19 ms·
Cinemark announces $8.99/mo. subscription to fill more seats, take on MoviePass
- sp332 9y agoThe more I think about MoviePass the less I like the model. In http://www.businessinsider.com/moviepass-business-model-2017-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/moviepass-business-model-2017... they say they're trying to offset high ticket prices in some places with lower ticket prices in other places. What kind of business model tries to shift money from places that have less to places that have more? Edit: had the last part backwards, d'oh
- gameshot911 9y ago>What kind of business model tries to shift money from places that have more to places that have less? The NFL and the (US) federal government come to mind.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- e1ven 9y agoI think their ideas about a business model are hogwash. Even in places where the movies are $6/month, they would need huge numbers of people to sign up, and use the service 0-1 times per month, month after month.. That doesn't seem realistic. Even with their new contract model, I don't see this working. I don't see how they could possibly survive without inventing a new revenue model. In the meantime, I'll keep enjoying my VC subsidized movies :)
- yalph 9y agoIsnt this the “communism” they are talking about all the time? Rich paying for the poor?
- sp332 9y agoDon't you have that backwards? They require people with lower ticket prices to pay the same amount as people with higher ticket prices. So the "poor" (or people the movie theaters think won't pay more money, anyway) are paying for the "rich".
- goialoq 9y agoAnother poster explained that their goal is to intermediate -- to get between moviegoers and movie theaters, and then charge theaters for access to moviegoers. This is how Google makes their AdWords money, for example, but the model is far older -- BBB, general contractors, etc. You may remember this concept from the net neutrality debate!
- rhino369 9y agoI just bought the year pass from them. I think the model is just going to fail. Right now they are the fabled "raising revenue by selling a dollar for 90 cents" start up that hopes to "make it up in volume." The only way it works is if people don't actually use it.
- firloop 9y agoSeems like this is the direction the industry is going, however the actual service here is much worse than MoviePass' (seemingly unsustainable) model. MoviePass is $9.95 for one movie per day. FTA: >...customers who pay a monthly fee of $8.99 will receive a credit for one movie ticket a month. Subscribers can also buy additional tickets for $8.99 each and get a 20% discount on food and drinks.
- ryandrake 9y agoThat doesn't sound like a subscription. That sounds like you're paying $8.99 for a ticket once a month. Why wouldn't you just buy an $8.99 ticket as-needed?
- icebraining 9y agoCan you get a $8.99 ticket without a subscription? These models (subscribe and get 1/month free) are not that uncommon - e.g. Audible. Usually you get a cheaper price, since you're more likely to keep paying and are therefore more profitable overall. Here even more, due to potential spending on concessions.
- ryandrake 9y agoFrom the article: "The average domestic ticket price (including matinee showings) reached a near record level of $8.93 in the quarter that ended in September, according to the National Assn. of Theatre Owners"
- icebraining 9y agoI don't know how it works in the US, but here that would include a lot of discounted tickets (students, seniors, promotions, etc). The average for a middle-aged adult going after work or on weekends would be much higher than the overall average.
- Jemmeh 9y agoHeck, if I go on Bargain Tuesday it's $5.75 and you get a free popcorn with each ticket. It's a really nice theatre too. Regular price is $9.50, but that's still not much more.
- cjlars 9y agoIt seems as though the cinema is finally entering a secular contraction. Home video hardware is getting cheaper and higher quality. Content going straight to netflix/hbo/hulu is getting better. And sitting in front of a movie sucking down 32oz of sugar water and fat soaked popcorn doesn't sound quite so appealing these days. I'll see the new Star Wars, no doubt about that, but besides that I can't remember a time in my life when I went to the movies less than I do now. For the same price, I can get a nice meal out and watch a movie at home.
- analogmemory 9y agoThis is why Alamo Drafthouse my only choice. Comfortable seating, prepicked seating, no ads before movies, and you can order drinks/snacks/dinner at your seat. And they take movie pass.
