8 ms·
Are “landscrapers” the new skyscrapers?
- curtis 9y agoI was imagining a giant hole in the ground, but low, very long buildings are no doubt more practical.
- menssen 9y agoStrip malls, factories, and suburban office parks are all associated with dense, vibrant, walkable cities, so, yeah, this makes sense.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here? I'm sure many of us share your sympathies. I probably do too, though it's hard to know for sure in the absence of any information. None of that matters, though, because this kind of comment just takes threads into internet brown. We need better than this, especially early on, in order to have thoughtful conversation.
- CyberDildonics 9y ago> Please don't post unsubstantive comments here? I don't understand your question.
- slowandlow 9y agolol wat?
- dang 9y agoI'm beginning to sense that it wasn't my clearest comment.
- ukulele 9y agoDoes this "landscraper" have the horizontal equivalent of an elevator (i.e. something where you push a button and it moves you anywhere horizontally in ~20 seconds)? It seems like that might knock you over, but maybe there's a fun workaround (or just seats I guess).
- MikeTheGreat 9y agoFrom the article: "Future employees might move around landscrapers on elevators that zoom back and forth laterally, not only up and down, she notes. That technology already exists in Germany, where ThyssenKrupp has recently sold the first elevator that can move up, down, sideways and diagonally—controlled by magnetic levitation—to a residential building in Berlin."
- dsr_ 9y agoWhy would you do something so bizarre when we have perfectly good conveyor belts, as used in most major airports?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- flukus 9y agoConveyor belts are slow. They realized long ago that you can't accelerate a standing human too fast and that stepping on to a conveyor belt takes you to max speed nearly instantly. Any faster and people need a running start to jump on.
- WalterBright 9y agoI wonder about the fire issues. I'd rather have two buildings with a gap to act as a fire break.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThis doesn't seem a good idea. I don't think cities should sprawl even more. Even Silicon Valley would probably be better off if they had built up instead of all the one or two level office parks.
- II2II 9y agoIt would depend upon many factors. Height restrictions are one of them. There are social, environmental, and engineering considerations on that front. Current land use practices are another. It may be possible to gain tremendous boosts in density even with mid-rise buildings. Then there are the diminishing returns to land use while building up since you are talking about many independent structures that require a certain amount of separation. These buildings are by no means sprawling office parks. They are simply the realization that horizontal may be better than vertical in some cases.
- arebop 9y agoMonoliths are problematic. They're dull, they're poorly connected, they're in the way. It's worse when they're arranged horizontally because people tend to move horizontally. When you build up, the problems mostly develop for the people inside your building. When you build across, you obstruct everyone around you. How are these "landscrapers" different from sprawling office parks? The key difference I notice is that the plan doesn't include an ocean of parking (which admittedly is a big part of why office parks are terrible).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- quickthrower2 9y agoIt's a "campus". That sure sounds cooler than "commercial office space".
- dade_ 9y agoAll the amenities made possible with high density but also convenient to take the stairs... Its a wonderful thing after living on the 33rd floor for many years. Interesting to see how this works out.
- IIAOPSW 9y agoI think this is a silly use of real estate. The entire point of building an n-story building is you get to multiply your usable land area by n. Those who point to tall down-towns are right. A built up city has more land area than the map would suggest and can thus fit more people and more activity. Even better is the fact that a single utility link (electric, gas, sewage) to an n-floor building does the same work as n links to n 1-floor buildings. Its just more efficient. I get the complaints about having to travel by elevator all the time and not having as much ground level community. Which is why I don't understand why sky-ways never became popular. There's no technological reason you couldn't have an interconnected upper level with shops and public/commercial space. Perhaps its just a problem on getting all the different developers and governments to agree on the standards for a modular interconnected second level.
- opensourcenews 9y agoI tend to agree with the comments about height, but re: skyways - they're just kind of weird. They're not public spaces, so they can be exclusionary. And the vibe is just kind of weird. Downtown Atlanta below the skyways is already eerily quiet for a major city, but within them... I don't know, I have a constant feeling that I'm trespassing even though I'm not. Does anyone else get this feeling?
- heartbreak 9y agoIn downtown Minneapolis the feeling I get is, “It’s -20° out there I don’t care if I’m allowed to be up here or not.” Edit: For anyone who hasn’t spent time in the twin cities, the skyways are public transit.
- junkscience2017 9y agoskyscrapers are mostly about making a statement....there are very few places in the world where land is truly so expensive that absolutely everyone, even the wealthiest corporations in the world, must build up. Apple's new campus for example is basically a landscraper.
- 9y ago
- agoodthrowaway 9y agoI don't think the author is familiar with the Merchandise Mart in Chicago nor the Frank Gehry design of Facebook's new mega building (to cite 2 well known non US govt. examples).
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoReminds me of ibm’s old boca raton campus (where they invented the PC and did OS/2 with MS). You could walk for a few hours down those corridors, it was just one long 3 or 4 story building, or at least that’s how it felt.
- BoiledCabbage 9y agoThis is really no different than existing low story construction except connect the building instead of leaving them unconnected. If anything it's worse since there is now now variety at all, and enormous multiple blocks of sameness. Part of what makes old-school cities so pedestrian friendly was having a variety of small shops to stop in. A bakery, grocer, butcher, clothing store all only a few windows wide. This is like building an enormous Home Depot, Costco and Circuit City in the middle of downtown. This does not make a pedestrian friendly city.
- flukus 9y agoDoesn't a good portion of London (where this is built) already have whole blocks of low rise terraced housing? The only difference seems to be more holes in the wall and less doors.
