5 ms·
> Transparency is a consequence of how light interacts with objects. There is no "transparent gold". And being transparent is not something we can program gold
by yorwba 9y ago
> Transparency is a consequence of how light interacts with objects. There is no "transparent gold". And being transparent is not something we can program gold to do.
Your remark made me research this, and apparently transparent gold exists, we can create it, and you can buy it [1]. The trick appears to be making the gold thin enough.
> Line up everything in the known universe that is conscious and you will find that it engages in a highly specific biochemical activity that requires a whole set of highly specific chemical interactions.
Line up everything in the known universe that engages in this highly specific biochemical activity, and you'll find a whole lot of things that most people wouldn't call "conscious". So the biochemical activity can't be enough on it's own to create "consciousness". If you compare those "unconscious" organisms with "conscious" ones, you'll find that that the "conscious" organisms have a large amount of cells with this biochemical activity arranged in an intricate network structure.
Now why do you think it's not this structure that creates "consciousness"? Why do the details of the biochemical activity matter beyond being a particular physical realization of some differential equations? Why would a machine made out of silicon, when it precisely emulates the behavior of that biochemical activity, be unable to replicate it's large-scale properties (including "consciousness")?
[1] http://www.reynardcorp.com/products/optical-components/coating-services/conductive-coatings/11-protected-gold-transparent-conductive-coating.html http://www.reynardcorp.com/products/optical-components/coati...
- mjburgess 9y agoSure, I meant we cannot impart the property of transparency to a gold bar by "programming" it. Programming isnt a magical spell that can rewrite the causal interactions that take place in the universe. > and you'll find a whole lot of things that most people wouldn't call "conscious" I disagree. I cannot think of anything with a nervous system engaging in the particular neurochemical reaction I'm talking about not being conscious. No example comes to mind? I dont mean any old reaction. As, the digestion of wheat. I mean the specific kind that define neurological systems. > why do the details of the biochemical activity matter beyond being a particular physical realization of some differential equations Because the "details" we're talking about are the causal effects. > precisely emulates the behavior of that biochemical activity For the same reason you cannot programme a gold bar into transparency. Or program a table into an elephant. Or to put it another way, a program which "precisely emulates the behavior of gold" doesnt turn machine into gold. A program which "precisely emulates the behavior of digestion" does not digest pizza. A program which "precisely emulates the behavior of" consciousness isnt conscious. By "emulation" you mean, "imitation in form". Since it is only the FORMS the program and the nervous system share (or, gold, whatever). Ie., that they can be both described to an extreme level of abstraction in the same way. But the universe isnt abstract. It isnt a form. A program simulating a gold bar may be an instance of some equation that a gold bar is -- but possesses none of the properties that make it gold. A machine which imitates some highly abstract equational description of thought is as close to thinking as a bird is to an aeroplane. The bird's heart will burn as much jet fuel as your machine will think. The universe isnt taking place in the abstract, it's taking place in the concrete. You have no soul. Your mind is not a program. You consciousness is not ideal. It isnt a number. A pattern, a structure, an equation. These are descriptions. Your mind is something your body is doing -- as so it is for every known thing that has a mind. To speak as if the mind could be abstracted enough to a description that may be realized in silicon is to believe in an almost magical power of electric.
- yorwba 9y ago>> and you'll find a whole lot of things that most people wouldn't call "conscious" > I disagree. I cannot think of anything with a nervous system engaging in the particular neurochemical reaction I'm talking about not being conscious. No example comes to mind? Is a jellyfish conscious? Does it have the particular neurochemical reaction you are talking about? > A machine which imitates some highly abstract equational description of thought is as close to thinking as a bird is to an aeroplane. The bird's heart will burn as much jet fuel as your machine will think. This is actually a good analogy for our disagreement. Your definition of "thought" seems to inherently depend on the implementing substrate; and if it doesn't burn jet fuel, a bird doesn't really "fly". But for me the substrate is irrelevant; I don't care whether a machine "really thinks", so long as it can solve any problem which I might have to "think" about otherwise.
- mjburgess 9y ago> I don't care whether a machine "really thinks", so long as it can solve any problem which I might have to "think" about otherwise. OK, well then your calculator satisfies your definition of "thinking". I'm concerned to know whether a machine is doing what my dog is or I am. And mostly when people become hysterical or tedtalky (which is the same thing most of the time) about AI they are presenting an "I, Robot" future where androids dream of electric sheep. > and if it doesn't burn jet fuel, a bird doesn't really "fly" When I think, "I'd like my pen" and subsequently my arm moves to get my pen, my thinking is causally connected to my arm moving. My arm moving is some chemical my muscles do, in order to be connected at all with my thinking, my thinking has to be something broadly chemical too. The plane doesn't move air out of the way because its flying. It does that because its burning fuel (etc.). "Flying" as a description of what the bird and the aeroplane are both doing isnt actually any physical process at all. Is a pattern they both very abstractly follow that we have invented. In this sense nothing in the universe actually flies: the bird does its thing, the aeroplane does its thing --- and from our point of view, they are both abstractly similar. IT's our pov which makes them similar though. The airplane isnt distressed to burn too much. The bird is.
- Dylan16807 9y ago