8 ms·
Dice Become Ordered When Stirred, Not Shaken
- ajarmst 9y agoMore accurately, cubes pack more closely when agitated one way than another. The fact that they are dice is irrelevant (they don't become ordered with respect to the facing side). To be honest, this isn't particularly odd, as the experiment removed the component of the agitation that would tend to displace the cubes vertically, which is the only dimension with an asymmetric force that would tend to increase the packing factor if undisturbed (gravity).
- wonderous 9y agoDice are not perfect cubes, since there edges and corners are rounded, so it would not make sense to generalize the results of dice as applying to perfect cubes.
- ajarmst 9y agoPerhaps, but the salient characteristic of dice is that the sides are marked. When you talk about dice becoming ordered, there is a very strong implication that you mean the sequence of facing sides, not the packing factor. If we must be pedantic, then the phrase "rounded cubes"---or even "dice-shaped-cubes"---would be more accurate and relevant than "dice" (which aren't even invariably cubes, but are invariably marked).
- PeachPlum 9y agoPlatonic cubes don't exist
- MereInterest 9y agoThat's a really deep statement about the nature of existence. A mathematical theorem exists, even if the underlying structure is not represented in reality. We know that spacetime is warped by mass distribution, and is therefore non-Euclidean. However, the Pythagorean theorem is still something that exists, despite applying only to Euclidean space. In the same way, a Platonic solid could be said to exist, even if it isn't represented in reality.
- lambda 9y agoCasino dice are actually cubes, at least as close as manufacturing tolerances of 0.0001 inch can make them. For example: https://www.casinosupply.com/collections/casino-dice/products/new-casino-dice-serialized-3-4-inch-set-of-6 https://www.casinosupply.com/collections/casino-dice/product... This is to help make it easier to spot alterations or flaws which could affect their randomness; shaved corners become very easy to spot, when packing them together it's easy to spot ones with height differences, etc.
- wonderous 9y agoTolerance you’re referencing relates to the distance of one side to another, not the shape of the corners; the dice you linked to have their corners rounded (aka shaved) if you look at the image.
- mohn 9y agoIndeed. I think anyone who has done some work with a milling machine will know firsthand that a freshly cut 90 degree edge that has not yet been rounded over is sharp like a blade. If casinos actually did use dice that were extremely cubic, the dice would be cutting patrons' fingers and wrecking the felted surface of the craps table.
- gambiting 9y agoFunnily enough, the website the parent linked actually calls them " Transparent with razor sharp edges" so I guess they are pretty sharp.
- mohn 9y agoI may have been wrong in my previous post. Apparently "razor" is one of several styles of dice edge and is intended to prevent excess tumbling, so a craps throw doesn't take too long to come to rest. I'm tempted to buy some new razor dice to see for myself. I can't find measurements for the radius of curvature on razor dice edges, but I'd be surprised if they're truly as sharp as claimed. Without even considering the liability aspect, it seems inconvenient for a casino to pause the game because someone is bleeding on the table or dice. I also wasn't able to learn how often the felt of a craps table is changed, though I came across something that said the felt's useful lifetime is prolonged by a foam rubber underlayer.
- WhoBeI 9y agoBut a cow is still basically spherical.
- thatcat 9y agoMost people would consider that an "edge case" which can be neglected in the model since it doesn't create any forces in the y direction.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoAn 8 edge case.
- dogruck 9y agoDice have 12 edges.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoSo I went up to my friend and I was like "How many edges does a dice have?" and they said "eight." "If it makes you feel any better, I thought the same thing. But we're both just idiots."
- wonderous 9y agoNot really, easy to make an error; for example, a cube has 12 edges, but a dice with rounded edges would have an infinite set of edges.
- xigency 9y agoSo it's a corner case?
- jonsen 9y agoOnly if you are cornered.
- dogruck 9y agoAs Lebowski would say, “Clearly, you’re not a golfer.” In casinos, dice have sharp edges and corners.
