6 ms·
Cognitive Difference Between Women and Men Gives Men Edge in Spatial Understanding
- badrabbit 9y agoThe question troubles me much more than the answer. Whether for a job position or college application acceptance,why is it ok to practice anything short of pure meritocracy? When a person attends a school or works at a company,why is that person seen as an ambassador and representative of a larger group as opposed to an individual representing himself or herself? If a person can demonstrate their ability to meet or exceed the demands of a job or their ability to succeed academically at the school of choice,why consider anything else? In case of multiple good candidates,pick the one that is most compatible with the company or school or whichever candidate scores best on additional testing. I don't care what $somegroup tend to be good at or bad at. I am not hiring a group,I am hiring an individual. If a person,irrespective of gender, can test better than other candidates,they should get a job. I assure you fully,I do not speak as a member of some "priviledged group", quite the contrary. However, I despise artificial equality. The argument of the emancipation and civil rights movement both were founded on the fact that all people are created equal. It means people should not be artificially stopped from participating in public activities and opportunities because they are somehow thought of as "naturally inferior". Test everyone equally (their merit for the opportunity and character as individuals) and do not artificially add or deduct points based on their membership to some group. If you treat,(for example) a woman in a special way - only because of her gender, you are being a sexist. The end does not justify the means,it does not matter if in the end that woman is better off(in your opinion). You are still being a sexist. The focus shouldn't be on measuring a certain group's representation at a company or school. The focus should be in enforcing strict meritocracy and auditing for any controls that might inhibit any individual from succeeding or progressing because of their membership to a group. Lastly,for downvotes' sake - a person's political affiliation or social views are frequently used to artificially " keep out" individuals out of silicon valley companies. In my opinion that is unjust and should be corrected. For example, a software engineer's political views,national origin,ethnicity,gender,what sports team he likes or if he voted for $politician is irrelevant to being a good software engineer. If he or she demonstrates their superior technical ability and ability to get along with your team,hire them. Look back at history and see how much evil could have been avoided if people did what was right-but-inconvenient. Nothing good ever comes out of injustice.
- racer-v 9y agoWhat was the question?
- jrs95 9y agoPeople are doing what feels good and what makes them look good. Social incentives have been highly politicized, so in many environments the sort of behavior you're talking about is seen as the highest virtue. Meritocracy or traditional liberal values are no longer the priority.
- spamizbad 9y agoWas meritocracy ever the priority? To my knowledge, at least the idyllic way this site sees it, meritocracy has never been in practice. It's merely been an ideal "strived" for, the same way a Christian may strive to live free of sin. What likely happened: We came the realization that what we consider "merit" is highly subjective and may not even correlate with better outcomes. Once that sank in, all bets were off.
- jrs95 9y agoIt was definitely never achieved, but at least people gave a shit about it. Thats no longer the case, and it's not in the mainstream monoculture that people seem to be convinced is somehow anti-establishment.
- fromthesky 9y agoThe principle of meritocracy is not an ethical program to reward the most meritorious (and hence deserving) people. The 17th-century liberal conception of meritocracy is to assign the most capable people to positions where they can have the most effect - as opposed to the ancien regime system where administrative duties were allocated on a hereditary basis. So I don't think "merit" in this sense is totally subjective - it's just a representation of our best estimate of who can do the best job in any given function.
- torstenvl 9y agoBecause not everyone views the world the same way that you do; some people discriminate, and some even do so in hiring and other contexts where it's unlawful. Only thing is, that is enormously hard to tell in any particular case, especially when (as in hiring) the decision is not well-documented. Statistical analysis is helpful in those circumstances. But you can't do that unless you check what happens by random chance in your control group.
- itissid 9y agoMy wife and I excelled in engineering drawing in school. But she still has great difficulty in keeping up with me in carpentry and trying to visualize how joints come together. I might have some hindsight and confirmation bias of course. And while what the author is saying about taking up engineering courses like these could be true to a varying extent, but a RCT is necessary to ascertain what sticks and what does not and how much.
- gpvos 9y agoRCT = randomized controlled trial, I assume.
- gpvos 9y agoThe current title doesn't highlight the salient bit in this article; I think the original article title is better, even if a little clickbaity. The salient bit in this article is that women can attain the same level of spatial abilities as men by following a fairly short training. (And the article discusses implications and likely causes of why this is so; it appears to be a biological factor that is enlarged by cultural factors. Or to expand on this a little: both "types" of brains are capable of the same things, but in men, somehow this development is usually automatically biologically triggered, maybe by testosterone, while in women, this usually doesn't happen automatically, and isn't stimulated by the cultural environment either, so it generally doesn't develop, even though it easily could, and can also be developed without problem at a later age. All this, of course, is about averages between women and men.)
- jesperlang 9y agoYes misleading title So whenever stuff like this pops up it's this read-between-the-lines idea that bothers me, but I am going to play along. OK, let's say there were scientific evidence on the biological part. What do you want me to do with that information? What exactly are people hinting at that constantly emphasize that information? If we could stop this fixed mindset nonsense we would be so much better off. The brain has incredible plasticity, lets work with that! The wander off for food and mates theory that they bring up here, how applicable is that for anyone in current society? All genders can benefit from spatial ability, so we should all practice it :)
- btwt 9y ago>this read-between-the-lines idea that bothers me This "ick" factor is holding back both science and society. Lifting the taboo of acknowledging the "scientific evidence on the biological part" could, for example, explain why certain populations skew towards, for example, lower salary. If we stopped ignoring questions and answers because of an uncomfortable implication, we could explain and possibly correct population differences in equity without resorting to "crabs in a bucket" style disregard for merit brought about by an irrational assumption of equality in ability. >If we could stop this fixed mindset nonsense Differences in cognitive performance among genders are no more nonsensical than physical differences in performance[1]. We know that cognition is influenced by brain structure, hormone concentration, neurotransmitter concentration, and we know that these differ markedly between the two genders, but for some reason people are unwilling to acknowledge that these could lead to different abilities in application. At the very least, one must admit that time and resources are required to "work with" the brain's plasticity to overcome fundamentally biological differences, and that leads to difference average performance among genders in different roles. 1.http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/04/study-finds-some-significant-differences-brains-men-and-women http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/04/study-finds-some-sign... Not the most official source, but a good overview of what amount to pretty old ideas, in an unbiased context. This science is only controversial because people are biased by the implication of the results.