- King-Aaron 9y ago> From some angles, it may resemble a landlocked cruise ship. - Does not look anything like a cruise landlocked cruise ship.
- Animats 9y agoThis, Sea World in Shenzhen, [1] is a mall built to look like a landlocked cruise ship. Google's building is not. The U.S. Government used to build office buildings a few stories high but huge in length. The Pentagon is the most notable example, but there were many others built in the 1940s through the 1960s. They were built sturdily and cheaply, like parking garages. [1] https://youtu.be/NTcx0OHehdE?t=35 https://youtu.be/NTcx0OHehdE?t=35
- slowandlow 9y agoThis style of architecture definitely allows for more sunlight and doesn't dirty the skyline with nasty highly reflective glass. Sometimes you're located in an area that is better without skyscrapers. Although I'm sure most of the posts here will be about "inefficiency".
- junkscience2017 9y agoI love it. We do not live on Coruscant, space is not at such a premium even in London or NYC that you must push higher and higher. Skyscrapers are sterile; nothing happens at street level. The entire purpose is to isolate. The landscrapers have a more humane elevation and will end up creating entire neighborhoods.
- curtis 9y ago"Landscrapers" will (obviously) have fewer, but larger floors. For certain types of organizations (e.g. software development organizations) this can be a real advantage, since more of the people that each person needs to work with can be on the same floor. Being separated by even a single floor can make a remarkably big difference to communication.
- klenwell 9y agoInteresting point. Reminds me of one of the major arguments in Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steels as to why the Old World conquered the New and not vice-versa. Eurasia is a "landscraper" (oriented longitudinally) allowing for easier trade and exchange of innovations (especially related to agriculture and animal domestication) along a broad expanse of land. The Americas are a skyscraper (more latitudinal orientation) with greater diversity of climate and topology that impeded the spread of some innovations and technologies.
- jcranmer 9y agoJared Diamond's thesis (rather like I feel the skyscraper/landscraper thesis is) is quite overstated. The climatic zones running from Mesopotamia to China are quite varied, and there's rather little evidence for technology transfer between these two endpoints. By contrast, the climatic zone from the northern edge of the Valley of Mexico to the boreal forests in Canada is basically one smooth temperature gradient, and we do know of rather extensive trading and tech transfer in North America (particularly, the introduction of maize to the independently-developed agriculture quite revolutionized developments in eastern North America). Not to mention the fact that the Americas don't seem so far behind Eurasia the more we do the archaeology: Norte Chico is now dated to at least 3200-3500 BC, a date competitive with Ancient Egypt and not too far behind Sumeria in terms of developing civilization.
- elguyosupremo 9y agoI definitely agree, our dev organization has been outgrowing our current space and one team move to an adjacent floor and I barely see them anymore. Even though I don't directly collaborate with them I miss the small chats about what they are doing.
- crazygringo 9y agoGoogle's NYC building (111 8th Ave) is 790 ft long -- not as long as the new one's 1,082 ft, but still comparable. Few people realize it's NYC's fourth-largest building, since it's only 15 stories. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/111_Eighth_Avenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/111_Eighth_Avenue
- frik 9y agoGoogle's 111 8th Ave NYC building completed in 1932, at 2.9 million square feet (270,000 m2), it is currently the city's fourth largest building in terms of floor area as of 2014. It was the largest building until 1963 when the 3.14-million-square-foot (292,000 m2) MetLife Building opened.
- bastijn 9y agoWhy is it an era of landscapers when Google builds it but not even thought of when it is a regular shopping mall? Plenty of shopping malls with these sizes around the world. Also build as one long “landscraper”. I would say landscapers are already there for many years, just not by a fancy company. You build skyscrapers in locations where ground is scarce and expensive, you build landscapers in locations where it is the opposite. In dense areas with high ground prices you accept the building cost overhead, in other areas you go for cheaper building costs and accept the increased price on land (as compared to a skyscraper at the same location).
- ACow_Adonis 9y agoNo offense, but this is clearly a marketing fluff peice. It looks like every other mid-rise commercial building development. Is it the future? Absolutely, if by future, you mean the 80's, but everything is shiny and labeled with the adjective "smart" for some reason. Almost as innovative as Apple's relabelling of the suburban office/business park. When the hell did everything become marketing...
- candiodari 9y agoYep, this is a Google overseas investment/tax dodge. Everything else about the building is secondary at best, for both Google and frankly, for the rest us too. https://www.theverge.com/2013/1/18/3889818/google-relocates-uk-headquarters-to-kings-cross-london https://www.theverge.com/2013/1/18/3889818/google-relocates-...
- gnode 9y agoI think the crucial technology which would make such cities practical in the future would be innovation in transportation, whether that be something like lateral elevators for short distances (of course "elevate" may be a misnomer here), or hyperloop for longer distances. Building vertically has the benefit of squeezing more utility out of land area, but has drawbacks which can make city life less comfortable.
- xversilov 9y agoThe only reason this is a "landscraper" and not a 50 story building is because of land use regulations, namely, London's height limits. Asia, unburdened by the West's ridiculous land policies, is skyscraper heaven.
- bitwize 9y agoNo, because skyscrapers are tall. They allow you to get a lot of working space out of relatively little of Earth's surface area. This thing doesn't offer anywhere near that sort of surface-area economy. They could get away with putting it in London, because London. Elongated buildings are commonplace in London, apparently because of local laws. If Google wants to build in a place where land surface area is precious -- downtown Manhattan, say, or any city in Japan -- it'll be hard to beat the good old skyscraper.
- meh2frdf 9y agoIt’s just a normal looking building for that area, or am I missing something?