- PacketPaul 9y agoI find Alamo service slow, food poor and the seats are not that comfortable. Have you been to the new recliner theaters? They are a much better experience.
- analogmemory 9y agoWhat city are you in?
- jjaredsimpson 9y agoValue proposition on theaters is very low. The popcorn isn't even good. I want butter and salt evenly distributed throughout the entire bucket, not a disgustingly over seasoning top inch, and a bland inedible bottom 90%. The cheapest matinee is a Tuesday 5.75 about 20m from me. It's just not worth it at all. Serialized dramas that I binge watch are killing movies. Attention economy continues to forces changes in old media.
- SippinLean 9y agoI ask them to fill it up halfway, then I add "butter," return to the counter to have it filled the rest of the way, and return for a second "butter" round to ensure even coverage.
- Frye 9y agoIt has been out for like 3 minutes and the price has already gone from $6.95/month to $8.99/month to $9.95/month.
- schlipity 9y agoHow does this take on Moviepass? MoviePass lets you watch 1 movie per day, whereas this is 1 movie per month with a very modest discount on concessions.
- madamelic 9y agoYeah, now the concessions will only have 240% markup. Wooo.
- mattl 9y agoConcessions are how most theaters make any money. What do you suggest instead?
- Brushfire 9y agoGetting out of that business.
- DigitalJack 9y agoConsidering this as fact (that concessions make the money), I would think a theatre would do everything in it's power to make purchasing and consuming concessions the most pleasant aspect of movie going that they possibly could. Having to juggle sodas, popcorn, napkins, etc., is always an adventure in the negative sense when I go to the movies.
- spike021 9y agoEasier just to bring in outside food, and in most cases the quality is guaranteed to be better.
- Spivak 9y agoProbably the opposite as long as MoviePass is paying the full ticket price to the theaters.
- TheBiv 9y agoBecause the credits roll-over from month to month. So if you watch less than 12 movies a year, then this service will be ~$12 cheaper.
- snug 9y agoSave 20% on a $10 soda!
- smaili 9y ago> The Plano, Texas-based company on Tuesday said customers who pay a monthly fee of $8.99 will receive a credit for one movie ticket a month. > It’s also the cinema industry’s first direct answer to MoviePass, a New York start-up that offers unlimited movies in theaters for $9.95 a month. How do they expect this to be successful when the average customer should be able to understand 1/day > 1/month?
- cwyers 9y agoBecause one per day is completely unsustainable and they only need to last longer than MoviePass burns VC money and fails?
- KallDrexx 9y agoIt's only unsustainable because of the current royalty structure. Most of the money actual theaters make is on concessions and I'm more likely to buy concessions when I'm not paying $15 per person for a single movie ticket.
- goialoq 9y agoHow much would you pay for concessions if the theater didn't show movies because they didn't like the royalties? Or if they didn't show the movie you apparently want to see?
- KallDrexx 9y agoIt's not a binary decision, the royalty structure is set in stone by movie studios and distributors. Theaters have no choice right now on how to license the movies and that's the part that is unsustainable (because theaters have almost no control over the price of a ticket). That's the truth of why the theater model is unsustainable and is more and more hard pressed to get traffic. Giving theaters more lee-way on how to pay for the movies they are licensing will allow for much more competitive opportunities and differentiation between theaters.
- ada1981 9y agoI'm confused why Movie Theatres don't actively promote MoviePass to their customers. Isn't MoviePass paying full ticket value to the theatres? They should be offering people discounts to show their movie pass cards on concessions, and otherwise get people showing up for free subsidized movies while they can. Am I missing something?
- Cyph0n 9y agoAs far as I understand, the theaters get little to no revenue on ticket sales. But I guess it would still make sense to advertise since it means more snacks will be sold (on average).
