5 ms·
Fortunately you're wrong. In reality, the US is one of the 20 least corrupt nations on the planet, on par with Ireland and Japan and less corrupt than France. I
by adventured 9y ago
Fortunately you're wrong. In reality, the US is one of the 20 least corrupt nations on the planet, on par with Ireland and Japan and less corrupt than France. It has very strong property protection laws, which is both why the judge returned the money (naturally that would happen in a nation with no rule of law huh), and why the Obama Administration took important steps to neuter civil asset forfeiture abuse. Can more be done to fully end the abuse? Of course.
https://www.transparency.org/news/feature/corruption_perceptions_index_2016 https://www.transparency.org/news/feature/corruption_percept...
The US also has rare universal Congressional support for ending civil asset forfeiture abuses. Jeff Sessions undid some of the fixes the Obama Administration made; it turns out that might have been ideal, as Congress is now going to put it down for good by law.
Sept 2017:
"In Surprise Vote, House Passes Amendment to Restrict Asset Forfeiture"
"The amendment passed with a voice vote, meaning it had overwhelming support."
https://theintercept.com/2017/09/12/in-surprise-vote-house-passes-amendment-to-restrict-asset-forfeiture/ https://theintercept.com/2017/09/12/in-surprise-vote-house-p...
Nov 2017:
"A bipartisan group of senators wants to defund Attorney General Jeff Sessions' expansion of the Justice Department's civil asset forfeiture program, following similar efforts by libertarian-leaning and progressive members of the House earlier this year."
http://reason.com/blog/2017/11/08/senators-press-for-defunding-of-jeff-ses http://reason.com/blog/2017/11/08/senators-press-for-defundi...
- leggomylibro 9y agoThat's fair, but I'm not saying it isn't better than many other places, I'm just saying that it is very bad. Anyways, I'll believe it when I see it stop happening.
- avs733 9y agoYour source doesn't quite say what you are implying. They define corruption thusly: >Generally speaking as “the abuse of entrusted power for private gain”. Corruption can be classified as grand, petty and political, depending on the amounts of money lost and the sector where it occurs. >Grand corruption consists of acts committed at a high level of government that distort policies or the central functioning of the state, enabling leaders to benefit at the expense of the public good. Petty corruption refers to everyday abuse of entrusted power by low- and mid-level public officials in their interactions with ordinary citizens, who often are trying to access basic goods or services in places like hospitals, schools, police departments and other agencies. >Political corruption is a manipulation of policies, institutions and rules of procedure in the allocation of resources and financing by political decision makers, who abuse their position to sustain their power, status and wealth. See animated definitions of many corruption terms in our Anti-corruption Glossary. The link you provided measures the PERCEPTION of corruption. It is perfectly plausible for there to be a huge amount of corruption and very little perception of corruption depending on many factors. The source describes it thusly: >No. The CPI is an indicator of perceptions of public sector corruption, i.e. administrative and political corruption. It is not a verdict on the levels of corruption of entire nations or societies, or of their policies, or the activities of their private sector. Citizens of those countries/territories that score at the lower end of the CPI often show the same concern about and condemnation of corruption as the public in countries that perform strongly. Their data sources primarily asks 'experts' which they define differently (additionally, one specifically asks business executives, one includes the general public, and one doesn't clearly specify) whether they perceive corruption to be an issue. While the exact questions vary, these two seem like representative examples: >In your country, how common is it for firms to make undocumented extra payments or bribes connected with the following and >First, how do you grade the problem of corruption in the country in which you are working? Second, has corruption decreased, stayed the same or increased compared with one year ago? Third, what aspects or implications of corruption in your country stand out to you as being particularly important? If the majority of the populace feels that seizure of drug profits is warranted, and the police generally label everything seized 'drug profits' than it is perfectly feasible that is an accepted narrative without any meaningful evidence being provided. They are the type of people who exist and are privileged by the normative power hierarchies in that society (hence the term 'expert' being applied to them by peers). These are the people least likely to experience that type of corruption/oppression...by design All of this comes down to the data they select. Your source uses the exact type of data which would hide corruption by this definition. That effect comes both through the selection of questions and the selection of people who will answer those questions. Their implementation of their definition of corruption largely results in a study of whether those with social capital feel like society treats them and their businesses fairly. It seems a poor metric of the types of systematic (designed) corruption experienced by others on a regular basis.
- markdown 9y ago> least corrupt nations on the planet Only because you don't define lobbying as corruption. In most (any?) other nation, individuals and corporations paying legislators to vote a certain way fits the definition of bribery and corruption perfectly.
- twoodfin 9y agoThat is bribery in the US, too, and it is illegal.
- FireBeyond 9y agoYeah, except in the US, the fine line can be as narrow as the difference between: "Take this money for your campaign and pass this law" - bribery; and "Take this money for your campaign. I'd really like to see this law pass." - lobbying.
- twoodfin 9y agoFirst, there’s a significant distinction between campaign donations and “paying legislators” cash. Second, so-called “hard money” corporate donations to federal electoral campaigns have been and remain illegal. Failing to make these distinctions and commenting as if corporate lobbyists are literally handing over suitcases full of cash is deceptive.
- lawn 9y agoThis combined with civil forfeiture gives me a really hard time classifying it as anything else than corrupt.
- CodeMage 9y agoLet's not forget about bill riders: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation)
- rayiner 9y ago
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>Fortunately you're wrong. In reality, the US is one of the 20 least corrupt nations on the planet, As someone who's lived in several states I think there's a lot of variability. Corruption tends to follow population density and money. If the brother of a cop or court official beat me to near death in a bar brawl I would not expect the court to sentence him to jail time. Fifty miles and one state border north of here I would expect jail time. Fifty miles and two counties west of here I'd give it 50-50. >The US also has rare universal Congressional support for ending civil asset forfeiture abuses. Jeff Sessions undid some of the fixes the Obama Administration made; it turns out that might have been ideal, as Congress is now going to put it down for good by law. I fully support legislation to obstruct or get rid of civil asset forfeiture (every bit helps) but I would fully expect that within a month my state would use it as an excuse to double all the fines for everything else to make up for it, not that we even make a lot of money off of it, just that it's an excuse to raise the fines.
- syshum 9y ago>>Fortunately you're wrong Unfortunately you are wrong >In reality, the US is one of the 20 least corrupt nations on the planet, on par with Ireland and Japan and less corrupt than France. In reality do to the distributed nature of the various governments of the US, corruption in local government is both wide spread and very very under reported, Sure maybe the Federal Government is one of the 20 least national governments, but there are over 3,000 local government units that are very very much corruptible and often are. Further I do not by the premise that just because you are less bad than others that makes you good... A murder that kills only 1 person is not "good" because he did not kill 20... > It has very strong property protection laws, which is both why the judge returned the money (naturally that would happen in a nation with no rule of law huh), You should really research this issue more if you think that is the common outcome. it is not I just looking at the work the Institute for Justice is doing in this space. Specifically their Policing for Profit Series >why the Obama Administration took important steps to neuter civil asset forfeiture abuse Those changes were superficial at best, did not really do much as have all been rolled back at this point Most Civil Asset Abuse some at the local level anyway not at the federal level, the Federal Programs are generally used as a end run around state that have enacted laws to eliminate civil asset forfeiture or severely limit its use >The US also has rare universal Congressional support for ending civil asset forfeiture abuses. No the US Congress play both sides of this issue, if there was universal support the law would already be changed Police Unions are a power lobby, most Congress Reps will claim publicly to be for it, while never ever allowing the issue to come up for a vote