5 ms·
As I look at how the US, China, Russia, and Japan run themselves and their economies; I start to think that the distinctions aren't what we think they are. The
by gwbas1c 9y ago
As I look at how the US, China, Russia, and Japan run themselves and their economies; I start to think that the distinctions aren't what we think they are. The life of a Japanese salaryman sounds like a communist distopia, even though Japan is fiercely capitalistic. China is a single-party "communist" state, but their economy looks and acts like capitalism.
- SauciestGNU 9y agoChina abandoned communism with Deng Xiaoping's reforms. They are fiercely capitalist, with strong authoritarian political structure.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAt different levels, right? There's still a party; they still run things. So at the local level its capitalist, but not at the city or federal planning level?
- SauciestGNU 9y agoIt's murky because they call themselves communist, but it's in name only. If anything I'd call it state capitalism, where the government is the biggest player in the market, but it's a market nonetheless.
- mistermann 9y agoWith benevolent and competent leaders, I believe this is the optimum approach, which is one of the main reasons China will be the undisputed global leader very soon. Obviously this requires ongoing benevolence and competency though.
- ameister14 9y agoWith benevolent and competent leadership, it's the most efficient approach. Unfortunately, benevolent and competent leadership has never lasted in the history of human civilization. Sooner or later, usually sooner, someone really nasty or incompetent takes over.
- AstralStorm 9y agoLike they did in the US therefore capitalism failed it? (No, I am not talking about current politics but economy.)
- ameister14 9y agoI don't really understand your question. I'm saying that if you concentrate power into one person's hands, it's awesome and efficient if that person is competent and benevolent. If he is not, it's really bad. Unfortunately, in the history of the world, there has been no government continuously run by benevolent and competent leaders. The US arguably concentrates too much power into the hands of a single person, but not nearly to the same extent as a centralized and managed economy does. This has nothing to do with capitalism.
- AstralStorm 9y agoNor does it have to do with communism. Specifically communism does not require nationalisation nor centralization of power. In fact the Marxist roots expect the workers to own and run the factories collectively and resolve conflicts by vote and consensus. The ideology called "communism" in the US is actually national socialism. Not to be mistaken with fascism, but close. (Yes, it is Nazism. Soviet ideology was actually identical.) Alleged soviet collectivism was actually nationalisation.
- ameister14 9y agoI wasn't talking about that, though - I was talking about State Capitalism and the efficiency of a concentration of power, responding to a person that said that was the optimal system.
- mistermann 9y agoPeople should be mindful of the sample size they're dealing with when making predictions based on the history of civilizations.
- baursak 9y agoHalf of China's economy are state-owned enterprises (SOEs). China is still way more centrally planned than people think, including good old Soviet-style 5-year plans. Most of strategically important industries have not been "liberalized". When compared to places like Venezuela, which people love to bring up as socialist disaster of sorts, but which has way more people employed in private enterprises than China, China looks more socialist by your standard mainstream definition of "socialism".
- api 9y agoChina is something new. It's capitalism without freedom and with a Soviet "politburo" type structure acting not as agency of the proletariat but as a hyper-Keynesian backstop to markets. Tangent but: I think this really killed Libertarianism. Libertarians and classical liberals from Adam Smith to Ayn Rand said this wasn't possible. Capitalism and freedom are inseparable, they said. China proves that Capitalism works perfectly well and in fact may work better under a more authoritarian system. Freedom is not required beyond a few degrees of freedom to act economically. The presence of a totalitarian ruler willing to constantly backstop markets prevents panics and actually makes the system work better. ... or seems to so far. History isn't over. China could crash.
- ameister14 9y ago>The presence of a totalitarian ruler willing to constantly backstop markets prevents panics and actually makes the system work better. Not really. Remember this? https://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonchang/2014/01/19/mega-default-in-china-scheduled-for-january-31/#628a39ec5e00 https://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonchang/2014/01/19/mega-def... If the government backs everything, people will engage in riskier behavior because they don't accurately assess risk. That creates a massive bubble of risky investments until it's too large for the government to effectively control. There's an interesting book on the subject you might want to check out: https://www.amazon.com/Chinas-Guaranteed-Bubble-government-propelled/dp/1259644588/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1511885714&sr=8-1&keywords=China%E2%80%99s+Guaranteed+Bubble%3A+How+Implicit+Government+Support+Has+Propelled+China%E2%80%99s+Economy+While+Creating+Systemic+Risk https://www.amazon.com/Chinas-Guaranteed-Bubble-government-p....
- api 9y agoI think you are right, but it hasn't happened yet. China keeps growing and developing with what seems to outside observers such unbelievable might that it's psyching people out. I think the rise of strong man rule and neo-fascist ideologies in the West and elsewhere is a reaction. "We need to become more totalitarian now or we will be left behind!" Bubbles always psych people out. They always go higher than anyone expects. They always make the nay-sayers look like fools... until they don't, and the nay-sayers end up looking like prophets. My brother in law lived and worked in China for about 10 years. He went from thinking China would conquer the world in the first few to thinking China is Enron.
- lucideer 9y agoJapan is an odd case, as what you describe seems to be culturally/socially enforced by tradition, &c. rather than directly and explicitly by a central power. Other than that though, are you talking about the distinction between totalitarianism and democracy? There has been a (imo very odd) tendency in the US to confuse Communism with totalitarianism and Capitalism with democracy (despite counter-examples like Chile), and I've seen same rhetoric in Eastern Europe (where Communism-branded totalitarianism is a recent experience) but this tendency isn't universal.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoexactly, mutually exclusive concepts many things about American society changed in the 50s to support this false dichotomy, primarily to draw a clearer distinction between communism, but most of them have nothing to do with anything related to the frameworks of nations, or any of the philosophical writings that underpinned these societal experiments.
- Bartweiss 9y agoFor this reason, I'm curious how much the headline change is a change in concrete goals versus a change in terminology. It feels like I know a lot of people who think "socialism is evil, and therefore we need a market economy made safe via government regulation and state control of essential services." And then I know a lot of other people who think "capitalism is evil, and therefore we need a market economy made safe via government regulation and..." At a certain point I just shrug and ignore the words; they often end up predicting more about team allegiances than what actual system someone wants to see established.