- TylerE 9y agoDepends. On a major tent pole release the theater will only be getting ~20% of revenue for the first couple of weeks. Later in the release cycle the split gets much more even
- slg 9y agoYou are missing the power the theaters lose to MoviePass. MoviePass is almost assuredly not sustainable in its current business model. It is only a matter of time until they go to the theater chains with data saying X% of your customers are because of us, give us Y% of that revenue or we will direct our subscribers to competing theaters.
- plorntus 9y agoCouldn't they just milk it until that happens and then release a more sustainable option? If the theatres say no, what is MoviePass's option? They have no real control there. I'm not claiming to know everything about this, literally just a 23 year old wanting to learn more. How is this different from me (hypothetically) with a ton of money offering to give everyone their weeks groceries for $10 a month for $40 worth of goods and then turning around and saying to the grocery chain pay me $x for this. It just seems completely bizarre, if they could already offer the price they are asking , why wouldn't they do that instead of paying the middleman?
- perfmode 9y agoMoviePass is a data play, right? After signing up recently, I read their terms of service and it seems like they exist in order to build customer profiles and harvest data: https://www.moviepass.com/content/terms https://www.moviepass.com/content/terms See "18. Collection and Use of Non-Personal Information" It's not that I object to this particular instance of this practice. I, for one, am willing to trade my movie-going data for cheap movie tickets. However, I am genuinely confused about how they intend to keep it going.
- stickydink 9y agoWhat data is MoviePass able to collect that Fandango doesn't have access to?
- perfmode 9y agoSince they’ve offer such a great deal, you’ll probably use their service for every movie that you can. With fandango, you have to make a conscious decision to use them as an intermediary every time. It’s reasonable to expect that MoviePass will, over time, have a more comprehensive (less sparse) record of movies you’ve gone to theaters to see.
- rdruxn 9y agoThey’ve been quite explicit in that it is a data-play https://www.marketwatch.com/story/moviepass-plans-to-make-money-by-selling-your-data-to-uber-eateries-and-hollywood-studios-2017-10-13 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/moviepass-plans-to-make-mo...
- perfmode 9y agoThanks for this link. I hadn't seen it until now.
- nsnick 9y agoCinemark is not in competition with MoviePass. If someone uses a MoviePass, Cinemark makes money because MoviePass bought a ticket. The reason Cinemark is losing money is because they have a bad product. They show terrible Hollywood films, have terrible seats, and terrible food. I still go to the theater, but when I do, I go to theaters like Alamo Draft House (Austin), Hollywood Theater (Portland), Manor Theater (Pittsburgh), Broadway Theater (Salt Lake City).
- hkmurakami 9y agoAre the theaters you list known for good films / good food / good seats? A theater showing great classic films with great seats would be a nice change and as a 30-something, quite an affordable entertainment option.
- nsnick 9y agoThey all have better food than Cinemark, and they all show better films than Cinemark. Most of them have better seats.
- hsndmoose 9y agoCan only really speak for Alamo Drafthouse, but yes to all. Reserve seating ahead of time, order food/drinks off a menu at your seat + sometimes movie-specific menu items. They do a lot of classic movie showings on various days, there are Signature Series events https://drafthouse.com/austin/series https://drafthouse.com/austin/series that fit more to a theme, Terror Tuesdays, Afternoon Tea, etc. Master Pancake is also incredibly popular which is a live comedy showing of a movie.
- 100001 9y agoAll that and the fanaticism about no talking and no phones
- MentallyRetired 9y agoThe Cinemark on International Drive in Orlando is fantastic. Cheap prices and big comfy reserved seating. Can't comment on the food but the snacks and drinks are much lower priced than anywhere else I've been recently.
- erickhill 9y agoHmmm... $8.99/mo childcare. Tempting.
- chipperyman573 9y agoYeah once a month for an hour and a half.
- kchoudhu 9y agoI forget which theater chain it was, but I had one of these subscriptions when I was in London alone, semi-broke and super bored for an entire summer back in 2007. I must have seen every damned movie that came out over a three month period. It was awesome.
- lebanon_tn 9y agoThis is useless if the quality of movies coming out remains the same. I usually only make it out to see a movie every 3-4 months. It's hard to find something worth a 2-3 hours of my time.
