3 ms·
Must say, I'm not a fan of yours or similar services, or whois databases for that matter. Privacy should be easier on the internet for people owning domain name
by megous 9y ago
Must say, I'm not a fan of yours or similar services, or whois databases for that matter. Privacy should be easier on the internet for people owning domain names.
- rosstex 9y agoSecurity through obscurity.
- megous 9y agoYou probably misread the word. It's not security, but privacy. And privacy is made by obscuring, usually.
- mxpxrocks10 9y agoHi! The only way on the current Internet to remain anonymous is to obscure the domain registrant from right when the domain is initially registered. It's also important to use a service that pools a lot of domains together or have diversity in the hosting providers so they can't be easily correlated. We try and help people understand and make the problem visible. You bring up a good point that it should be easier.
- megous 9y agoYeah, it's hard. If one has multiple domains from multiple tld's pointing to the same server, it's really easy to find out other domains and tlds with more detailed and easier to access records that will reveal the owner's identity. Privately registered eu domains are quite nice. I couldn't even find two of such that I own in your database and whois only reveals email (which I made sure from the beginning to be of the same domain that I just registered, so that's useless for anything). People can probably pay for more info though.
- starsinspace 9y agoA good option for people living in the EU is to register a .eu domain. For private individuals (like private non-commercial websites), the whois data is by default restricted to show an e-mail address only. (see section 2.4. in https://eurid.eu/en/other-infomation/whois-policy/ https://eurid.eu/en/other-infomation/whois-policy/)
- jstanley 9y agoThis capability is already available to lots of large organisations. Making it available to everybody just sheds light on the problem, it doesn't create the problem.
- andreasley 9y agoWhy do you think privacy should be easier for domain owners? Shouldn't it instead be easy for a visitor to find out who owns the domain and is responsible (content, technical or legal) for a certain site?
- amelius 9y agoAlso think about online shops which turn out to be scams. But perhaps there should be a possibility to remain anonymous (and the browser informing the user that this is the case).
- chrisper 9y agoNot everyone needs to know my home address. Especially not for a domain I use for emails. Way too many weird people out there.
- always_good 9y agoAlso, any content that people could take issue with. Any hobbies I might have that I wouldn't share on facebook. This is why I lie in my whois data, to the horror of the goody two-shoes on HN I'm sure. The whois data is a great place to start a social engineering hack. The address or any past address is often used for identity.
- megous 9y agoI bought an internet domain in order for people to be able to contact me via some stable handle on the internet, that only I control. That's all. I don't want my phone, my home address, my all other domains, etc. to be easilly accessible for no reason whatsoever by nosy types. Also your question may apply to the other end too. Shouldn't it be easy for an owner of the server to find out who is behind an IP address that is connecting to his server - and I mean easy access to his/her phone number, home address and a complete history of those, too? It's easy to concot legal, technical and content reasons why this should be.