2 ms·
I really enjoy the string of responses your comment has elicited. People really like only being liable for the amount of money they put into something. Regardle
by sitkack 9y ago
I really enjoy the string of responses your comment has elicited. People really like only being liable for the amount of money they put into something. Regardless if the downsides of their actions end up costing more than the inputs.
- jacquesm 9y agoIndividual shareholders are not capable of meaningfully directing company action unless they act in aggregate and even then it would be very hard for individual stockholders to make this happen because of the low frequency with which shareholder meetings are held. Stockholders - especially those that originally bought company stock when it was issued - assume liability already, if the company goes under their stock is worthless, if the company is fined their dividends drop. To make them liable beyond that for something they themselves do not control in a way that would enable you to assign blame is excessive.
- sitkack 9y agoPeople would make more responsible choices if they were liable for the effect of their actions and not just what the corp could get away with. > their dividends drop Corporations are rarely fined even 100% of their profits from illegal actions. If the punishment is simply going to be temporary drop in returns, and that maximum damage inflicted upon a corporation and investor is dissolution, that dissolution should be wielded with a casual frequency. Corporations are benefiting from breaking the law. They get caught, and they still benefit. Many of these arguments center around 1) a drop in returns is punishment enough 2) it would be difficult. Both are simplistic pat answers that defend the corporation as a one-way valve for wealth that disintermediates the criminal from the crime. How is it that I am responsible for all of my actions, except when my action is a pooled investment? The ultimate question is can money only harm up to its denominal value?