- choward 9y agoIt's also useless because no matter what the theater does, nothing beats the experience of being at home. It's not like a restaurant. A different atmosphere is a plus with restaurants. Not with theaters: you stare at a screen with the lights off the whole time. Also, with a restaurant you are served food without doing any work. Sure, watching a movie in the theater requires no work, but it's also trivial to play a movie at home.
- singingboyo 9y agoIMO this is very dependant on the theatre. The ones here have fancy seating, better sound, 3D, etc. For many movies, it's very much a better experience. If you're watching the bog-standard 2D version of the latest comedy film? Yeah, sure, home is better. Latest action/superhero movie? Unless I spend thousands to put together a home theatre, the added bits at the theatre just make it much better. Mind you, from the descriptions I've heard of other theatres, I'm mildly amazed by how nice the ones around here are - especially since Cineplex more or less has a monopoly. I suspect they're just gouging us on ticket prices (and snacks, though if you do it right it's not too bad). Still, its nice to go on occasion.
- djrogers 9y agoSo for $8.99/mo I can go to one movie a month (which is a little higher than matinee pricing around here), but only at Cinemark. Option 2 is spend $1/mo more with MoviePass but I can go to a movie every day, and I can use it at my local independent theater. Kind of a no-brainer here...
- zwily 9y agoYeah but I’ll be extremely surprised if MoviePass is still in business with the same model in a couple years.
- 27182818284 9y agoAlthough...you can say that about Cinemark or theaters as a whole right now. AMC Theater stock prices have plunged in the last year. Culture shifts have killed theaters before in the US like with drive-in theaters which were decimated by such a shift.
- Spivak 9y agoBoth services have ruined the thing that differentiated 'unlimited movies' from just buying movie tickets which is seeing a bunch of movies as an event. Just go from 6:00 to 2:00 and watch anything that looks good or funny.
- redleggedfrog 9y agoAwesome. $9 a month to see the crap they shovel into the theaters. And now that they get paid regardless of whether I go or not I fully expect the crap to get even worse.
- RandomInteger4 9y agoThis seems like a dark marketing pattern: Pay $7.50 normally or experience the deluxe super duper savers package for $8.99! WOOOO!!!
- Touche 9y agoStill waiting for the ability to purchase a new movie from home. Can't think of a single reason why it hasn't happened yet. Charge $50 if you want, people would pay it. And it would probably actually recreate that water-cooler conversations that don't really happen all that often any more.
- buckminster 9y agoThis is a thing. Only $35,000 and you can probably haggle. http://www.primacinema.com/ http://www.primacinema.com/
- Touche 9y agoThat's wild. From the website it's not clear which movies are available though. Is it all of them, or does this company make arrangements with certain studios? Also, what's the cost per-movie once you've done the installation?
- buckminster 9y agoThe media coverage when they launched claimed they had all the latest movies, but I've no idea what the truth is.
- rhino369 9y ago>Can't think of a single reason why it hasn't happened yet. Piracy. Any home version of a movie would be ripped and put on warez in hours after release in 4k. I'd never go to the theater again. But CAMs and TS suck.
- Touche 9y agoSolid point. I'm really surprised this doesn't already happen. You could argue that this hasn't hurt on-demand services like iTunes and Amazon Video, where people could torrent the videos instead of buying/renting them. With piracy you're always going to lose some small number of customers, but if you make renting them legally easy, people will pay.
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoI'd pay them $20 a month to watch it at home instead.
- atmz 9y agoReminder about Cinemark: - they sued Aurora victims for legal costs - their founder is a donor to Roy Moore's campaign
- lozaning 9y agoBecause the winning side in a civil lawsuit is allowed to recover its legal costs from the losing side. If the victims wouldn't have brought their insane suit first, Cinemark wouldn't have had costs to recover. If you bite off more than you can chew don't blame anyone but yourself when you choke.