11 ms·
California updates laws around salary and criminal histories of job applicants
- goialoq 9y agoAn article that explains the perverse results of "Ban the Box", and then attempts to rebut it: https://onlabor.org/ban-the-box-and-perverse-consequences-part-i/ https://onlabor.org/ban-the-box-and-perverse-consequences-pa... > Ban the Box interacts with racial profiling because, unless it checks or asks, an employer has no information one way or the other about an applicant’s criminal record. > Without individualized information, employers apply racial stereotypes that place applicants of color under a cloud of suspicion. > But when employers check, they confirm not only who does have a record but also who does not, enabling employers to target the former for more accurate exclusion. > The racial exclusion from stereotyping when employers don’t check could exceed the racial exclusion from accurate screening when they do check. > That is exactly what happens, according to the studies.
- conanbatt 9y agoWow I am impressed at this analysis and finding. I am currently debating with myself about the cost of hiding information, and cases where there is a deliberate attempt at hiding it are the ones that are more likely to counter my intuition that information truly should be absolutely free. Thanks for the contribution!
- throwaway613834 9y agoIt needs more upvotes. I'm confused at how it's at the bottom of the comments here. It's an excellent one.
- Veelox 9y agoTl;dr Since employers cannot ask about criminal history, they use stereotypes to make there decision instead. Studies show the stereotype filtering leads to worse outcomes for PoC. I came here to say this, thank you for finding the souce.
- geofft 9y agoThanks, that data is useful. How are they determining race? Names? Is "ban the name" a sensible policy proposal? (Hold the name in escrow with someone who will contact references, do background checks, etc., until you're ready to make the offer.)
- sokoloff 9y agoI personally don't find "ban the name" to be a sensible policy. I google and LinkedIn anyone whom I'm about to interview. I want to be equipped with information to make that hour together as productive as possible for both sides. I get that my personal preference to do homework and be prepared prior to an interview might not outweigh a societal reason to prevent that.
- geofft 9y agoYeah, I think that is extremely likely to lead to subconscious bias. In the good case, you find something worth talking about with that person, and you have a productive conversation where you go deep onto a topic they should be familiar with and you figure out whether they're actually familiar or not, yes. In the not-so-good case, you find that they were accused and then cleared of charges for something odious, or that they sued their former employer for entirely justifiable reasons, or that they're an ardent supporter of a political party or religious view you just can't stand, or that they just tweeted that they're pregnant, or whatever. And even in the good case, you're asking this person something very different from what you're asking other candidates, which means you're likely to be influenced by something as irrelevant as other candidates not having a public record. (e.g., one candidate worked somewhere with an oppressive OSS policy, one didn't, you got to have a good conversation about a project the second candidate's GitHub but did not get as far talking about an internal project the first candidate did.) Which doesn't actually seem that good. I am incredibly curious to see data, if anyone has it, about who interviews most effectively (in the sense of saying "yes" to candidates that do well, being the one "no" on candidates who left the company quickly, being the one "yes" to candidates whose LinkedIn implies they ended up being successful, etc.) I suspect - but have no data - that asking consistent questions to each candidate leads to higher accuracy. But perhaps you miss out on the rare, extraordinary candidates.
- thriftwy 9y agoHow about background checks? Now that they can't go thru the door, they'll crawl up your window.
- brianwawok 9y agoOr just job history. If you were in jail, you have a gap in your resume. Seems like you could just filter out anyone with a gap in their resume of more than say a year. The intentions are good on this bill. I worry it is going to be a challenge to actually implement.
- lordnacho 9y agoAre people in America legally bound to write the truth on their CVs? You could just say you worked for some made-up firm or for your friend's firm.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThat's a good way to be fired later.
- larrik 9y agoOf course. Lies on your CV are committing fraud.
- brianwawok 9y agoDo you have an actual legal reference for this? If you ask me what my favorite food is and I say Fish (when it is really Pizza), I did not commit fraud. If I testify before a court and lie, I commit a specific offense (perjury). It is not actually clear to me what lying on a CV is in the United States. It may actually depend if you are applying to a government agency vs McDonalds....
