4 ms·
That's a pretty complex financial problem that you're over simplifying. The flyover states can't very easily invest more, they don't have the growth to do it. T
by adventured 9y ago
That's a pretty complex financial problem that you're over simplifying. The flyover states can't very easily invest more, they don't have the growth to do it. The coastal areas do largely have the growth to invest (in some cases a lot of growth), which makes it dramatically easier to do so. They have the flowing tax base expansion, the labor expansion.
It's the difference between being Facebook with 45% net income profit margins, and being a manufacturer in Ohio with 4% net income margins. If you're Facebook, you're drowning in opportunity and cash. Growth does that for you, in many cases it begets further easy growth. The manufacturer's scenario is rock and a hard place stagnation, and if they slip up even a bit, it's bankruptcy.
In 77 years, Arkansas has added one million people. They might add 20k to 30k per year in a good year.
West Virginia hasn't grown its population 84 years.
Mississippi has added one million people in a hundred years.
Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania have barely grown their populations in half a century.
Some of this is down to their mistakes, some of it is shit luck of getting slammed by very large macro economic forces, huge technology changes (whereas earlier technology changes had blessed those locations).
These states are perpetually trapped in a scenario where they can't afford to make the moves to attract sustained growth, and they can't grow because they can't afford to make those expensive moves. It's stagnation hell. The only likely way out, is a major technology inflection point, and being sure to catch the wave.
- ameister14 9y agoPercentage-wise, the population of Ohio has grown more than New York since 1960. edit: Another way to put it is that Mississippi has doubled in population in 100 years - roughly 1.5 million to 3 million
- muninn_ 9y agoSo I live in Ohio and wanted to comment on this. You're right that the population hasn't really been growing. What I'm interested in is why it's necessary? Overall unemployment is low, the state is slightly growing each year, and new businesses are continuing to spring up, although not on the scale of Facebook. Why do we need to be California? Growth comes with it's own problems. I feel like in this country there is this need to grow grow grow at all costs, but we also mismanage that growth (look at the California housing issues). Why do we need more people? I'd say we want fewer people and those people concentrated in cities. Let the rest of the state be used for growing crops or for nature reclamation. So what exactly is this "stagnation hell"? I live in Ohio. I mean, I miss the mountains/ocean but besides that things seem alright to me compared to everywhere else I've lived. Anyway, just my 2c.