- wonderous 9y agoDid you even look at the dice used in the experiment? The edges & corners are clearly rounded.
- walshemj 9y agoCasino craps dice are, I have a set for rolling my dnd characters stats for true randomness
- amalcon 9y ago"Ordered" is accurate, as they mean it in the thermodynamic sense. It's not that precise because of the other meaning, though.
- hexane360 9y agoActually, a similar distinction is important in thermodynamics as well. Even at 0K (with no movement of atoms), you can still have a "residual entropy" related to the randomness in the crystal structure. For example, a solid CO crystal at 0K still has disorder in the direction the molecule is oriented (possible because the C-O dipole is small but nonzero). http://images.slideplayer.com/24/7362502/slides/slide_18.jpg http://images.slideplayer.com/24/7362502/slides/slide_18.jpg
- scott_s 9y agoThe published paper: "Experimental Study of Ordering of Hard Cubes by Shearing", https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.228002 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.11... Calling them "dice" (which is what was actually used in the experiment) is fine for a summary of the research for laypeople. If confused, any interested reader will quickly know what "ordered" means in this context. As to the work itself, if someone had asked me one hour ago if this would happen, I would have guessed not. I know that light shaking of small objects will tend to organize them, and that large objects in particulate matter (such as sand) will tend to rise in such circumstances. But I still am surprised enough by this result to think it's notable - and, I assume, so were the editors of Physical Review Letters.
- malkia 9y agoAnd I was expecting a gamedev studio story...
- santaclaus 9y ago> To be honest, this isn't particularly odd, as the experiment removed the component of the agitation that would tend to displace the cubes vertically, which is the only dimension with an asymmetric force that would tend to increase the packing factor if undisturbed (gravity). The consequences here are still interesting with respect to object shape. Why do certain shapes easily reach optimal packings under perturbations like this? Will mono-disperse spheres reach their tightest theoretical packing under such a perturbation? Probably not. Ellipsoids? Probably. Tetrahedra? No idea. Anecdotally, I've heard this is why most candies are ellipsoidal and not spherical. Ellipsoids naturally gravitate to tighter packings and are thus more efficient to ship. Maybe we can now get cube-shaped chocolate candies.
- wonderous 9y agoPaper is titled, “Experimental Study of Ordering of Hard Cubes by Shearing” - does anyone have a link to the paper as a PDF?
- selimthegrim 9y agoDoesn't seem to be on arxiv but here's a conference abstract - ignore the certificate warning https://fises17.gefenol.es/media/contribution/abs-fises17-asencio.pdf https://fises17.gefenol.es/media/contribution/abs-fises17-as...
- lukasm 9y agoany youtube mirrors? videos don't work.
- microcolonel 9y agoI suspect this phenomenon is already in use in material science and manufacturing.
- Hupriene 9y agoThat's what I was thinking. Vibratory sorting/feeding machines are common and a lot of engineering effort has gone into optimizing them. I'd be very surprised if rotary oscillation had not been tried, and probably used, on many occasions.
- mattmanser 9y agoI have a friend who's got a doctorate in CS. He always adamantly insists his work was utterly pointless as any company interested in solving the problems he solved would simply throw people at it and solve it independently in a couple of months, they'd never find his work.
- skybrian 9y agoSounds like a search problem. I wonder why sharing knowledge works so well when using Stack Overflow but not for his research results?
- 21 9y agoBecause the purpose of research is to produce papers, not disseminate information or help others. See how many CS papers talk about various algorithms without also providing the source code of said implementation.
- skybrian 9y agoOK, but for any individual researcher (such as the original poster's friend) what if they want to try harder?
- 9y ago
- nerdponx 9y agoI think their definition of "ordered" is different from most people's when it comes to something like dice. Cool effect, but it makes for a pretty misleading headline.