- dsp1234 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraud "Although elements may vary by jurisdiction and the specific allegations made by a plaintiff who files a lawsuit that alleged fraud, typical elements of a fraud case in the United States are that: 1.) somebody misrepresents a material fact in order to obtain action or forbearance by another person, 2.) the other person relies upon the misrepresentation, and 3.) the other person suffers injury as a result of the act or forbearance taken in reliance upon the misrepresentation." Example lie: I'm CCNA certified. 1.) Yes 2.) Yes (I'm hired) 3.) The company loses a government contract after finding out that I'm not actually CCNA certified, and the bid required all engineers on the project are CCNA certified (alternately, I completely screw up the routers and take the companies infrastructure out of the global routing tables) Basically, if the company relies on the lie to hire you, and then later suffers an injury from that lie, then a fraud has been committed. Note that it works both ways[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employment_fraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employment_fraud]
- perfmode 9y agoI didn't see anything about payscale disclosure in the body of the article, but at the end it mentions, "Prepare payscale information for applicants that may request it." Is there anything to this?
- _rpd 9y agoIt does seem to be the case ... > (c) An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180AB168 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- maxk42 9y agoCongratulations California. You just capped everyone's salaries. All you had to do before was say "It doesn't matter. My price is $x." I've done it many times and still been offered the job.
- Terr_ 9y agoOn the other hand, when CEO salaries were made public, the trend -- contrary to expectations -- was for them to rise rather than be capped.
- s73ver_ 9y agoNot everyone is in your position, and feels they have a strong enough bargaining position to do that. Nothing in this law changes things for you, but it can change things for the better for many other people.
- maxk42 9y agoYes, actually, everyone is in a strong enough bargaining position to do that. You can teach people they're helpless or you can teach people how to negotiate. California seems intent on teaching people to be helpless.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoBanning asking about criminal history seems silly. It's not like you accidentally become a criminal. Your criminal history directly reflects your judgment and character.
- ribosometronome 9y agoHave you ever had sex with someone you're not married to? Which church do you go to?
- dang 9y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment with a worse one. Even if the other comment doesn't deserve better, the community does.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoYes, and I don't go to church. As far as I know neither is a crime in my state/country.
- booleandilemma 9y agoIf a person does their time, the mistakes they made in the past shouldn’t haunt them forever.
- whack 9y agoWould you ever hire a convicted paedophile as your babysitter? Thankfully, the law agrees that you shouldn't have to, and allows for the following: "If an employer does decide to deny an applicant the position solely or in part because of the conviction history, the employer must make an individualized assessment of whether the applicant’s conviction history has a direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the job that justify denying the applicant the position."
- throwaway613834 9y agoThe rub though is that people probably wouldn't want to hire that kind of a person for any job. The law doesn't allow for that.
- Dowwie 9y ago"If an employer does decide to deny an applicant the position solely or in part because of the conviction history, the employer must make an individualized assessment of whether the applicant’s conviction history has a direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the job that justify denying the applicant the position." You could drive a semi through that loophole
- frankc 9y agoIt's not really a "loophole", per se. It would be ludicrous to say that a bank should not be able to exclude someone from hiring if they have been convicted of a serious financial crime, or that a day care should not be able to exclude a convicted child molester. Now, will other companies take advantage of this so that they defeat the spirit of the law? Perhaps. But the fact that they need to make an assessment means that might be subject to review at some point.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- randyrand 9y agoIt's amazing we need to explicitly say this. This should be obvious, yet by many comments you wouldn't realize it.
- bertil 9y agoIt is obvious: I'm stunned that people on HN still use uninformed “but who will think of the children?!“ So to make it clear: as a day-care owner, you do not need to refuse employment to a previously convicted child-molester after they’ve successfully applied. You don’t because they violated their life-long-parole-like control and are in back in jail.
- golergka 9y agoAlternative would be allowing people convicted of violence towards children to be teachers, for example.
- alexasmyths 9y agoGoogle does credit checks, at least they did. While I can see some science behind that - I'm weary about it. It's pretty easy to get in a whack credit situation for all sorts of reasons - 1/2 of issues are healthcare related. Then to have to have people say 'I refuse sign' or whatever and risk their jobs. Uncool.
