4 ms·
"Any foreign company eating up the market share of a local company will get blocked eventually or be forced into merging into a local entity." Can you provide
by rahimnathwani 9y ago
"Any foreign company eating up the market share of a local company will get blocked eventually or be forced into merging into a local entity."
Can you provide an example of a foreign company that was willing to comply with Chinese law, but still faced this outcome?
- EZ-E 9y agoFacebook Zuckerberg is all ready to comply and multiply his attempts to get closer to the Chinese government (look it up), but stays blocked.
- ddorian43 9y agoThe dude even learned Chinese (mandarin?).
- musage 9y agoIt's so. much. worse. http://www.worldtribune.com/archives/chinese-president-snubs-mark-zuckerbergs-request-to-name-his-unborn-child/ http://www.worldtribune.com/archives/chinese-president-snubs... https://www.quora.com/Did-Mark-Zuckerberg-really-ask-Xi-Jinping-to-name-his-daughter https://www.quora.com/Did-Mark-Zuckerberg-really-ask-Xi-Jinp... > In China this privilege is nominally given to the father or grandfather of the child. Asking a complete stranger, albeit a famous one to name your child is unheard of.
- rahimnathwani 9y agoWhich company's market share was Facebook 'eating up'?
- cdancette 9y agoUber, WhatsApp
- richardknop 9y agoWasn't Uber losing ton of money in China? Also they had problems with regulators and local governments. I thought that was the main reason why they left.
- jbigelow76 9y agoI think the "problems with regulators and local governments" part is the implementation of the "forced into merging into a local entity" effect the great grandparent comment referred to.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIronically, while it may be part of the implementation in China, Uber also has "problems with regulators and local governments" in every single place they do business. I am surprised Uber even got the chance to try in China.
- paulie_a 9y agoTo be fair uber is losing a ton of money everywhere
- rahimnathwani 9y agoDidi was also losing a ton of money in China. When they were competing head-to-head, both were offering ridiculous subsidies to both riders and drivers.
- xmly 9y agoUber lost the battle against didi, so was forced to merge with didi. Just a loser case. WhatsApp never entered into China market, never register as a company in China, so how it could follow the regulation?
- 9y ago
- adventured 9y agoBeing willing to comply with Chinese law is the catch to your question. Being willing to comply, means you're instantly put into a weak, disadvantaged state versus their domestic entities who get to play by an entirely different set of rules. Disney can't even own their own park in China, they have to be a minority owner. So they build a nice, very expensive park, Disney Shanghai, and get 43% of it. That's the world's largest, most powerful media company, forced to beg on its knees just to get access to build in China. That tells you everything you need to know about how accessible China really is. How's this for an example of how Chinese law works for outsiders? Jack Ma stealing tens of billions of dollars from Softbank and Yahoo, by taking Alipay away from Alibaba shareholders without proper compensation and without shareholder voting. He gave it to himself, discharging it out Alibaba and into his own hands, with complete disregard for what the ownership percentages were of Alibaba. It's one of the greatest thefts in world history, and these other large corporations were powerless to do anything about it. Ant Financial / Alipay of course is a critical piece of Chinese technological infrastructure, and is likely to go on to be worth a couple hundred billion dollars over time. For example this Wiki quote: "In the fourth quarter of 2016, Alipay had a 54% share of China's $5.5 trillion mobile payment market" That says it all about the extraordinarily vast scale of that theft. No chance China was ever going to allow Softbank and Yahoo to have such a big stake in that. So they looked the other way while Ma robbed the bank. What outside technology company possibly trust being in business with Chinese tech companies on anything important or valuable to the Chinese economy after something like that? They'll just change or ignore the rules at will. I liken it to Jeff Bezos choosing to give himself most of AWS, discharge it out of Amazon.com's ownership structure, and not compensate the other Amazon shareholders for it. It'd be like Bill Gates granting himself Windows LLC, removing the product from Microsoft circa 1994 without shareholder compensation, and reaping tens of billions in additional gains that should have gone to Microsoft shareholders.
- usaphp 9y ago> That's the world's largest, most powerful media company, forced to beg on its knees just to get access to build in China. Nobody is forcing them to build in China, disney just wants to make more money for themselves, so China can do whatever they want since it’s their land. If Disney agreed to this terms - it only means that it’s still profitable for Disney.
- westiseast 9y agoCheck out Mark Kitto’s story for the ‘original’ example of this. To modify the original sentiment, it’s more like ‘any foreign company doing well in China will eventually be forced into a corner by unfair state aid to its competitors’