7 ms·
I guess this sort of misses the main point, IMO. Sure, my taxes will go down, but I have grad student friends that may have to drop out because they now have t
by monocasa 9y ago
I guess this sort of misses the main point, IMO.
Sure, my taxes will go down, but I have grad student friends that may have to drop out because they now have to treat waived tuition as income, and pay ~10k tax on it somehow with their 20k-30k stipend they get. And I've got friends with kids that are going to see their tax burden go up by thousands.
Meanwhile with all of this 'simplification' and 'getting rid of subsidies', we're not doing the same for corporate or high income 'subsidies'.
- kthejoker2 9y agoWhat are you basing your contention that people with kids are going to see their taxes going up on? All evidence I've seen has them significantly expanding the child tax credit.
- koolba 9y agoMortgage interest, local property taxes, and state taxes deductions are the biggest high income subsidies.
- bradleyjg 9y agoThe biggest high income subsidy is the favorable treatment of investment income. That'll probably be supplanted in the new tax regime by the passthrough discount.
- xyzzyz 9y agoI have grad student friends that may have to drop out because they now have to treat waived tuition as income If this happens, this will be a huge failure on their institution part. The only reason their tax bill might be affected is due to creative accounting practices of universities, who use the tuition waiver as a way to skim more money from the grants. Universities will just start offering education for free instead of waiving the tuition, and will find a new accounting trick to take money from federal science grants in "overhead".
- learc83 9y agoMany institutions make a lot of money from charging foreign, and out of state grad students the full price for tuition. If they keep charging everyone else and make education free for employees, the tuition they would have paid becomes taxable income.
- bradleyjg 9y agoIf a university is charging tens of thousands of dollars to some students and waiving those charges for other students because of the work they are doing for the university then that's a value being provided in trade for work. Why shouldn't it be taxed? Contrariwise if no one is really paying these tens of thousands of dollars in tuition, with the university just eating the "tuition bill" in the case of e.g. an English grad student, then why should a grantor have to pay that tuition bill for a microbiologist grad student on top of her stipend? I get that this sucks for people caught up in it but I don't see a lot of stepping back and thinking about what makes sense.
- madengr 9y agoYep, I was down voted in another thread for pointing out the the same thing. 20 years ago, I had to pay tax on all my employer provided tuition assistance for graduate level classes. Even if my employer cuts a check directly to the university, it's still counted as my income. So why should it be any different for a university as the employer? This is just a loophole being closed. Just get rid of the damned "dissertation credits" and problem solved.
- privong 9y ago> If they keep charging everyone else and make education free for employees, the tuition they would have paid becomes taxable income. Is this really true though? Some universities charge in-state and out-of-state students different tuition rates, but the in-state students aren't liable for paying taxes on the difference between the tuition rates. It seems like those are just different degrees of the same thing so the same rules should apply. Perhaps the distinction is that the schools who differentiate between in-state and out-of-state students are state schools and thus play by slightly different rules?
- rayiner 9y agoThat’s whataboutism. And why should grad students get special treatment? Most other people making $20-30k (ones that aren’t privileged enough to be in grad school) will get a tax cut.
- Rotten194 9y agoWhat are you talking about? Lower class people are only able to afford grad school because of tuition waivers. By taxing them as income, only people who are able to pay out of pocket will have access to postsecondary degrees that grant higher incomes.
- rayiner 9y agoOnly a small minority of lower class people ever go to grad school. Overwhelmingly, it’s a tax break that benefits the kids of upper middle class and wealthy families.
- deong 9y agoI don't know that I'd say "overwhelmingly". I certainly wouldn't have been able to go to grad school under this system.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoDo you know what "overwhelmingly" means? Your anecdote about a single person (you) being able to or not being able to afford college doesn't mean anything. The other commenter's unsourced "overwhelmingly" claim is silly but so is yours.
- deong 9y agoThink of my comment as two separate statements. First, "overwhelmingly" is silly. Second, and more or less unrelated, it would have personally affected me. The second wasn't intended as support for the first.
- 9y ago
- hartator 9y agoAt the time, why a young person who is too poor to go to college and has to work should be taxed higher than a college student?
- subroutine 9y agoThis doesn't apply to all college students. This is specifically to PhD programs at each state's best research universities. The kind where we'd want our brightest students to attend, no matter what their financial situation. Currently, these students are paid a small salary to attend these programs ($20-$30k per year), and their tuition is waived. Under the new tax rules, the tuition waiver counts as income. So for example, a student at MIT who makes ~28k/yr is going to be taxed like they earn $80k/yr.
- hartator 9y agoIt seems an issue for the university side, why they can't make the price of their tuition zero?
- ecnahc515 9y agoThe universities prefer to give the discount because it let's them do stupid accounting tricks that let them get more money in grants and stuff. Universities should just adjust the tuition for these students instead of giving a discount.
- nshelly 9y agoBecause they want to receive the full $80k from the grant - often federal - and pay the student $25-30k. The right answer is to fix the accounting measures. For a PhD student primarily doing research which benefits the university and grantor, and taking no or few classes, why are they paying tuition? If it’s for facilities or university staff salaries, then just send the full grant to the university directly, and let the university pay the students whatever both parties see as fair.
- 9y ago
- conanbatt 9y agoYou can give your tax savings to your friends!
- OfficeOfStuff 9y agohttps://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/resources/faq/faq_publicdebt.htm#DebtFinance https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/resources/faq/faq_public... You can write a check payable to the Bureau of the Fiscal Service, and, in the memo section, notate that it's a gift to reduce the debt held by the public. Mail your check to: Attn Dept G Bureau of the Fiscal Service P. O. Box 2188 Parkersburg, WV 26106-2188
- Romanulus 9y agoAre you implying that college/university should be cheaper?
- txcwpalpha 9y agoThe senate bill does not have the change which counts tuition waivers as income, so at least on the senate side of the things, this site really isn't missing that.
- acchow 9y agoThis makes no sense. Of course the University has to waive the tuition fee to avoid their grad students leaving en masse. If they don't, then another University will offer waived tuition.
- grigjd3 9y agoYou have no idea just how expendable grad students are to universities.