- wsetchell 9y agoSome roles have regulations requiring a credit checks (IRCC). I think this is most relevant for government jobs with security clearance. If a person has serious money issues, they might be more easily influenced or bribed.
- sova 9y agoCredit Checks at Google are an effort to mitigate bribery ... what sorts of positions are likely to have this as a possibility? I'm genuinely curious.
- sigstoat 9y ago> what sorts of positions are likely to have this as a possibility? all the ones with access to the personal data of millions of people?
- alexasmyths 9y ago"all the ones with access to the personal data of millions of people?" So most Google employees who own homes are carrying bazillions in mortgage loans are 'less risk' than others? I understand the motivation, but it's a tricky thing. Again - 1/2 of bankruptcies are due to healthcare issues. It's these kind of systematic things that keep the underprivileged in down, while those with parents who can 'bail them out' get to move on unscathed. I'm fully not a 'SJW' type of person, weary of it - but I have parents of at least 'reasonable' means (not rich by any stretch) and there were a few times where my life may have turned out very differently. Specifically with respect to employment.
- kelukelugames 9y agoThe ban is not on asking about criminal history. It's a ban on asking about criminal history before a conditional offer is made. Quote from article: Under this law, employers will no longer be allowed to ask applicants about their criminal conviction histories until after a conditional offer of employment has been made.
- ApolloFortyNine 9y agoSo they're just making it more clear to potential employees that if you don't lie now, you'll lose the offer? Seems either pretty useless and will just waste more of a company's time, or will just encourage more people to lie about prior convictions (as it will be literally spelled out that they'll rescind the offer if they have a criminal history).
- kelukelugames 9y agoYeah, I think both laws are right steps in the right directions. But I don't know if they are big steps. The hope is by the time a company has invested enough to make a conditional offer that they are more willing to forgive a conviction history.
- numbsafari 9y agoI think the point is to encourage companies to go through the initial assessment of a potential employee in the hopes that they will find the candidate to be the best option, and then have to actively choose not to employ the person because of a prior conviction. In addition, they will have to evaluate (and it sounds like document) whether they feel the conviction would impact the candidate's ability to perform that specific job for that specific company. Today, many employers have a blanket "no convicts" check-box on their application forms. This makes it very hard for convicts to find work. Yes, many companies will continue to have this practice, and some for very good reason, but this creates the potential for a little more sanity to be applied.
- syshum 9y ago>>will just encourage more people to lie about prior convictions What is the point in lying about conviction? All convictions from every location are recorded into central databases run by companies like Lexis Nexus, so unless the employer is not using any kind of quality back ground check service lying is pointless as your criminal history is about 2 clicks away on a keyboard.
- loteck 9y agoNote that, as part of this same law, pay scales for jobs must be provided to applicants, upon request. Effective January 1 2018.
- milofeynman 9y agoIs there an example payscale somewhere? Does this apply to remote employees if a company is headquartered in California?
- larrik 9y agoOr more importantly, to non-California companies with California employees.
- syshum 9y agoMost likely yes, if the employer has employee's in the state, they have a legal nexus thus must follow that states laws
- kingnothing 9y agoIf you have a physical presence in a state, you must be incorporated in that state. You'll then have to follow the laws of that state for the business conducted there. This includes what are otherwise considered remote employees.
- syshum 9y agoSome companies may do it anyway but I doubt it would be required of them, Most of the time employees are governed under the laws in the location where they work, there are exceptions but they are rate For example California has different Overtime requirements than say Kentucky, employees of a CA firm in KY do no get overtime based on CA law but based on KY law
- largote 9y agoI'm guessing that pay scale would cover base salary, but not necessarily equity/bonuses?
- leifaffles 9y agoThey banned asking about salary history to close a gender wage gap that... wait for it... doesn't exist! (There are entire books about this! http://amazon.com/Why-Men-Earn-More-Startling/dp/0814472109 http://amazon.com/Why-Men-Earn-More-Startling/dp/0814472109) So brave! Way to go, California!
- analogmemory 9y agoWell, I'm glad a man has settled this.
- leifaffles 9y agoWhat? Are men not capable of looking at data? Imagine if someone said that about a woman... Perhaps you should keep your sexist comments to yourself.
