob/ma...
- blueprint 9y agozookeeper, etcd, and/or consul function according to something only trivially different from Nakamoto Consensus? That would be news to me. His IT dept must have misinformed him.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoHas anyone discussed the future of forks with respect to futures? Or indeed to any cryptocurrency denominated debts. The easy case is: Alice owes Bob 1.0 BTC in year 2020. Between then and now, BTC forks into BTC and BTZ -- and so now Alice Owes bob 1.0 "new" BTC and zero BTZ. On net, does this mean that whatever fork retains the legal position of BTC is going to be in more demand than hypthetical BTZs? Given that, will it create a incentive for forkers to fight for legal recognition such that debts can be / have to be payed in their own currency. And if they do this with some success, what happens when instead of having a clear BTC/BTZ split, you have a BTC_forkA and BTC_forkB for paying debts in.
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoThat is indeed a hell of a problem. The only thing you could objectively do is to nominate the bitcoin client that you use in order to retrieve coins. That includes the version. "Alice pays Bob 1.0 in year 2020 using bitcoin core node client v0.15.2"
- partiallypro 9y agoAnother question (this is just my ignorance) but...if BTC has a fork, does that mean that the new fork has a new entire supply? I thought the "value" in BTC is that there is a limited supply and it can't be degraded like a fiat currency. If you can just keep forking...how is that not immeasurably increasing supply just like the ECB and Fed do?
- tlrobinson 9y agoNo, the forked coins and the original coins aren’t fungible. It’s more like me saying “show me your dollar bills at the time of the fork and I’ll give you an equivalent amount of Monopoly money”. It’s not going to be worth anything unless you somehow convince a bunch of other people it’s worth something, and even then it’s likely going to be worth far less than the original coins because fewer people will accept it and it will be easily attacked due to lack of hashing power.
- 9y ago
- Frogolocalypse 9y ago> “Given that this is a new product, as expected we are evaluating the specifications and risk attributes for the bitcoin futures contracts as part of our standard due diligence process,” How can you be diligent at identifying risks in bitcoin derivatives? O_o
- mrgordon 9y agoI bet Ethereum futures come within a year or so. Now that the banks are executing trades for one, it’s much easier to add more.
- gleenn 9y agoI have no idea if Bitcoin is going to succeed or fail, but if anyone thinks the second guy in the video has no idea what the block chain is because he mumbled "block-coin", you have been fooled. Who the hell is that "reporter"? When would the CEO come out and boast this is all a joke. Of course Goldman has an very keen understanding of what's going on. They are almost guaranteed to have a position on BTC one way or another and be goading people into buying it. That doesn't mean smart or lucky people won't be able to ride their wave up if they are successful, but to think Goldman is dumb as those two guys seem is completely ludicrous, its obviously an act.
- joyes 9y agohttps://www.aprexcoin.org/ https://www.aprexcoin.org/