4 ms·
I'm not particularly animated by the issue but I'm also not convinced the compensation has much to do with relative ability and performance. It's based on lucky
by maxerickson 9y ago
I'm not particularly animated by the issue but I'm also not convinced the compensation has much to do with relative ability and performance. It's based on lucky positioning and risk averse ass covering (the board thinks it is more defensible to pay lots for a star than take a risk paying less).
- Nrsolis 9y agoWho gets to decide this? As I understand it, it's the board of directors that put together a compensation committee. It's not like they are spending your money. They're spending the shareholder's money. If only you owned stock in CVS or Aetna you'd be able to make your voice heard.
- maxerickson 9y agoWhat's your point? You think I should keep my opinion to myself or something?
- Nrsolis 9y agoI don't understand the animus towards CEO pay. It can easily be applied to any major celebrity or athlete. If anyone could do what they do, they'd be paid accordingly. The market (via the shareholders) sets the rate of pay. Why the general public cares about one and not the other is beyond me.
- maxerickson 9y agoMy post questions the ability of the market to price CEO value a lot more than it expresses outrage. Athletes and celebrities are different, their pay is a natural consequence of gathering lots of attention. A more rational species would substitute cheaper entertainment.
- bkanber 9y ago> Athletes and celebrities are different, their pay is a natural consequence of gathering lots of attention. And a Fortune 500 CEO's pay is a natural consequence of being a Fortune 500 CEO. There are only 500 of them. This is the top of the game, just like pro athletes. > A more rational species would substitute cheaper entertainment. But we aren't, and we don't.
- jimbokun 9y ago"If anyone could do what they do, they'd be paid accordingly." This is not at all self evident. There is a lot of reporting suggesting CEO compensation is not really tied to the best interests of share holders. As cited elsewhere in this thread: http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2005ltr.pdf http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2005ltr.pdf
- bkanber 9y agoYou're right, partially. The thing about free markets is that the average value across all data points will converge to the free market value, and there are outliers on both sides. There are lots of CEOs that are under-paid for their abilities as well as lots of CEOs that are over-paid for their abilities. If you were to look at all CEO salaries averaged over all companies in an industry, you probably would get a pretty fair view of what the average CEO is worth, but of course an N=1 can deviate greatly from the average. A company's performance may be strongly correlated to a CEO's ability and performance, or not. These salaries aren't set algorithmically and there's no way to predict ahead of time exactly what the impact of a given person on an organization will be. Past performance is not a guarantee of future returns, but there's really nothing else to determine CEO salary by except for experience, fit, and past performance. The salaries are set by whatever the board and shareholders are willing to pay, which is influenced by all the data (objective and subjective alike) -- a central tenet of free markets. The truth is there's really no other way to do it.
- maxerickson 9y agoYou are begging the question. First you have to prove that the CEO market is efficient. Then you can praise the free hand.
- bkanber 9y agoAll free and competitive markets are taken to be efficient. In a market where a million wannabe-CEOs are vying for one of the top 500 spots, you get tough competition and the compensation is commensurate with the level of competition.
- maxerickson 9y agoLots of people willing to do the job should drive down the compensation. High compensation is partly a result of businesses choosing from a small pool of candidates...
- 9y ago