- scarmig 9y agoIt's interesting that a man can come in and start proclaiming he understands statistics, and then take umbrage when people explain to him he doesn't know what he's talking about. Two gender gaps exist. One is much larger than the other, and popular discourse regularly conflates them. Oh well. That doesn't give you carte blanche to state things that are false.
- analogmemory 9y agoI'd argue, but it's more facinating to watch you dig that hole.
- dang 9y agoWe ban accounts that take HN into this kind of flamewar, especially when their comments are trollish. Since you've been doing this a ton, I've banned your account. If you don't want to be banned on HN, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and promise to follow the rules in the future. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 9y ago
- noja 9y agoWhat about looking up their salary at a credit agency?
- paulie_a 9y agoYou can opt out of that particular piece of info being available.
- sotojuan 9y agoIn my experience for "good" salaried jobs, background checks come with or after the job offer (in NY it's after). Do these kinds of laws affect that? If I had a record, I'd rather know up front than accept an offer and then have it rescinded because of a background check. I've actually had friends with a record accept offers, work at place for a few days or even weeks, and be asked to do a background check (and then told to leave!).
- randyrand 9y agoGiving your previous salary was a good way to help them offer you you a higher salary.
- cjensen 9y agoSeems like they can still ask "what Salary are you expecting?" Then you can quote them a higher salary. Or if your salary has previously suffered due to discrimination, you can quote a slightly higher salary than you should have received.
- jachee 9y agoYou can still volunteer it. They just can't ask up-front anymore.
- geofft 9y agoIf there is a pay gap in any form, that's a way to perpetuate it. Suppose Group A is currently paid higher than Group B. Group A will be able to say, "I was paid this amount and I expect that much or more." Group B won't. Group A will get higher salaries than Group B. Next time they apply for jobs, the same thing will happen. Yes, this potentially sucks for the people currently in Group A. A moral society cannot have "We will not make things worse for anyone" as an axiom, because that axiom would prevent taking power away from a tyrant. It's fine to say "We will not make things worse for people without a really good reason" - so the debate is just about whether fixing a pay gap is a good enough reason.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoI wonder if this applies to services that connect workers with employers (e.g. caregivers, etc.) and premptively do background checks. People have been unconditionally blocked from those over things like tiny mariajuana possession charges that are years old (and in a state where such a charge wouldn't even be filed now).
- bulatb 9y ago> Salary history may be discussed if an applicant “voluntarily and without prompting” discloses salary history to a potential employer. People who believe they're highly paid might find it advantageous to disclose that: they'd avoid an accidental lowball, companies that can't afford them, etc. So there should be three types of people: (1) those who disclose and are highly paid, (2) those who disclose and think they're highly paid but aren't, and (3) those who don't disclose. If being in group 1 is advantageous, then not disclosing (group 3) could be taken as a signal that the person thinks their salary is low and doesn't want to be anchored--but isn't that the information this law is supposed to be hiding? Even though they haven't named a price, it's still a signal that they might accept an offer under market. On the other hand, that makes it harder for employers to calculate an offer that's more than they're making but still under market. And the gap should shrink with every job change, in theory. Is there any data (maybe from other states) on how the game theory shakes out here? Edit: another provision makes it more complicated. > (c) An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment.
- stale2002 9y agoWell, you missed group 4. Group 4 is "people who aren't doing game theory in their head, and don't even think to give their salary, if they weren't asked it". And group 4 likely makes up the vast majority of people.
- cjensen 9y agoIs this Constitutional? People with a criminal history are not, as far as I understand, a protected class. So it's not clear to me why the government can forbid speech about prior convictions. Second, as an at-will state, these protections on behalf of the convicted seem pointless. How does this prevent companies immediately firing people with a criminal record? On the part about prior salary, at least the State can attempt to claim that it is connected to age-discrimination (a protected class) and prior sex-discrimination (also a protected class). It's not clear to me whether that will work, but at least there's an attempt to provide a Constitutionally-permitted reason.