- bkanber 9y agoYou have to apply the context before you call the (correct) headline misleading. This is a physical sciences context so this is the correct use of "ordered" -- as in "order and disorder", i.e. symmetry and correlation. You're talking about "ordered" as in "ordinal", meaning "related to position in a series", which makes more sense in a computer science context (and we are on HN), but still -- it is your job to apply the context to the situation, not anyone else's.
- Terr_ 9y agoIf it's all about bloodless scientific rigor, why'd they choose to highlight "Dice" in the headline when it is probably a property of "cubes" in general? I'm imagining some biologists studying how human cells have some unique negative reactions to C3H8O, and then they title the a report "Humans just can't resist alcohol."
- dahart 9y agoWhen I'm measuring my food, I like to shake it, so I can fit more in the measuring cup without increasing the calorie count. ;) Oatmeal will pack down quite a bit with some shaking. The title is funny. I realize it's sometimes hard to translate and summarize scientific results for the layperson, but the paper wasn't comparing stirring or shaking. They compared rotating the container to tapping the container. Rotating is, ironically, a type of shaking, and closer to shaking than tapping. I would expect a good deal of dice packing in this experiment using vertical shaking, as opposed to lateral tapping.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoThat's why you always use a weighing scale :)
- dahart 9y agoYeah, but then I wouldn't get to cheat. :P
- lisper 9y agoTry putting your thumb on the scale when you turn it on. ;-)
- AnkhMorporkian 9y ago"Honey, why are your hundred grams of oatmeal taking up 5 bowls?" "I'm not sure! It must be exceptionally light."
- derefr 9y agoVertical shaking would unpack just as many things as it would pack. Horizontal shaking works because gravity is biasing the reorganization toward more packed arrangements. Maybe you're thinking of (the equivalent in a crystalline solid) of "boiling"? E.g., giving a bump on the bottom of the cylinder, that would have enough force to scatter individual cubes, but not enough force to unlock cubes from the crystal.
- herodotus 9y agoA very well-known parlour trick with dice is called "dice stacking" - here is a nice youtube video showing how to do this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLtOVFE3mYc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLtOVFE3mYc
- SubiculumCode 9y agoI was blown away until I realized that they did not mean that all the face-values of the dice become aligned.
- guelo 9y agoClick bait
- nyc111 9y agoIsn't there also a probabilistic angle? On the second video, on the outer circle I see that same sides repeat at most 3 times. Can this be a true random number generator? Here are the numbers: 1-2-6-4-6-6-6-4-5-3-6-1-2-6-1-2-6-4-6-3-1-1-6-4-3-6-3-2-3-1-3-1-6-3-4-1-4-6-4-3-2-2-4-1-6-1-2-3-4-4-5-5-5-4-1-1-5-4-5-2-6-5-1-1-1-5-4-4-1-1-3-6-6-4-1-4-1-2-4-1-4-6-5-2-1-4-5-1-1-4-1-2-5-3-6-6-3-6-2-5-5-2-3 And here is the distribution: 1 --> 24 2 --> 13 3 --> 13 4 --> 20 5 --> 13 6 --> 20
- nl 9y agoBy "Ordered" they don't actually mean anything to do with the numbers. It's unfortunate terminology clashing.
- kebman 9y agoImagine that. Centrifugal force will actually pull the cubes to the side of the container in an ordered fashion... What a miracle!
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 9y agoOrdering alignment of rectangular prisms under simple shear is well established by now. As is the variable effects of shaking - can increase or decrease packing fraction and order depending on magnitude. In addition ordering in packings of rectangular prisms extend up to 8 particle lengths from the side walls - and are variable with time and history. This experiment's results could be partly due to edge effects.
- bertr4nd 9y agoI wonder if there’s any insight here that could be applied to optimization via simulated annealing.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoHas nobody else noticed the James Bond pun? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaken,_not_stirred https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaken,_not_stirred
- rbanffy 9y agoIt's kind of applying the Bogosort method in the physical world, with the exception the physical world favors it.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIt took .5g to get the effect. But the dice in the center never aligned. Probably because, so near the axis, they never experience anywhere near .5g.