4 ms·
Local farm services guy had this to say: "Used to buy truckloads of fertilizer, then the coop would buy train car loads and undercut us. So we bought a train ca
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
Local farm services guy had this to say: "Used to buy truckloads of fertilizer, then the coop would buy train car loads and undercut us. So we bought a train car - they bought a train. We bought a train - they bought a barge. The margins are disappearing entirely"
Almost everybody is being squeezed out by 'economies of scale'. And its going to get worse, when we start making simple foodstuffs electrically (starch, sugar, protein). Then we'll see the entire farm industry turned upside down.
- Moru 9y agoThe first thing I learned when I started working life in a store was: "We do not compete by undercutting the competition. That will kill us both."
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoBut, corn is corn. There's no winning in a commodity market. And grain is the classic commodity.
- alistairSH 9y agoBut is it? I don't know about corn, but the mega-crop varieties of tomato and apple are bred to maximize revenue/reduce cost (larger, more robust for shipping, more consistent shape), not taste and nutrition.
- cortesoft 9y agoRight, there are two different markets, commodity crops and specialty crops (e.g. mega-crop tomatos vs organic local tomatoes) You can be in either market, but it is hard to switch between them. The equipment, land area used, process, etc are different.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoAlso there is no middle ground, it's one or the other.
- linkregister 9y agoI disagree; most of the produce at Whole Foods is mass-produced organic food, which is in between the quality of megafarm produce and small-farm produce.
- princekolt 9y agoBut how objective is the difference between all these three? I have the impression most of the people who buy speciality crops wouldn't be able to tell the difference between them in most cases on a blind test.
- sumedh 9y agoI have seen lot of comments on reddit about Europeans complaining that vegies from Dutch greenhouses don't taste good. I always wonder if then can differentiate if they did a blind taste.
- alistairSH 9y agoPersonally, I'm not sure I could tell in a blind test, though I'd like to think I could. But, I do know that when I travel abroad (outside the US), the produce seems to taste better. Maybe it really does, or maybe it's just my own biases. Regardless, we try to buy a substantial portion of our produce at farmers markets, when available (they aren't usually open in the winter months near DC).
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoThere's a huge difference between different vegetables and fruits. But its probably due to selection of variety, not so much how its grown. Mass production limits what can be planted, according to what will survive the automated harvesting equipment and the trip to the store. So, tasteless tomatoes that are hard and picked green etc.
- adventured 9y agoYou can win in a commodity market by changing the commodity, or by cornering the commodity in some manner (whether distribution, demand + supply angles, or supply). OPEC for example exists to create such an atmosphere for its members. DeBeers managed to keep the price of not-very-scarce diamond comically inflated for many decades. Monsanto is going to use CRISPR to create its own unique variations of crops (changing the commodity).
- Analemma_ 9y agoWhich only works until someone like Amazon comes around. Market inefficiencies which only persist by mutual agreement are doomed in the long run.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoThat's not an example of a market inefficiency. It's an example of Amazon having a structural advantage that allows it to be profitable at a lower cost to consumers.
- azernik 9y agoThe market inefficiency being referenced was not Amazon coming in; it was the existing producers keeping their prices above fair market value by gentleman's agreement.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoIf they're both going to go out of business by cutting prices then the prices are already at fair market value.
- claudiulodro 9y agoThis happens any time your only differentiator is price. The small guy is never going to be able to compete with a larger company on only price. Never make your differentiator "we're cheaper"! It's business 101.
- danielvf 9y agoUnless that’s a game you can win - see Amazon.
- sjg007 9y agoBut Amazon is not cheaper for all things.. I think their original value add was free shipping.
- sbarre 9y agoOutliers should never be used to guide your strategy.
- claudiulodro 9y agoI was always under the impression their differentiator is speed, convenience, and selection. They're marketing is heavily towards how quickly and how conveniently they can get anything you want to you. Either way, that's exactly my point. Why would you compete with Amazon on price? They can get anything in larger bulk quantities than you ever could.
- Domenic_S 9y agoI do a substantial amount of personal shopping on Amazon -- 6-7 orders a month -- and they are rarely the cheapest option. Shipping & hassle-free returns is the value-add.
- JBlue42 9y agoEh...I've worked in a few businesses that do this. Visual effects was the most notable. Also, in the US, isn't the government required to go with the lowest bidder to some degree on contracts?
- Tade0 9y ago> when we start making simple foodstuffs electrically (starch, sugar, protein). Interesting. Do you happen to know what's the state of research on this?
- mythrwy 9y agoProbably something like this is more imminent than creating non-biological food from water and sunlight electrically. After all, wood is just long chains of sugar. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2013/04/could-wood-feed-world http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2013/04/could-wood-feed-world From there proteins can be created using the sugars as a substrate. Once again, will probably be a biological process. Nutritive yeasts are interesting.
- tomjen3 9y agoSounds like they could use the model that made Danish farmers rich in the 19th century: you get everybody together and buy seeds, etc through one company, then you divide any profit and loss on that company equally among everybody (so the company effective does not make any profit). The same thing can be done for a dairy processing system, meat plant or anywhere else that a large number of people need to buy and sell things that are similar.
- zeveb 9y agoHow does that handle a 'farmer' who just does a desultory job of farming? I.e., he doesn't outright not farm, but he barely seeds, harvests badly and thus produces very little.
- tomjen3 9y agoThat is the smart part of the system: he will get very little out it, as the proceeds are distributed based an how much money you spend/sell for.