- geofft 9y agoThe government is not forbidding speech - you can disclose your prior convictions and your salary if you like. (If you look at it with a reductionist-enough lens, it forbids speech on behalf of the employer, but there are plenty of cases where you can't do that, e.g., trademark infringement, copyright infringement, fraud, claiming that your patent medicine cures certain diseases, etc.) Also, the bill bans "the box" - the question on the initial application form. It does not ban inquiring into criminal history once you're ready to extend an offer, and requires that you consider whether the history is relevant. It seems to me that the motivation is to force employers to actually think about whether it's relevant instead of blanket refusing to consider people with a criminal history: once you've put time into interviewing candidates and preparing an offer, you're much less likely to give up on that sunk cost for irrational reasons, and the policy is betting that blanket refusal to hire people with a criminal history is only rational if you use it as an initial filter. So there's no need to prevent immediately firing people: that's expensive, and you're going to think twice about doing that, and that's enough. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180AB1008 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
- SamReidHughes 9y agoAsking questions is speech.
- 9y ago
- AcerbicZero 9y agoIf California doesn't want people to be judged on their criminal history, then perhaps California should look into the unjust laws they've enacted which place so many otherwise functional members of society into prison in the first place.
- Helmet 9y agoCan you name some of these unjust laws?
- drdeadringer 9y agoCan you give an example of an unjust law?
- ghostly_s 9y agoLike who? Or are you just presuming we're all intimately familiar with state law in California?
- ryandrake 9y agoThe problem is not unjust laws. The problem is companies' "Once a criminal, always a criminal" mentality that fails to allow for the possibility that rehabilitation can happen.
- trhway 9y agohard to blame companies when they can be sued if a person with a criminal record, say for assault, gets hired and later assaults somebody while on the company's time/premises/etc.
- interlocutor 9y ago>> The ban applies to both oral and written inquiries, whether they’re made directly by an employer or through an agent. So employers can't ask job applicants, but they can still ask Equifax, right? Your current employer may be sharing your salary with Equifax. (There is no law preventing employers from doing so.) Equifax offers various services using the salary info shared by your employer. For more info see: https://www.theworknumber.com/ https://www.theworknumber.com/
- Retric 9y agoCompanies don't get data from Equifax without asking for it. So they would need to ask for salary data before getting salary data. A more general rule is 'cute' interpretations of the law don't work.
- DavidWoof 9y ago"Ban the box" laws have a pretty horrible track record. In practice, they unsurprisingly generally result in higher levels of discrimination against demographics with higher crime rates, especially low-skilled Blacks and Hispanics. Here's a decent article on the topic. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/08/consequences-of-ban-the-box/494435/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/08/consequ...
- RangerScience 9y agoAlso notably, > An employer, upon reasonable request, shall provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment. So not only can they no longer ask you for salary history, they must tell your about their salary practices if you request the information.
- 0xWilliam 9y agoWhat is to stop people from just lying about their salary information?
- miketich 9y agoI mean, you can find quite a bit of public data to back it up, so them lying about it won't really do that much good. IE Glassdoor, H1B database, etc.
- greenleafjacob 9y agoHaven’t read the law, but what’s to stop people from lying on their tax returns? Upfront notice via the law, and backend enforcement via IRS auditing. Same principle could apply here.
- tomjen3 9y agoHow would that work if you don't have a set scale? IE you will pay depending on what you can get away with? "We are willing to pay upto 300 thousand for this SE position, but we will negotiate that with the other applicants and take their offers into account".
- analog31 9y agoMeanwhile, Wisconsin just moved in the opposite direction. A bill has been introduced which grants employers the right to ask job candidates for salary information. http://dailyreporter.com/2017/11/17/bill-would-prevent-local-officials-from-setting-stricter-licensing-minimum-wage-standards/ http://dailyreporter.com/2017/11/17/bill-would-prevent-local...
- cmiles74 9y agoJust in case you weren't sure how corporations feel about this issue. ;-)
- SamReidHughes 9y agoWould it be unconstitutional for a law to prohibit employees from asking each other what their salaries are? If so, it's hard to see how this could survive scrutiny.
- pkaye 9y agoI wonder if this would put higher paid experienced people at a disadvantage as companies often use your previous salary as a reference for how much you are worth. Maybe you are not so good on your interviews but in the actual job you perform well so you are paid a higher salary.