9 ms·
I'm confused what the move should be then? People want more features and capabilities from the products they use, websites included. What im reading here is a
by madeofpalk 9y ago
I'm confused what the move should be then? People want more features and capabilities from the products they use, websites included.
What im reading here is a preference for web technologies to be frozen as they were since 2000.
- amelius 9y agoThat's a difficult question for which there are probably many answers, so here's my attempt at it. One first insight: we don't need the "semantic web" because Machine Learning can recover semantics. (This is also how Google's webcrawler views the web, so why not apply it to browsers too? People mix up semantics and formatting too often for the "semantic web" to be a useful concept). Another thing to realize is that overcomplicated systems benefit from factorization, i.e. splitting functionalities into different modules with their own responsibilities. This doesn't just apply to code, but also specifications. A better factorization will immediately solve the "monopoly" situation, because now many players can develop many modules, and browser vendors can simply combine module implementations at will. What it will also solve is security issues. A modularized architecture is much easier to keep secure than a system where all functionality has been thrown together on one big heap without structure. You can say that browsers are (if the developers are smart) already structured in a modularized way, but that is not the point, because the internal boundaries of the modules are not openly available in any kind of specification. Personally, I long for a world where formatting a document or showing a video on a computer screen is not considered "high tech". And this might be the way towards it. Note that an "extreme" interpretation of this would be to replace the browser by a simple virtual machine. In that case, every web-developer is their own browser vendor, and they can mix and match existing libraries at will. People will then probably object that the user loses power, and accessibility is lost. But we live in a world of Machine Learning now, so any "structureless" rendering can be easily restructured by an appropriate tool. E.g. an image containing text can be OCR'd and read aloud by a tool. This would also make these tools more robust against formatting hacks. And machine learning can do many more useful things, like removing ads.
- madeofpalk 9y ago> Personally, I long for a world where formatting a document or showing a video on a computer screen is not considered "high tech". And this might be the way towards it. Okay so here's the thing. Web pages do a lot more than just 'formatting a document' or showing a video. Any serious talk about the web platform has to acknowledge the that that it's an 'application platform' that is more than just an .rtf file.
- amelius 9y agoYes, but do you consider launching an app "high tech"? If yes, then that must change, otherwise we'll never reach a higher level of enlightenment. So what I wanted to say is that the "high tech" is currently not as much in the functionality, as it is in the software engineering effort to reach that functionality. Also, the paragraph after the sentence that you quoted addresses web-apps, if that's what you are concerned about.
- roca 9y agoThe semantic Web was always a W3C boondoggle that never became part of the Web as implemented by browsers. So that's a bad example in this context. It's hard to see exactly what you're asking for. Web specs are already quite modular. The modularity could be improved, but it's not like nobody's trying.